Introduction
Methods
Objectives
1. What is the overall epidemiology and disease burden of severe RSV infection in Western countries, and what are the associated risk factors for RSVH? 2. What is the predisposition and associated morbidity, long-term sequelae and mortality of preterm infants (<37 wGA) without CLD/BPD or CHD, overall, and split by gestational age segments, to severe RSV infection, and what are the risk factors associated with RSVH? 3. What is the predisposition and associated morbidity, long-term sequelae and mortality of infants with underlying CLD/BPD to severe RSV infection in Western countries? 4. What is the predisposition and associated morbidity, long-term sequelae and mortality of infants with underlying CHD to severe RSV infection in Western countries? 5. What is the nature, incidence and impact of long-term respiratory morbidity associated with RSVH in infancy in Western countries, specifically early and late wheeze? 6. What other groups of infants with underlying medical conditions or chronic diseases are at high risk of RSVH and associated morbidity? 7. What are the optimal approaches and strategies for the prevention and treatment of severe RSV infection and what are the future perspectives in this regard? |
Search Strategy and Selection Criteria
Data Synthesis
Methods used for Current Study: Overall Epidemiology and Burden of RSV
Statement of Ethics Compliance
Results and Discussion
Articles Selected
Incidence of RSV Hospitalization
Study | Country | Design | % RSV/total ARIs | Hospitalization rate |
---|---|---|---|---|
Resch (2002) [57] | Austria | 1-year prospective study (1999–2000); single center; all children <2 years hospitalized with viral U/LRTIs (included high-risk children [preterm, CHD]) | 21%b
| Term: 7/1000/year |
Resch (2000) [56] | Austria | 4-year retrospective study (1994–1998); single center; all children hospitalized with viral U/LRTIs (included high-risk children [preterm, CHD, pulmonary disease, neurological disease]) | 26.7%b
| Term: 6/1000/season |
Santibanez (2012) [36] | Canada | 2-year retrospective study (2008–2010); regional; all hospitalized children <19 years old with LRTI and RSV/LRTI (included high-risk children and infants [preterm, CHD, BPD/CLD]) | 29.5% | NR |
Mlinaric-Galinovic (2009) [46] | Croatia | 11-year retrospective study (1994–2005); national; all children <10 years old hospitalized with an ARI | 32.2% | NR |
Haerskjold (2015) [2] | Denmark | 7-year population-based cohort study (1997–2003); 6 national registries; infants ≤24 months old (included high-risk infants [preterm, chronic disease (e.g. congenital malformations, intestinal lung disease, chromosomal abnormalities)]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | <2 years: 14.9/1000 years at risk |
Kristensen (1998) [83] | Denmark | 6-month population-based, retrospective study (1995–1996); regional; infants <6 months old (included high-risk infants [preterm, CHD, BPD/CLD, neurologic disease, other]) | NR | <6 months: 34/1000/season |
El-Hajje (2008) [48] | France | 3-year prospective study (2002–2004); single center; children <16 years old admitted with an ARI, fever or asthma | 80.8%b
| NR |
Weigl (2001) [29] | Germany | 3-year retrospective study (1996–1999); city; children <16 years old admitted with an ARI | 12.1% | <2 years: 7.25/1000 |
Tsolia (2003) [84] | Greece | 4-year retrospective/prospective (1997–2000); regional; infants <12 months old admitted with bronchiolitis (included high-risk infants [preterm infants ≤36 wGA, CHD, and other underlying illnesses]) | 61.5% | NR |
Constantopoulos (2002) [27] | Greece | 2-year prospective, epidemiological study (1999–2000); 4 regions; children ≤2 years old admitted with ARI (included healthy full-term infants and high-risk infants [preterm, CHD, BPD/CLD]) | 33.1% | NR |
