Introduction
The metabolism of glutamate to glutamine by the enzyme glutamine synthetase (GS) is a key process for maintaining healthy synaptic function. GS (encoded by the gene glutamate-ammonia ligase, Glul) is predominantly expressed in astrocytes [
1] and converts glutamate released into the synapse during neurotransmission to glutamine, for recycling to neuronal glutamate and gamma-amino butyric acid (GABA). GS is therefore critical to the homeostasis of excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmission and normal brain activity [
2,
3]. This process may be compromised in several brain disorders [
3], and neuroimaging techniques to assess GS activity in vivo could have wide-ranging research or clinical impact.
Abnormalities in GS have been most clearly linked to epileptogenesis [
4]. Very rare inherited deficits in GS are associated with neonatal seizures [
5,
6]. Pharmacological inhibition of GS [
2] or genetic GS deficiency [
7] can be used as animal models of epilepsy, and there are marked reductions in GS in areas of hippocampal tissue resected from patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy [
8,
9]. Furthermore, regional differences in the level of GS protein, mRNA expression or activity have been detected in post-mortem brain tissue across many psychiatric and neurological disorders. The results of these studies, summarised in Additional file
1: Table S1, suggest that in addition to applications in epilepsy, GS imaging could be important in understanding or predicting schizophrenia, depression or suicidal behaviour, amongst other disorders.
GS is also the main pathway for metabolism of brain ammonia, which is required for the conversion of glutamate of glutamine [
10]. This raises the possibility that radiolabelled ammonia in combination with positron emission tomography (PET) may be utilised to measure brain GS activity. [
13N]Ammonia PET is used clinically to assess myocardial perfusion (“blood flow”) and has been applied in research studies examining abnormalities in brain ammonia uptake associated with liver disease [
11‐
20] and in the diagnosis of brain tumours [
21].
The aim of this study was to evaluate [
13N]ammonia as a PET tracer for quantification of brain GS activity. This evaluation requires kinetic modelling of the dynamic concentrations of
13N-derived radioactivity in the brain and arterial blood following radiotracer injection, in an attempt to reliably extract rate constants, as the rate of conversion of [
13N]ammonia to [
13N]glutamine, from the signal relating to [
13N]ammonia brain uptake and clearance (see Additional file
1: Figure S1). To do this we sought to acquire two [
13N]ammonia scans (test and re-test) in eight healthy volunteers. In order to account for effects of cerebral blood flow (CBF), we additionally acquired test and re-test [
15O]water PET scans in the same subjects on the same day, with [
15O]water PET scans preceding [
13N]ammonia PET.
Primary analysis of the suitability of the method assessed the identifiability and repeatability of the
k3 rate-constant representing GS activity in the kinetic model (see Additional file
1: Figure S1). While this is not sufficient to prove evaluation of GS activity, it would be a pre-requisite to using this standard kinetic modelling approach. Secondary analysis assessed identifiability and repeatability of other parameters, kinetic model selection, and comparisons to previous work using [
13N]ammonia to evaluate blood–brain-barrier function [
11].
Methods
The study had ethical approval from the NHS Ethical Committee (NRES South East Coast, Surrey), the local Research and Development offices and the Administration of Radioactive Substances Advisory Committee (ARSAC). Participation required provision of written informed consent to all study procedures.
Participants
The study aimed to acquire complete datasets (including one T1-weighted MRI scan, two [13N]ammonia scans and two [15O]water PET scans) in eight healthy volunteers. Participants were recruited internally though King’s College London’s recruitment system. Inclusion required that participants were aged 18 or older and were able to provide written informed consent in English. Exclusion criteria included the standard contraindications to PET and MRI, including pregnancy. Absence of pregnancy in female participants was confirmed by a negative urine pregnancy test on arrival to the PET scanning visit.
MRI
MRI scans were performed at the Centre for Neuroimaging Sciences, King’s College London, UK on a General Electric MR750 3T MRI scanner. A T1-weighted structural MRI scan based on the ADNI protocol (voxel size 1.05 × 1.05 × 1.20 mm, TE 3.016 ms; TR 7.312 ms matrix 256 × 256; FoV 270 mm; inversion time 400 ms) was acquired for co-registration of the participants’ PET images.
