Background
Pear ring rot, caused by the destructive pathogen
Botryosphaeria, is responsible for substantial economic losses through widespread fruit rots and stem canker. This caused a severe recession in the growth of pear fruit trees in China [
1‐
5]. Due to the lack of disease-resistant varieties, many fungicides are recommended for treatment of Botryosphaeria canker, which induces drug resistance and environmental pollution [
3]. It is urgent to find new, safe, and effective means to control pear ring rot disease. Mycovirus-mediated hypovirulence in plant pathogenic fungi is a powerful method to control fungal crop diseases such as the hypovirulent strain of
C. parasitica (CHV1) to heal cankers of chestnut blight, and Sclerotinia sclerotiorum hypovirulence-associated DNA virus 1 (SsHADV-1) to control the rapeseed stem rot [
6‐
13]. Recent studies of fruit tree fungal diseases have reported that the mycovirus Rosellinia necatrix megabirnavirus 1 (RnMRV1) has potential to control white root rot (
Rosellinia necatrix) diseases of fruit trees [
8]. In recent years, several dsRNA mycoviruses have been identified and sequenced in
B. dothidea strains isolated from pear trees with ring rot and stem wart symptoms in China [
14,
15]. Chrysovirus BdCV1 and partitivirus BdPV1 mixed infection results in hypovirulent
B. dothidea LW-1 strain in our study, revealing BdCV1 to be the first mycovirus found to be responsible for hypovirulence (reduced virulence), growth rate, and phenotypic sectorization of the phytopathogenic fungus
B. dothidea [
16]. BdCV1 is therefore a good candidate for biological control of apple and pear ring spot diseases, while BdPV1 does not cause any visible symptoms in virulent pathogenicity [
5,
16].
High throughput sequencing technology provided comprehensive information on gene expression. Measuring the expression patterns of mRNAs at the transcriptome level from fungi infection with mycovirus is vital to reveal the mechanism of mycovirus-mediated hypovirulence in pathogenic fungi [
6,
17,
18]. Only a limited number of studies, using high throughput sequencing technologies and bioinformatics, have demonstrated transcriptional or translational changes in fungi infection with mycovirus, such as
Cryphonectria parasitica,
Aspergillus fumigatus,
Neurospora crassa,
Sclerotinia sclerotiorum, and
Fusarium graminearum [
17‐
24]. For instance, 150 genes representing a wide spectrum of biological functions were down-regulated in the strain Ep-1PN by Sclerotinia Sclerotiorum Debilitation-associated RNA Virus (SsDRV), of which
S. sclerotiorum integrin like gene (
SSITL) was verified affect pathogenic fungus virulence and growth rate [
20,
23]. Genes associated with viral replication, maintenance of viral life cycle, transcription and translation machinery, and signal transduction were up-regulated while those including membrane-associated transporters and cellular transport systems were down-regulated based on a genome-wide transcriptome analysis of
F. graminearum infected with Fusarium graminearum virus 1 (FgV1) [
18,
21,
22,
25].
The main objective of our study is to characterize the mRNAs from
B. dothidea involved in biological processes associated with the host infecting with mycovirus. Currently, there are no studies published on the
B. dothidea transcriptome. No direct and detailed functional genomics resources in public databases for understanding the molecular mechanism of
B. dothidea exist except the draft genome sequences from two
B. dothidea strains reported, the pathogen of Apple ring rot disease and isolated from grapevine host, respectively [
26,
27]. Therefore, large-scale transcriptome sequencing using Illumina sequencing technology was performed to explore the potential mRNAs expression in
B. dothidea related to pathogenic factors and hypovirulence determinants in response to two mycoviruses BdCV1 and BdPV1.
Discussion
In this report, the transcriptome of
B. dothidea strains was sequenced using the Illumina platform. A total of high-quality 18.87 Gb bases were obtained. We then assembled 4 fungi samples occurred in
B. dothidea infection with mycovirus and obtained 30,058 Unigenes (≥200 bp). The N50 and GC content of unigenes was 3338 bp and 56.32%, respectively. We then annotated the unigenes using 7 functional databases. 24,836 (82.63%) unigenes were annotated with at least one functional database (Tables
1 and
2; Figs.
2 and
3). To the best of our knowledge, this is the first large-scale characterization of the
B. dothidea genome at transcriptome level. Our results lay the foundation for further genomics research in
Botryosphaeria species.
Previous research has demonstrated that mycovirus infections change the expression of a broad range of genes and cause hypovirulence or phenotypic alterations in the fungal host except plant [
17‐
19,
22,
38,
39].
C. parasitica infected with Cryphonectria Hypovirus 1 (CHV1) is used as a model for studies on virus/host interaction. cDNA library analysis of differentially expressed genes involved viral replication, transmission, host growth, development, and defense. The pro1 and CpBir1 genes have important biological functions for hypovirus and chestnut blight fungus host [
17,
40,
41]. In our study, RNA-Seq-based genome-wide expression profiling analysis in response to single or mixed mycovirus chrysovirus 1(BdCV1) and partitivirus 1 (BdPV1) infection was performed. The expression patterns of 9 putative genes involved in mycovirus stress measured by quantitative real-time PCR were consistent with their transcript changes as identified by RNA-seq (Table
4). It revealed specific and common alterations in host gene transcript accumulation following infection of
B. dothidea by BdCV1 and BdPV1 [
17]. As expected, more transcriptional changes occurred in response to the hypovirulent LW-CP and LW-C compared to the LW-P (Table
3; Fig.
