Background
Schizophrenia (SCZ) is associated with increased risk of obesity, impaired glucose tolerance, and type 2 diabetes (T2D) [
1]. The prevalence of T2D among patients with SCZ in European populations is estimated to be up to 22.0% [
2‐
6]. No information is available on T2D prevalence among psychiatric disease patients in Greece, whereas the current prevalence of T2D in the general Greek population has been estimated to be 11.97% (men 13.98%, women 9.25%), clearly indicating a major public health problem [
7]. T2D is a major risk factor for cardiovascular disease and the fourth highest cause of excess mortality in patients with SCZ [
8], leading to significantly shorter life expectancy [
9]. Antipsychotic-naïve individuals with a first-episode SCZ often present with elevated fasting plasma glucose, impaired oral glucose tolerance and fasting plasma insulin levels, as well as insulin resistance, possibly owing to shared disease pathways [
10]. Further factors possibly associated with the increased risk of T2D amongst patients with SCZ include ethnicity, obesity, a sedentary lifestyle, smoking, unhealthy dietary habits, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, social determinants of health, genetics, as well as long-term treatment with psychotropic drugs.
In order to investigate the epidemiological and genetic associations with cardiometabolic disease in patients with psychiatric disorders we established the GOMAP study (Genetic Overlap between Metabolic and Psychiatric disease), a new hospital-based collection of patients with psychiatric disease, with and without T2D. Commonly prescribed drugs include SGA, FGA, antidepressants, and mood stabilizers. These can be applied as monotherapy, 2-drug combination, or as 3- or more drug combinations in SCZ patients. A small number of studies have evaluated the potential diabetogenic effect of specific psychotropic drug classes.
Antidepressants and mood stabilizers have been individually associated with T2D risk. Associations between antidepressants [
11‐
17], such as amitriptyline and mirtazapine, mood stabilizers [
16,
18], such as lithium and valproate, modest weight gain and T2D have been reported, although the literature is still inconclusive [
19]. A 9-year longitudinal study of the Data from an Epidemiological Study on the Insulin Resistance Syndrome (D.E.S.I.R. cohort) reported that the association between antidepressants use and diabetes might not be causal [
20]. However, a recent meta-analysis indicated that antidepressants increase the likelihood of new-onset T2D [
21]. A further cohort study conducted between 2005 and 2015 including 2579 SCZ patients revealed an independent association between antidepressants and risk of T2D for SCZ patients [
9]. Furthermore, mood stabilizers have been found to be associated with an elevated risk for the development of insulin resistance in patients with epilepsy [
22] or depression [
23], whereas no association was found in patients with severe mental illness, with the exception of lithium [
17]. Two studies have evaluated the effects of co-prescribed medications on T2D risk and both focused on youths exposed to limited medication regiments [
24‐
26]. One of these studies [
25] found a higher risk of T2D in patients receiving SGA together with antidepressants compared with patients receiving SGA only or antidepressants only.
A better understanding of the underlying mechanism linking T2D and psychiatric disorders can provide evidence and help shape strategies for the prevention of T2D in this group of patients. Here, we have studied risk factors linking pharmacological treatment and the risk of T2D in patients with SCZ.
Results
The clinical and demographic characteristics of participants are displayed in Table
1, and treatment regimens are presented in Table
2. Of the 1653 participants with SCZ included in our analysis, 611 (36.96%) also had T2D. Our study achieved a collection of 3.2–5.9% of the entire Greek T2D and SCZ comorbid population, calculated according to the T2D general Greek population prevalence and to the European SCZ and T2D comorbidity prevalence, respectively. The whole sample included 672 women (40.7%) and 981 men (59.3%) with mean age 50.22 years (SD 14.03) and mean BMI 27.58 kg/m
2 (SD 5.77).