Radiochemistry
Aqueous [
13N]ammonia was produced on a CTI RDS 112 biomedical cyclotron via the
16O(p,α)
13N nuclear reaction. The target contained 8 mL H
2O with 5 mM ethanol according to Wieland et al. [
22].
[
15O]water: Oxygen-15 was produced in the form of [
15O]oxygen gas by the bombardment of enriched [
15N]nitrogen gas containing 1–2.5% oxygen gas via the
15 N(p,n)
160 nuclear reaction. [
15O]water was subsequently obtained by passage with hydrogen over a platinum catalyst according to Berridge et al. [
23].
PET image acquisition
PET scans were acquired at St Thomas’ Hospital, King’s College London on a GE Discovery 710 PET-CT scanner with 3D acquisition and list mode. Each participant underwent two PET scanning sessions, performed in the morning and afternoon of the same day. Each of the two scanning sessions consisted of an initial low dose CT scan to enable correction for tissue attenuation of radioactivity, a dynamic [15O]water scan (5 min), and a dynamic [13N]ammonia scan (30 min). There was a break of approximately one hour between the two sessions, during which lunch was provided, and an appropriate gap (at least 5 half-lives) between subsequent scans to avoid residual counts (i.e. at least 10 min following the [15O]water scans and 50 min following the [13N]ammonia scan).
At the start of the PET scan visit, a cannula was inserted in a vein in the arm for radiotracer injection. After application of local anaesthetic, an arterial line was inserted into the radial artery and flushed every 20 min with heparinised saline (20 IU/mL of heparin in sterile 0.9% w/v sodium chloride) until removal at the end of PET scanning. Just before the start of each scanning session, 6 mL of arterial blood was taken to measure baseline blood ammonia levels.
Participants were positioned in the PET-CT scanner, with head movement minimised via a moulded headrest and head strap. The arterial cannula was connected to an automated blood sampling system (Allogg ABSS,
www.allogg.se, Sweden) using a 150 cm PTFE coated tubing (inner diameter 1 mm). CT scout (0.015 mSv) and CT attenuation correction (0.05 mSv) scans were acquired.
15O-water (target dose at time of administration: 960 MBq, 1.10 mSv) was injected through the venous cannula over 10 s. PET image acquisition started 10 s before the start of [
15O]water injection and continued for a total of 5 min. Arterial blood collection via the fluid analyser commenced 70 s before [
15O]water injection and 60 s before the start of scan acquisition and continued for the 5 min scan duration, to a total of 25 mL. Additionally, a single 2 mL arterial blood sample was manually drawn at 4 min into the scan.
After completion of the [15O]water scan the arterial line was flushed with heparinised saline. At least 20 min after the end of the 15O-water scan (25 min after [15O]water injection), [13N]ammonia (target dose at time of administration: 550 MBq, 1.5 mSv) was injected through the venous cannula. PET image acquisition started 10 s before the start of [13N]ammonia injection and continued for 30 min. Arterial blood collection via the fluid analyser commenced 70 s before [13N]ammonia injection and 60 s before the start of scan acquisition and continued for 15 min, to a total of 75 mL. In addition, 6 manual arterial blood samples of 10 mL each were drawn at 4, 6, 8, 12, 20 and 30 min after scan start during the [13N]ammonia scans, which were used for whole blood, plasma and metabolite analysis.
In the second session, a minimum of 1 h later, both the [15O]water and [13N]ammonia scans were repeated using identical acquisition protocols.
The method used for separation of ammonia and metabolite from plasma samples was based on the method published by Keiding et al. [
11] and is described below.
Levels of non-radioactive ammonia in arterial blood were determined from samples collected before radiotracer collection. These samples were collected in K-EDTA tubes (pre-tested and confirmed as ammonia-free) and transported on ice within 20 min of collection to the hospital laboratory for standard analysis.
Unless stated otherwise, all water used in these metabolite analyses was passed through ion exchange resin and 0.22 μm membrane filtered to produce water with a specific resistance of 18.2 micro-ohms using a Milli-Q Ultrapure water purification system manufactured by Millipore Corporation.
