The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13054-017-1710-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
The aims of this systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials are to evaluate the effects of active heated humidifiers (HHs) and moisture exchangers (HMEs) in preventing artificial airway occlusion and pneumonia, and on mortality in adult critically ill patients. In addition, we planned to perform a meta-regression analysis to evaluate the relationship between the incidence of artificial airway occlusion, pneumonia and mortality and clinical features of adult critically ill patients.
Computerized databases were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing HHs and HMEs and reporting artificial airway occlusion, pneumonia and mortality as predefined outcomes. Relative risk (RR), 95% confidence interval for each outcome and I 2 were estimated for each outcome. Furthermore, weighted random-effect meta-regression analysis was performed to test the relationship between the effect size on each considered outcome and covariates.
Eighteen RCTs and 2442 adult critically ill patients were included in the analysis. The incidence of artificial airway occlusion (RR = 1.853; 95% CI 0.792–4.338), pneumonia (RR = 932; 95% CI 0.730–1.190) and mortality (RR = 1.023; 95% CI 0.878–1.192) were not different in patients treated with HMEs and HHs. However, in the subgroup analyses the incidence of airway occlusion was higher in HMEs compared with HHs with non-heated wire (RR = 3.776; 95% CI 1.560–9.143). According to the meta-regression, the effect size in the treatment group on artificial airway occlusion was influenced by the percentage of patients with pneumonia (β = -0.058; p = 0.027; favors HMEs in studies with high prevalence of pneumonia), and a trend was observed for an effect of the duration of mechanical ventilation (MV) (β = -0.108; p = 0.054; favors HMEs in studies with longer MV time).
In this meta-analysis we found no superiority of HMEs and HHs, in terms of artificial airway occlusion, pneumonia and mortality. A trend favoring HMEs was observed in studies including a high percentage of patients with pneumonia diagnosis at admission and those with prolonged MV. However, the choice of humidifiers should be made according to the clinical context, trying to avoid possible complications and reaching the appropriate performance at lower costs.
Additional file 1: Quality assessment. Quality assessment of these studies included: 1) use of randomization sequence generation, 2) reporting and type of allocation concealment, 3) blinding, 4) reporting of incomplete outcome data, 5) comparability of the groups at baseline. H: high, L: low, U: unknown. (PDF 80 kb)13054_2017_1710_MOESM1_ESM.pdf
Additional file 2: Meta-regression. Meta-regressions for artificial airway occlusion, pneumonia and mortality. (PDF 411 kb)13054_2017_1710_MOESM2_ESM.pdf
Additional file 3: Meta-analyses for hydrophobic and hygroscopic HME vs HH for Artificial airway occlusion, mortality and Pneumonia. (PDF 231 kb)13054_2017_1710_MOESM3_ESM.pdf
American Association for Respiratory Care, Restrepo RD, Walsh BK. Humidification during invasive and noninvasive mechanical ventilation: 2012. Respir Care. 2012;57(5):782–8. CrossRef
Branson RD, Chatburn RL. Humidification of inspired gases during mechanical ventilation. Respir Care. 1993;38:461–8.
Kelly M, Gillies D, Todd DA, Lockwood C. Heated humidification versus heat and moisture exchangers for ventilated adults and children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;4:CD004711. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004711.pub2.
Denzin N, Riessman C. Narrative analysis. J Commun. 1995;45:177–84. CrossRef
PRISMA guideline. http://www.prisma-statement.org/
Bissonette B, Sessler DI, La Flamme P. Passive and active inspired gas humidification in infants and children. Anesthesiology. 1989;71(3):350–4. CrossRef
Campbell RS, Davis Jr K, Johannigman JA, Branson RD. The effects of passive humidifier dead space on respiratory variables in paralyzed and spontaneously breathing patients. Respir Care. 2000;45(3):306–12. PubMed
Linko K, Honkavaara P, Nieminen MT. Heated humidification in major abdominal surgery. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 1984;1(3):285–91. PubMed
Roustan JP, Kienlen J, Aubas S, Du Cailar J. Evaluation of an exchange filter on heat and humidity in long duration mechanical ventilation. Comparison with heated humidification. Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 1989;8 Suppl:R275.
Alagar R. Heated humidification reduces saline instillations, nebulized therapy, and cost in long term ventilated patients (abstract). American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. American Thoracic Society 2000 International Conference; May 5-10; Toronto, Canada. 2000; Vol. 161; 3 Suppl: A552.
