Background
Endometriosis is a gynecological disease that is characterized by occurrence of tissue similar to the lining of the uterus elsewhere in the body [
1,
2]. Endometriosis lesions can be located in the cavity and walls of the pelvis, on the ovaries, the fallopian tubes, the rectal-vaginal septum, and other body sites [
1,
2]. This disease is often accompanied by pelvic pain, inflammation and results in infertility in 30 to 50% of the affected women [
3‐
5].
It has been suggested that endometriosis-associated infertility may be due to disorders of folliculogenesis, decreased fertilization, defective implantation, and reduced oocyte quality with low capacity of blastocyst implantation [
6,
7]. Estrogen and progesterone are responsible for the regulation of numerous genes' expression during the follicular and luteal phases of the menstrual cycle [
8]. In women with endometriosis, progesterone is not able to induce several genes' expression during the window of implantation as compared to women without endometriosis. This defective response to progesterone may cause hostile conditions for blastocyst implantation in women with endometriosis [
9‐
11].
The occurrence of endometriosis can be linked to some genetic factors, immunological disorders, defective estrogen metabolism, and exposure to environmental contamination and toxins [
12‐
15]. However, the etiopathogenesis and pathophysiology of subfertility in women with endometriosis is still elusive [
2].
Endometriosis has been recognized as a disease accompanied by aberrant methylation and expression of
steroidogenic factor-1 (
SF-1),
estrogen receptor 2 (ESR2),
progesterone receptor (PR-B) and
HOXA10 genes in the eutopic endometrium of women with endometriosis [
16‐
19]. The deficient expression of
HOXA10 and
HOXA11 in infertile women with endometriosis and in animal models has been demonstrated [
16,
20‐
23]. However, it is still unclear whether the observed decreased expression of the
HOXA11 gene can be related to its hypermethylation in endometriosis-associated infertility. Therefore we studied the effect of DNA regulatory sequences' methylation on the HOXA11 transcript and protein levels in eighteen infertile women with minimal endometriosis, sixteen fertile women and sixteen infertile women with fallopian tubal occlusion from a Polish cohort. In these groups of women, we also evaluated transcript levels of DNA methyltransferases DNMT1, DNMT3A and DNMT3B.
Discussion
Hoxa11 belongs to the
Hox gene family, which are genes that encode transcription factors expressed throughout embryonic development [
34]. An equivalent of
Hoxa11 has been found in the murine model as the
Abdominal-B-type homeobox gene expressed in the limbs, kidney and stromal cells surrounding the Mullerian and Wolffian ducts [
35]. Continued expression of
hox genes has also been found in the female reproductive tract [
36,
37]. Mice that have either either
Hoxa11 or
Hoxa10 gene deletion are sterile, suggesting that these genes' products play an elementary role in endometrial growth, differentiation, receptivity, embryonic development, and female fertility [
36,
37].
Previously, we reaffirmed that DNA hypermethylation can be one of the mechanisms silencing
HOXA10 expression in the mid-secretory endometrium in infertile women with endometriosis [
38]. We subsequently decided to extend this study for
HOXA11 in these patients.
In present study we confirmed that both HOXA11 mRNA and protein levels were significantly decreased in eutopic mid-luteal endometrium in infertile women with endometriosis as compared to fertile women. However, there were no correlations between HOXA11 transcript and protein levels to age, disease duration, and clinical characteristics of patients with endometriosis (results not shown).
HOXA10 and
HOXA11 have displayed significant up-regulation in endometrial glands and stroma in humans during the mid-luteal phase at the period of implantation [
39,
40]. By contrast, women with endometriosis did not demonstrate an increase in the expression of these genes throughout the window of implantation [
20,
21]. The reduced expression of
HOXA11 along with
HOXA10 in the endometrium has been reported by Taylor
et al. (1999), who suggested that this may result in infertility in patients with endometriosis [
21]. Recently, Rackow
et al. (2011) demonstrated a marked decrease in HOXA11 and HOXA10 mRNA levels in women with endometrial polyps with reduced pregnancy rates [
41].
Our bisulfite DNA sequencing of
HOXA11 CpG rich region II (Additional file
2, Figure S1) showed significantly increased levels of DNA methylation in eutopic mid-secretory endometrium from infertile women with minimal endometriosis as compared to fertile women. However, we did not find DNA methylation in
HOXA11 CpG rich regions I and III in the same patients. Differential methylation in these regions might be due to distinct histone modifications and/or distinct interactions of nuclear proteins and non-coding RNAs to various chromatin conformations. These events might modulate DNA methyltransferase (DNMTs) accessibility to DNA, resulting in differentially methylated gene regions [
42].
The hypermethylation of
HOXA10 DNA regulatory sequences have been well documented to date in humans, and in murine and baboon endometriosis [
16,
22,
43]. However, little is know about effect of
HOXA11 gene methylation on its expression in infertile women with endometriosis. Recently, it has been demonstrated that
HOXA11 DNA methylation is significantly associated with residual tumors after cytoreductive surgery and is a marker independently associated with poor outcome in ovarian cancer [
44].
In humans, three CpG islands in the
HOXA11 gene were localized: the first is 2408 bp upstream of exon 1, the second is mainly in exon 1, and the third is in the intron separating exons 1 and 2. (Additional file
2, Figure S1). The methylation of mammalian genomic DNA is carried out by DNMTs [
45]. The role of some DNMTs in silencing
HOXA gene transcription in eutopic endometrium in women with endometriosis has been reported [
46]. We observed markedly increased levels of DNMT3A transcript in eutopic mid-secretory endometrium from women with endometriosis compared to fertile women. Our observations were on par with Wu
et al. (2007), who also found significantly higher levels of DNMT3A in eutopic endometrium from infertile women with endometriosis as compared to controls [
46].
Endometriosis has been considered as an epigenetic disease. Hypomethylation of
SF-1 and
ESR2 promoters may be responsible for increased estrogen action in women with endometriosis [
18,
19]. By contrast, a loss of progesterone response in women with endometriosis may be associated with hypermethylation of the
PR-B promoter and a reduction in this receptor's isoform levels in endometrial tissue [
17]. Moreover, hypermethylation of
HOXA10 causes its reduced expression, accompanied with some defects in blastocyst implantation in mid-luteal endometrium [
16].
We observed that decreased HOXA11 expression was associated with hypermethylation of HOXA11 CpG rich regions in eutopic mid-secretory endometrium from infertile women with endometriosis compared to fertile women. Our findings may support a view of endometriosis as an epigenetic disease.
HOXA11 protein alone is a repressor of the decidual prolactin promoter, but combined with FOXO1A transcription factor induces transcription of decidual prolactin [
47]. Therefore,
HOXA11 expression may control the proper production of decidual prolactin, which is essential for implantation and pregnancy [
48]. This may indicate that changes in
HOXA11 expression in eutopic endometrium throughout the implantation window can be one of the possible molecular mechanisms of endometriosis-associated infertility in women.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
MS contributed to designing the study, acquisition of data, analysis and interpretation of data, and in writing the manuscript. PW participated in the in the acquisition and interpretation of the data. As Principal Investigators, JS and JPP were involved in the intellectual and experimental programming of the study, the assays and interpretation of data, and writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.