Background
Methods
Study overview
Cohort enrollee recruitment
Medical enrollee recruitment
Measures
Comparisons of enrollees, refusers, and never reached potential participants
A | B | A vs. B | C | A + B vs. C | D | A + B + C vs. D | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cohort Enrollees | Medical Enrollees a | Medical vs. Cohort Enrollees | Reached but Refused to Participate | Medical and Cohort Enrollees vs. Refused | Never Reached for Participation Invite | Never Reached vs. Reached (Enrolled + Refused) | |
Total N | 1374 | 98 | 5564 | 6717 | |||
Source: Medical Record, Categorical Variables, N (Col. %) | |||||||
Study Site | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | ||||
Site 1 | 565 (41) | 16 (16) | 1248 (22) | 786 (12) | |||
Site 2 | 809 (59) | 82 (84) | 4316 (78) | 5931 (88) | |||
Race (White) | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | ||||
White | 934 (68) | 46 (47) | 3304 (59) | 3822 (57) | |||
Non-White | 440 (32) | 52 (53) | 2037 (37) | 2689 (40) | |||
Unknown Race | 223 (4) | 206 (3) | |||||
Ethnicity | p < .0005 | NA b | NA b | ||||
Hispanic/Latina | 173 (13) | 27 (28) | 1114 (20) | 1802 (27) | |||
Non-Hispanic | 1201 (87) | 71 (72) | 2213 (40) | 2375 (35) | |||
Unknown Ethnicity | 2237 (40) | 2540 (38) | |||||
High Risk Medical Conditions | |||||||
Chronic Condition (prior to pregnancy) | 277 (20) | 21 (21) | p = .76 | 581 (10) | p < .0005 | 731 (11) | p = .007 |
Pregnancy Complication | 1034 (75) | 89 (91) | p < .0005 | 3567 (64) | p < .0005 | 4292 (64) | p = .001 |
Medical visits for ARI (1 or more) | |||||||
Year Prior to Study (12 months) | 320 (23) | 38 (39) | p = .001 | 925 (17) | p < .0005 | 1075 (16) | p = .33 |
During Study Period (6 months) | 307 (22) | 98 (100) | p < .0005 | 953 (17) | p < .0005 | 850 (13) | p < .0005 |
Study Season’s Influenza Vaccination | 1038 (76) | 53 (54) | p < .0005 | 3029 (54) | p < .0005 | 3533 (53) | p < .0005 |
Medical Record, Continuous, Mean (95% CI) | |||||||
Woman’s Age (at start of season), Years c | |||||||
Both Sites | 31.7 (31.4–31.9) | 29.9 (28.7–31.1) | |||||
Site 1 | 30.6 (30.1–31.0) | 28.1 (26.8–29.4) | 29.1 (28.8–29.4) | 28.9 (28.5–29.3) | |||
Site 2 | 32.4 (32.1–32.7) | 30.3 (29.7–31.0) | 31.4 (31.2–31.5) | 31.4 (31.3–31.5) | |||
Gestational Age (at start of season), Days c | |||||||
Both Sites | 179 (176–182) | 184 (172–196) | |||||
Site 1 | 155 (151–160) | 159 (146–172) | 132 (127–138) | 134 (127–141) | |||
Site 2 | 199 (195–202) | 178 (171–185) | 168 (166–173) | 166 (164–168) | |||
Source: Enrollment Interview, Categorical, N (Col. %) | |||||||
Race (Self-Reported) | p < .0005 | ||||||
White | 934 (68) | 46 (47) | |||||
Asian | 205 (15) | 19 (19) | |||||
Black | 64 (5) | 5 (5) | |||||
Mixed or Other | 171 (12) | 28 (29) | |||||
Marital Status | P = .009 | ||||||
Married or Partnered | 1286 (94) | 85 (87) | |||||
Not Married and Not Partnered | 88 (6) | 13 (13) | |||||
Education | p < .0005 | ||||||
High school or less | 119 (9) | 19 (19) | |||||
Some college or bachelor’s degree | 744 (54) | 64 (65) | |||||
Advanced degree | 511 (37) | 15 (15) | |||||
Subjective social status | p = .002 | ||||||
1 to 3 (low) | 25 (2) | 5 (5) | |||||
4 to 6 (medium) | 697 (51) | 63 (64) | |||||
7 to 9 (high) | 632 (46) | 28 (29) | |||||
