Background
Methods
Participants and recruitment
Procedures
Data analysis
Results
Key Themes | Quotes | |
---|---|---|
Structure | Taster sessions | “Maybe have lots of different activities there just in case someone gets bored or something and they don’t want to do that, and they want to do something or maybe they have different things each week.” [Child, Rural school] “Yes, but each week you could do a different thing though.” [Child, Rural school] “...drama the next day, dancing, music, art mix it up, because if you do the same thing every day it’s going to get boring” [Child, Rural school] |
After-school | “I think you’d probably have to do it straight after school, 3.20 to 4.20…the clubs that we do run…seem to run okay in that session…” [Teacher, Urban school] “After school.” [Child, Urban school] “This is where you want to be careful because the majority of pupils, 5 o'clock they go to the Mosque and they finish at seven so it would either have to be straight from school or possibly on the weekend.” [Parent, Urban school] | |
Single-sex sessions | “They’ve just done multi-sports and we had lots of take up and the girls have actually really, really enjoyed it and said how they like being involved in a club where there are not so many boys…” [Head teacher, Rural school] “No, only girls.” [Child, Urban school] “Sometimes mixed, sometimes only girls.” [Child, Urban school] | |
Content | Fun | “By sometimes playing like little mini games.” [Child, Urban school] “Letting us try new things.” [Child, Urban school] “Maybe they could make a little bit of their own game up.” [Child, Rural school] “Maybe we could have kits?” [Child, Rural school] |
Competitive | “To see how good you are and see how much you need to improve?” [Child, Rural school] “So you can see who is the best.” [Child, Rural school] “Then you can show your skills.” [Child, Urban school] “…there are not many dance groups out there that do it for fun. It is too competitive.” [Parent, Urban school] “Keep us more active.” [Child, Rural school] “You might lose at competition.” [Child, Urban school] | |
Appealing activities | “Something a little bit different, obstacle courses.” [Child, Urban school] “We won’t be able to play curbsy because we got no curbs and we can only do that on the road.” [Child, Urban school] “And it’s actually finding what they are interested in.” [Head teacher, Urban school] “It would be quite nice if you were going to do something for girls that it wasn't just about falling back on dance [laughs], you know, dance or aerobics which is the other thing which is a wildly boring thing to teach a child.” [Parent, Urban school] “Maybe like tennis or badminton, something a bit different.” [Parent, Rural school] | |
Key themes | Quotes | |
Content | Health messages | “…as long as it was all there and the resources were there and we didn’t have to provide them for ourselves.” [Teacher, Rural school] “…in a way, those free school meal children are at an advantage, because you know they’re getting the right nutrition. They’re not eating rubbish whilst they’re in school.” [Head Teacher, Urban school] “…factors to bear in mind for this age group in particular include how interventions are delivered. With more effective interventions using methods such as peer mentoring, rather than what can be perceived as ‘preachy’ type approaches.” [Senior Researcher, Policy department] “It sounds like the programme would fit in beautifully with our Healthy Schools. We are a Healthy School. So that sounds yes, like something they would understand and participate in.” [Head teacher, Urban school] |
Delivery | Female role models | “Because say like you have a problem like, in the body section, girls understand more if it's only girls in the club.” [Child, Urban school] “I don't know why, but I don't feel comfortable with male teachers.” [Child, Urban school] “The only teachers we got in our school is girls, we got no boy teachers.” [Child, Rural school] “I think you would have trouble with after school clubs for girls if there weren’t women running the sessions for all sorts of reasons, but I don't know.” [Parent, Urban school] “So from our point of view, for our Muslim parents to agree to the girls coming, it would probably need to be a female instructor.” [Head teacher, Urban school] “…if someone was my role model, I don't want them to be boring, I want them to be fun.” [Child, Urban school] “…it doesn’t matter if they’re famous or not… because they are who they are…because we think they’re role models, not other people.” [Child, Rural school] |
Links to community opportunities | “I think if we had something on our doorstep, I think they would go. I definitely think they would get more involved…we’ve got parents that are you know… willing to take up opportunities with children, whenever we have things here, if we have events here like after school…” [Head teacher, Rural school]. “I think really it’s having an increase in opportunities for them to try a different variety of sports beyond the school really.” [Head teacher, Rural school] |
Theoretical lens | Barriers* | Quotes | Intervention strategies |
---|---|---|---|
