Drug resistance predictive utility of age of onset and cortical imaging abnormalities in epilepsy: a systematic review and meta-analysis
- Open Access
- 01.12.2024
- Review
Abstract
Introduction
Study aims
-
To assess the independent relationship between the age of onset of the first seizure and the development of drug resistance.
-
To assess the independent relationship between cortical abnormalities found on imaging and the development of drug resistance.
-
To aid patient selection for neurosurgical management of epilepsies.
-
To reduce the burden of drug resistance in epilepsy.
Methods
Literature search
Inclusion/exclusion criteria
Study selection
Data extraction
Statistical analysis and data synthesis
Results
Study selection
Author | Year | Country | Study design | Medical condition | Types of seizures | Sample size | Mean age/median age in years | Male-to-female ratio(M/F) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chen [18] | 2021 | China | Retrospective case–control | Epilepsy | – | 141 | Mean (± SD) 33.49 (± 1.42) | 89/52 |
Taghreed l [19] | 2018 | Egypt | Retrospective case–control | Refractory epilepsy | Partial seizure, generalized seizure, multiple seizure | 186 93 case 93 control | Mean (± SD) 5.7 (± 3.0) refractory group 5.4 (± 2.9) responsive group | 118/68 |
Jeong [20] | 2017 | USA and Belgium | Retrospective case–control | Epilepsy and tuberous sclerosis complex | Infantile seizure, focal seizure, others | 1546 | Median (IQR) 16 (9.6 – 25.5) | 803/743 |
Gasparin Sara [21] | 2013 | Italy | Retrospective case–control | Cryptogenic focal epilepsy | – | 186 | Median (IQR) 25 (9–99) | 105/81 |
Rawat [22] | 2018 | India | Prospective cohort | Epilepsy | – | 1056 | Median (IQR) 20 (5–67) | 665/391 |
Berg [23] | 2011 | USA | Prospective cohort | Epilepsy | – | 613 | – | – |
Berg [24] | 2014 | USA | Prospective cohort | Epilepsy | – | 599 | – | 307/292 |
Karaoglu [25] | 2021 | Turkey | Retrospective case–control | Epilepsy | – | 458 | Mean (± SD) 7.37 (± 4.72) | 248/210 |
Lattanzi [26] | 2021 | Italy | Retrospective case–control | Post-stroke epilepsy | Focal onset, focal to bilateral tonic–clonic, generalized, unknown | 159 | – | 104/55 |
Ramos-Lizana [27] | 2009 | Spain | Prospective cohort | Epilepsy | Partial, generalized | 343 | Mean (± SD) 4.8 (± 3.8) | 191/152 |
Ayca [28] | 2019 | Turkey | Retrospective case–control | Epilepsy | Generalized tonic–clonic, myoclonic | 241 | Mean (± SD) 7.00 (± 4.36) Intractable group 7.00 (± 4.36) Control group | 130/111 |
Tripathi [29] | 2011 | India | Retrospective case–control | Intractable epilepsy and well-controlled epilepsy | Generalized, partial, myoclonic, other/mixed | 400 200 intractable 200 control | – | Case 142/58 Control 128/72 |
Description of included studies
Association between age of onset and drug resistance
Publication | Average age of onset | Length of follow-up | Age of onset threshold | No patients with/without an event | Event ratio (95% CI) | Inference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Taghred [19] | – | 12 months | < 1 year > 1 year | Age of onset < 1 year: 70/40 > 1 year:23/53 | OR: 4.0 p < 0.001 | Age of onset lesser than 1 year is associated with an increased risk of drug resistance |
Jeong [20] | Median (IQR): 5 (3–7.2) months | – | < 1 year > 1 year | 650/896 | OR 1.9 (1.4–2.5) p < 0.001 | Age of onset of less than 1 year increases the risk of drug resistance |
Rawat [22] | Median(IQR): 15 (0–56) months | 12 months | 5 years | 581/475 | OR 2.02 (1.31–3.13) p = 0.0016 | Age of Onset younger than 5 years is associated with increased risk for drug resistance or recurrence |
Chen [18] | Mean (SD) 22.18 (± 1.38)years | 4–9 years | – | 41/100 | 2.508 (0.270, 23.316) p = 0.419 | Age of onset is not associated with drug resistance |
Berg [23] | – | ≥ 10 years < 10 years | 2–5 years | 205/311 | – | – |
