Introduction
Gitelman syndrome (GS, OMIM 263800), one of the most common hereditary disorders of potassium homeostasis, is characterized by hypokalemia, hypomagnesemia, and hypocalciuria without hypertension [
1,
2]. The prevalence of GS is approximately 1–10 per 40,000 people, and, accordingly, the prevalence of heterozygotes is approximately 1% in Western countries [
3,
4]. In Asia, the prevalence of GS increases to an astonishing 10.3 per 10,000 people [
5], and the prevalence of mutations may be as high as 3% [
3].
Inherited in an autosomal recessive pattern, GS is caused by inactivating mutations in the solute carrier family 12 member 3 gene (SLC12A3, Gene ID: 6559; MIM: 600968; Gene Bank: NC_000016.10), which encodes the thiazide-sensitive sodium-chloride cotransporter (NCC) [
6]. To date, 453 mutations have been deposited in the Human Gene Mutation Database (HGMD,
http://www.hgmd.cf.ac.uk/). Interestingly, the phenotype of GS patients is highly heterogeneous [
7]. Some researchers have analyzed the clinical and genetic characteristics in unrelated patients with GS. However, a comprehensive genotype and phenotype correlation has not been well established. Moreover, pedigree members have identical geographic backgrounds and similar dietary habits. The careful study of GS pedigrees may help to obtain more valuable information about this disorder.
The long-term prognosis of GS is considered to be favorable. However, hypokalemia and hypomagnesemia in GS are difficult to cure. Patients exhibit a significantly reduced quality of life due to the presence of several unspecific symptoms, such as salt cravings, thirst, dizziness, fatigue, muscle weakness, cramps, paresthesias, nocturia, polydipsia, and polyuria. Compared with the typical population, patients with GS may be at increased risk for the development of chronic kidney disease and type 2 Diabetes [
8]. Therefore, follow-up study is imperative for in-depth research to seek out a better method for GS treatment and to prevent further exacerbation of the disease.
Thus, we analyzed the clinical and genetic characteristics among all the members of 13 GS pedigrees, and continuous follow-up was performed for about 3 years to accumulate valuable data on the treatment of GS. Our research may assist in the understanding of phenotypic variability and provide useful insight into the characteristics of GS as well as therapeutic strategies for this disease.
Discussion
In this study, we summarized and analyzed the genotype and phenotype associations of all the members from 13 GS pedigrees. As expected, male patients had more severe hypokalemia and associated neuromuscular symptoms than females. Importantly, we found that the 24-h sodium urine excretion was significantly higher in heterozygous individuals than in healthy controls, though there was no difference in blood pressure levels between them. Continuous 3-year follow-up showed the difficulty of correcting hypokalemia and hypomagnesemia in GS patients, especially the former. Remarkably, we identified two novel SLC12A3 mutations that enriched the mutation database. Our findings may facilitate the understanding of the clinical and genetic characteristics of GS as well as therapeutic strategies for this disease.
Different from previous studies which focused on the genotype and phenotype of GS patients, we performed an innovatively contrastive analysis of the clinical and genetic characteristics of patients, carriers, and healthy controls in GS pedigrees. As expected, GS patients exhibited the lowest blood pressure, serum K
+ and Mg
2+ levels, and 24-h urinary Ca
2+ levels compared with the carriers and healthy controls. It is worth noting that 24-h sodium urine excretion was significantly higher in the carriers than in the healthy controls, though the blood pressure was not different between them. Diet, such as the intake of Na
+, K
+, Ca
2+, and Mg
2+ may play an important role in the serum and urine levels of Na
+, K
+, Ca
2+, and Mg
2+, respectively. Salt wasting caused by diminished NCC activity leads to lower blood pressure in GS patients. Although carriers have higher 24-h sodium urine excretion than healthy controls, they do not have lower blood pressure because of self-selected higher Na
+ intake. However, carrier children had lower blood pressures than those of the wild-type relatives because young individuals may have a lower likelihood of self-selected salt intake [
11]. This suggested that heterozygous individuals may have a potential mild salt-wasting defect and we raised the possibility that the heterozygous state might underlie additional phenotypes.
As we know, the presence of hypocalciuria and hypomagnesemia is highly predictive of the clinical diagnosis of GS, but hypocalciuria and hypomagnesemia are not always present [
12‐
15]. In our study, typical hypocalciuria and hypomagnesemia were not found in one and two patients, respectively. The reasons for normocalciuria and normomagnesemia in patients with GS remain obscure. Perhaps chronic severe hypokalemia results in secondary medullary damage and thereby compromises the function of the loop of Henle (LOH), an important site of calcium reabsorption, and induces a high distal delivery of calcium that exceeds the capacity of the DCT and connecting tubule to reabsorb this calcium [
14,
16]. Like calcium, almost all filtered Mg
2+ is reabsorbed in the LOH. Contracted extracellular fluid might lead to higher initial aldosterone levels in plasma, which could upregulate NCC in the DCT; the Mg
2+ reabsorption that depends on the reabsorption of Na
+ was also enhanced in DCT [
14]. Moreover, some unknown Mg
2+ regulators, such as ionic channels belonging to the transient receptor potential channel family, may diminish renal Mg2
+ wasting caused by SLC12A3 mutation [
17]. This could explain the normal urine calcium and blood magnesium observed in some patients with GS.