Branson RD, Campbell RS, Johannigman JA, Ottaway M, Davis Jr K, Luchette FA, et al. Comparison of conventional heated humidification with a new active hygroscopic heat and moisture exchanger in mechanically ventilated patients. Respir Care. 1999;44(8):912–17.
Dias MD, Pellacine EN, Zechineli CA. The new system of gaseous mixture humidification and heating of respirators: comparative study. Rev Assoc Med Bras. 1993;39(4):207–12. PubMed
Johnson PA, Raper RF, Fisher MDM. The impact of heat and moisture exchanging humidifiers on work of breathing. Anaesth Intensive Care. 1995;23(6):697–701. PubMed
MacLeod R, Bucknall T. Mechanical ventilation with heated humidifiers or with heat and moisture exchangers with microbiological filters did not reduce ventilator associated pneumonia in adults. Evid Based Nursing. 2006;9(3):82. CrossRef
McEvoy MT, Carey TJ. Shivering and rewarming after cardiac surgery: comparison of ventilator circuits with humidifier and heated wires to heat and moisture exchangers. Am J Crit Care. 1995;4(4):293–9. PubMed
Schiffmann H, Rethgeber J, Singer D, Harms K, Bolli A, Zuchner K. Airway humidification in mechanically ventilated neonates and infants: A comparative study of a heat and moisture exchanger vs. a heated humidifier using a new fast-response capacitive humidity sensor. Crit Care Med. 1997;25(10):1755–60. CrossRefPubMed
Takumi Y, Aochi O. Effect of emphysematous expansion and humidification on the intrapulmonary gas exchange. Anaesthesist. 1970;19(10):373–83. PubMed
Alonso-Iñigo JM, Almela A, Albert A, Carratalá JM, Fas MJ. Active humidification with Boussignac CPAP: in vitro study of a new method. Respir Care. 2013;58(4):647–54. PubMed
Schena E, Quaranta A, Saccomandi P, Silvestri S. Performances of heated humidifiers in mechanical ventilation: a preliminary intra-breath analysis. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2013;2013:934–7. PubMed
Schena E, De Paolis E, Silvestri S. Gas pre-warming for improving performances of heated humidifiers in neonatal ventilation. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2011;2011:1205–8. PubMed
Kirkegaard L, Andersen BN, Jensen S. Moistening of inspired air during respirator treatment. Comparison between the water-bath evaporator and hygroscopic moisture heat exchanger. Ugeskr Laeger. 1987;149(3):152–5. PubMed
Dreyfuss D, Djedaini K, Gros I, Mier L, LeBourdelles G, Cohen Y, et al. Mechanical ventilation with heated humidifiers or heat and moisture exchangers: effects on patient colonization and incidence of nosocomial pneumonia. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1995;151(4):986–92. PubMed
Branson RD, Davis Jr K, Brown R, Rashkin M. Comparison of three humidification techniques during mechanical ventilation: patient selection, cost and infections considerations. Respir Care. 1996;41(9):809–16.
Kirton O, De Haven B, Morgan J, Morejon O, Civetta J. A prospective, randomised comparison of an in-line heat moisture exchange filter and heated wire humidifiers: rates of ventilator-associated early-onset (community-acquired) or late-onset (hospital-acquired) pneumonia and incidence of endotracheal tube occlusion. Chest. 1997;112(4):1055–9. CrossRefPubMed
Luchetti M, Stuani A, Castelli G, Marraro G. Comparison of three different humidification systems during prolonged mechanical ventilation. Minerva Anestesiol. 1998;64(3):75–81. PubMed
Diaz RB, Barbosa DA, Bettencourt AR, Vianna LAC, Gir E, Guimaraes T. Evalution [sic] the use of hygroscopic humidifier filters to prevent nosocomial pneumonia. Acta Paulista de Enfermagem. 2002;15(4):32–44.
Bench S. Humifification in thr long-term ventilated patients; a systematic review. Intens Crit Care Nurs. 2033;19:75–84. CrossRef
Hess DR, Kallstrom TJ, Mottram CD, et al. American Association for Respiratory Care are of the ventilator circuit and its relation to ventilator associated pneumonia. Respir Care. 2003;48:869–79. PubMed
- Heat and moisture exchangers (HMEs) and heated humidifiers (HHs) in adult critically ill patients: a systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of randomized controlled trials
Antonio M. Esquinas
- BioMed Central
Neu im Fachgebiet AINS
Meistgelesene Bücher aus dem Fachgebiet AINS
e.Med Kampagnen-Visual, Mail Icon II