Background
Multiplicity in care options for back pain: choice and complexity
Examining choice through the experiences of older women
Methods
Data Analysis
Results
Influences on health service utilisation | Example |
---|---|
Familiarity/relationship with providers and familiarity with treatment type | - Current/previous experience with a provider group for back pain related or unrelated complaint |
- Familiarity with the treatment procedures for a provider group (irrespective or previous effectiveness for same or different ailment/complaint) | |
- Exclusion of future encounters with a provider group due to previous negative experience | |
Family/social networks: | - Anecdotes from family/social networks for the effectiveness of a specific practitioner |
- Recommendations for a provider group | |
- Recommendation based on second-hand knowledge or community reputation of a specific practitioner | |
Proximity of practitioners | - Attractiveness of nearby/local practitioners |
- Difficulty travelling to practitioners for treatment due to physical pain/mobility | |
- Difficulties finding appropriate/suitable practitioners in local proximity | |
- Highly valued practitioners worthy of travelling greater distances for treatment | |
Qualifications and credentials | - Research on internet/talking to friends/family about provider group approaches to treatment, efficacy and evidence base |
- Consideration/assessment of formal qualifications | |
- Difficultly knowing what qualifications mean | |
- Experience and practical expertise outweigh formal qualifications |
Familiarity with treatment type and of existing relationship with providers
Participant | Example |
---|---|
Interviewer: | So why [did you choose] chiropractic? |
#16 | Why? Because I had had chiropractic before… for my neck actually, because I’ve done a lot of office work, and I think bad posture, sitting over computers and all things like that, for my neck, and I think just tension in there, and they managed to relieve that. So ah, that was where I found ah, and I just had a confidence there, I had a confidence and I felt it was helping. |
#8 | So I already knew somebody [a physio], [who runs my] hydrotherapy class. So I organised…to do the hydrotherapy in the morning. And the lady that does it is a physio, and I also arranged to start going to her as well…because I knew that, I’d been already previously. |
#4 | But I had a really bad experience with one person where I thought, no, never again, it was really painful and horrible. |
#25 | Like I had [a bad] experience with [a] chiropractor where initially I was quite happy, and then I wasn't. But that's not going to stop me going back if someone says to me, “I have a really good chiropractor, why don’t you just try him?” I’d go. |
#30 | We’re very happy with our GP, we’ve been with her for quite a number of years, and she keeps an eye on us. We go every six weeks. |
Family/social networks
Participant | Example |
---|---|
#19 | Because people had said…that this was a good thing to try. |
#10 | Yeah. And the guy over the road said that he went to a [practitioner], who is up over here at [local suburb], and said “he’s really good.” |
#6 | Invariably it would've been a friend’s referral that might have done it. |
#12 | I thought “yes, I’ll make an appointment,” and I went to the [practitioner] that my girlfriend goes to and swears by… |
#32 | But you always ask people as well who they recommend, a personal recommendation is better than any advert. |
#33 | …I think hearsay is an important one, where someone's been and they’ve given relief. |
#36 | Well, I usually talk to people, especially if I move to a new place where I don’t know anyone, I’ll talk to people, and say “well where do you go?” or “what do you do?” |
Proximity of practitioners
Participant | Example |
---|---|
#47 | I'm trying to negotiate, or try and meet some new people [practitioners] up here in [town], so I don’t have to travel so far. |
#15 | I’m [currently] trying to find somewhere [any practitioner] nearby… |
#3 | I thought, “well what am I going to do?” So I looked up, and I found this person, and this was really off-the-cuff, who was close by at [suburb] where we lived at the time… |
#27 | But normally, it is word of mouth, or the yellow pages, or the Internet, its hit and miss. |
I might look up, depending how quickly I want to get there, look up the Yellow Pages, what I usually do. Sometimes I’ll ring a couple of them and just ask a few questions. | |
#18 | So I thought “well, nothing ventured nothing gained,” so I gave a ring, gave a call, and it turns out that he just lives down the road from me here, and that's where he practices from. So I just think “well, give it a try.” |
#28 | Just picked him out of the book, the phonebook I think. |
Credentials and measures of validity
Participant | Example |
---|---|
#3 | And I, as far as I can, I make sure that they’re registered with whatever body is relevant to that particular practice… Online, and researching it that way. And I know that there is a list of physiotherapists who are trained in dry needling, and that’s the term that they use on the Internet, so it’s all listed there, they even have the qualifications that they have done, whether it’s the introductory course, whether its lower sections or upper sections of the body, it’s very specific. |
#19 | Oh, I don’t think that qualifications are particularly helpful, it’s only by experience with them and working with them that you start to work out whether they’ve got the goods or not |
#12 | It impressed me with the initials after her name because there are a lot of people around that don’t have the qualifications, and you’ve got to be very careful about that, because they can do you lot of damage as well. |
#18 | I am conscious that they do need to be qualified, not just some person that decides to put their name and practice in something. So you know, the qualifications is probably part of the judgement you sort of make, yeah. |
#25 | And people don’t necessarily have to have the high qualifications to be really good at what they do you know, some people just have that natural affinity for touch, and they can just do it, they’re brilliant. And I'm open to all of that. |
#35 | Now with chiropractic, that's a little bit easier in that you can see their degree, you can see a chiropractic degree, and in this case with my current bloke, I can see he's got his degree and he’s done his Masters in something else, and Masters in something else, and is doing one in public health at the moment. And I think “well, he's not an idiot,” and “he’s not someone who’s gone and printed something off the computer for you know, a certificate, that doesn't mean anything, and I can see that it came from which university. So I like to see that up first. With Bowen or massage or something, that's a little bit trickier…I think I saw her certificates and stuff up on the wall, but really honestly, that doesn't mean anything to someone like me. I can't, that you know, if the Bowen Therapists Association or something or other has issued a certificate, it probably doesn't mean much to anyone who isn't already doing Bowen maybe you know, if you're not involved in it already, you probably won't know whether that means much or not. |