Background
Methods
Stage 1: Understanding the behaviour
Stage 2: Identifying intervention options
-
(Affordability) Is the cost of the proposed intervention within budget?
-
(Practicality) Can the intervention be delivered as designed in the intended setting?
-
(Effectiveness) How effective is the intervention? What is the magnitude (effect size) of the relationship between intervention and behaviour?
-
(Acceptability) Is the intervention deemed appropriate by key stakeholders?
-
(Side effects) Are there any unwanted side effects from delivering this intervention that need to be considered?
-
(Equity) Does the intervention reduce or increase disparities between different sectors of society?
Stage 3: Identify content and implementation options
Results
Stage 1: Understanding the behaviour
Stage 2: Identifying intervention options
TDF Domain | Intervention Function | Intervention Function Definitionsa | Included/excluded from next stage | Reasons for Inclusion/exclusion (against APEASE criteria) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Knowledge | Education | Increasing knowledge or understanding | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Training | Imparting skills | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Enablement | Increasing means/reducing barriers to increase capability (beyond education/ training) or opportunity (beyond environmental restructuring) | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Beliefs about consequences | Education | Increasing knowledge or understanding | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Persuasion | Using communication to induce positive or negative feelings or stimulate action | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Incentivisation | Creating an expectation of reward | Excluded | Not considered affordable, unlikely to be acceptable to policy makers and would possibly be impractical to incentivise over a sustained period of time | |
Coercion | Creating an expectation of punishment or cost | Excluded | Not considered practical to deliver (as HCPs often want to maintain good and balanced relationships with patients), unlikely to be acceptable to HCPs or patients morally and ethically, enforcing punishment or cost onto patients will also likely have unwanted side effects, and could reduce equity for some sectors of the community | |
Emotions | Persuasion | Using communication to induce positive or negative feelings or stimulate action | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Incentivisation | Creating an expectation of reward | Excluded | Not considered affordable, unlikely to be acceptable to policy makers and would possible be impractical to incentivise over a sustained period of time | |
Coercion | Creating an expectation of punishment or cost | Excluded | Not considered practical to deliver (as HCPs often want to maintain good and balanced relationships with patients), unlikely to be acceptable to HCPs or patients morally and ethically, enforcing punishment or cost onto patients will also likely have unwanted side effects, and could reduce equity for some sectors of the community | |
Restriction | Using rules to reduce the opportunity to engage in the target behaviour (or to increase target behaviour by reducing the opportunity to engage in the competing behaviour) | Excluded | Not considered practical to deliver as medicine taking can be carried out alone and so there will be no one present to enforce rules, unlikely to be acceptable to patients, HCPs or policy makers as rules often require legislation changes to be enforceable and acted upon | |
Environmental Restructuring | Changing the physical or social context | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity unless patients do not have access to similar healthcare services or possess similar abilities | |
Modelling | Providing an example for people to aspire to or imitate | Excluded | Not considered to be practical to deliver as patients do not always have contact with HCPs or other patients when collecting prescriptions for medications, could potentially create disparities in equity | |
Enablement | Increasing means/reducing barriers to increase capability (beyond education/ training) or opportunity (beyond environmental restructuring) | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Intervention Function | Policy Category | Policy Category Definitiona | Included/excluded from next stage | Reasons for Inclusion/exclusion (against APEASE criteria) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Education | Communication/Marketing | Using print, electronic, telephonic or broadcast media | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Guidelines | Creating documents that recommend or mandate practice. This includes all changes to service provision | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Regulation | Establishing rules or principles of behaviour or practice | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to current health practice regulations | |
Legislation | Making or changing laws | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to law | |
Service Provision | Delivering a service | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Persuasion | Communication/Marketing | Using print, electronic, telephonic or broadcast media | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Guidelines | Creating documents that recommend or mandate practice. This includes all changes to service provision | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Regulation | Establishing rules or principles of behaviour or practice | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to current health practice regulations | |
Legislation | Making or changing laws | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to law | |
Service Provision | Delivering a service | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Training | Guidelines | Creating documents that recommend or mandate practice. This includes all changes to service provision | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Fiscal Measures | Using the tax system to reduce or increase the financial cost | Excluded | Not considered practical (partially due to free prescriptions over the age of 60 in UK, which encompasses a large proportion of stroke survivors), unlikely to be acceptable to policy makers who would probably need to instigate legislation changes, potentially not affordable contingent on the economic climate at the time of the change | |
Regulation | Establishing rules or principles of behaviour or practice | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to current health practice regulations | |
Legislation | Making or changing laws | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to law | |
Service Provision | Delivering a service | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Environmental Restructuring | Guidelines | Creating documents that recommend or mandate practice. This includes all changes to service provision | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Fiscal Measures | Using the tax system to reduce or increase the financial cost | Excluded | Not considered practical (partially due to free prescriptions over the age of 60 in UK, which encompasses a large proportion of stroke survivors), unlikely to be acceptable to policy makers who would probably need to instigate legislation changes, potentially not affordable contingent on the economic climate at the time of the change | |
Regulation | Establishing rules or principles of behaviour or practice | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to current health practice regulations | |
Legislation | Making or changing laws | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to law | |