Plasma was separated from whole blood by centrifuging at 3000 ×
g for 3 min at room temperature (RT). Levels of radioactive metabolites in plasma were estimated through solid phase extraction, based on the methods of Keiding et al. [
17]. In preparation for solid phase extraction, one cartridge was filled with 0.6 mL Dowex 1X8-50 anion exchange resin and pre-treated with 6 mL 0.75 M sodium acetate solution. A second cartridge, connected in series via an Agilent Bond Elut adapter, was filled with 0.35 mL AG50W-X8 cation exchange resin and pretreated with 3.5 mL 0.8 M Tris–acetate solution. The third cartridge which connected to the second cartridge in the same way via adapter was filled with 0.35 mL AG50W-X8 cation exchange resin and pretreated with 3.5 mL Millipore water.
For extraction, 0.5 mL of the supernatant protein-free plasma was loaded onto the first cartridge followed by washing with 3 mL of Millipore water through the cartridge stack and flushed with 10 mL of air. The eluent from the first cartridge passed through the second cartridge and third cartridge, which were subsequently washed with 7 mL of Millipore water followed by 10 mL of air. The third cartridge was washed with 7 ml Millipore water and followed by 10 mL of air. All eluates were collected with a 25 mL pot. With this method, the radioactivity measured on the first cartridge corresponded to [13N]glutamate, on the second cartridge corresponded to intact [13N]ammonia, on the third cartridge corresponded to [13N]glutamine, and the pot corresponded to [13N]urea.
A 10-detector gamma-counter (Wizard2 2470, Perkin-Elmer) cross-calibrated to the PET scanner was used to measure radioactivity concentrations in whole blood (0.5 mL per sample), plasma (0.5 mL per sample) and metabolite fractions (3 mL for urea and full cartridge contents for other fractions). All samples were counted for 3 min on a fixed energy window (358–664 keV) with software cross-talk correction and in-house volumetric geometry correction. The samples and cartridges were corrected for weight to calculate the total radioactivity of blood sample analysed. All sample data were background and decay corrected to scan start time prior to data analysis.
Image processing
[15O]water PET list mode data was unlisted to 26 frames (1 × 10 s, 10 × s, 6 × 10 s and 9 × 20 s). [13N]ammonia PET list mode was unlisted to 47 frames (1 × 10 s, 10 × 5 s, 6 × 10 s, 3 × 20 s, 27 × 60 s). All PET images were reconstructed to a 2562 matrix with 47 slices with 0.98 × 0.98 × 3.27 mm voxel size, 3D iterative reconstruction (GE “VuePoint”, 4 iterations, 24 subsets, 4 mm FHWM Gaussian post-filter), scatter correction and inter- and intra-frame decay correction. Images were reconstructed with CT attenuation correction (attenuation corrected, AC) and without (non-attenuation corrected, NAC).
Frame-by-frame motion correction was performed on dynamic PET data using the NAC image to derive the rigid-body motion parameters which were applied to the paired AC image (first 9 frames ignored to avoid low counts). Regions of interest (ROI) were defined by the “Hammers_mith Atlas” [
24,
25] (83 regions) in MNI stereotaxic space. Nonlinear warps from MNI to subject space were defined using the unified segmentation algorithm [
26] in SPM8 (
www.fil.ucl.ac.uk/spm) on each subject’s T1 MRI. Resliced atlases for each subject were then co-registered to a summed PET image (sum of total scan duration of motion corrected AC image ignoring first 60 s) for each PET scan via the MRI.
For both the [
15O]water and [
13N]ammonia scans, time activity curves (TACs) were extracted from the co-registered Hammers_mith atlas [
24,
25] (ignoring ventricular and white matter regions). Using each subject’s co-registered probabilistic grey matter mask from the segmented MRI, TACs were extracted using the mean voxel value within the region or a weighted mean for cortical regions using each subject’s grey matter probabilistic mask. Whole-brain grey matter and white matter weighted mean TACs were also defined. A total of 79 regions were explored (77 atlas ROIs plus global grey and white matter).