Previous research has shown that patients with deep intronic mutations and two mutated alleles probably had the most severe phenotype [
8,
18]. In the correlation between phenotype and genotype analysis in this study, we found that patients carrying intronic or nonframeshift mutations had more severe hypokalemia. The reasons for these interesting discoveries remain incompletely understood. Maybe intronic mutations alter the splicing pattern of RNA precursors and result in the deletion of one or more exons in the mature RNA, which induces a greater loss of NCC activity. It seems difficult to explain the correlation between frameshift or nonframeshift mutation and phenotype we observed. Theoretically, the frameshift mutation should have a more severe phenotype and hypokalemia, which is contrary to the phenomenon we observed. Therefore, more patients are needed to further verify this phenomenon. In addition to the genotype’s effect on phenotype, gender differences could also account for phenotype variability. We confirmed that male patients had more severe phenotypes than females since sex hormones can control the density of NCC in the DCT cells, which leads to changes the renal excretion of electrolytes [
19]. In addition, estrogens, progesterone, and PRL can increase NCC activity by increasing renal NaCl cotransporter phosphorylation [
20].
It is worth noting that 58.8% of patients never reached normal potassium levels, but only 17.6% of patients never reached normal magnesium levels after treatment. Therefore, we hypothesize that hypokalemia is more difficult to correct than hypomagnesemia, which calls for in-depth research in a large population of GS. We noticed difficulty in reaching normal serum potassium and magnesium levels because a large dose of potassium can cause serious side effect, including gastric ulcers, diarrhea, and vomiting with worsening biochemistries. Furthermore, poor adherence and irregular medication may lead to a poor curative effect, which suggests that long-acting preparations, even weekly preparations, may work better. Interestingly, we found that patients with higher blood potassium levels mainly had higher magnesium intake. The insufficient supplementation of magnesium aggravates hypokalemia and renders it refractory to cure by potassium [
21]. Therefore, for some patients with a poor effect of potassium supplementation, we can try to increase the dosage of magnesium supplementation. Previous studies reported that spironolactone might be helpful for hypokalemia to some degree, and spironolactone combined with potassium supplements tended to be more effective [
22,
23], but we did not find an advantage of spironolactone treatment. During follow-up, one GS patient developed IFG and two patients presented proteinuria. Some studies have observed the correlation between GS and DM, suggesting that long-term hypokalemia and hypomagnesemia may lead to impaired glucose metabolism. Chronic hypokalemia results in decreased insulin secretion by holding back the closure of ATP-sensitive K + channels and L-type Ca2 + channels on the β cell surface [
24,
25]. Moreover, hypomagnesemia can impair the insulin signal transduction pathway and consequently reduce the sensitivity of insulin to glucose, followed by insulin resistance [
26]. In addition, the secondary hyperreninemia and hyperaldosteronism observed in GS probably cause insulin resistance [
27]. However, the incidence of DM is also increasing. Therefore, the relationship between GS and DM still deserves further study. We will enlarge the sample size and extend the follow-up term to further clarify the correlation between them. GS patients are at high risk for CKD; however, the mechanism is indeed complicated and yet not well clarified. Some studies showed that chronic hypokalemia resulted in renal damage through the generation of renal tubule vacuolization, cyst formation, and tubulointerstitial nephritis [
8]. However, other studies demonstrated that increasing of circulating renin, angiotensin II, and aldosterone by hypokalemia-independent volume depletion might be a more important factor of renal impairment and fibrosis [
28]. Therefore, blood glucose and renal function indicators should be closely followed up in GS patients.
Notably, we identified two novel mutations (p.G212S, p.W939X) that were predicted to be pathogenic by bioinformatic analysis. Amino acid alignment analysis revealed that the glycine at position 212 and the tryptophan at position 939 were highly conserved among species. The visible differences in the whole protein configuration caused by a single base substitution further confirmed the pathogenicity of the novel mutations. All these findings indicated that the two novel SLC12A3 mutations were probably harmful and pathogenic in the GS patients. We found four recurrent mutants in SLC12A3, which would provide significant information for the screening and genetic counseling of GS. Consistent with our study, Shao, Tseng and Liu et al. also considered the missense mutations T60M and D486 N as highly frequent mutations in the Chinese population [
8,
23,
29]. Although GS is inherited in an autosomal recessive manner, up to 30% of patients have simple heterozygous mutations [
30]. We identified only one mutant allele in two patients. There are several possible reasons why we did not discover any mutations in the second allele: (a) existing sequencing methods can only screen exons and their intron–exon boundaries, which are incapable of finding mutations located in gene-regulating sequences such as the 5′-untranslated region and 3′-untranslated region, promoter and enhancer segments, or some harboring deep intronic mutations [
16]; (b) it is difficult to identify gene sequence rearrangements involving one or more exons based on single exon analysis [
31]; (c) the normal NCC protein is inactivated in some way by mutant proteins, such as kinases 1 and 4 with no lysine [
32,
33]; and (d) epigenetic modifications and/or silent polymorphisms could influence the expression of the NCC [
34]. In addition, one (approximately 5.8%) patient was determined to carry three SLC12A3 mutations, which was in line with other published reports [
23].
There are certain limitations to our study, such as the relatively small number of pedigrees and slightly short follow-up time. Nonetheless, we are still expanding the scale of the pedigrees and extending the follow-up time to perfect our research. Moreover, conclusion on the treatment is mostly based on observational study which may seem slightly unreliable relative to random control trial (RCT) study. However, our research is rigorously designed and followed up regularly with a dedicated person responsible for regular guidance and testing. If possible, we will design a RCT study to confirm the relevant viewpoints in the future.
In conclusion, the phenotypic variability and characteristics of GS as well as therapeutic strategies merit further research to improve the diagnosis and prognosis of this disease. Moreover, our findings suggested that 24-h sodium urine excretion may be a predictor of early NCC dysfunction and SLC12A3 heterozygous individuals may be more susceptible to diuretic-induced hypokalemia.