Urothelial carcinoma is the most common tumor arising in the urinary tract [
4], and the most common variants have glandular or squamous differentiation [
1]. Little is known, however, about urothelial carcinoma with predominantly clear cells, other than the few clinical cases reported previously, as listed in Table
2[
5].
Table 2
Bibliographic references of case reports of clear cell urothelial carcinoma
71 M | Painless hematuria | Left wall involvement into perivesical fat | Glycogen positive | Prostatic adenocarcinoma | Death after 20 months | |
Mucin negative | Gleason grade 2+3 (>25%) | 1995 |
PSA negative |
PSAP negative |
EM: no gland formation |
58 F | Dysuria and infected urethral cyst with pyuria | Urethral involvement with invasion | Glycogen positive | | Data not available | |
1995 |
Mucin negative |
70 F | Intermittent, gross hematuria | Right upper ureter stenosing lesion | Glycogen positive | | Alive at six months | |
Mucin negative | 1997 |
70 M | Frequency, urgency, anuria | Red, irregular mucosa Invasion within 0.5mm of detrusor muscle. | | | Data not available | |
1997 |
70 M | Asymptomatic hematuria | Left wall tumor, muscle invasive, treated with TURBt | | History of clear cell renal cell carcinoma, pulmonary metastasis | No recurrence after | |
2006 |
seven months |
69 F | Gross hematuria | Right wall tumor, treated with TURBt | | Chronic renal failure, hemodialysis treatment | No recurrence after | |
2010 |
20 months |
82 M | Asymptomatic | Deep infiltration of muscularis propria | GATA3+ | History of clear cell renal cell carcinoma, | Alive at 12 months | |
UroVysion fluorescence in situ hybridization |
Furhman grade 2 |
2010 |
67 M | Progressive lower urinary tract symptoms | Bilateral ureteral stenosis due to muscle invasive mass in trigone, treated with TURBt | | | Death at 14 weeks | |
2012 |
75 M | Intermittent hematuria | Right wall with near obliteration of ureter and invasion into fat | Glycogen positive | Prostatic adenocarcinoma | Alive at ten months | Present case |
Mucin negative | Gleason grade 3+3 (<5%) | 2013 |
Lipid negative |
| | | PSA negative | | | |
Although the presence of clear cells in otherwise typical urothelial carcinoma is not uncommon [
3,
4], the tumor in this case had clear cells far in excess of what is normally seen in urothelial carcinoma. To the best of our knowledge, no study to date has shown that clear cell dysplasia progresses to clear cell urothelial carcinoma [
3,
4]. “In fact, the infrequent reporting of clear-cell transitional cell carcinoma, when compared with the relatively common observation of clear-cell dysplasia, makes this unlikely,” per Braslis
et al.[
4].
Regarding PAS staining, Braslis and colleagues similarly reported dense and spotty positivity for cytoplasmic glycogen in one of their cases of clear cell urothelial carcinoma (Table
2) [
4]. Normal urothelium contains glycogen, and positive reactivity of urothelial carcinomas for glycogen was explored by Kotliar and colleagues [
6]. They selected 24 random urothelial carcinomas ranging from low-grade superficial papillary tumors to high-grade invasive tumors [
6]. Approximately two thirds of tumors, despite their non-clear cytoplasm, showed varying degrees of PAS positivity that disappeared with diastase digestion (PAS-D). The overall apparent pattern of PAS/PAS-D reactivity correlated with tumor grade; in general, low-grade superficial urothelial cell carcinomas tended to have stronger diffuse staining, whereas poorly differentiated tumors tended to have negative or focal positivity [
6].
Differential diagnosis
The finding of a clear cell carcinoma in the urinary tract usually implies the diagnosis of an adenocarcinoma [
6]. Clear cell adenocarcinomas show a distinct predominance affecting the female urethra, although it may occur in men and in the urinary bladder [
6]. These adenocarcinomas are characterized by tubules, cysts, papillae, or diffuse sheets of clear cells containing abundant, clear glycogen-rich cytoplasm [
1]. The tumor cells lining the tubules and cysts may be cuboidal, hobnail, or flattened and usually show strong immunostaining for PAX 8 [
1,
8]. A signet-ring cell type is observed in some cases and is distinguished by abundant intracytoplasmic mucin globules of varying size displacing the nucleus to the cell periphery [
4]. By contrast, clear cell urothelial carcinomas, as observed in our case, do not show luminal formation or hobnail cells, and are mucin and PAX8 negative.
