Introduction
Methods
Literature Review
Institutional Clinical Cohort and Clinical Data Extraction
Operative Technique
Results
Literature Review
First author | Title | Year | Journal | Patient Sample | Technical Considerations and Recommendations | Level of evidence |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ousterhout, DK. | Feminization of the forehead: contour changing to improve female aesthetics | 1987 | Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | 26 | •Group 1: correct with bone reduction •Group 2: contour the frontal bone, augment the concavity above the frontal bossing •Group 3: frontal sinus osteotomy, anterior sinus wall and supraorbital rim set back; contour lateral and superior bone of the sinus and orbital rim | IV |
Dempf, R. | Contouring the forehead and rhinoplasty in the feminization of the face in male-to-female transsexuals | 2010 | Journal of Cranio-Maxillo-Facial Surgery | 1 | •Reduction of frontal bossing: subperiosteal coronal incision, anterior wall mobilized and stabilized with resorbable osteosynthesis plates. •Widening of nasofrontal angle: from 110° to 130° | V |
Hoeing, J. | Frontal bone remodeling for gender reassignment of the male forehead: a gender-reassignment surgery | 2011 | Aesthetic Plastic Surgery | 21 | •Hydroxy- apatite cement (HAC) used as an alternative for the correction of cranial vault irregularities | IV |
Spiegel, JH. | Facial determinants of female gender and feminizing forehead cranioplasty | 2011 | The Laryngoscope | 100/168 | •Burring technique alone: ideal for patients with a small frontal sinus, relatively posterior, and covered with a thick anterior table bone •Island technique: create ‘‘islands’’ of bone over the frontal sinus and set them back in interlocking fashion without violating frontal sinus •Osteotomy and set-back technique: burring; osteoplastic flap created, reduced, and secured into opening of forehead | I |
Altman, K. | Facial feminization surgery: current state of the art | 2012 | International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery | N/A | •Trichophytic incision following the hairline: for hairline modification and encouraging hair growth •Increase dimension of anterior orbital rim: all patients should undergo orbital rim contouring | V |
Capitán, L. et al. | Facial feminization surgery: The Forehead. Surgical Techniques and analysis of results | 2014 | Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | 172 | •Modified coronal approach: provides excellent access to frontonasal-orbital region and easier to reposition soft tissues •Repositioning technique (Osteotomy and Osteosynthesis): allows for modification of the nasoglabellar angle •Oblique cutaneous incision with a 35° - 45 ° scalpel inclination | IV |
Capitán, L. et al. | Facial feminization surgery: simultaneous Hair Transplant during Forehead Reconstruction | 2017 | Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | 65/492 | •Specific HLS recommendations based on transgender female hairline types •Modified temporoparietal (anterior coronal) approach: patients with good hair density and an absence of hair miniaturization •Modified temporoparietooccipital (posterior coronal) approach: patients with low temporoparietal hair density and temporoparietal hair miniaturization | IV |
Altman, K. | Forehead reduction and orbital contouring in facial feminization surgery for transgender females | 2018 | Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery | N/A | •Group I: burring with pear bur •Group II: forehead reduction with bur; may need filling for potential concavity of superior forehead •Group III: contour forehead and osteotomy of the anterior table •Bony plate cut with Toller fissure at 45° angle, trimmed with pear burr, inferior aspect placed into a retruded position under a pericranial bridge | V |
Villepelet, A. et al. | Fronto-orbital feminization technique. A surgical strategy using fronto-orbital burring with or without eggshell technique to optimize the risk/benefit ratio | 2018 | European Annals of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Diseases | 8 | •Frontal remodeling: •Simple burring with acrylic then diamond burr: used for small frontal sinus with thicker anterior walls •Eggshell burring technique: used for highly pneumatized sinus with a thin anterior wall and groups II-III •Lateral canthopexy: stretch and raise the palpebral sling | IV |
Capitán, L. et al. | The upper third in facial gender confirmation surgery: forehead and hairline | 2019 | Journal of Craniofacial Surgery | 129 | •If rhinoplasty involved: a conical burr is used to lower the frontonasal transition to the desired position •Piezoelectric scalpel for osteotomy: to free the supraorbital nerve or if patient has a thick bony septum | IV |
Di Maggio, M. | Forehead and orbital rim remodeling | 2019 | Facial Plastic Surgery Clinics of North America | N/A | •Radical reshaping of orbit: ostectomy of superolateral orbital rim •Increase orbital height: bur beneath the upper border of the orbital aperture •Selective Sinus Ablation: •Type A anatomy (Frontonasal duct open and functional): sinus mucosa removed, and sinus walls burred out •Type B anatomy (Sinus is defunctionalized): burr out mucosa and ablate the sinus with bone chips and pasting •Hair implant recommended as separate procedure to get better results | V |
Eggerstedt, M. | Setbacks in forehead feminization cranioplasty: a systematic review of complications and patient-reported outcomes | 2020 | Aesthetic Plastic Surgery | 673 | •Complications are rare: 1.3% and need for revision is low: 0.4% •Complication types: Transient CSF leak, transient frontal branch weakness, transient chemosis, pneumosinus dilatans, recurrent fluid collection | III |
