Background
Results
Training in point-of-care ultrasound
Timing and length of training
Educational methods
Educational method | Utility |
---|---|
Didactic lectures | Effective for new learners to process the basics of ultrasound, knobology, introductions to specific applications. An interactive approach is helpful, with immediate demonstration of concepts on an ultrasound machine. Online didactics may be used to save instructor time |
Procedural task trainers | Individual procedure-oriented trainers such as central line, thoracentesis and paracentesis mannequins, as well as ultrasound-compatible gel-blocks for IV placement |
Ultrasound trainers | More costly, comprehensive ultrasound models manufactured by several companies capable of replicating the scanning experience, image acquisition and interpretation. Ultrasound trainers can be used to display idealized normal anatomy, or a variety of expandable pathologies |
Live models | Represent a good resource, especially for students immediately after initial didactics. These can be standardized patients or individual learners who are part of the course (if comfort level permits) and are usually used to achieve standard views with normal anatomy. Often rated highly by students |
Direct patient scanning | A powerful way for learners to solidify their knowledge. Usually positioned after learners acquire basic image acquisition and interpretation skills, it can be structured as a known or unknown assessment to increase challenge. Often very highly rated by students |
Individual portfolio creation | A method to allow continued, independent learning. The learner acquires a collection of saved exams, which is later reviewed and appraised by an instructor |
Resident supervision/continued quality assurance
Point-of-care ultrasound applications
CWRU | UMN | OHSU | BU | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Procedural guidance
| ||||
Central venous catheterization | + | + | + | + |
Paracentesis | + | + | + | + |
Thoracentesis | + | + | + | + |
Arthrocentesis | + | − | − | − |
Lumbar puncture | # | − | # | − |
Peripheral access | + | − | − | + |
Peripherally inserted central catheter (PICC) | − | − | − | − |
Cardiac
| ||||
Pericardial effusion | + | + | + | + |
Left ventricular contractility | + | + | + | + |
Right ventricular enlargement | + | + | + | + |
Chamber size/wall thickness | # | + | # | + |
Severe valvular abnormalities | # | − | − | + |
Other valvular abnormalities | − | − | − | − |
Right atrial pressure (IVC) | + | + | + | + |
Wall motion abnormalities | # | − | − | # |
Pulmonary
| ||||
Pleural effusions | + | + | + | + |
Pulmonary edema | + | + | + | + |
Consolidation | + | + | # | + |
Pneumothorax | + | + | + | + |
Abdomen
| ||||
Ascites | + | + | + | + |
Bladder volume | + | + | + | + |
Hydronephrosis | + | + | + | + |
Organomegaly | # | + | # | − |
AAA | + | − | # | # |
Gallbladder | # | − | − | # |
Vascular
| ||||
Lower extremity DVT | + | − | # | + |
Musculoskeletal
| ||||
Cellulitis/abscess | + | + | + | + |
Muscle/tendon tears | − | − | − | − |
Joint effusions | + | − | − | − |
Fracture | # | − | − | − |
Ophthalmologic
| ||||
Optic nerve sheath diameter | − | − | − | − |
Resources and interdepartmental collaboration
Equipment
Faculty
Discussion
Conclusions
CWRU | UMN | OHSU | BU | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Timeline of curriculum | PGY-1: 2 half day mixed didactic and hands-on sessions
Implemented 2013
PGY-2/3: optional 2-week elective (30 h/week)
Implemented 2015
ALL: interspersed hour long didactics throughout the 3 years of training (based on faculty availability)
Implemented 2015
| PGY-1: 25 h of training during intern orientation (all interns)
Implemented 2012
PGY-2/3: optional 40 h “advanced course”
Implemented 2014
Procedural service also available as a 2-week elective
Implemented 2016
| PGY-1: 3 half day mixed didactic and hands-on sessions
Implemented 2014
PGY-2/3: optional 2 to 3-week elective (30 h/week)
Implemented 2014
| PGY 1: ultrasound-guided procedural training during orientation (8 h) plus several sessions throughout the year (6 h) + OSCE
Implemented 2012
PGY-2/3: optional 1 week elective (36 h)
Implemented 2014
Procedural service which relies heavily on ultrasound also available as elective (40 h/week)
Implemented 2007
|
Primary educational methods | Combination of didactics with supervised scanning using task trainers, ultrasound simulators and live ultrasound models For optional advanced elective, direct scanning of hospitalized patients | Intro course: largely web-based video didactics with quizzes, extensively uses of scanning of models, use of ultrasound simulators, and procedural task trainers Advanced course uses similar techniques, with addition of 25 h of scanning patients on wards | Didactic lectures alternating with hands-on scanning practice. Uses ultrasound simulators, and procedural task trainers | Didactic lectures followed by task trainers for procedures. Practice scanning on learners and ultrasound simulator followed by bedside patient scanning |
Equipment | Multiple dedicated laptop and hand-held machines on wards and in simulation center available for resident use (hospital funded) | Multiple dedicated laptop machines on wards (hospital funded) and in simulation center (university funded) | Multiple dedicated laptop machines on wards (some hospital, some university funded) and simulation center (university funded). Have not yet received requested funding for hand-held units | Multiple laptop and larger machines based in ICU with loans to floor, and simulation center (all hospital funded) |
Image management | Images uploaded to a dedicated network drive | Residents may keep portfolios and submit interpretations submitted manually starting with advanced course Process to use PACS and EMR in development | Middleware (see resources paragraph) | Locally stored on machines Residents may keep portfolios and submit manually as part of 1 week ultrasound elective |
Quality assurance | Resident image review occurs from faculty supervision at the time of image acquisition | No formal system specific to residents. Exists in many clinical departments that residents rotate through | Weekly image review sessions for residents on elective, clinical image QA varies by department | No formal system. Confirmatory studies highly encouraged/stressed during didactics |
Primary faculty involved | Hospitalists | Hospitalists, critical care | Hospitalists, emergency medicine, anesthesia | Critical care, cardiology, ER staff (case review during elective), internists at early stages |