Environmental/ Social Planning | Designing and/or controlling the physical or social environment | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Enablement | Guidelines | Creating documents that recommend or mandate practice. This includes all changes to service provision | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Fiscal Measures | Using the tax system to reduce or increase the financial cost | Excluded | Not considered practical (partially due to free prescriptions over the age of 60 in UK, which encompasses a large proportion of stroke survivors), unlikely to be acceptable to policy makers who would probably need to instigate legislation changes, potentially not affordable contingent on the economic climate at the time of the change | |
Regulation | Establishing rules or principles of behaviour or practice | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to current health practice regulations | |
Legislation | Making or changing laws | Excluded | Not considered practical for this project as the timeline would not allow for the process of changes to law | |
Environmental/ Social Planning | Designing and/or controlling the physical or social environment | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity | |
Service Provision | Delivering a service | Included | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable, should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Stage 3: Identify content and implementation options
TDF domains | Intervention Functions Identified | BCTs identified |
---|---|---|
Knowledge | Education Training Enablement | 1. Feedback on outcome(s) of the behaviour (2.7) 2. Provide normative information about others behaviour/ experiences (BM5) 3. Information about health consequences (5.1) 4. Self-monitoring of behaviour (2.3) 5. Provide reassurance (RC10) 6. Feedback on behaviour (2.2) 7. Biofeedback (2.6) 8. Information about antecedents (4.2) |
Beliefs about consequences | Education Persuasion | 1. Information about health consequences (5:1) 2. Credible source (9:1) 3. Self-monitoring of outcome(s) of behaviour (2.4) 4. Information about antecedents (4.2) 5. Pros and cons (9.2) 6. Salience of consequences (5.2) 7. Information about social and environmental consequences (5.3) 8. Information about emotional consequences (5.6) 9. Anticipated regret (5.5) 10. Comparative imagining of future outcomes (9.3) |
Emotions | Persuasion Environmental restructuring Enablement | 1. Information about health consequences (5.1) 2. Credible source (9.1) 3. Prompts/cues (7.1) 4. Action planning (1.4) 5. Habit formation (8.3) 6. Self-monitoring of behaviour (2.3) 7. Feedback on behaviour (2.2) 8. Feedback on outcome(s) of the behaviour (2.7) 9. Social support (emotional) (3.3) 10. Reduce negative emotions (11.2) |
BCTs | Reasons for Inclusion/exclusion (against APEASE criteria) |
---|---|
BCTs Included | |
Information about health consequences (5.1) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects |
Self-monitoring of behaviour (2.3) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Biofeedback (2.6) | Considered affordable (as patients’ blood pressure and cholesterol, for example, are often monitored and discussed within routine care), practical, potentially effective and potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs) |
Information about antecedents (4.3) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Credible source (9:1) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Self-monitoring of outcome(s) of behaviour (2.4) | Considered affordable (as patients can access, for example, blood pressure monitors for free from local GP surgeries and pharmacists), practical, potentially effective and potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs) |
Pros and cons (9.2) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective and potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs) |
Prompts/cues (7:1) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Action planning (1:4) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Habit formation (8:3) | Considered affordable, practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects and shouldn’t create significant issues of equity |
Social support (emotional) (3.3) | Considered affordable (as patients may be able to get this support from their own social networks or from community stroke support groups already running), practical, potentially effective, potentially acceptable (for patients and HCPs), should have limited side effects |
BCTs Excluded | |
Feedback on outcome(s) of the behaviour (2.7) | Not considered practical as most feedback on behavioural outcomes (for stroke medication adherence) routinely provided in NHS is a form of biofeedback and so would add additional workload if HCPs were providing feedback |
Feedback on behaviour (2.2) | Not considered practical in this context. Although HCPs based in primary care/community pharmacy have access to prescription acquisition records, this is a proxy measure of adherence and so could be difficult to provide accurate estimates of adherence. Even if stroke survivors provided self-reported accounts of adherence to HCPs/carers and adherence rates were fed back this could be too onerous as an intervention strategy |
Provide normative information about others behaviour/ experiences (BM5) | Not considered practical to deliver. BCT originally utilised for smoking cessation. The impact of stroke and varying medication regimens will make generalised comparisons challenging |
Salience of consequences (5.2) | Not considered practical for negative consequences of non-adherence e.g. use images of the consequences of stroke - hard to demonstrate paralysis, aphasia and other stroke implications in an image. Potential to have unwanted side effects also, if BCT evokes upsetting emotional responses. Enhancing view about positive consequences of adherence may not be considered acceptable as patient could have suffered a stroke even when adherent to medication and may not find the salience of the consequences meaningful |
Information about social and environmental consequences (5.3) | Not considered acceptable. Potential ethical issues. E.g. informing patients that it’s not socially acceptable to miss medication doses – patients can have valid reasons for not taking medications |
Information about emotional consequences (5.6) | Not considered acceptable and could cause unwanted side effects if information about negative emotions is given. Provision of this information could be upsetting, and patients can have valid reasons for not taking medications so seems inappropriate in this context. Even if provide information about positive emotions (e.g. taking medicines give peace of mind) may not be considered acceptable to those who have suffered a stroke even when adherent to medication and so may not find the information meaningful |
Anticipated regret (5.5) | Not considered acceptable and could cause unwanted side effects. Provision of this information could be upsetting, and patients can have valid reasons for not taking medications so seems inappropriate in this context. If a patient suffered a stroke following good adherence to medications BCT could be considered unacceptable by intervention facilitators delivering this BCT |
Comparative imagining of future outcomes (9.3) | Not considered acceptable. Asking people to imagine different outcomes might not be something HCPs are confident doing or patients are familiar with |
Reduce negative emotions (11.2) | Not considered practical and potentially not affordable. Not all patients would require this type of BCT and training in stress management, for example, would be costly and time/labour intensive |
Provide reassurance (RC10) | Not considered practical. Patients experiences (e.g. of side effects) are likely not time limited and may vary person to person. Reassurance may not always be the appropriate response and so may not be considered acceptable |