Missing or refused | 20 (1) | 2 (2) | |||||
Child(ren) aged < 13 years at home | p = .049 | ||||||
No | 644 (47) | 36 (37) | |||||
Yes child | 730 (53) | 62 (63) | |||||
Self-rated Health Status | p < .0005 | ||||||
Poor, fair, or good | 301 (22) | 46 (47) | |||||
Very good | 548 (40) | 32 (33) | |||||
Excellent | 525 (38) | 20 (20) | |||||
Smoking | p = .23 | ||||||
Never smoked | 1016 (74) | 67 (68) | |||||
Previously or currently smoke | 358 (26) | 31 (32) | |||||
Stressful events in past year (0–17) | p = .11 | ||||||
0 | 276 (20) | 11 (11) | |||||
1 | 349 (25) | 24 (24) | |||||
2 | 310 (23) | 23 (23) | |||||
3 or more | 439 (32) | 40 (41) |
A | B | A vs. B | C | A + B vs. C | D | A + B vs. D | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Medical Enrollees (Year 2) a | ARI-Negative Control Enrollees (Year 2) a | Medical vs. Control Enrollees | Reached for Recruitment but Refused to Participate | Medical and Control Enrollees vs. Refused | All Other Pregnant Women During Study (Year 2) b | Enrollees vs. All Other Pregnant Women | |
Total N | 151 | 103 | 514 | 19,264 | |||
Source: Medical Record, Categorical Variables, N (Col. %) | |||||||
Study Site | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | ||||
Site 1 | 50 (33) | 20 (19) | 229 (45) | 3466 (18) | |||
Site 2 | 101 (67) | 83 (81) | 285 (55) | 15,798 (82) | |||
Race (White) | p = .01 | p = .01 | p < .0005 | ||||
White | 81 (54) | 39 (38) | 309 (60) | 11,213 (58) | |||
Non-White | 79 (52) | 64 (62) | 178 (35) | 7409 (38) | |||
Unknown Race | 27 (5) | 642 (3) | |||||
Ethnicity | p = .045 | NA c | NA c | ||||
Hispanic/Latina | 53 (35) | 24 (23) | 96 (19) | 3684 (19) | |||
Non-Hispanic | 98 (65) | 79 (77) | 147 (29) | 7206 (37) | |||
Unknown Ethnicity | 271 (53) | 8374 (43) | |||||
High Risk Medical Conditions | |||||||
Chronic Condition (prior to pregnancy) | 37 (25) | 12 (12) | p = .01 | 95 (18) | p = .27 | 2108 (11) | p = .03 |
Pregnancy Complication | 128 (85) | 76 (74) | p = .03 | 380 (74) | p = .47 | 11,816 (61) | p = .001 |
Medical visits for ARI (1 or more) | |||||||
Year Prior to Study (12 months) | 39 (26) | 24 (23) | p = .21 | 133 (26) | p = .67 | 2799 (15) | p < .0005 |
During Study Period (6 months) | NA | NA | NA | NA | |||
Study Season’s Influenza Vaccination | 79 (52) | 65 (63) | p = .09 | 130 (25) | p = .008 | 7432 (39) | p = .17 |
Medical Record, Continuous, Mean (95% CI) | |||||||
Woman’s Age (at start of season), Years d | |||||||
Site 1 | 28.5 (26.8–29.5) | 28.5 (26.8–29.5) | 30.0 (29.2–30.7) | 29.4 (29.1–20.5) | |||
Site 2 | 30.9 (230.1–31.7) | 30.9 (230.1–31.7) | 31.3 (30.7–32.0) | 31.4 (31.3–31.5) | |||
Gestational Age (at start of season), Days d | |||||||
Site 1 | 105 (79–130) | 105 (79–130) | 123 (108–137) | 146 (142–150) | |||
Site 2 | 97 (85–110) | 97 (85–110) | 91 (81–101) | 105 (104–107) |
Active surveillance
Statistical analysis
Results
Cohort enrollees compared to non-participants in year one
Cohort enrollees compared to medical enrollees in year one
Influenza vaccination differences in year one
Medical enrollees vs. controls vs. non-participants in year two
Characteristics associated with participation in follow-up surveillance
Cohort Enrollees (Year 1) | Completed One or More Surveillance Reports | Among Surveillance Participants, Percentage (95% CI) of Weeks with Completed Reports a | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
