A Different Vantage Point: Commentary on “Theories for Psychotherapeutic Genetic Counseling: Fuzzy Trace Theory and Cognitive Behavior Theory”

Excerpt

Raised in a psychosocial model of genetic counseling, I have long believed that understanding and addressing our patients’ psychological needs are critical to our role as genetic counselors. As such, I was pleased to see Biesecker et al.(2016) article, “Theories for psychotherapeutic genetic counseling: Fuzzy trace theory and Cognitive Behavior Theory” and their presented framework for how to apply psychological theories to genetic counseling practice. I wholeheartedly agree that the use of a counseling approach to guide our interactions will enrich our work - for both patients and also for genetic counselors as professionals. Where I disagree, however, is Biesecker et al.‘s argument for the adoption of a practice descriptor or “moniker” of “psychotherapeutic genetic counseling.” Having practiced in both worlds, psychotherapy and genetic counseling, I struggle with their assertion and find myself wondering, are we looking at the same end goal, but from a different vantage point? In this commentary, I offer an alternative perspective in hopes of continuing the conversation of how to best meet our patients’ psychological needs. …