Intra | Prior commitments Motivation | “If they were doing another activity.” [Parent, Urban school] “One minute they're all for it, the next minute 'Oh I am not doing that today, I don't want to.” [Parent, Rural school] | • Straight after-school hours • Engaging activities |
Inter | Parental interest Family logistics | “I think it would be selling the programme to the parents. I think we need to you know, get the parents involved from the beginning…” [Deputy head teacher, Urban school] “I've got the younger ones, they have to be in bed by eight so as long as we were home by about seven thirty at the very latest so that they could be fed, bathed then bed.” [Parent, Urban school] | • Opt-out consent • Sessions run straight from school |
Organisational | Inadequate provision Lack of facilities Lack of staff Cost of activities | “A lot of parents have complained to the school because initially, years ago, I'd say about three years ago, there was a lot of after school activities and they've all just phased out.” [Parent, Urban school] “There isn't a lot of space in this school for sports so a lot of sports really have to be outside if you want to play with any number of people really.” [Parent, Urban school] “I think they’d like a lot of sport after school, but with such a small school … there’s only five members of staff five days of the week, so we can’t offer that.” [Teacher, Rural school] “we haven’t got the capacity if you like to do any more clubs…that would mean buying in somebody else to do that and then that would be the cost implication for them, no matter how much.” [Head Teacher, Rural School] “Would we have to pay to come to the club?” [Child, Rural School] “…it's just the cost of it. That would be the only problem, wouldn't it, really?” [Parent, Rural school] | • Maximum of 30 per session • Minimal requirement of staff time • Sessions run straight from school • Low cost/ free sessions |
Community | Role model nature | “I think the barriers are finding somebody to come in and do it. Finding somebody who knows the nature of the culture that the girls are coming from and can you know, not offend anybody, make sure that they’re on side with the parents.” [Head teacher, Rural school] | • Provide parents with role model information |
Societal | Cultural perceptions Cultural commitments | “I think you will find it difficult in this school because a lot of the girls are not allowed to take part in these things, whereas the boys are.” [Parent, Urban school] “Because you need to get ready for mosque.” [Child, Urban school] | • Provide single-sex sessions • Appropriate activities • Straight after-school hours |
Theoretical lens | Barriers* | Quotes | Intervention strategies |
---|---|---|---|
Intra | - | ||
Inter | Family resource Family logistics | “We have a lot of new families that are coming in to the country who are still going through the process of actually getting their funding sorted or finding a job.” [Teacher, Urban School] “So, especially when you've got more than one child, I've only got the one so swimming was easy for me, but that was like fifty-odd pound for a term, so if you've got like three, four kids...” [Parent, Rural school] | • Low cost options |
Organisational | Awareness of opportunities | “I’m not aware… well aware of what’s available in the community …” [Deputy Head Teacher, Urban School] “There may well be things out there. But here, I’m not aware of what I can and can’t have, and it may be something as simple as communicating.” [Head teacher, Rural school] | • Mapping community provision • Engage key community groups and leaders |
Community | Unreliable transportation Lack of opportunities Mixed-sessions Cost of activities Club opening hours | “Geographically, we’re not best placed here. … We need to take a bus to the local pool and most clubs… are quite a distance from here .” [Head teacher, Rural School] “…if it was four o’clock and it was up in [local area], sometimes we don't have a bus until ten to four, because it stops.” [Parent, Rural school] “I’d say in this area, there isn’t much.” [Teacher, Rural School] “…our comprehensive school is closing and that’s got a leisure centre attached to it. That’s our nearest facility here.” [Head teacher, Rural school] “… but from what the children tell us they do, I don’t believe there can be a lot.” [Deputy Head Teacher, Urban School] “…we wanted something that would encourage those that were put off by maybe what they saw as more aggressive actions of the boys when they’re playing… their competitive edge comes out and it puts the girls off.” [Deputy Head Teacher, Urban School] “It’s maybe not at an appropriate time or it costs.” [Deputy Head Teacher, Urban School] “I think there’s possibly things available for them but for our girls it’s obviously quite difficult to access because of time constraints really.” [Head Teacher, Urban school] | • Mapping community provision • Options within close proximity or linked to local transport • Source single-sex opportunities • After-school hours |
Societal | Cultural perceptions | “They’re in the Mosque at five and they’re there till seven o clock. So obviously accessing sports facilities is quite difficult for them and it’s not necessarily part of their culture really to do sporting activities after school.” [Head Teacher, Urban school] | • Challenging cultural norms |