Table 1
Characteristics of 1390 SCZ patients with T2D (n = 536) and without T2D (n = 854)
Mean (SD)* |
Age (years) | 45.83 (12.98) | 57.07 (12.25) | < 0.0001 |
SCZ duration (years) | 18.57 (11.69) | 26.30 (11.61) | < 0.0001 |
BMI (kg/m2) | 25.97 (4.54) | 30.56 (6.75) | < 0.0001 |
n (%)** |
Male | 516 (60.42%) | 310 (57.84%) | 0.467 |
Female | 338 (39.58%) | 226 (42.16%) |
Number of subjects who reported outdoor physical activity in last week | 16 (1.87%) | 4 (0.75%) | 0.172 |
Number of subjects who reported no outdoor physical activity in last week | 838 (98.13%) | 532 (99.25%) |
Median (IQR)*** |
Number of Hospitalizations | 4.00 (3.00–7.00) | 3.00 (2.00–6.00) | < 0.0001 |
Positive Symptoms | 31.00 (27.00–36.00) | 32.00 (27.00–37.00) | 0.532 |
Negative Symptoms | 30.00 (26.50–34.00) | 30.00 (25.00–34.00) | 0.486 |
General Psychopathology Scale | 55.00 (48.00–64.00) | 54.00 (47.00–64.00) | 0.179 |
PANSS total score | 118.00 (105.00–130.50) | 117.00 (103.00–131.00) | 0.467 |
Table 2
Psychiatric medication
Monotherapy |
FGA | 246 (17.7%) | 127 (9.14%) |
SGA | 126 (9.06%) | 89 (6.40%) |
Combination Therapy |
2-Drug Combination (Antipsychotic + 1 more psychiatric medication) | 361 (25.97%) | 209 (15.04%) |
≥3-Drug Combination (Antipsychotic + 2 or more psychiatric medications) | 121 (8.71%) | 111 (7.99%) |
We considered four non-overlapping treatment categories: those receiving monotherapy with FGA antipsychotics (
n = 373), those receiving monotherapy with SGA antipsychotics (
n = 215), those under combined therapy of two psychiatric medications, one of which antipsychotic (
n = 570), and those under triple or more psychiatric medications, one of which antipsychotic (
n = 232). Consistent with the literature, our study confirms that obesity [
36,
37] and increasing age [
38,
39] represent independent risk factors for T2D in patients with SCZ (Additional file
1: Table S1). Adjusting for age and BMI (Table
3, column 1) the results indicated that sex (
p = 0.063), SGA (
p = 0.595), 2-drug combination (
p = 0.937), duration of SCZ (
p = 0.960), number of hospitalisations (
p = 0.937) and outdoor physical activity in last week (
p = 0.858), were not significantly associated with risk of T2D. However, the combined use of at least three psychotropic drugs was associated with higher risk of T2D (
p = 0.035) compared with FGA monotherapy.
Table 3
Crude and adjusted odds ratios (OR) of T2D occurrence based on logistic regression modelling among patients with SCZ
Sex (Reference group = Female) | 1.38 (1.06–1.81) | 0.063 | 1.42 (1.08–1.85)a | 0.0112 |
Psychiatric Medication (Reference group = FGA) |
SGA | 1.27 (0.84–1.93) | 0.595 | 1.27 (0.84–1.93) | 0.259 |
2-Drug Combination | 0.96 (0.69–1.33) | 0.937 | 0.98 (0.71–1.35) | 0.885 |
≥3-Drug Combination | 1.75 (1.19–2.59)b | 0.035 | 1.81 (1.22–2.69)b | 0.003 |
Number of hospitalizations | 1.00 (0.96–1.03) | 0.937 | 0.99 (0.96–1.03) | 0.749 |
Duration of SCZ | 1.00 (0.98–1.02) | 0.960 | 1.00 (0.98–1.02) | 0.975 |
Outdoor Physical activity in last week: (reference group = No) | 0.62 (0.16–2.38) | 0.858 | 0.71 (0.19–2.66) | 0.613 |
Furthermore, in multivariable logistic regression analysis that included adjustment for age, BMI, sex, duration of SCZ and number of hospitalizations, the combination use of at least three psychotropic medications [odds ratio (OR), 95% confidence intervals (CI)] [1.81 (1.22–2.69),
p = 0.003] was significantly associated with higher risk of T2D (Table
3).
We examined the genetic relationship between psychotropic medication and T2D risk in the subset of individuals who were on a polypharmacy medication regimen in the GOMAP cohort. No significant findings were observed, likely due to small sample size and low power (Additional file
1: Figure S1 and S2).
Discussion
We have established a novel case-control sample collection (GOMAP) with extensive phenotyping to examine clinical epidemiological factors that may increase the risk of T2D in patients with SCZ. We identify a previously unreported association between T2D and the concomitant prescription of three or more different psychotropic medication classes, including at least one antipsychotic, when compared to FGA monotherapy.
We do not identify SGA as a significant risk factor compared to FGA, despite high power to detect moderate effects (86% power to detect an OR of 2). Both FGA and SGA have been previously linked to an increased risk of T2D [
40‐
43]. While some studies suggest that SGA use is associated with a higher risk of T2D development compared to FGA use [
24,
44], others were inconclusive [
42]. One possible explanation is that there is no difference in diabetogenic effect between SGA and FGA [
45]. A recent meta-analysis [
17] demonstrated that individual FGA and SGA drugs were associated with higher T2D risk, but did not find a significant difference in T2D risk between drugs of these classes. In addition, a systematic review of 22 randomized control trials detected no difference in glycemic effect of antipsychotics versus placebo [
46].