Blood data processing
For the [
13N]ammonia scans, arterial whole blood input functions were created from decay-corrected continuous blood samples with manual samples used for cross-calibration to scanner and interpolation to scan end. Plasma-over-blood ratio was calculated as the mean of the manual plasma and whole blood sample ratios for each subject (Additional file
1: Figure S2). Parent fraction data (ratio of [
13N]ammonia to total
13N activity) was fitted to a biexponential curve for each subject as used by Keiding et al. [
11]. Parent plasma input functions (i.e. [
13N]ammonia in plasma only) for the kinetic modelling were created by multiplying the whole-blood input function by plasma-over-blood ratios and the biexponential curve fitted to the parent fractions. To account for delay between the blood sampling detector and PET scan whole blood and parent plasma input functions were delay corrected by visually matching the blood rise with the grey matter TAC, with decay correction.
Kinetic analysis
Regional cerebral blood flow (CBF) was calculated from the [
15O]water TACs using the 5-parameter free diffusion model as described by Meyer [
27] applied to each time activity curve. In brief, a nonlinear least squares fit method was used to simultaneously estimate the 5 free parameters of this 1-tissue compartment model: CBF,
\(k\prime_{2}\) (
15O wash-out), blood fraction, and delay and dispersion of the blood curve between the brain and sampling point (in addition to the visual delay correction described above).
Ammonia is a freely diffusible tracer and as such has been used to quantify perfusion in myocardium [
28] and brain [
29]. Though ammonia is rapidly trapped in tissue, in order to index GS activity, the kinetic parameters describing the uptake of [
13N]ammonia by GS must be distinguishable from those reflecting CBF. The model chosen for primary analysis of [
13N]ammonia scans was an irreversible two tissue compartment model (2TCM) as used in Keiding et al. [
11]. To confirm the model choice a nonlinear spectral analysis approach was used to identify the most appropriate tissue uptake model [
30]. In brief, the data was fitted to a number of candidate PET compartmental models with increasing numbers of parameters. In this case, a reversible 2TCM [Additional file
1: Figure S1] was the most complex model considered, with increasingly simpler models defined by setting
k4,
k3,
k2 to zero (i.e. 4 candidate models). The blood fraction contributing to the TAC for each region was also included as a free parameter.
Each compartmental model was fitted using a weighted least squares method with weighting inversely proportional to the variance of each frame determined by frame duration and radioactive decay: \({{\Delta }_{i}e}^{-\lambda {t}_{i}}\), where \(\lambda\) is the decay rate constant, and \({\Delta }_{i}\) and \({t}_{i}\) are the frame duration and frame mid-point time, respectively, for frame \(i\).
Additional macroparameters from the
15O and
13N scans were calculated to compare with the results of Keiding et al. [
11]. These parameters are not directly of interest to the identification of the
k3 parameter, but were obtained solely for the purpose of comparison. PS
BBB (flow independent permeability-surface area product of the blood brain barrier to [
13N]ammonia) was calculated as
$${\text{PS}}_{{{\text{BBB}}}} = - {\text{CBF}} \ln \left( {1 - K_{1} /{\text{CBF}}} \right)$$
where CBF is calculated from the [
15O]water scan (assuming a 100% extraction fraction), and
K1 from the [
13N]ammonia scan. Extraction Fraction (EF) was also calculated as the simple ratio of
K1 to CBF. Net metabolic clearance of [
13N]ammonia in blood into intracellular [
13N]glutamine,
Kmet, was calculated using the Patlak graphical method using the complete data, with a
t* of 20 min [
32]. PS
met (flow-independent permeability-surface area product of conversion of ammonia to intracellular glutamine) was calculated as
$${\text{PS}}_{met} = - {\text{CBF}} \ln \left( {1 - K_{{{\text{met}}}} /{\text{CBF}}} \right)$$
Finally, metabolic flux of ammonia molecules from blood to glutamine in tissue, Flux
met, (as described by Keiding et al. [
11]), was calculated as
$${\text{Flux}}_{{{\text{met}}}} = K_{{{\text{met}}}} A$$
where
A is the measured concentration of endogenous ammonia in the blood.
Statistical analysis
Identifiability of the
k3 rate-constant from the [
13N]ammonia data was evaluated by testing if the estimated parameter value, relative to estimated error, was significantly greater than zero (using the one-sided
t-test). For the irreversible 2TCM model (4 parameters) with 47 frames, this corresponds to a proportional estimate parameter error of 39%. In addition, optimal model selection on the [
13N]ammonia data was assessed using the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) [
31].
