Introduction
Gaucher disease (GD) is one of the most common autosomal recessive lysosomal storage diseases caused by variants in the acid β-glucosidase (
GBA1) gene, which encodes the glucocerebrosidase enzyme [
1]. Deficiency of enzymatic activity leads to progressive glucocerebrosidase accumulation, primarily in the mononuclear phagocyte system, within macrophages [
2]. GD is a multisystemic disease with heterogeneous phenotypes; however, it is clinically classified into three types based on age of onset, neurological involvement, and disease progression [
3]. Type 1 (non-neuronopathic) is the most common subtype and presents with early onset of symptoms, hematological involvement, hepatosplenomegaly, and skeletal manifestations. Type 2 GD (acute neuronopathic) is the most serious subtype and presents in early infancy with rapid brain deterioration. Type 3 GD (chronic neuronopathic) is a subacute form where clinical expressions start in childhood and adolescence [
3,
4].
The
GBA1 gene, located on chromosome 1q22, has a highly homologous pseudogene sequence. Thus, variant detection is not easy, and amplification primers are required to discriminate between the functional gene and the pseudogene. More than 721 different
GBA1 gene variants have been reported in GD [
5]. Numerous variants have been associated with specific clinical characteristics; however, genotype-phenotype correlation is characterized by variable expression and appearance in different individuals and ethnic groups. The most frequent variants in GD patients are c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) and c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) [
6]. The most frequent variant recognized in Romanian patients is p.(Asn409Ser) [
7], while c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) and c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) are common in Spain [
6]. In Ashkenazi Jewish patients, the p.(Asn409Ser) variant, along with c.84dupG (84GG) and IVS2 + 1G > A, represent approximately 96% of variants, whereas in non-Jewish patients these three account for 50–60% of variants [
8]. In Caucasian patients, 60–70% of variants are c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser), c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro), and c.1342G > C p.(Asp448His) [
8].
Thus, c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) variant has not been associated with neurological involvement and is usually found in type 1 GD. The c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) variant is associated with neurological manifestations and typically allied with type 2 or type 3 GD, even in the heterozygous form [
6,
8]. Moreover, the c.680 A > G p.(Asn227Ser) and c.1180G > T p.(Val394Leu) alleles are linked to type 3 GD, accompanied by myoclonic epilepsy [
9]. This study was designed to identify variants in Egyptian GD patients living in an area of high consanguinity and correlate their genotypes with clinical characteristics.
Discussion
In this study, we describe the clinical characteristics and GBA1 variant spectrum of 68 patients with GD from Upper (southern) Egypt, all of whom received GD-specific enzyme replacement therapy, imiglucerase (Cerezyme®), at the hematology units of Assiut and Ain Shams University Children’s Hospitals. GD exhibits significant heterogeneity in both clinical manifestations and genetic variation, a phenomenon evident in our patient cohort. Clinically, patients exhibited a wide range of phenotypes associated with GD; 30 patients (44.1%) were classified as type 1, 3 patients (4.4%) as type 2, and 35 patients (51.5%) as type 3. Among those with the most severe manifestations, we identified patients with progressive central nervous system involvement, with fatalities occurring as early as 1.5 years of age. At the other end of the spectrum, we identified a patient with mild disease diagnosed at the age of 57 years after the detection of GD in family members. The former patient was homozygous for c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro), whereas the latter was homozygous for c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser), a variant often associated with very mild disease.
Although GD is an autosomal recessive disease, we observed a male predominance with a 2:1 ratio. This is consistent with previous Egyptian studies that reflect cultural behavior in Upper Egypt, where males receive greater medical care and attention [
12]. In Upper Egypt, GD is the most diagnosed sphingolipidosis and the second most common lysosomal storage disease after mucopolysaccharidoses. It results from biallelic pathogenic variants in the
GBA1 gene, located on chromosome 1q21, which comprises 11 exons [
13]. More than 700 distinct
GBA1 variants have been reported globally, with distribution varying significantly by population [
14]. The most common variants worldwide include c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) (previously N370S); c.1448 T > C p.(Leu483Pro) (previously L444P); c.115 + 1G > A (previously IVS2 + 1G > A); and c.84dupG p.(Leu29AlafsTer18) (previously 84 GG [84-85insG]) [
15].