Frassanito (2015) [31] | Italy | 5-year retrospective study (2009–2014); single center; children <3 years old admitted with a viral ARI | 54.2% | NR |
Ferrara (2014) [32] | Italy | 9-year retrospective study (2004–2013); single center; infants <12 months old admitted with bronchiolitis | 31.3% | NR |
Zuccotti (2011) [30] | Italy | 12-month prospective, epidemiological study (2008–2009); 2-center; children <15 years old admitted with an ARI | 34.1% | NR |
Corsello (2008) [38] | Italy | 7-month prospective, surveillance study (2005–2006); regional; children <2 years old admitted with LRTI (included infants born <36 wGA) | 40.9% | NR |
Medici (2006) [50] | Italy | 4 year prospective, observational study (2000–2004); national; children ≤4 years old admitted for an ARI (included previously healthy term and at-risk [≤35 wGA BPD/CLD] infants) | 49% | NR |
Lanari (2002) [33] | Italy | 6-month prospective, epidemiological study (1999–2000); multicenter; children <2 years old admitted for LRTI (included preterm infants <36 wGA) | 40.6% | NR |
Zomer-Kooijker (2014) [51] | Netherlands | 5-year prospective birth cohort study (2003–2005 and 2006–2007); single center; infants <12 months old (all previously healthy term infants) | Only RSV cases enrolled | <1 year: 8.4/1000/year |
Gooskens (2014) [47] | Netherlands | 2-year retrospective cohort study (2006–2007); single center; children <18 years old admitted with an ARI (included preterm infants and infants with bronchial hyper-responsiveness and cardiovascular disorders) | 31%b
| NR |
Fjaerli (2004) [7] | Norway | 8-year retrospective, population-based study (1993–2000); single center/region; children <2 years old admitted with bronchiolitis (included at-risk infants [preterm, Trisomy 21, CHD]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | <12 months: 21.7/1000/year 1–2 years: 6.8/1000/year <2 years: 14.1/1000/year |
Flores (2004) [85] | Portugal | 2-year prospective study (2000–2002); single center; children <3 years old admitted with acute bronchiolitis (included high-risk children [preterm <36 wGA, pulmonary disease]) | 60.9% | NR |
Tatochenko (2010) [52] | Russian Federation | 6-month prospective, observational study (2008–2009); multicenter; children ≤2 years old admitted with LRTI (included high-risk children [preterm, CLD/BPD, CHD]) | 37.9% | NR |
Gil-Prieto (2015) [4] | Spain | 15-year observational, retrospective survey (1997–2011); included >98% Spanish hospitals; children <5 years old admitted with bronchiolitis (included high-risk children [preterm, congenital cardiopathies/defects, BPD]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | <2 years: 24.1/1000/year <5 years: 10.7/1000/year |
Hervás (2012) [12] | Spain | 12-year retrospective study (1995–2006); single center/region; children ≤2 years old admitted with acute bronchiolitis (included high-risk children [preterm, CHD, atelectasis/condensation, urinary tract infection]) | 62.7% | ≤2 years: 55/1000a
|
García-García (2012) [42] | Spain | 6-year prospective study (2004–2010); single center; children <14 years old admitted with community-acquired pneumonia | 41.6%b
| NR |
Salvador García (2012) [28] | Spain | 1-year prospective study (2008–2009); region; children <18 months old admitted with bronchiolitis | 56.4% | NR |
Calvo (2010) [39] | Spain | 3-year prospective study (2005–2008); single center; children <2 years old admitted with acute viral bronchiolitis | 61.3% | NR |
Artiles-Campelo (2006) [43] | Spain | 3-year prospective study (2002–2005); single center; children <14 years old admitted with an ARI | 74.5%b
| NR |
Díez Domingo (2006) [40] | Spain | 2-year retrospective study (2001–2002); province; children <2 years old admitted with bronchiolitis | 42.2% | <12 months: 40.2/1000/yearc