Kinetic parameter repeatability between the test–retest scans was assessed using mean fractional difference (VAR), absolute fractional difference (AbsVAR), and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) using a two-way random model for consistency [
33]. For 8 subjects, the threshold for a significantly positive ICC is 0.58 at the
p < 0.05 level. VAR and AbsVAR were calculated for N subjects as a percentage:
$$\begin{aligned} & {\text{VAR}} = \frac{1}{N} \mathop \sum \limits_{i = 1}^{N} 200 \times \frac{{{\text{retestValue}}_{i} - {\text{testValue}}_{i} }}{{{\text{testValue}}_{i} + {\text{retestValue}}_{i} }} \\ & {\text{AbsVAR}} = \frac{1}{N} \mathop \sum \limits_{i = 1}^{N} 200 \times \frac{{\left| { {\text{testValue}}_{i} - {\text{retestValue}}_{i} } \right|}}{{{\text{testValue}}_{i} + {\text{retestValue}}_{i} }} \\ \end{aligned}$$
Image registration, TAC extraction, blood data processing, kinetic modeling and statistical analyses were performed in MATLAB (
www.mathworks.com). Data are presented as mean ± s.d. unless otherwise stated.
Discussion
This study evaluated kinetic models for [13N]ammonia PET as an in vivo method to assess whether a reliable estimate of trapping could be determined which could be a basis for estimating the rate of conversion of glutamate to glutamine by the enzyme glutamine synthetase (GS) in the human brain. We were able to acquire full datasets comprising two [13N]ammonia (test and retest) scans, two [15O]water scans and corresponding arterial input functions in five subjects, each on a single day. Kinetic modelling in these subjects was unable to reliably estimate the rate constant relating to GS activity (k3) from that related to [13N]ammonia brain uptake (K1) and indicated non-negligible back-flux of [13N] from the brain to the blood. In addition, comparison of K1 estimates with [15O]water CBF across brain regions and within-subjects found that these measures were highly correlated and of comparable reliability. Together these results indicate that the applied [13N]ammonia PET method is unable to quantify GS activity in the human brain, and instead may principally index CBF.
Studies in experimental animals have indicated [
13N]ammonia PET might be able to index GS activity, as irreversible blockade of GS with methionine sulfoximine (MSO) decreases the brain [
13N]ammonia signal [
34]. In kinetic modelling of dynamic [
13N]ammonia PET images of the human brain, GS activity would be captured by the rate constant
k3 in an irreversible two tissue compartment model. Using this model, our analysis returned values for
k3 that were highly variable within subjects, as well as between subjects and across grey matter regions. In most instances,
k3 values were also too low to be estimated compared to the estimated error. Only one region of 79, left hippocampus, favoured a model including a
k3 parameter in a majority of subjects, however, considering the small number (3/5) and the poor estimability of
k3 in this region it is possible this is a false positive, though we present the data for future interest. A previous [
13N]ammonia study in subjects with cirrhosis and healthy volunteers using similar methodology was also unable to provide estimates of
k3 [
20]. While volume of distribution (
VT =
K1/
k2) may potentially have provided a surrogate index of GS activity from a reversible model, we were also unable to reliably estimate
k2, with absolute variability of both
k2 and V
T around 30% (Additional file
1: Table S11). Overall, this indicates that [
13N]ammonia PET is unlikely to be a suitable method for measuring the rate of metabolism of glutamate to glutamine by GS in the human brain.
Although the question as to whether ammonia in the brain can diffuse into the blood has previously been debated [
35], back-flux of [
13N]ammonia from brain to blood has now been demonstrated in healthy volunteers as well as subjects with cirrhosis [
11,
19,
20]. Similar to these studies, our finding of small but positive values for [
13N]ammonia
k2 also indicate nonzero back-flux of
13N to blood. Consistent with this, the simplest irreversible model with a single tissue compartment and one rate constant,
K1, showed a poor fit in nearly every dataset. The presence of non-negligible wash-out was also consistent with the plateau of the decay-corrected brain time-activity curves in conjunction with approximately 10% of parent tracer compound remaining in the arterial plasma at the end of the scan. Patlak plots were nonlinear at late times, also indicating the presence of reversibility of the tracer. Our data as well as that of Goldbecker et al. [
20] indicate that back-flux of ammonia may be observed (although not reliably quantified) within 30 min of [
13N]ammonia injection. Potential biochemical explanations for washout could include the immediate back-flux of ammonia as well as a longer-term action of glutaminase recycling
13N from the neuron back to the astrocyte [
36].
