The aim of this study was to assess the inter observer and intra observer reliability of acute scaphoid fracture classification methods including a novel ‘long axis’ measurement, a simple method which we have developed with the aim of improving agreement when describing acute fractures.
We identified sixty patients with acute scaphoid fractures at two centres who had been investigated with both plain radiographs and a CT (Computed Tomography) scan within 4 weeks of injury. The fractures were assessed by three observers at each centre using three commonly used classification systems and the ‘long axis’ method.
Inter observer reliability: based on X-rays the ‘long axis’ measurement demonstrated substantial agreement (Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) =0.76) and was significantly more reliable than the Mayo (p < 0.01), the most reliable of the established classification systems with moderate levels of agreement (kappa = 0.56). Intra observer reliability: the long axis measurement demonstrated almost perfect agreement whether based on X-ray (ICC = 0.905) or CT (ICC = 0.900).
This study describes a novel pragmatic ‘long axis’ method for the assessment of acute scaphoid fractures which demonstrates substantial inter and intra observer reliability. The ‘long axis’ measurement has clear potential benefits over traditional classification systems which should be explored in future clinical research.
Eastley N, Singh H, Dias JJ, Taub N. Union rates after proximal scaphoid fractures; meta-analyses and review of available evidence. J Hand Surg European Vol. 2013;38(8):888–97. CrossRef
Russe O. Fracture of the carpal navicular. Diagnosis, non-operative treatment, and operative treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Amer Vol. 1960;42-A:759–68. CrossRef
Dias J, Brealey S, Choudhary S, et al. Scaphoid waist internal fixation for fractures trial (SWIFFT) protocol: a pragmatic multi-Centre randomised controlled trial of cast treatment versus surgical fixation for the treatment of bi-cortical, minimally displaced fractures of the scaphoid waist in adults. BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2016;17:248. CrossRefPubMedPubMedCentral
Viera AJ, Garrett JM. Understanding interobserver agreement: the kappa statistic. Fam Med. 2005;37(5):360–3. PubMed
Desai VV, Davis TR, Barton NJ. The prognostic value and reproducibility of the radiological features of the fractured scaphoid. J Hand Surg. 1999;24(5):586–90. CrossRef
Bhat M, McCarthy M, Davis TR, Oni JA, Dawson S. MRI and plain radiography in the assessment of displaced fractures of the waist of the carpal scaphoid. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004;86(5):705–13. CrossRef
Trail I, Stanley D. The Scaphoid edited by Slutsky, D. 1st edition . 2010;Chapter 6.
- A new acute scaphoid fracture assessment method: a reliability study of the ‘long axis’ measurement
Benjamin J. F. Dean
Nicholas D. Riley
Earl Robert McCulloch
Jennifer C. E. Lane
Amy Beth Touzell
Alastair J. Graham
- BioMed Central
Neu im Fachgebiet Orthopädie und Unfallchirurgie
Mail Icon II