Background
Methods
Steps | Objectives | Methods | |
---|---|---|---|
1.
|
Problem analysis
| ▪ Gain insight into health problem, quality of care, underlying causes and target population | ▪ Problem analysis using PRECEDE-PROCEED model; |
▪ Analysis based on: | |||
- Literature research | |||
- Individual interviews (n = 321) | |||
- Focus group interviews (n = 26) | |||
- Process maps (n = 5) | |||
- Artifact analyses (n = 5) | |||
- Ishikawa (fishbone) diagrams (n = 5) | |||
2.
|
Identify intervention outcomes, performance objectives and change objectives
| ▪ State intervention outcomes | ▪ Use evidence from literature and empirical data from problem analysis (step 1) |
▪ Specify performance objectives | |||
▪ Select important and changeable determinants | ▪ Input from experts in the field of patient handover (healthcare providers, and organizational, social and health scientists) | ||
▪ Develop matrices with change objectives based on performance objectives and determinants of suboptimal hospital discharge | |||
3.
|
Select theory-based methods and strategies
| ▪ Identify and select theoretical methods | ▪ Literature search on theory-based methods |
▪ Select evidence-based interventions and design of practical strategies | ▪ Input from experts (n = 220) | ||
▪ Ensure that interventions and strategies address change objectives | |||
▪ Systematic literature review on evidence based discharge interventions | |||
▪ Additional search for experience based practical strategies | |||
▪ Matching methods and practical strategies with determinants and performance objectives (step 1 and 2) | |||
4.
|
Develop an intervention
| ▪ Provide suggestions for developing an intervention | ▪ Input from literature search and experts |
5.
|
Implementation
| ▪ Provide suggestions for writing an implementation plan | ▪ Literature search of implementation strategies and tools |
6.
|
Evaluation
| ▪ Provide suggestions for writing an evaluation plan | ▪ Literature search on methods for effect and process evaluation on complex interventions |
Step 1: Problem analysis
Procedure and participants
Step 2: Identify intervention outcomes, performance objectives and change objectives
Procedure and participants
Step 3: Selection of theory-based methods and strategies
Procedure and participants
Step 4: Develop an intervention
Steps 5 and 6: Implementation and Evaluation
Results
Step 1: Problem analysis
Step 2: Matrices of change objectives
Intervention outcomes and performance objectives
Healthcare providers
| |
Discharge information | 1a. Complete discharge information |
1b. Clear discharge information | |
1c. Accurate discharge information | |
Coordination of care | 2a. Ensure that follow-up services are being organized at actual discharge |
2b. Tailor follow-up care to patient needs and preferences | |
2c. Organize timely and accurate follow-up | |
Discharge communication | 3a. Seek direct/personal contact with primary care counterpart |
3b. Discharge information easily accessible to counterpart care providers and patients (and relatives) | |
3c. Exchange discharge information on time to primary care counterparts | |
3d. Inform patient (and relatives) personally and in timely manner | |
Patients
| |
Participation in discharge process | 4. Contribute, if capable, to the continuity of care in the discharge process |
Awareness of health status and treatment | 5. Well aware about medical history and medication use, diagnosis/indication and (side) effects of the treatment, post discharge appointments, scheduled tests and (pending) test results |
Selected determinants and change objectives
Step 3: Selecting theory-based methods and strategies
Determinants and change objectives | Theory-based methods | Examples of strategies/ practical applications | Examples of activities and materials | References* | Evidence† |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Individual healthcare provider
| |||||
Aware of the consequences of suboptimal hospital discharge | Knowledge transfer/Active learning | Education in the medical and nursing curriculum | Lectures on patient handover and exercises with workbook and online materials (e.g., communication skills and discharge letter requirements) | 52 | 3a |
Perceive handover administrative tasks as important part of patient discharge care and act accordingly | Stimulus control/ Reinforcement | Punishment by financial penalties; visual electronic reminders | Red, orange and green flags indicating status of discharge letter and planning; visualization of deadline for sending discharge letter | NF | NA |
Interpersonal
| |||||
Outward focus by hospital-based care providers to ensure continuity of care after discharge | Integrated care | Post-discharge monitoring of follow-up | Standard post-discharge telephone call or home visit to the patient to evaluate follow-up, provide additional instructions and answer questions | 53 | 1a |
Hospital and primary care provider collaborative during the discharge process | Integrated care/ Intergroup contact/ Case management | Case conference | Hospital or community-based face-to-face or telephone meetings between hospital and primary care providers | 54-57 | 1b |
Liaison person | Designated care provider coordinating hospital discharge, follow-up care and the communication between hospital and primary care providers | 58-60 | 1b | ||
Knowledge and understanding of the primary care organization, expectations and needs | Team building/ Intergroup contact/ Shifting perspective | Meetings between hospital and primary care providers to increase mutual understanding and respect between both parties | Focus group sessions, regular meetings and site visits to get to know each other, to learn each other’s organization and needs and to identify improvement opportunities | 61 | 1b |
Structural, problem-related feedback between hospital and primary care providers | Stimulus control | Means to facilitate and stimulate structural feedback | Standard feedback form and return envelop along with discharge letter send to primary care providers | NF | NA |
Patient-centered attitude | Modeling/ Individualization | Use of plain, patient-friendly, nonmedical language | Discharge summary in language that is understandable for patients and relatives | 62 | 1b |
Active listening | Teach back | Care provider checks if patients received all discharge information needed and if they understood the received information | 63 | 2b | |
Organizational
| |||||
Guidelines and standards of evidence-based practice | Standardized working processes | Standardized discharge letter (e.g. templates, formats) | Templates, formats, required (web-based) fields, clinical decision-support, pick lists | 64-66 | 1b |
Standardized discharge planning | Guidelines, protocols, checklists for discharge planning, organizing follow-up | 67-68 | 1b | ||
Medication reconciliation | Standardised medication reconciliation checklist/medication discrepancy tool/ reconciliation by (liaison) pharmacist | 54,57,65-67,69-71 | 1b | ||
Technical
| |||||
Shared electronic information exchange system | Multi-disciplinarycollaboration | Shared electronic patient information system | Electronic notifications to primary care providers to inform them about patient hospital visits and to provide them (web-based) access to available discharge information | 65,66,71-73 | 1b |
Patient and relative
| |||||
Participation in the discharge process | Self- management/ Guided practice | Encouraging and facilitating patients in self-management skills | Provide patient with discharge record (e.g., active problem list, medication, allergies, patient concerns) owned and maintained by the patient to facilitate cross-site information transfer | 62,74,75 | 1b |
Skills and dare to speak up | Coaching/ Guided practice | Encouragement to assert a more active role during discharge | Question form for patients | 74 | 1b |
Understanding of medical history and/or medication | Guided practice/ Knowledge transfer | Medication counseling at the hospital at discharge or at the patient’s home | Visits by a pharmacist counselor | 76 | 1b |