N (Col. %) | N (Row %) | p-value b | p-value c | ||
Total N | 1374 (100) | 1106 (80) | 55 (53–56) | ||
Medical Record Variables | |||||
Study Site | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | |||
Site 1 | 565 (41) | 503 (89) | 63 (61–65) | ||
Site 2 | 809 (59) | 603 (75) | 47 (46–49) | ||
Race (White) | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | |||
White | 934 (68) | 785 (84) | 57 (56–59) | ||
Non-White | 440 (32) | 321 (73) | 48 (45–50) | ||
Ethnicity | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | |||
Hispanic/Latina | 173 (13) | 122 (71) | 48 (44–52) | ||
Non-Hispanic | 1201 (87) | 984 (82) | 55 (54–57) | ||
High Risk Medical Conditions | |||||
Chronic Condition (prior to pregnancy) | 277 (20) | 228 (82) | p = .39 | 57 (54–60) | p = .08 |
No condition | 1097 (80) | 878 (80) | 54 (52–56) | ||
Pregnancy Complication | 1034 (75) | 830 (80) | p = .72 | 54 (53–56) | p = .50 |
No complication | 340 (25) | 276 (81) | 55 (53–58) | ||
Medical visits for ARI (1 or more) | |||||
Year Prior to Study (12 months) | 320 (23) | 255 (80) | p = .68 | 55 (53–56) | p = .69 |
No visit | 1054 (77) | 851 (81) | 55 (53–56) | ||
Study Period (6 months) | 307 (22) | 234 (76) | p = .03 | 55 (53–56) | p = .76 |
No visit | 1067 (78) | 872 (82) | 55 (53–56) | ||
Study Season’s Influenza Vaccine (received) | 1038 (76) | 847 (82) | p = .07 | 55 (52–58) | p = .88 |
Not received | 336 (24) | 259 (77) | 55 (53–56) | ||
Interview variables, N (Col. %) | |||||
Woman’s Age (at start of season), Years d | p = .04 | p = .04 | |||
< 25 | 112 (8) | 93 (83) | 49 (44–54) | ||
25–29 | 317 (23) | 261 (82) | 55 (52–58) | ||
30–34 | 558 (41) | 459 (82) | 56 (54–58) | ||
≥ 35 | 387 (28) | 293 (76) | 54 (51–56) | ||
Gestational Age (at start of season), Days d | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | |||
< 137 | 339 (25) | 306 (90) | 65 (53–67) | ||
137–172 | 363 (26) | 283 (78) | 56 (54–59) | ||
173–224 | 356 (26) | 301 (85) | 53 (51–55) | ||
≥ 225 | 316 (23) | 216 (68) | 40 (37–43) | ||
Race (Self-Reported) | p < .0005 | p < .0005 | |||
White | 934 (68) | 785 (84) | 57 (56–59) | ||
Asian | 205 (15) | 154 (75) | 52 (48–55) | ||
Black | 64 (5) | 40 (63) | 44 (37–51) | ||
Mixed or Other | 171 (12) | 127 (74) | 44 (40–48) | ||
Marital Status | p = .61 | p = .003 | |||
Married or Partnered | 1286 (94) | 1037 (81) | 55 (54–57) | ||
Not Married and Not Partnered | 88 (6) | 69 (78) | 47 (41–52) | ||
Education | p = .14 | p = .08 | |||
High school or less | 119 (9) | 92 (77) | 50 (42–54) | ||
Some college or bachelor’s degree | 744 (54) | 589 (79) | 55 (53–57) | ||
Advanced degree | 511 (37) | 425 (83) | 55 (53–57) | ||
Subjective social status | p = .23 | p = .77 | |||
1 to 3 (low) | 25 (2) | 20 (80) | 51 (41–61) | ||
4 to 6 (medium) | 697 (51) | 555 (80) | 55 (53–57) | ||
7 to 9 (high) | 632 (46) | 518 (82) | 54 (52–56) | ||
Missing or refused | 20 (1) | 13 (65) | 57 (43–71) | ||
Child(ren) aged < 13 years at home | p < .0005 | p = .001 | |||
No | 644 (47) | 549 (85) | 57 (55–59) | ||
Yes child | 730 (53) | 557 (76) | 52 (51–54) | ||
Self-rated Health Status | p = .11 | p = .24 | |||
Poor, fair, or good | 301 (22) | 234 (78) | 52 (49–55) | ||
Very good | 548 (40) | 435 (79) | 55 (53–57) | ||
