Introduction
Methods
Search Strategy
Inclusion Criteria
Exclusion Criteria
Study Selection and Data Extraction
Assessment of Risk of Bias
Data Analysis
Results
Characteristics of Included Studies
Study | Diagnosis | Intervention | Comparison | Sample Size | Duration of disease | Follow-up period | Outcomes | Adverse events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Xu 2014, China [35] | Cervical spondylosis | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | IG:260 CG:266 | IG:50.42 ± 65.80 CG:49.94 ± 73.18 (months) | 1, 3 months after completion of treatment | NPQ | NR |
Liang 2011, China [27] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | Sham acupuncture | IG:93 CG:97 | ≥ 6 months | 1, 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS, NPQ, SF-36 | 8%/6% |
Gattie 2021, USA [31] | Chronic neck pain | Dry needling + Manual therapy, and exercise | Sham acupuncture + Manual therapy, and exercise | IG:40 CG:37 | ≥ 3 months | 4 weeks, 6 months, 1 year after completion of treatment | VAS, NPQ, NDI | NR |
Witt 2006, Germany [21] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | No treatment | IG: 1753 CG: 1698 | IG:6.0 ± 6.9 CG:6.1 ± 7.3 (years) | 3, 6 months after completion of treatment | SF-36 | 8.9%/NR |
Irnich 2001, Germany [22] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | Massage | IG:56 CG:60 | NR | 1 week, 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS | 33%/21% |
Ilbuldu 2004, Turkey [23] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Dry needling | Laser | IG:20 CG:20 | IG:38.48 ± 31.94 CG:36.95 ± 33.65 (months) | 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS | NR |
Salter 2006, UK [24] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | Medication, massage, and recommended exercise | IG:10 CG:14 | IG:5.7 ± 6.4 CG:5.5 ± 5.5 (years) | 1, 3 months after completion of treatment | NPQ | 60%/ NR |
Franca 2008, Brazil [25] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Acupuncture | Physiotherapy | IG:15 CG:15 | ≥ 3 months | 10 weeks, 6 months after completion of treatment | VAS, NDI | NR |
MacPherson 2015, UK [28] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | Usual care | IG:173 CG:172 | ≥ 3 months | 1, 3, 12 months after completion of treatment | NPQ | 14%/5% |
De 2017, Belgium [30] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Dry needling | Manual Pressure Technique | IG:22 CG:20 | ≥ 3 months | 3 months after completion of treatment | NRS, NDI | NR |
Nejati 2021, Iran [33] | Chronic neck pain | Acupuncture | Exercise | IG:34 CG:34 | ≥ 3 months | 1, 6 months after completion of treatment | NDI | NR |
Valiente 2021, Spain [34] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Dry needling | Usual care | IG:21 CG:20 | ≥ 3 months | 1, 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS, NDI | NR |
Lin 2017, China [36] | Cervical spondylosis | Warm needle moxibustion + Traction therapy | Traction therapy | IG:35 CG:35 | IG:18.03 ± 18.97 CG:16.86 ± 25.35 | 3 months after completion of treatment | NRS | NR |
Huang 2019, China [37] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Press needle + TENS | TENS | IG:40 CG:40 | ≥ 6 months | 2 weeks, 1, and 6 months after completion of treatment | VAS, NDI | NR |
Tang 2022, China [38] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Acupuncture + Massage | Massage | IG:40 CG:40 | IG:5.8 ± 3.8 CG:5.6 ± 4.2 (months) | 1 week, 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS, MPQ, NDI | NR |
Ma 2010, China [26] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Acupuncture + Self neck—stretching exercises | Self-neck—stretching exercises | IG:15 CG:13 | ≥ 6 months | 2 weeks, 3 months after completion of treatment | VAS | 74%/ NR |
Cerezo 2016, Spain [29] | Chronic mechanical neck pain | Dry needling + Stretching | Stretching | IG:64 CG:64 | ≥ 6 months | 15,30,90, 180 days after completion of treatment | VAS, NDI | NR |
Stieven 2020, Brazil [32] | Chronic neck pain | Dry needling + Physical therapy | Physical Therapy | IG:58 CG:58 | ≥ 3 months | 1, 3, 6 months after completion of treatment | NDI | 13%/10.3% |