Hyperphosphorylated tau in young and middle-aged subjects

As indicated above, 31 out of 95 (33%) unimpaired middle-aged subjects, ranging from 22 to 50 years of age at death, manifested HPτ pathology in one or both of the assessed regions, i.e. the transentorhinal cortex and the LC, during assessments of routine diagnostic sections. Moreover, in 25 subjects out of 89 (28%) lacking HPτ pathology in the transentorhinal cortex, HPτ pathology was seen solely in the LC. Thus, our results are, in principle, in agreement with Braak et al. [7] who recently reported the LC, frequently being affected with HPτ pathology even in very young subjects. They reported that in as many as 22 out of 26 (85%) young subjects lacking HPτ pathology in the transentorhinal cortex, some HPτ pathology was seen in the LC. This percentage of 85%, in subjects ranging from 4 to 29 years of age at death, was significantly higher when compared to our results of 28%.

It is noteworthy that in our study the subjects were older in comparison with subjects studied by Braak and Del Tredici. Thus, one would have expected that the ageing-related HPτ pathology would have been observed even more frequently in our material, given that the age at death ranged from 22 to 50 years in our study. We noted in our material that indeed the incidence of HPτ pathology in the LC increases with age, being 14% in the youngest and 42% in the oldest group. There are two significant differences when comparing our study with the study reported by Braak and Del Tredici. The studies differ based on: (1) the methodology used while assessing HPτ pathology and (2) the sampling strategy of subjects.

Specifically, Braak and Del Tredici used 100 μm thick sections in comparison with our 7 μm thick sections. Consequently, cases displaying only occasional or few HPτ-IR neurites might have been missed, due to us assessing sections that were 14 times thinner. Braak and Del Tredici reported that in 12 out of 26 cases, only HPτ-IR neurites were observed in the LC (minimal pathology) whereas in 10 out of these 26 subjects, in addition to HPτ-IR neurites, IR nerve cells were also noted (moderate amount of pathology). Thus, the finding of 10 subjects out of 26 (38%) with IR neurites and nerve cells when assessing 100 μm thick sections is more in line with our results of 28%, given that we assessed sections that were 14 times thinner. While studying subjects with AD-related pathology, Busch et al. [8] reported that there is a significant difference with regard to distribution of HPτ pathology in the LC. While carrying out a topographical analysis, the dorsal and medial portions of the LC were reported to be more affected when compared with the ventral and lateral portions, emphasising the importance of neuroanatomical sampling strategy [8]. This variation in topographical distribution of pathology should not have contributed to the observed differences as the sampling strategy in our study and that of Braak and Del Tredici is comparable, i.e. the tissue block assessed was obtained at the level of pontine tegmentum. Thus, the primary difference in the presence of HPτ pathology in the LC is probably due to the thickness of the sections assessed, i.e. 7 versus 100 μm.

The selection strategy of subjects to be studied also differed. The cause of death among subjects studied by Braak and Del Tredici was quite various, including brain tumours and transplantation of organs; all diseases associated with heavy pharmaceutical treatment. Thus, in some cases hyperphosphorylation of the microtubule-associated τ protein might be due to the used pharmacological therapy. Agents such as cell cycle inhibitors, mitochondrial complex I inhibitors, anti microtubule agents as well as glucocorticoids have been reported to induce hyperphosphorylation of τ in in vivo and in vitro studies [10, 16‐18, 30]. In addition, some of the subjects had suffered from head injury. An association between acute head injury and accumulation of HPτ has been reported to be seen in both experimental animal studies as well as in human studies [12, 19, 32]. Our selection strategy was more stringent. Specifically, we only included subjects who died acutely without prolonged disease or heavy pharmaceutical treatment. Thus most of our subjects, 67 out of 95, died due to an acute vascular event, i.e. cerebral or cardiac insults. Cardiovascular alterations in middle age have been suggested as being a risk factor regarding cognitive decline and dementia in later life and cardiovascular disease and AD share many common risk factors [21, 29]. However, it is noteworthy that cerebrovascular lesions were seen just as frequently, both in subjects with and also without HPτ pathology. Thus, 33% of our subjects, with age ranging from 22 to 50 years at death, displayed HPτ pathology in the transentorhinal cortex and/or locus coeruleus without any specific known causative reason.

Interestingly, while studying drug abusers, Anthony et al. [3] reported the LC to be affected with HPτ pathology in young subjects (age at death <30 years). It is noteworthy that the LC was more involved than compared to the hippocampus in these young subjects; a finding in line with both our observations, and those reported by Braak and Del Tredici. Surprisingly, in subjects >30 years of age at death, the HPτ pathology was reported to be more severe in the hippocampus than compared to the LC [3]. Overall, the HPτ pathology increased with age; a finding in line with ours. Thus, based on the above it is obvious that the LC is indeed frequently affected with HPτ pathology prior to other brain regions.