The results of this study show that the most frequent
GBA1 variant was c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) (50.7%), followed by c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) (7.35%), matching other Egyptian studies that reported the
c.1448T > C variant in 50–60% of cases [
16,
17]. Our findings also align with studies from Turkey, Iran, and the JAPAC region (China, India, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, and the Philippines) [
18‐
22]; however, some populations report lower prevalences ranging between 18.5% and 25% [
7,
23,
24]. In European, American, Brazilian, Venezuelan, and Jewish populations, c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) is the most frequently reported variant [
25‐
28]. Thus, c.1226 A > G variant prevalence declines from west to east, whereas the prevalence of the c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) variant increases in the same direction.
In our study, the pathogenic c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) variant was detected in both homozygous and compound heterozygous forms, with frequencies of 45.8% and 10.3%, respectively. In the homozygous state, this variant was associated with type 2 (3/3; 100%) and type 3 (28/35; 80%) phenotypes. Among patients with type 1 GD, c.1448T > C appeared in a heterozygous combination with c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser), c.1604G > A p.(Arg535His), and c.380 C > G p.( Ala127Gly) in 3 out of 30 cases (10%). These patients require close monitoring due to their subtle course and potential late neurological manifestations.
Genotype–phenotype correlation in GD is not absolute. In our study, several patients homozygous for c.1448T > C were initially diagnosed as type I GD based on early presentations of hepatosplenomegaly and cytopenia without neurological manifestations. However, with long-term follow-up, these patients developed supranuclear gaze palsy and cognitive impairment, prompting reclassification to type 3 GD. This occurred despite ongoing enzyme replacement therapy, which appeared to delay, but did not prevent neurological progression [
17]. Conversely, some patients initially classified as type 3 based on neurological involvement were reclassified to type 2 due to rapid clinical deterioration and early mortality. Notably, survival beyond two years is atypical for classical type 2 GD. While the homozygous L444P mutation is traditionally linked to Type 3 Gaucher disease [
12], our study shows that, in uncommon instances it could lead to a phenotype resembling Type 2, possibly as a result of unidentified genetic modifiers or hidden variants [
29]. Additional genomic and functional investigations are necessary to clarify the mechanisms underlying this unusual severity.
Despite having the neuropathic
GBA1 genotype, Egyptian patients with type 3 GD often exhibit a milder phenotype and improved outcomes with enzyme replacement therapy, suggesting potential modifying genes that enhance prognosis following treatment [
30‐
32]. However, not all patients with neuropathic GD carry the c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) variant. In our study, we identified two known variants associated with type 3 GD. The c.710 A > C p.(Lys237Thr) variant, one of the most common variants globally, was found in two patients in the homozygous state, and in one patient in compound heterozygosity with c.754T > A p.(Phe252lle). The latter is a unique pathogenic variant in Asian populations and has been reported in three neuronopathic GD patients in Morocco [
33,
34].
The second GAB1 variant identified in this study was the missense c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) variant. It was detected in four patients in the homozygous state and in two patients in the heterozygous state, all of whom were diagnosed with GD type 1 without neurological involvement. The frequency of this variant is consistent with previous Egyptian studies, which reported it in 8.7% of 195 patients (34 alleles out of 390) [
12]. The c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) variant is prevalent among Ashkenazi Jews, comprising 75–80% of alleles; however, it is rare or absent in populations such as the Japanese [
8,
35,
36]. This variant is considered neuroprotective, being exclusive to type 1 patients. The compound heterozygous variant c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro)/c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser) was found in one patient. The two alleles are rarely found together in Egyptian cohorts, except for isolated cases reported by Khalifa et al. [
17] and Fateen et al. [
12]. In contrast, this genotype is more frequent in Spanish and Portuguese populations [
37].
