Background
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a primary tumour of the liver whose incidence has steadily increased in recent years, reaching the fifth place worldwide. HCC has a dismal prognosis and it ranks second in terms of mortality. A minority of patients benefit from curative therapies (liver transplantation, tumour resection) and a high incidence of postoperative recurrence is observed after resection. Tumour recurrence is the major cause of death following resection [
1‐
3]. In this context, efforts must be pursued to better characterize HCC at genetic, molecular and cellular levels to identify key oncogenic pathways and therapeutical targets.
HER3 (ErbB3) belongs to the HER family including HER1 (ErbB1 or epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR)), HER2 (ErbB2), and HER4 (ErbB4). Heregulin-1ß (or neuregulin-1ß) is a high affinity ligand for HER3. HER3 has minimal tyrosine kinase activity and its full activation upon heregulin-1ß binding, depends on its association with other HER members such as EGFR and HER2. Activated HER3 has six tyrosine-containing binding sites for the p85 regulatory subunit of PI3K in the cytoplasmic tail, making HER3 a major regulator of AKT-dependent signalling [
4‐
6]. These last years, the heregulin-1ß/HER3 signalling axis has generated much interest in medical oncology. Indeed, high tumour expression of HER3 has been shown to be predictive of tumour progression and poor survival in patients with ovarian [
7], breast [
8,
9], melanoma [
10] or gastric [
11,
12] cancers. The presence of paracrine/autocrine heregulin-1ß loops also defines a subset of agressive tumours with higher recurrence in head and neck squamous cell carcinomas [
13,
14]. Yet, the poor prognostic value of HER3 and/or heregulin-1ß remains controversial in other cancers such as bladder cancer [
15], uveal melanoma [
16] and lung adenocarcinoma [
17].
Data regarding the HER3 status in HCC are scarce. Available data have been essentially obtained from populations of Asian patients with viral hepatitis. A Japanese study reported that 64 out of 84 HCC were positive for cytoplasmic HER3 by immunohistochemistry [
18]. The transcriptomic profile of 37 hepatitis B virus (HBV)-related HCC showed that HER3 mRNA was one of the most frequently induced [
19]. More recently, a Taiwanese group reported that upregulation of HER3 mRNA was associated with HBV etiology, microvascular invasion, early recurrence and poor clinical outcome in 71 patients with HCC [
20]. No data are available regarding heregulin-1ß expression in HCC.
The present study was defined to gain information regarding the status of HER3 and heregulin-1ß in a French collection of HCC. We observed that HER3 mRNA expression was increased in 52 % of 85 tumours while heregulin-1ß mRNA expression was reduced in 82 %. No prognostic value was found for HER3 or heregulin-1ß mRNA expression in this collection. In addition, no correlation was observed between HER3 mRNA and protein levels. The analysis of the post-transcriptional regulation of HER3 in HCC cell lines revealed that the heregulin-1ß/HER3 signalling pathway was controlled negatively by insulin at different levels.
Discussion
Our study shows that HER3 mRNA is upregulated (52 %) in a French collection of 85 HCC compared with adjacent nontumour tissue. In accordance with studies performed on Asian collections of HCC [
19,
20], we observed that the upregulation of HER3 mRNA was associated to chronic HBV infection. Therefore, it is tempting to speculate that HBV may favour higher HER3 expression during liver carcinogenesis. In this setting, a recent
in vitro study showed that the viral protein Hbx transcriptionally up-regulates HER3 expression in HCC cells [
26]. Moreover, secreted HER3 has been shown to be a biomarker for early HCC in patients with chronic B hepatitis and cirrhosis [
27]. By contrast, it has been recently demonstrated that HCV down-regulates HER3 expression at both transcript and protein levels in the Huh7 cell line [
28]. Accordingly, we observed that HER3 mRNA levels were low in HCV-related HCC. Altogether, these data suggest that the expression of HER3 mRNA is regulated differentially by the viral factors contributing to HCC.
Fold induction for HER3 mRNA expression was also higher in well/moderately differentiated tumours than in poorly differentiated ones. In the same setting, studies conducted on a large panel of hepatoma cell lines showed that HER3 expression was higher in cell lines with an epithelial phenotype than in those with a mesenchymal phenotype [
29,
30], suggesting that HER3 is rather a marker of epithelial traits in HCC.