Excellent | 525 (38) | 437 (83) | 55 (53–54) | ||
Smoking | p = .34 | p = .68 | |||
Never smoked | 1016 (74) | 824 (81) | 55 (53–56) | ||
Previously or currently smoke | 358 (26) | 282 (79) | 54 (51–57) | ||
Stressful events in past year (number) | p = .11 | p = .001 | |||
0 | 276 (20) | 231 (84) | 55 (54–58) | ||
1 | 349 (25) | 290 (83) | 56 (54–59) | ||
2 | 310 (23) | 243 (78) | 57 (55–60) | ||
3 or more | 439 (32) | 342 (78) | 51 (48–53) |
Characteristics of women retained compared to those lost to 6-month post-delivery follow-up
All Enrollees a N (Col. %) | Completed 6-Month Follow-up Interview N (Row %) | ||
---|---|---|---|
Total N | 1726 (100) | 1595 (92) | |
Medical Record Variables | |||
Study Site | p < .0005 | ||
Site 1 | 651 (38) | 625 (96) | |
Site 2 | 1075 (62) | 970 (90) | |
Race (White) | p = .047 | ||
White | 1100 (64) | 1027 (93) | |
Non-White | 626 (36) | 568 (91) | |
Ethnicity | p = .007 | ||
Hispanic/Latina | 277 (16) | 245 (88) | |
Non-Hispanic | 1449 (84) | 1350 (93) | |
High Risk Medical Conditions | |||
Chronic Condition (prior to pregnancy) | 347 (20) | 326 (94) | p = .23 |
No condition | 1379 (80) | 1269 (92) | |
Pregnancy Complication | 1327 (77) | 1226 (92) | p = .95 |
No complication | 399 (23) | 369 (92) | |
Medical visits for ARI (1 or more) | |||
Year Prior to Study (12 months) | 358 (21) | 324 (91) | p = .13 |
No visit | 1368 (79) | 1271 (93) | |
Study Period (6 months) | 393 (23) | 352 (90) | p = .02 |
No visit | 1333 (77) | 1243 (93) | |
Study Season’s Influenza Vaccine (received) | 1235 (72) | 1152 (93) | p = .03 |
Not received | 491 (28) | 443 (90) | |
Interview variables, N (Col. %) | |||
Woman’s Age (at start of season), Years b | p < .0005 | ||
< 25 | 176 (10) | 140 (80) | |
25–29 | 412 (24) | 382 (93) | |
30–34 | 677 (39) | 642 (95) | |
≥ 35 | 461 (27) | 431 (93) | |
Gestational Age (at start of season), Days b | p = .58 | ||
< 137 | 447 (26) | 410 (92) | |
137–172 | 437 (25) | 406 (93) | |
173–224 | 437 (25) | 409 (94) | |
≥ 225 | 405 (23) | 370 (91) | |
Race (Self-Reported) | p = .035 | ||
White | 1100 (64) | 1027 (93) | |
Asian | 248 (14) | 231 (93) | |
Black | 88 (5) | 76 (86) | |
Mixed or Other | 290 (17) | 261 (90) | |
Marital Status | p < .0005 | ||
Married or Partnered | 1603 (93) | 1496 (93) | |
Not Married and Not Partnered | 123 (7) | 99 (80) | |
Education | p < .0005 | ||
High school or less | 178 (10) | 151 (85) | |
Some college or bachelors degree | 955 (55) | 879 (92) | |
Advanced degree | 593 (34) | 565 (95) | |
Subjective social status | p < .0005 | ||
1 to 3 (low) | 43 (2) | 33 (77) | |
4 to 6 (medium) | 896 (52) | 837 (93) | |
7 to 9 (high) | 763 (44) | 705 (92) | |
Missing or refused | 24 (1) | 20 (83) | |
Child(ren) aged < 13 years at home | p = .02 | ||
No | 786 (46) | 739 (94) | |
Yes child | 940 (54) | 856 (91) | |
Self-rated Health Status | p = .002 | ||
Poor, fair, or good | 416 (24) | 372 (89) | |
Very good | 693 (40) | 658 (95) | |
Excellent | 617 (36) | 565 (92) | |
Smoking | p = .005 | ||
Never smoked | 1272 (74) | 1189 (93) | |
Previously or currently smoke | 454 (26) | 406 (89) | |
Stressful events in past year (number) | p = .81 | ||
0 | 325 (19) | 300 (92) | |
1 | 438 (25) | 409 (93) | |
2 | 369 (21) | 338 (92) | |
3 or more | 594 (34) | 548 (92) |