This study detected known
GBA1 homozygous variants: c.847T > C p.(Tyr283His) and c.1604G > A p.(Arg535His), detected in two patients each, and c.1193G > A p.(Arg398Gln) and c.1342G > C p.(Asp448His), detected in one patient each. Additionally, c.475 C > T p.(Arg159Trp) and c.680 A > G p.(Asn227Ser) was detected in two patients as compound heterozygous variants. All these variants were detected in type 1 GD patients and were previously reported in the literature. Furthermore, our study identified two different recombinant alleles in six of our patients (4.4% of total alleles and 8.8% of patients). To date, over 20 recombinant
GBA1 alleles have been identified, with RecNcil and Recdelta55 being most prevalent, either alone or in conjunction with other point variants [
38,
39]. RecNcil originates from a cross-over between intron 9 and exon 10, leading to the incorporation of a C.P1 segment into the functional
GBA1 gene, including the missense variants c.1448 T > C p.(L483P), c.1483G > C p.(A495P), and c.1497G > C p.(V499 V). Recdelta55 [c.1265_1319del p.(Leu422fs)] involves a 55-bp deletion in exon 9 of the
GBA1 gene, corresponding to the deleted portion of the pseudogene [
40]. Recombinant alleles that include the 55-bp deletion in exon 9 were reported with other point variants or with RecNcil [
41,
42].
In our study, the recombinant variant RecNcil (c.1574G > A/RecNcil) was identified in a compound heterozygous state in two patients with type 1 GD. Interestingly, a complex and rare variant resulting from the recombination of Rec1263del55 and RecNcil alleles was identified in four patients (5.88%) with type 3 GD in a compound heterozygous form with c.1448T > C p.(Leu483Pro) [
40]. Nevertheless, these patients exhibit phenotypic heterogeneity. The frequency of recombinant alleles (Rec) in our study was lower than previously reported rates, which include 38.1% in Egyptian patients with type 1 GD [
16], and 9.5–21% reported in other international studies [
23,
43].
Our study identified known GBA1 variants such as c.847T > C p.(Tyr283His), c.1604G > A p.(Arg535His), each in two patients, and c.1193G > A p.(Arg398Gln), c 1342G > C (p Asp448Hs); each in one patient, all were homozygous. Additionally, c.475 C > T p.(Arg159Trp) and c.680 A > G p.(Asn227Ser) were identified in two patients as compound heterozygous variants. All variants were identified in type 1 GD patients, as previously documented in the literature. In addition, our study revealed seven novel variants in 22% of our cohort: c.263 C > T p.(Met88Thr) and c.1331 A > G p.(Asp444Gly) each in four homozygous patients; c.1409 C > T p.(Ser470Phe) in three patients; and c.907 C > G p.(Leu303Val) in one patient, all in homozygous form. The remaining variants, c.1574G > A p.(Gly525Asp) and c.380 C > G p.(Ala127Gly), were each found in one patient as compound heterozygous variants along with the other known variants. All patients carrying these novel variants exhibited reduced enzyme levels and clinical symptoms characteristic of type 1 GD, without neurological signs during disease progression. None of these variants have been previously reported in PubMed or publicly available databases such as ClinVar, HGMD, or dbSNP.
In addition, a splice-site variant, c.453 + 2T > C in intron 4, was identified and located within the intronic regions. Although its exact protein has not been determined, it may be disease-related due to a splicing alteration. This variant was detected in a 22-year-old female patient with type 1 GD, in heterozygosity with c.1226 A > G p.(Asn409Ser). We found a high rate of consanguinity (77.9%) in our cohort, resulting in the high frequency of homozygous variants (80%). The Middle East, particularly Upper Egypt, has some of the world’s highest consanguinity rates (21–33%), contributing to elevated homozygosity even among non-related couples in rural communities due to the long-standing national traditions [
44].
Publisher’s note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.