The candidate compartmental models considered for [13N]ammonia in this study assumed that no 13N labelled metabolites crossed the blood brain barrier and contributed to brain tissue signal. We did not test this assumption explicitly, however, metabolites entering the brain would require a more complex kinetic model and would likely make the estimation of k3 in the parent [13N]ammonia component even less reliable due to increased numbers of parameters.
The process used in this study to separate parent [
13N]ammonia from
13N labelled metabolites was taken from the method described by Keiding et al. [
11]. However, over- or underestimated parent fractions from any uncertainties in this method and fitted model would affect the parent plasma input function and therefore the kinetic analysis. The model comparisons favoured a one-tissue compartment. If the parent fraction model overestimated the true plasma [
13N]ammonia concentration, a positive
k2 could be a bias to fit the data better and
k3 even less likely separable from
K1. An underestimate of parent plasma fraction would likely consider
k2 an underestimate of true washout, though again is unlikely to improve
k3 estimates.
Although
k2 ICC values were high in this study, the parameter estimates correspond to a half-live of approximately 100 min and accurate parameter estimates would typically require longer scan durations and consequently isotopes with more suitable half-lives. Though dependent on noise levels and simulated model specifics, Turkheimer et al. [
39] found the slowest identifiable components close to those corresponding to scan duration. Therefore we would not consider these values to be truly representative without further work.
While our data did not support estimation of GS activity, it did indicate that [
13N]ammonia PET may provide an index of CBF. [
13N]ammonia
K1 correlated with the
K1 (CBF) from the preceding [
15O]water scans in the same subjects, and based on fractional difference metrics, [
13N]ammonia brain uptake (
K1) was of comparable reproducibility to [
15O]water CBF measures over the test and retest scanning sessions. The correlations between
K1 and CBF were observed when
K1 was calculated with either a reversible one-tissue or reversible two-tissue compartment model, and to a lesser extent between
Ki (calculated using Patlak analysis) and CBF. The correlations between
K1 and CBF were qualitatively tighter for
K1 calculated from the one compared to two-tissue compartmental model, as would be expected given there are fewer parameters. Nonetheless the slope of the best fit was not identical between subjects and scans (Fig.
3). Correlating CBF and
K1 within region, across subjects and scans, did not yield significant correlations. In rhesus monkeys, Phelps et al. [
37] found nonlinear relationships between
K1 (or specifically extraction fraction, EF) and CBF, over a wide range of CBF values. Our data indicate that a linear relationship between
K1 and CBF exists when CBF lies within the normal range investigated here.
Compared to the previous study of Keiding et al. [
11] the values for [
13N]ammonia
K1 obtained in our study are approximately 35% lower and approximately 20% lower for CBF, though relative
K1 and CBF between basal ganglia (putamen and thalamus), cerebellum and cortex were similar. In addition, inter-subject variances of both parameters were comparable to that study. The absolute values of CBF were also in keeping with the variances seen between centres for quantitative PET studies (approximately 40–60 mL/min 100g), as well as inter-scan and inter-subject variability (approximately 10%) [
38]. The estimates for permeability-surface area product values and Flux
met were similar, while PS
met estimates were also slightly lower in our study, which is consistent with lower
Kmet found from the possibly unsuitable graphical method. As in Keiding et al., [
11] we applied the Patlak method [
32] to calculating
Kmet which avoided replicating the poor identification of
k2 and
k3 values with an explicit calculation. Nonetheless the fractional differences for
Kmet, PS
met and Flux
met between test and retest scans were high.
This work uses standard PET acquisition and analysis methodology, however the rapid incorporation of ammonia into glutamine [
29] along with the practicalities of using short half-life tracers (2.03 min and 9.97 min for
15O and
13N, respectively) and multiple scans with blood sampling within one day present challenges to accurately measuring the tracer kinetics which could have impacted parameter identifiability, model selection and repeatability. A number are explored here in more detail.