|
Vicente (2003) [6] | Spain | 4-year retrospective, population-based study (1996–2000); single center/province; children <5 years old admitted with an ARI | 59.1% | <6 months: 37/1000/year <12 months: 25/1000/year |
Svensson (2015) [61] | Sweden | 7-year retrospective study (2004–2011); regional; children <5 years old with an RSV infection (included high-risk children [wheezy bronchitis, CHD, Down syndrome, small for gestational age]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | <12 months: 17.4/1000/year 1–4 years: 0.6/1000/year <5 years: 4.2/1000/year |
Erikksson (2002) [86] | Sweden | 12-year retrospective study (1987–1998); single center; children admitted with confirmed RSV infection (included high-risk children [preterm, BPD/CLD, cardiac malformation, respiratory malformation, other chronic disease]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | 0.8–0.14/100/year |
Bicer (2013) [52] | Turkey | 1-year retrospective cohort study (2010–2011); single center; children <9 years old admitted with an ARI | 32%b
| NR |
Hacımustafaoğlu (2013) [54] | Turkey | 1-year study; multicenter; children ≤2 years old admitted with LRTI | 37.9% | 7.8/1000/year |
Turkish Neonatal Society (2012) [55] | Turkey | 2-year prospective, epidemiological study (2008-2010); multicenter; children <2 years old with diagnosis of respiratory failure due to LRTI (excluded children with immunodeficiency, CF or congenital or acquired disorders affecting respiratory system) | 16.9% | NR |
Ajayi-Obe (2008) [37] | UK | 2-year prospective, descriptive study (2002–2003 and 2003–2004); single center; children <6 years old presenting with influenza-like illness (included high-risk children [asthma, CHD, BPD, CF, sickle cell disease, chronic renal disease, thalassemia immunodeficiencies]) | 19.1% (2002–2003)b
27% (2003–2004)b
| <6 months: 56.2/1000 person-years <12 months: 42.7/1000 person-years 2–3 years: 7.28/1000 person-years 4–5 years: 0.67/1000 person-years <6 years: 12.87/1000 person-years |
Deshpande (2003) [63] | UK | 3-year retrospective, population-based study (1996–1999); county; children <2 years old admitted with a respiratory illness (included high-risk children [preterm, BPD/CLD]) | 58.8% | <2 years: 16.3/1000a
|
Müller-Pebody (2002) [34] | UK | 3-year retrospective study (1995–1998); national; children <5 years old admitted with LRTI (included high-risk children [preterm, BPD/CLD]) | 17.5% | <12 months: 28.3/1000/year 1–4 years: 1.3/1000/year |
Hall (2013) [16] | US | 5-year prospective, population-based study (2000–2005); 3 counties; children <2 years old admitted with an ARI (included preterm infants <37 wGA and infants with comorbid conditions) | 26% | 1 month: 25.9/1000a
3 months: 10.3/1000a
6 months: 4.1/1000a
12 months: 3.2/1000a
18 months: 2.6/1000a
<2 years: 5.2/1000a
|
Hasegawa (2013) [70] | US | 4-year serial, cross-sectional analysis of a nationally representative sample of children (2000, 2003, 2006, 2009); national; children <2 years old hospitalized with bronchiolitis (included high-risk children [preterm or ≥1 complex medical condition]) | NR | <2 years: 17.9/1000 person-yearsc (2000); 14.8/1000 person-yearsc (2009) |
Stockman (2012) [35] | US | 10-year retrospective study (1997–2006); national; children <5 years old admitted for LRTI (included high-risk children [preterm, CHD, chronic respiratory distress]) | ~24% | 0–2 months: 48.9/1000/year 3–5 months: 28.4/1000/year <12 months: 13.4/1000/year 1–2 years: 5.0/1000/year <5 years: 6/7/1000/year |
Zhou (2012) [49] | US | 16-year retrospective surveillance study (1993–2008); 13 states; all ages including adults admitted with influenza or RSV | 19.5%b
| <12 months: 23.5/1000 person-years 1–4 years: 1.78/1000 person-years |