Berg [24] | The group followed < 10 years: 7.0 (4.2) Group followed ≥ 10 years: 5.5 (4.1) | ≥ 10 years < 10 years | – | 347/266 | Age of onset < 2 Hazard ratio: 1.000 Age of onset 2–5 Hazard ratio: 0.72 (0.48, 1.11) Age of onset 5–10 Hazard ratio: 0.78 (0.52, 1.18) Age of onset 10 + Hazard Ratio: 0.50 (0.30, 0.82) | Age of onset of less than 2 years increases the likelihood of drug resistance |
Karaoglu [25] | Mean Drug-resistant: 1.85 years Drug receptive: 4.92 years | Median 46 months (range: 28–126 months) | – | 177/281 | p < 0.001 Univariate analysis | There is an association between the Early age of Onset and the development of drug-resistant epilepsy |
Senem [28] | Range, intractable group: 0–1 Control group: 1–5 | 4 years | > 1 year < 1 year | 61/180 | Odd ratio Age < 1: 9.43 (3.66–24.30) 1–4 years: 1.79 (0.65–4.89) 5 and above: 1.04 (0.11–9.91) p = 0.001 | Age of onset of less than one year was found to be associated with an increased risk for intractable seizure |
Lattanzi [26] | Mean (± SD) Overall = 56.7 (± 14.9)years Refractory group = 52.1 (± 15.3)years Responsive group = 57.8 (± 14.7)years | Median (range) 5 (3–9) years | – | 29/130 | Multivariate OR = 0.97 p = 0.044 | There is an association between younger age of stroke onset and the development of drug resistance post-stroke epilepsy |
Ramos-Lizana [27] | 4.8 years (± 3.8 SD) Mean used | Mean (± SD) (range) 76.2 (± 35.2 SD) month (24–139) | > 1 year | 30/313 | Univariate HR = 4.9 p = 0.000 Multivariate HR = 2.6 p = 0.051 | Age of onset lesser than 1 year was found to be associated with refractory epilepsy with univariate analysis and almost associated with multivariate analysis |
Tripathi [29] | Mean(± SD): Case = 5.18 (± 7.62) Control = 5.62 (± 9.18) | – | < 14 years > 14 years | 200/200 | Multivariate analysis Age of onset < 14 OR = 3.09 + p < 0.005 | There is an association between an age of onset of less than 14 years and the development of intractable epilepsy |
Sara [21] | Mean ± SD 31 ± 21 | Mean 9.4 years SD (4.2) Median 8.1 years range (5.0–23.1) | 17 year | 143/43 | – | Age of onset does not predict drug resistance |
Estimate | SE | Z | p | CI lower bound | CI upper bound | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intercept | 0.6849 | 0.1405 | 4.88 | < 0.001 | 0.410 | 0.960 |
Moderator | −0.0430 | 0.0341 | −1.26 | 0.207 | −0.110 | 0.024 |
Tau | Tau2 | I2 | H2 | R2 | df | Q | p |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.253 | 0.0639 (SE = 0.0292) | 99.55% | 220.133 | 13.98% | 9.000 | 3622.119 | < 0.001 |
Association between cortical imaging abnormalities and drug resistance
Publication | Length of follow-up | Types of cortical imaging abnormalities | Numbers of patients with/without event | Event ratio 95% CI | Inference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chen [18] | 4–9 years | – | 8/41 | OR 6.838 (1.518,30.809) p = 0.012 | Imaging abnormalities are associated with drug resistance |
Karaoglu [25] | Median 46 months range (28–126 months) | – | Drug resistance 134/177 Drug receptive 108/281 | OR 1.9 (0.71–5.05) p = 0.0000 multivariate | There is an association between MRI abnormalities and the development of drug-resistant epilepsy |
Senem [28] | 4 years | – | 49/192 | OR: 37.55 (16.41–85.94) p = 0.000 | Abnormal imaging suggesting Cortical involvement was found to be associated with the development of intractable seizure |
Ramos-Lizana [27] | Mean (± SD) (range) 76.2(± 35.2 SD) month (24–139) | – | 30/313 | Univariate analysis: HR = 5.0 + p = 0.000 Multivariate analysis: HR = 2.3 + p = 0.693 | Multivariate analysis shows there is no relationship between abnormal cortical lesions and refractory epilepsy while univariate does |
Tripathi [29] | – | Case: Known epileptogenic structural lesions (133) None (26) Nonspecific (41) Control: Known epileptogenic structural lesions(15) None (63) Nonspecific (122) | 200/200 | Univariate OR = 20.46 + p < 0.05 Multivariate OR = 20.47 + p < 0.005 | There is an association between findings of cortical structural lesions on brain imaging and development of refractory epilepsy |