Eisemann, BS. et al. | Technical Pearls in frontal and periorbital bone contouring in gender-affirmation surgery | 2020 | Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | N/A | •Anterior table osteotomy: use reciprocating saw with blade at 45-degree angle •Anterior table contouring: Complete thinning of ipsilateral side before contouring contralateral side •Stabilizing the anterior table during contouring: use finger only to secure bone, do not use instrument to stabilize. | V |
Garcia-Rodriguez, L. et al. | Scalp advancement for transgender women: Closing the gap | 2020 | The Laryngoscope | 29 | •Author’s technique (combination of brow lift, frontal cranioplasty, & scalp advancement) both advances and rounds the hairline •overall scalp advancement of 2.01 cm | IV |
Spiegel, JH. | Gender affirming and aesthetic cranioplasty: what's new? | 2020 | Current Opinion in Otolaryngology & Head and Neck Surgery | N/A | •Patients should be on feminizing hormones to stabilize hair follicles and prevent ‘male pattern baldness’ •Use of titanium microplates for fixation of bone: faster fixation and a smoother contour. •3D-cutting guides can be helpful for novice surgeons but can provide a false sense of security | V |
Telang, PS. | Facial feminization surgery: a review of 220 consecutive patients | 2020 | Indian Journal of Plastic Surgery | 220 | •Hairline incision: addresses receding/ M pattern hairline while providing lifting effect to eyebrows •Recommends a top-to-down and two-stage surgical approach for smoother recovery •Remove portion of the outer table of frontal sinus and cover it with a titanium mesh and pericranial flap | IV |
Basa, K. | Frontal bone cranioplasty for facial feminization: long-term follow-up of postoperative sinonasal symptoms. | 2021 | Facial Plastic Surgery and Aesthetic Medicine | 98 | •No difference in SNOT scores, or sinus and headache symptoms in patients with violation of the frontal sinus compared to those without •SNOT scores did not vary between this cohort and the non-symptomatic control group population | IV |
Dang, B. et al. | Evaluation and treatment of facial feminization surgery: part 1. forehead, orbits, eyebrows, eyes, and nose | 2021 | Archives of Plastic Surgery | N/A | •Hairline advancement: •Reduction of the length of the non-hair bearing forehead: pretrichial coronal incision •Galeotomies and intraoperative tissue expansion for further advancement •Simultaneous hair transplantation with forehead reconstruction •Temporal fossa augmentations: hyaluronic acid filler, autologous fat or implants | V |
Hohman, MH. et al. | 3D-Printed custom cutting guides facilitate frontal cranioplasty in gender affirmation surgery | 2021 | Journal of Craniofacial Surgery | 5 | •Notable better definition of the frontal sinus border compared to transillumination with an endoscope •Can be used for removal of the anterior table for sinus obliteration or oncologic resection | V |
Louis, M. et al. | Narrative review of facial gender surgery: approaches and techniques for the frontal sinus and upper third of the face | 2021 | Annals of Translational Medicine | N/A | Hairline approaches: •Non-surgical: estrogen or hormone replacement therapy •Surgical: FUT, FUE, and HLS Role of VSP: location of frontal sinus can be considered preoperatively; frontal sinus setback faster and more accurate | IV |
Pansritum, K. | Forehead and hairline surgery for gender affirmation | 2021 | Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery | 23 | Grid method in combination with clinical classification (Ousterhout’s) is the best method to achieve facial feminization •provides common reference points between x-ray and frontal bone intraoperatively and allows surgeons to do a 1-piece frontal bone osteotomy Frontal sinus is the key factor •Height of the frontal sinus highly determines the plan for osteotomy •Use height as only parameter because it is related to the width Fronto-orbital reassembly: primary bone contact and maintenance of a reduced bone gap •Sutures or small wires used instead of fixation with plates and screws; Bone powder rarely used | IV |
Tawa, P. et al. | Three-dimensional custom-made surgical guides in facial feminization surgery: prospective study on safety and accuracy | 2021 | Aesthetic Surgery Journal | 45 | •3D custom made surgical cutting guides have a 90.8% accuracy rate on forehead procedures on type III foreheads | IV |
Retrospective Chart Review
Variable | n (%) |
---|---|
Gender identity | |
Female | 79 (93%) |
Non-binary | 5 (6%) |
Agender | 1 (1%) |
Age | |
Mean (SD) (years) | 32.4 (9.9_ |
Ethnicity | |
Caucasian | 48 (56%) |
Hispanic/latino | 20 (24%) |
Asian | 6 (7%) |
African American | 4 (5%) |
Other | 7 (8%) |
Smoker status | |
Former smoker | 17 (20%) |
Never smoker | 68 (80%) |
Forehead classification | |
Type 1 | 7 (8%) |
Type 3 | 77 (92%) |
Lateral hairline recession | |
Yes | 68 (80) |
No | 17 (20) |
Decreased soft tissue volume of the temple regions | |
Yes | 60 (71%) |
No | 25 (29%) |
Medical history | |
DM | 3 (4%) |
HTN | 2 (2%) |
Operative | n (%) |
---|---|
Type of incision | |
Hairline | 74 (87%) |
Coronal | 11 (13%) |
Brow Lift | |
Temporal | 53 (62%) |
Bone channels | 29 (34%) |
Coronal | 3 (4%) |
Frontal sinus reconstruction/fixation | |
Autologous bone graft (split calvarial) | 78 (92%) |
Titanium mesh | 2 (2%) |
Metal plates | 76 (90%) |
Average anterior table setback | 4.12 mm |
Complications | |
Mucocele | 1 (1%) |
Re-operations/revisions | |
Brow lift revision | 5 (6%) |
Scar revision | 5 (6%) |
Bony recontouring | 1 (1%) |
Removal of hardware | 1 (1%) |
Mean follow-up period | 12.1 Months, Range: 3 weeks–3 years |