García (2010) [44] | US | 6-year retrospective study (2002–2007); single center/region; children <2 years old admitted with bronchiolitis (included high-risk children [prematurity, CHD, BPD/CLD, Trisomy 21, congenital syndromes, immunodeficiencies, CF, neuromuscular disorders, respiratory tract disorders]) | 66%b
| NR |
Iwane (2004) [45] | US | 12-month prospective, active, population-based, surveillance study (2000–2001); 2 counties; children <5 years old admitted with an ARI (included children with chronic conditions) | 20%b
| <5 years: 3.5/1000/year |
Leader (2003) [62] | US | 3-year retrospective study (1997–2000); national; infants ≤12 months old admitted with RSV (included high-risk children [premature, CHD, BPD/CLD, chromosomal abnormalities]) | Only RSV cases enrolled | ≤12 months: 22.7/1000a
|
Incidence of RSV in Emergency Departments and Outpatient Settings
Trends in RSV Hospitalization Rates
Co-infections
Morbidity and Mortality Associated with Severe RSV Infection
Morbidity
Study | Country | Age | Study participants | LOS, median days (range) | ICU admission (%) | ICU LOS, median days (range) | Oxygen requirement (%) | Intubation and/or mechanical ventilation (%) | Non-invasive ventilation (%) | Case-fatality rate (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Resch (2002) [57] | Austria | <2 years | 58 RSV+ (included preterms and children with comorbidities) | 8.9 (mean) | 3.4 | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0 |
Resch (2000) [56] | Austria | 83% ≤6 months | 245 RSV+ (included preterms and children with comorbidities) | 11 (mean) | NR | NR | NR | 6.1 | 1.2 | 0 |
Kristensen (1998) [83] | Denmark | <6 months | 459 RSV+ (included children with comorbidities) | Overall: 6 (1–23) Without predisposing conditions: 5 (1–22) | NR | NR | NR | 1.3 | 28.3 | 0 |
Soilly (2012) [91] | France | <2 years | 467 (76% RSV; included children with comorbidities) | NRa
| 100a
| 8 (5–13) | 36.9 | 26.5 | 22.7 | 1.28e
|
Grimaldi (2002) [63] | France | 484 RSV+ (included preterms) | 6 | 6.4 | NR | NR | 1.7 | NR | 0.2b
| |
Weigl (2002) [79] | Germany | <16 years | 150 RSV+ (included children with comorbidities) | 9 (mean) | 7.5% | NR | 24.8 | 0.6 | 2.7 | 0 |
Tsolia (2003) [84] | Greece | <1 year | 473 tested (61.5% RSV; included preterms) | 6.3 (mean, SD 4.3) | Overall: 3.0 RSV+: 6.2 | NR | NR | RSV+: 3.2 | NR | 0.7 |
Constantopoulos (2002) [27] | Greece | <2 years | 1710 (33.1% RSV) | 5.4 (mean) | NR | NR | 67.6 | NR | NR | NR |
Zuccotti (2011) [30] | Italy | <15 years | 575 (34.1% RSV; included children with comorbidities) | 5.6 (mean) | 0 | NA | RSV+: 28.6 | NR | NR | NR |
Gijtenbeek (2015) [88] | Netherlands | 43–49 months | 2099 (3% confirmed RSVH; included preterms) | <32 wGA: 8 (mean 3–20) 32–36 wGA: 7 (mean 2–25) 38–42 wGA: 7 (mean 4–12) | NR | NR | <32 wGA: 82.4 32–36 wGA: 60.5 38–42 wGA: 85.7 | <32 wGA: 5.9 32–36 wGA: 15.8 38–42 wGA: 42.9 | NR | NR |
Gooskens (2014) [47] | Netherlands | <18 years | 274 (31% RSV; included children with comorbidities) | NR | NR | NR | 73.0 | 2.0 | NR | 0 |
Fjaerli (2004) [7] | Norway | <2 years | 764 RSV+ (included children with comorbidities) | 4 (1–41) | NR | NR | NR | 1.2 | NR | 0.3b
|
Gil-Prieto (2015) [4] | Spain | <5 years | 326 175 RSV+ (included children with comorbidities) | ≤5 years: 5.7 (SD 8.2) ≤2 years: 5.9 (SD 8.7) | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | 0.14 |
Hervás (2012) [12] | Spain | ≤2 years | 2384 (62.7% RSV; included children with comorbidities) | 6 (SD 6–7) | RSV+: 10.7 | NR | RSV+: 67 | RSV+: 2.7 | RSV+: 1.1 | 0.13 |
Calvo (2010) [39] | Spain | <2 years | 370 (69.3% single RSV) | 5 (mean) | 2.3 | NR | 78.6 | NR | NR | NR |
Vicente (2003) [6] | Spain | <5 years | 635 bronchiolitis hospitalizations (59.1% RSV) | 5.9 (mean) <6 months: 6.9 (mean) >6 months: 5.2 (mean) | 7 | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR |
García-García (2001) [41] | Spain | <2 years | 617 (viral agent in 55.6% of episodes [83.6% due to RSV]) | 6.6 (mean, SD 3.5) | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR |
Svensson (2015) [61] | Sweden | <5 years | 1764 RSV + children (included children with comorbidities) | 3 (1–150) | 3.7 | 3 (1–130) | NR | 1.5 | 1.1 | 0 |
Deshpande (2003) [63] | UK | <2 years | 497 RSVH (included children with comorbidities) | 2 (IQR 0–19) | 2.7 | NR | NR | 1.5 | NR | 0.2d
|
Thorburn (2009) [11] | UK | All children admitted to PICU | 406 RSV+ (included children with comorbidities) | PICU admissions only reported | NR | 5 (IQR 4–9) | NR | 96.5 | 3.5 | 4.4 |
Müller-Pebody (2002) [34] | UK | <5 years | 12,298 admissions (17.5% RSV; included children with comorbidities) | <1 year: 8 (0–243)e
1–4 years: 7 (0–560)e
<1 year: 3 (0–305)f
1–4 years: 3 (0–478)f
| NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | <1 year: 0.2–3.3b,e
1–4 years: 0.6–2.7b,f
|
Hasegawa (2013) [70] | US | <2 years | 544 828g
| 2.4–2.5h
| NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR for RSV |
García (2010) [44] | US | <2 years | 4800 (66% RSV+; included children with comorbidities) | 3 (IQR 2–5) | 11.6 | 4 (IQR 2–7) | 56.3 | 6 | NR | 0.1 |
Leader (2003) [62] | US | ≤1 year | 718,008 ED visits (311,077 RSV) | 3.9 (mean, 95% CI: 3.2–4.6) | NR | NR | NR | NR | NR | 4.1c
|
Brooks (1999) [87] | US | ≤1 year | 542 RSV+ | 12 (3–96)h
| 1.8 | NR | NR | 25 | NR | NR |
Nosocomial RSV Infection
Case-Fatality Rates
Risk Factors for RSV Hospitalization
Independent risk factors for severe RSV infection requiring hospitalization | |
Male sex [108] Maternal age [110] Suburban residence [110] | |
Other risk factors associated with RSV hospitalization | |
Vitamin D deficiency [111] High altitude above 2500 m [104] Socioeconomic status/parental education [117] Delivery by cesarean section [105] |
Level of evidencea
| |
---|---|
Key statements/findings | |
In western countries, RSV has been associated with 12–63% of all ARIs and 19–81% of viral ARIs causing hospitalization in children | 1 |
Annual hospitalization rates for RSV-associated ARIs ranged from 3.2/1000 children to 42.7/1000 in the first year of life, and decreased with decreasing age to 0.6/1000–1.78/1000 in children 1–4 years | 1 |
Longitudinal studies have reported varying annual incidences of RSVH over time: some have reported an increase, some a decrease, and others relative stability | 2 |
RSV co-infections are frequent (bacterial and viral co-infections have been reported in up to 50% of patients hospitalized with severe RSV ARI). However, the relationship with severity of disease is not clear | 1 |
Infants spend an average of 2–11 days in hospital for RSV ARIs, around 2–12% are admitted to the ICU, and the mortality rate is <0.5% and limited to children with severe comorbidity | 1/2 |
A number of risk factors have been independently associated with an increased risk for severe RSV disease in children, including: male sex; age <6 months; birth during the first half of the RSV season; crowding/siblings; and day-care exposure | 1 |
Key areas for research | |
The current evidence base likely underestimates the true epidemiology and burden of severe RSV infection, particularly, the burden related to outpatient and emergency department visits requires further study | |
The impact of co-infections on the severity of RSV infections requires further definition and study | |
Mortality rates are mainly based on excess mortality estimates during the RSV season in a few studies. Refining global mortality estimates and defining associated risk factors require further study | |
Geographical differences in RSV epidemiology need to be defined |