4), revealing that chrysovirus 1(BdCV1) would have a stronger effect than partitivirus 1 (BdPV1) on the
B. dothidea transcriptome, and gene expression changes in transcriptome caused by hypovirulent and non-hypovirulent mycoviruses were related to the observed host phenotypes and pathogenicity [
17,
18]. Meanwhile, changes in differential accumulation of BdCV1 and BdPV1 in
B. dothidea strains were demonstrated that the accumulation level of BdPV1 decreased by co-infection with BdCV1 (Fig.
1). It revealed that the BdCV1 and hypovirulent determinants may inhibit the expression level of BdPV1, prediction that it is the main reason to induce to the phenotype and hypovirulence of
B. dothidea LW-1 strain (Figs.
1 and
4), which need to be further verified.
It is known that transcription factors play important roles in fungi response to mycovirus. Mycovirus can activate TFs expression differentially [
18]. In this study, 1083 transcription factors classified into 18 families were predicted. The above data revealed many TFs from
B. dothidea were expressed differentially among the mycoviruses, especially Zn2Cys6 and C2H2 zinc finger families (Table
5). This corroborates the results from the
F. graminearum transcriptome, whose differentially expressed TFs included fungal-specific and dominant Zn2Cys6 and the C2H2 zinc finger members involved in transcriptional regulation [
18,
22,
42,
43]. The results demonstrate that TFs are down-regulated in response to BdCV1 in LW-C, revealing that BdCV1 inhibits TFs expression in
B. dothdiea (Table
5; Additional file
9: Table S9). In addition, a class of heat shock proteins (HSPs) was up-regulated in response to mycovirus infection (Additional file
6: Table S6), which supports the speculation that HSPs homologues are influenced by mycovirus [
17].
To better survey the biological behavior of defense response, it is necessary to understand the functional distribution of these DEGs in
B. dothidea following mycovirus infection based on the transcriptome and bioinformatics analysis [
44‐
47]. Through the enriched GO terms analysis, it is also revealed that in biological processes, DEGs mainly distributed to metabolism. Differential expression of genes related to metabolism might be associated with the host phenotype [
17,
39,
48]. In addition, GO terms for genes associated with signal transduction, including phosphatidylinositol signaling system and MAPK signaling pathway were more enriched in response to infection by BdCV1 compared to BdPV1. This reveals that it is necessary to determine the role of the MAPK signaling pathway in the regulation of mycovirus and host interactions [
25]. Genes involved in membrane, oxidoreductase activity, RNA biosynthetic processing, and ribosomal assembly were enriched in
B. dothidea following mycovirus infection (Fig.
5; Additional file
11: Table S11), which indicates the diversity of genes affected by mycoviral infection. Furthermore, KEGG pathway analysis uncovered DEGs involved in important pathways. A mass of metabolism pathways, both primary and biosynthesis of secondary metabolism, are identified and significantly enriched in response to mycovirus infection (Fig.
6; Additional file
12: Table S12). Similar metabolic pattern is exhibited in different fungi-virus combinations, which indicated these pathways play important role in fungi host in response to mycoviral infection [
17,
18,
22]. In addition, ‘carbohydrate metabolism’, ‘lipid metabolism’, ‘membrane transport system’, ‘transport and catabolism’, ‘translation’ and ‘signal transduction’ which were highly enriched (Fig.
6; Additional file
12: Table S12). It also provides insight into the various biological pathways associated with mycoviral infection with plant pathogenic fungi.
RNAi machinery is involved in the regulation of fungi and mycovirus infection by controlling endogenous and exogenous RNA [
49]. Indeed, the biological functions of the RNA silencing pathway have been characterized in the
Neurospora crassa,
Cryphonectria parasitaica,
Rosellinia necatrix, and
F. graminearum [
50‐
56]. As reported, FgAGO-1 and FgDICER-2 are responsible for hairpin RNA-triggered RNA silencing and related small interfering RNA accumulation in
F. graminearum [
18,
49,
51]. In this study, RNA interference components, including dicer-like (
Dicer), argonaute-like (
Ago), and
RdRp genes in
B. dothidea were expressed differentially in response to mycovirus infection (Additional file
5: Table S5). Small RNA sequencing demonstrates that microRNA exists and is expressed differentially in
B. dothidea infection with mycovirus (not published). This suggests that
B. dothidea possesses RNA silencing pathways for antiviral defense and endogenous gene regulation. These data indicate that mycovirus may activate host antiviral defense. Furthermore, it is necessary to determine and analyze the RNA silencing component responsible for transcriptional regulation and antiviral defense mechanism in
B. dothidea.
Conclusions
In this study, 30,058 unigenes were obtained from hypovirulent and non-hypovirulent
B. dothidea strains infected with mycovirus by
de novo assembly. To identify potential mycovirus-responsive genes, DEGs were screened and further validated by RT-qPCR. Hierarchical clustering, which identifies gene sets of significantly differentially expressed genes occurred in
B. dothidea infection with mycovirus, was performed. The expression analysis demonstrates that hypovirulent mycoviruse chrysovirus 1 (BdCV1) have a stronger effect than non-hypovirulent mycoviruse patittivirus 1 (BdPV1) on the
B. dothidea transcriptome. This data indicates that the phenotypes and pathogenicity observed for mycovirus-infected
B. dothidea are correlated with the numbers of DEGs and mycovirus variety [
17,
18]. In addition, we found that most
B. dothidea TFs were differentially expressed by each mycovirus, suggesting that fungal TFs have important roles in the response to mycovirus infection. Gene ontology (GO) enrichment and KEGG functional pathway analysis revealed that differential expression mRNAs played important roles in regulating the complex biological processes involved in
B. dothidea infection with mycovirus. The obtained transcriptome data can provide molecular genomics resource for further functional characterization analysis of
B. dothidea in response to mycovirus infection.