It is also possible that we did not detect a difference in T2D risk between SGA and FGA use because of varying diabetogenic profiles among the individual drugs within these classes [
47‐
49]. There is conflicting evidence for differential diabetogenic effects of antipsychotics of the same class [
50]. For example [
51], the SGA aripiprazole has been associated with decreased T2D risk in first-episode patients with SCZ, while olanzapine (SGA), low-potency FGAs and clozapine (SGA) have all been found to increase T2D risk [
51]. Conversely, the SGA risperidone has been shown to confer a similar diabetogenic risk to FGAs [
52]. A further study found no statistically significant differences in fasting glucose between patients receiving FGA and SGA when patients treated with clozapine and olanzapine were excluded [
53]. Further, the inconsistency of these findings in the literature could be partly due to unmeasured confounding factors [
54], such as genetic background. For example, the Australian National Survey of Psychosis has shown that antipsychotic treatment had no additional impact on T2D risk in those with a T2D family history, whereas antipsychotics increased T2D risk in those without a T2D family history [
39].
A recent meta-analysis of studies on comorbid SCZ with T2D in China showed that duration of schizophrenia (> 10 years) is a significant risk factor for T2D development [
55]. We observed similar statistically significant results, but no association when we dichotomized SCZ duration into less or more than 10 years (OR 1.46, 95% CI: 0.89–2.4). We do not identify association between PANSS psychopathology scores, examined separately for positive symptoms, negative symptoms and the total score with T2D risk. A single study has shown an inverse relationship between PANSS score and BMI in SCZ patients, but contains no information on T2D prevalence [
56]. Moreover, we do not find an association between physical activity and T2D in SCZ; this may be due to the effect of hospitalization, which results in a largely uniform environment in terms of physical activity and nutrition.
Many combinations of different classes of medications were used for the management of SCZ in our sample; this does not allow us to perform robust sub-analysis to examine the diabetogenic effect of different classes of medications, because of the small number of patients in each category. Importantly, we identify a significant risk attributable to the potential diabetogenic effect of psychotropic combinations, which are frequently applied in SCZ treatment, though we attempted no such association analysis for antidepressants or mood stabilizers applied as monotherapy given our small sample size in these groups respectively. To date, most studies have not extensively considered other medication variables or their combinations. Similarly, a recent study [
25] on youths identified a higher risk of T2D in patients receiving SGA together with antidepressants compared with patients receiving only SGA or only antidepressants. Moreover, no difference in T2D occurrence was detected between receiving stimulants concomitantly to SGA, as compared with SGA only. There is further acknowledgement that the increase in T2D risk in SGA-exposed youths remains small. Both studies emphasize the importance of including all psychotropic regimens received by SCZ patients when analyzing T2D risk to avoid missing synergy in this direction. Our study demonstrates the effect of combined psychiatric medication on T2D risk. Given the widespread use of combined categories of psychiatric medications, we suggest future studies should prospectively explore the effect of different treatment options on type 2 diabetes incidences, in order to formulate clinical guidelines.
A limitation of our study is that we only had access to retrospective medication information of up to six months prior to study commencement. This means that metabolic adverse effects of drugs beyond that period could not be accounted for and we cannot evaluate the effect of previous treatment regimens on T2D risk. Further we cannot make inferences about T2D causality, medication dose-effect, additional medication categories effect, differences in medication effects when patients are drug-naïve, or experience first SCZ episode; nor how effective, in terms of T2D prophylaxis, switching from one medication category to another might be. Additional factors that should be considered in a study of the metabolic effects of antipsychotic medications are duration of treatment [
51,
57] and body weight before treatment initiation. Due to limited sample size it was not possible to study the effect of specific psychotropic medications, or various combinations thereof.
However, this study has examined a relatively large number of hospitalized participants, who have been carefully selected and ascertained for T2D and SCZ diagnoses based on established criteria rather than self-reporting. The homogeneity in the ethnicity of the studied population limits the potential for ancestry bias. Furthermore, our study is estimated to have collected 3.2–5.9% of the entire Greek T2D and SCZ comorbid population. We were further able to assess the effect of psychotropic medication in the context of SCZ alone, rather than having to account for several different psychiatric diagnoses [
58]. Adherence to treatment was strictly inspected.
While the genetic analysis did not yield any robust signals, it might prove useful in downstream meta-analyses. The genotype data used here have been made available through the European Genome/Phenome Archive.