In 2004 Braak and Del Tredici stated in a commentary that the pathological process of AD, displays a simultaneous involvement of the transentorhinal cortex, magnocellular nucleus and the LC. Furthermore, in 2011 they reported that HPτ pathology in the LC is frequently seen in subjects under the age of 30 and they suggest that this pathology might be the initiation of AD or other tauopathies [6, 7]. In 2011, while assessing 889 cases fulfilling the Braak criteria of more than IV, Murray et al. identified three different distributional patterns, i.e., classical (75%), limbic predominant (14%) and hippocampal sparing (11%). This finding suggests more than one pattern of pathological progression of AD [24]. 33% of our unimpaired subjects, with age ranging from 22 to 50 years at death displayed HPτ pathology in the LC and/or entorhinal cortex. It could be interpreted from these findings that these subjects are in a preclinical stage of a tauopathy. This interpretation would further be in line with the report of tauopathy spreading from one site to another in a transgenic mice model, indicating that tauopathy might propagate in a prion-like way and thus, all those with HPτ pathology in the LC would in due time progress into a tauopathy [9, 13]. The suggestion that young and middle-aged individuals that display HPτ pathology in the LC and entorhinal cortex would progress to a symptomatic tauopathy is, however, controversial. A substantial number of neurologically unimpaired subjects even at a very old age display only sparse to modest extent of neurodegenerative pathology and only a subset of the middle-aged subjects with HP tau pathology in the LC and entorhinal cortex seem to develop a dementing disorder with aging. This observation indicates that other, yet unknown modifying mechanisms lead to the regional progression of pathology causing a symptomatic disorder.

It is noteworthy that most of our cases with HPτ-IR pathology in the LC did not display cortical Aβ aggregates. This finding is in line with results reported by Braak and Del Tredici [7]. Thus, our results and the results reported by Braak and Del Tredici are in line with the presumption that the neuronal cytoskeletal alteration is a primary lesion that might induce the extracellular deposits of Aβ. It is also important to note, however, that Wirths et al. [33] recently reported that they were able to detect intraneuronal oligomeric assemblies of N-terminally truncated Aβ peptides starting with pyroglutamate (AβpE3), not detectable with other commonly applied antibodies in an unimpaired control lacking extracellular aggregates of Aβ. Consequently subjects, even at a very young age, should be examined for oligomeric intracellular Aβ in order to assess which of the two pathologies, HPτ or oligomeric Aβ is primarily observed.

In our study, the pathology was only seen in the transentorhinal cortex in three cases. This finding of the LC being unaffected in these three cases might be due to the methodological aspects discussed above. We only stained one section, thus a minute amount of pathology could easily have been missed. Another explanation might be related to the hypothesis proposed by Braak and Del Tredici [6], that of simultaneous involvement of the transentorhinal cortex, magnocellular nucleus and the LC with HPτ pathology.

Behavioural and psychological symptoms such as depression, mood and emotional disturbances, confusion and agitation are observed in AD patients [28]. Several studies have suggested that pathological alteration in the LC and substantia nigra are probably causative regarding the depression in AD [34]. Previous assessment of the LC in subjects with mood disorders has been centred on cell count/loss. Assessment of HPτ pathology in the LC in subjects with the clinical diagnosis of pure mood disorders has not been systematically carried out to our knowledge. Association of LC pathology with depression and observation of early involvement of the LC with HPτ pathology is disturbing. First, this could suggest that a tauopathy is initiated much earlier than previously even suspected. Secondly, this finding might implicate that young subjects with depression might be at risk for developing AD or other tauopathy in later life. Rapp et al. [27] reported that the load of pathology in subjects with AD was significantly higher in those who had suffered from a lifetime history of depression, thus, suggesting an association between these two disorders. In line with the observations above, an association between AD and history of early onset of depression has been reported [11]. Thus, additional post-mortem studies assessing HPτ pathology in the brain stem of subjects of all ages with a diagnosis of a mood disorder are urgently needed to clarify this issue.

In summary, we conclude that HPτ pathology is indeed frequently seen in the LC in unimpaired middle-aged subjects without any obvious risk factors known to alter the microtubule-associated protein. HPτ pathology was noted in the LC in 25 out of 83 subjects (30%) lacking concomitant cortical Aβ or transentorhinal HPτ. This observation was obtained when assessing only one section with 7 μm thickness. The finding of frequent involvement of LC with HPτ pathology in early middle-aged subjects raises many questions and concerns. It is not clear whether this pathology is the primary stage of AD or other tauopathy or merely an insignificant alteration related to ageing. The suggestion of prion-like propagation of neurodegeneration would be in line with the former interpretation [13] whereas the observation of sparse extent of pathology in most aged subjects supports the latter. In most cases, HPτ was observed without concomitant Aβ pathology. Recent observations have shown the presence of oligomeric Aβ in aged cases without Aβ aggregates. Thus, assessment of oligomeric Aβ in individuals with sparse HPτ pathology should urgently be carried out. The association between the LC and mood disorders raises the question of whether some subjects with a mood disorder are at risk of developing a tauopathy. Clinicopathological studies on young subjects and particularly those with mood disorders are thus urgently needed.