Background
Stress and psychological and physical health
Other stress outcomes and associations
Concerns about impact of NG911 technologies
Project aim
-
Investigate the impact of new technologies and information sources on 9–1-1 TC work
-
Understand moderators, mediators and buffers to stress in the emergency call center workplace
-
Investigate the influence of stress on outcomes such as attrition, work-related absenteeism, and turnover intention
-
Describe the roles of job demands, job controls, and job resources on stress
Theoretical framework
Methods/design
Study design
Study setting
Population
Sample size
Study variables and measurement instruments
-
Enrollment Demographic Information. Participants will enroll online using electronic consent as approved by Human Subjects Review. Call center characteristics such as call center staffing data, absenteeism, etc., will be provided by managers (see Table 1A). TC (see Table 1B) and manager (see Table 1C) demographic information will be requested at enrollment and updated at each data collection point.
-
Online TC Survey. The survey will be administered through a secure web site and will include items regarding personal stress from the cSOSI [46] which measures the type of and frequency with which respondents experience physical, psychological, and behavioral responses during a designated time frame selected by the investigator. The cSOSI is a self-report survey consisting of 56 items with 8 subscales: cardiovascular, muscle tension, neurological/GI, depression, anger, sympathetic arousal, upper respiratory and cognitive disorganization. The survey asks the frequency of occurrence of each item in the previous week using a 5 point scale (0 = never to 4 = very frequently). Both predictive and concurrent validity of the tool have been established in studies that captured effects of stress management therapies and correlation with levels of exposure to sources of occupational and illness related stress [48]. Participants will also be asked to complete survey items regarding job performance self-assessments, job satisfaction, impact of technologies (anticipated and actual) on performance, workplace support, and workplace demands (such as mandatory overtime) as described in Table 2.
-
Online Manager Survey. At each data collection point managers will be asked to update call center information regarding absenteeism, vacancies, etc. as well as indicate number of hours they have had to fill in for TCs due to absenteeism, training or low census, their current work-related stress level and their perception of overall stress level at the call center as listed in Table 1A and C.
1A. Call Center Work Environment Demographics & Characteristics | ||
Type of Center (urban/rural) # TCs Basic Shift Structureb Shift Assignment Processb Overtime Structure (voluntary/mandatory, # hours between shifts)b Break Structureb Benefitsb | Training Protocolsb Absenteeism Levela Attrition (Voluntary, Terminated, Laid Off, Retired)a Current Vacancies/Vacancy Levela Citizen Complaints/Inquiriesa | Mandatory Overtime Requireda General Call Center Stress Levela Call Center Technology-Related Stress Levela Ongoing Training (topic, length)a |
1B. TC Demographics & Characteristics | ||
Gender Age Range Age (years)c Educational Level Race Ethnicity | Position/Role Years Worked as TC Current Shift/Work Schedule Partner Status Children under 18 Years Sick Days Taken (last month) | Vacation Taken (last month) Overtime, Mandatory & Voluntary (last month) Stressful Calls (last month) Regular Exercise Pet Ownership |
1C. Manager Demographics & Characteristics | ||
Gender Age Range Age (years)c Educational Level | Race Ethnicity Years Worked in Center Years as Manager in Center | Fill-in for TCs, # Hours (last month) Current Personal Work-Related Stress Level |
2A. Primary Outcome Variables | |
Construct/Variable | Definition |
Stress | Symptoms of stress [46] |
Job Satisfaction | |
Job Performance: Perceived Usefulness & Utility | |
Job Performance: Job-Fit/Job Complexity | Utilization of a new tool or system as strongly influenced by perception of expected consequences (complexity of use and fit between the job and what the technology offers) [62] |
Job Performance: Professional Efficacy | The extent to which a person believes s/he can meet workplace demands can mitigate the effect of high job demands on stress and stress-related burnout [39] |
2B. Moderators | |
Support Satisfaction | |
Network Conflict | Perceptions of manager and co-worker conflict as direct sources of stress and which influence appraisal of occupational stressors [65] |
Multi-tasking | |
Technologies & Task Load | Stress experienced by end users in organizations as a result of their use of ICTs, constant ICT changes and the physical, social and cognitive responses demanded by their use. Technostress is a combination of 5 different aspects or dimensions: techno-overload (ICTs force users to work faster and longer), techno-invasion (invasive effect of constantly being connected), techno-complexity (complexity associated with ICTs leads users to feel inadequate, forcing them to spend time and effort learning new skills), techno-insecurity (users feel threatened about losing their job due to ICTs) and techno-uncertainty (continual ICT changes and upgrades unsettle users and creates uncertainty about skills) [31, 32] |
Overcommitment | |
Attitude toward Behavior | |
Turnover Intention | An employee’s intention to leave or stay at their current place of employment or current job role/title which is important in relation to job satisfaction, a salient antecedent of turnover intent and a key mediating variable between the work environment and turnover intent [70]. |
Absenteeism | |
Specific Technologies | Perceptions of anticipated and actual impact of specific NG911 information sources on performance [71] |
Work-Life Balance & Job Satisfaction | The extent to which an individual is engaged in and satisfied across different life roles—work role and family role—which is associated with quality of life and well-being, with a positive balance implying a high level 2of satisfaction and a negative balance suggesting a low level of satisfaction [72] |
2C. Individual Characteristics & Open-Ended Items | |
Current Overall Work-Related & Non-Work-Related Stress Levels Stress Coping Methods Self-Care/Outside of Work Support | Attitude towards Overtime Current & Preferred Position/Role Current & Preferred Shift/Work Schedule |