The lipoid-cell variant of urothelial carcinoma could also be considered in the differential diagnosis. De Giorgi and colleagues described a bladder tumor featuring poorly differentiated, pleomorphic cells with nuclear pleomorphism and large, optically clear intracytoplasmic vacuoles imparting an adipocytic appearance [
9]. Leroy and colleagues did stains on such tumors and found that mucin stain, alcian blue and PAS stains were negative, implying lipid content [
10]. By contrast, clear cell urothelial carcinomas, as observed in our case (oil red O negative), show no lipid cytoplasmic content.
Though less likely in the differential diagnoses, we could still consider a nephrogenic adenoma, especially the variant of a nephrogenic adenoma-like clear cell carcinoma. Herawi and colleagues did a study comparing clear cell adenocarcinoma, nephrogenic adenoma-like clear cell adenocarcinoma, and nephrogenic adenoma [
11]. Features discriminating nephrogenic adenoma-like clear cell adenocarcinoma from nephrogenic adenoma included occasional clear cells, a prominent pleomorphism, and extensive muscular invasion [
11]. The cytologic atypia of nephrogenic adenoma falls short of that seen in our case of clear cell urothelial carcinoma. In addition, nephrogenic adenoma has a low Ki-67 rate (0% to 5%) and is negative for p53, whereas in our case the Ki-67 and p53 nuclear expressions were very high (>70% and approximately 30%, respectively) [
11].
The most likely clear cell metastatic disease to consider would be renal cell carcinoma. However, renal cell carcinoma metastasis to the bladder is very rare, with only approximately 30 cases reported in the literature [
7]. On histology, renal cell carcinoma is frequently characterized by compact nests of cells with clear, abundant cytoplasm and delicate blood vessels [
12]. This vascular network was not present in our case. In difficult cases, immunohistochemistry may be helpful. Renal cell carcinoma is typically negative for CK7 and CK20, but positive for RCC antigen, CAM 5.2, Vimentin, and PAX 8, in contrast to our case presented here [
7].
Clear cell carcinomas can also arise from other organs including prostate, lung, breast, uterus, ovary, and vagina [
4,
5,
7]. The latter sites are in females, and thus not applicable to this case. Prostatic origin however, is a consideration because our patient was discovered to have prostatic adenocarcinoma. Nevertheless, the prostate cancer observed in this case was low grade and focal (<5% of the gland was involved). As described previously, no glandular formation was seen in the bladder tumor, the clear cell vacuoles were negative for lipid content (lipid material has been reported in prostatic adenocarcinoma [
4]), and the tumor was p63 positive and PSA negative.
Before identifying the tumor as a carcinoma, we also considered metastatic melanoma, clear cell sarcoma, and seminoma. These other possibilities were excluded by negative staining for S-100 protein, HMB-45, CD117, and PLAP, whereas positive staining for CK7 supported the diagnosis of carcinoma.
Prognosis
The clinical course of clear cell variant urothelial carcinoma of the bladder is currently not known due to the lack of a larger number of cases (Table
2) [
5]. Our patient in this case was alive ten months after initial presentation. In one of the cases reported by Braslis and colleagues, the longest patient survival was reported as at a six-month follow-up [
4]. A less aggressive course was also reported in two patients who were treated with transurethral resection of the bladder tumor; even though one had detrusor muscle invasion, both were free from recurrence after seven and 20 months [
5,
7,
13].
In a case report by Kramer and colleagues, the urothelial clear cell carcinoma showed a very aggressive behavior with rapid local recurrence and development of peritoneal carcinomatosis from which the patient survived only 14 weeks after diagnosis [
5]. A similar aggressive course was described by Kotliar and colleagues, in which a 71-year-old man underwent a radical cystoprostatectomy and two pelvic lymph nodes were found to be positive for metastatic disease; despite adjuvant chemotherapy, their patient died after 20 months [
5,
6].