Autocrine expression of heregulin-1ß has been reported to be a predictive biomarker for response to anti-HER3 antibodies, even in tumours showing no significant prognostic association between heregulin-1ß and OS or PFS [
31,
32]. In our HCC collection, the expression of heregulin-1ß transcript was lower in tumours (82 %) than in adjacent tissue, which does not support the existence of heregulin-1ß/HER3 autocrine loops in HCC. Moreover, we have not been able to assign a prognostic value to HER3 and heregulin-1ß mRNA levels. These data contrast with the study by Hsieh and colleagues [
20], which reported that upregulation of HER3 mRNA was predictive of early recurrence and poor clinical outcome in a Taiwanese collection of 71 HCC. The reason for such a discrepancy remains unclear. One potential explanation is that the two patient populations diverge in terms of liver-disease etiology. Altogether these data suggest that HCC patients may not derive significant clinical benefit from HER3-directed monotherapies.
There is no standardized method for HER3 detection by immunohistochemistry and information regarding HER3 staining in HCC are limited. The sole extensive study was published with the clone 2F12, which showed frequent HER3 cytoplasmic staining in HCC [
18]. In our hands, this clone (and two other ones) did not give signals while the clone RTJ1 yielded cytoplasmic staining but was not reproducible in terms of intensity. The clone RTJ1 has been previously used to detect HER3 in breast [
8,
33] and lung [
34] cancers. However, the reliability of this clone has been challenged by others [
35]. An internationally accepted and validated method for immunohistochemistry detection of HER3 needs consideration.
HER3 is a receptor that is finely regulated at the post-transcriptional and post-translational levels in several cell types. Notably, the steady state level of HER3 protein can be regulated by the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway [
25]. Since we did not observe correlation between HER3 mRNA and protein levels in human liver tissue, it is highly probable that HER3 is submitted to post-transcriptional and/or post-translational regulation in this tissue. Although insulin is generally considered as an anabolic hormone that supports protein synthesis and inhibits protein degradation, prolonged exposure of cells to insulin also promotes ubiquitin-proteasome degradation of specific proteins such as insulin-receptor substrate-1 [
36] and Foxo1 [
37]. Liver tumours express IR and insulinemia plays a key role in the pathogenesis of HCC [
38]. We show here that insulin promotes the degradation of HER3 protein in untransformed human hepatocytes and that this negative regulation is maintained in some HCC cell lines such as HepG2 and PLC/PRF5 cells. The pathway whereby insulin acts to repress HER3 protein expression involves proteasome engagement. Further studies are needed to examine whether insulin enhances HER3 ubiquitination in HCC cells. In any case, we did not find evidence of a contributory role of NRDP1 in the effect of insulin.
In HCC cells in which insulin did not promote HER3 degradation, we demonstrate that insulin is able to counteract the pro-migratory effect of heregulin-1ß namely Hep3B and Huh7 cells. The functional interplay between IR and HER3 signalling can be at least partly explained by the physical proximity between the two receptors proved by a coimmunoprecipitation assay. We demonstrate that insulin, through its receptor, was able to rapidly phosphorylate HER3. However, the striking observation was that the insulin-induced HER3 phosphorylation was partial, involving Y1289 but not Y1197 residue. Moreover, we report that the depletion of IR protein with siRNA was accompanied by an increase in heregulin-1ß-induced AKT phosphorylation, indicating that HER3 activation was dependent on IR expression levels. The inhibitory effect of IR on heregulin-1ß/HER3 signalling probably explains the ability of insulin to restrict cell migration in response to heregulin-1ß. The underlying mechanisms remain to be deciphered. In particular, it will be of interest to examine the impact of insulin-induced HER3 phosphorylation on heregulin-1ß affinity and heterodimers balance (EGFR/HER3, IR/HER3) at the plasma membrane.
Abbreviations
CK19, cytokeratin 19; DAPI, 4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole; FBS, fetal bovine serum; HBV, hepatitis B virus; HCC, hepatocellular carcinoma; IR, insulin receptor; NT, non tumour; OS, overall survival; RFS, recurrence-free disease; T, tumour
Acknowledgements
The authors thank tumour biobank HUEP (APHP) for providing human liver tissues, Sylvie Dumont for immunohistochemistry, Claire Calmel for cell line genotyping and Diane Girard for technical assistance and English editing.