Measured blood curves would be delayed and dispersed between the arterial sampling point and the PET signal (further exaggerated by the length of the line from the arterial cannula to the Allogg detector). CBF was calculated with delay and dispersion explicitly included in the model fits [
27], though standard 1TCM and 2TCM were explored for [
13N]ammonia kinetics without this accounted for. As noted in work by Toussaint and Meyer [
40] delay and dispersion estimates can be highly correlated, so while including these parameters improves accuracy of CBF, their individual estimates can be inaccurate. We did extend the 5-parameter Meyer model for CBF up to a 7-parameter 2TCM (i.e. including
k3,
k4, delay and dispersion) and applied this to the [
13N]ammonia data analysis, however this did not improve
k3 estimates and the preferred model remained the reversible 1TCM. In addition, increasing the number of free parameters increased the correlation and errors in parameter estimates.
Despite the preliminary work from simulations and dry runs, due to the blood processing time and to avoid low counts from
13N decay in subsequent scans, blood sample timings for [
13N]ammonia scans were changed after the first subject’s scans (see Fig.
1, blue circles and lines) from 5-min intervals to those described in the methods. However the parent fraction fit is well within those of the remaining subjects used for the main analysis and those found by Keiding et al. [
11] so we believe it is reasonable to assume this impact would be negligible.
Two errors in acquisition for some scans could have impacted the repeatability in CBF and/or K1. Subjects 1 and 2 did not have manual blood samples measured for the [15O]water scans. For these subjects, the average plasma-over-blood values from all remaining subjects were used (mean 1.14, s.d. 0.03). For the 2nd pair of scans for subject 3 and all 4 scans for subject 4, equipment failure meant that the exact timing of the continuous blood sampler was not recorded directly but was estimated from unsynced system logs after assessment of complete datasets. As an example, for 15O, a 20 s delay would result in a 12% bias from incorrect decay correction (2% for 13N). Both these errors (plasma and sampler timing) would effect the scaling of the plasma input functions but not other properties, hence there may be biases in CBF and K1 for these subjects, but not other rate-constants or model selection.
The parent fraction model was taken from the work of Keiding et al. [
11], however the earliest blood sample was taken 4 min after tracer injection by which point most subjects showed a parent fraction under 50% (Fig.
1). It is possible that the biexponential fit is not ideal at earlier times and could influence the shape of the parent plasma curve, which may be necessary to accurately capture rapid kinetics. Similarly rapidly changing plasma-over-blood ratios (Additional file
1: Figure S2) would also have a similar impact. However, with standard PET methodology, continuous arterial sampling, while providing a detailed trace of the arterial concentration, does limit the ability to acquire large enough manual samples for further analysis without impacting the measurement of the blood peak.
The parent fraction estimation was also complicated by the outlying data from subjects 6, 7 and 8 (Fig.
1: black symbols and lines) in terms of values comparative to the remaining subjects or Keiding’s [
11] data quality as well a quality of fit to the biexponential model. Smaller sample size does not just limit power but may also increase the impact of outliers. For the main analysis we considered data from the first 5 subjects only, however the analysis from all subjects did not improve repeatability (Additional file
1: Tables S8 and S9) or model selection. A population parent fraction curve from the first 5 subjects was also used to for model fits but neither did this improve repeatability or model selection for 2TCM.
Repeatability may have been limited by participant fatigue during the second scanning session, due to the technical complexity of the study and as subjects remained in the PET centre for an average of 3.5 h between the start of the first scan and end of the last. However, interscan variability for CBF and
K1 were comparable and in line with previous CBF studies [
38].
The strong correlations observed between K1 and CBF yielded variable slopes between subjects and scan pairs. It is unclear how much is attributable to a true representation of physiology or to unforeseen errors from the challenges of complex timing with short half-life tracers.
While the CBF and K1 ([13N]ammonia) correlated well within each scan pair, this study did not investigate the quantification or detectability of changes in perfusion per se. However, PET tracers with longer radioisotope half-lives are in general easier to incorporate into a scanning schedule and the slower washout of [13N]ammonia may yield images with improved signal to noise compared to [15O]water. Our results therefore suggest that the use of [13N]ammonia as a brain perfusion marker for low to normal blood flow may warrant further investigation.