Introduction
An antifungal metabolite, Rapa initially discovered from
Streptomyces hygroscopicus, was subsequently identified as being a potent suppressor of a serine/threonine kinase, S6K1 [
1‐
3] as well as functioning as a pivotal inducer of PI3 kinase (PI3K) signaling axis [
4], thereby inducing immunosuppression and anti-proliferation in mammalian cells [
5]. At the same time, TOR was also discovered within yeast cells in addition to animal cells [
6,
7]. This involves the binding of Rapa with the FK506-binding protein (FKBP12). Rapa forms a gain-of-function complexes, mTOR complex (mTORC) and various biochemical and genetic analyses have revealed that there are two functionally distinct complexes related to mTOR, that is mTORC1 and mTORC2 [
6,
8]. It is known that the S6 kinase 1 (S6K1) is the best characterized substrate for mTORC1 [
9]. Functionally Rapa can inhibit only mTORC1 but in case of a long-term exposure to Rapa, mTORC2 could be also inhibited in some cells by newly produced mTOR proteins [
6]. In terms of the physiological roles of mTORC1 regulation, mTORC1 was identified as a signal processor in response to various biological signals related to growth, nutrition, energy production and consumption and oxygen levels to regulate energy metabolism and autophagy by regulating nucleotide, proteins and lipids synthesis [
5]. Pathologically, improperly regulated mTORC1 signaling has been frequently observed in malignant tumors, several genetic disorders and age-related diseases [
10]. However, although the physiological and pathological roles of the mTORC2 have not been well characterized in contrast to mTORC1, mTORC2 has been identified as being involved in the activation of Akt and SGK1–related cell survival mechanisms by regulating the actin-cytoskeleton organization [
6].
TGF-β has been identified as a pivotal inducer of fibrogenesis [
11‐
14], through the stimulation of downstream signaling mechanisms [
15‐
17], such as Smad related and unrelated signaling pathways [
18,
19]. Such TGF-β induced fibrogenesis is pivotally involved in nearly all wound healing related phenomena including subconjunctival fibrogenesis [
20]. Regarding TGF-β isoforms, it has been reported that TGF-β1, TGF-β2, and TGF-β3 have been identified, and among these, TGF-β2 was predominantly located within corneal tissues [
21], conjunctival fibroblasts [
22] vitreous, aqueous humor, and tears [
23,
24]. In fact, it was reported that significantly high concentrations of TGF-β2 are present in the AH of patients with glaucoma as compared to non-glaucoma subjects [
25].
To maintain healthy barrier functions in human conjunctiva, subconjunctival fibrosis that occurs in response to conjunctival wound healing needs to be appropriately controlled [
26‐
34]. It has been shown that among the non-Smad signaling pathways, the PI3K-Akt-mTOR axis function as an important role in TGF-β-evoked fibrogenesis [
35,
36]. In fact, several recent transcriptomics studies have demonstrated that mTOR, fibrogenesis and TGF-β are cooperatively involved in the molecular pathogenesis of vascular alterations such as inherited retinopathies (IRDs) [
37,
38], brain arteriovenous malformation (bAVM) and cerebral cavernous malformations (CCM) [
39‐
41]. Therefore, we rationally speculated that pharmacological suppressors of the PI3K-Akt-mTOR pathway represents a promising strategy for preventing TGF-β-induced conjunctival fibrogenesis without the requirement for the full inactivation of TGF-β signaling. In fact, Sun et al. [
42] and Huang et al. [
43] demonstrated that PI3K/Akt signaling is involved in the migration, differentiation, and ECM synthesis of HconF, and that the PI3K/Akt pathway in subconjunctival fibrosis of conjunctival fibroblast was activated by TGF-β1 [
44] and TGF-β2 [
45]. Furthermore, fibrogenesis in human conjunctival epithelial (HCjE) cells is induced by prolonged exposure to TGF-β1 and/or TGF-β2 [
46] and Rapa inhibited proliferation and differentiation of human corneal myofibroblasts [
47].
In addition, since, among the various TGF-β-induced conjunctival wound-healing responses [
48,
49], there are two different issues, namely, (1) superficial re-epithelialization and wound contraction, and (2) subconjunctival fibrous scar formation [
50]. Appropriate in vitro models that replicate these two different conjunctival fibrosis processes are needed. For this purpose, we have established in vitro models mimicking planar fibrosis and subconjunctival fibrosis of human conjunctiva utilizing 2D and 3D cell culture methods using HconF that had been treated with TGF-β2 as the representative TGF-β isoform [
51‐
53]. Here, to obtain insights into this issue, we studied the effects of the mTORC1 inhibitor, Rapa and the mTORC1 and 2 inhibitor, Torin1, on 2D and 3D HconF cell cultures that had been treated and untreated with TGF-β2.
Discussion
Rapa, an immunomodulator approved by the FDA, efficiently binds to the FK506 binding protein (FKBP12), and the Rapa-FKBP12 complex allosterically inhibits mTOR signaling, thereby possibly modulating both innate and adaptive immune responses by regulating the functions of antigen-presenting cells [
65] as well as autophagy, thus having a pivotal role in immunity and inflammation [
66]. In the ophthalmic field, interest has been shown in the suppression of mTOR signaling as a possible method for treatment of ocular surface-related diseases. In fact, previous studies have shown that the significant up-regulations of several cytokines and Akt3 in the lacrimal gland (LG) of a mouse model of Sjögren’s syndrome (SS) were significantly inhibited by 12-week Rapa treatment [
67‐
70]. Thus, these observations suggest that upon topical administration of Rapa, a potent anti-inflammatory effect within the LG could be expected by reducing autoimmune inflammation in the LG, increasing tear secretion, and restoring the ocular surface homeostasis in an SS mouse model. Trujillo-Vargas et al. recently reported that, in addition that significant decreases in inflammatory markers in the LG, conjunctival goblet cell density and area were substantially increased by daily instillation of eyedrops containing Rapa for 3 months in aged mice [
71]. Based upon their findings, they suggested that the use of eyedrops containing Rapa may be a potential therapeutic strategy for suppressing the unfavorable age-related phenomena within the ocular surface including tear-producing tissues. It was also reported that the increased expression of mTOR signaling proteins in experimental allergic conjunctivitis (EAC) was effectively reduced by Rapa treatment, thus suggesting that Rapa has a role in the attenuation of allergic conjunctivitis [
72].
In addition to the above-described effects of Rapa that are related to immunity and inflammation, Rapa also appears to have the ability to modulate several other mechanisms including cellular growth and proliferation, protein synthesis, and autophagy through mTORC1. It was shown that upon substantially stimulated mTORC1 signaling, aberrant apoptosis as well as cell proliferation seemed to occur in pterygium since their resting epithelial cells exhibit aberrant apoptosis and cell proliferation. This suggests that mTORC1 could provide a potential therapy for the treatment of pterygium [
58]. As an additional therapeutic possibility within the ophthalmic field, Igarashi et al. recently reported that mTOR inhibitors, Rapa and Torin1, significantly inhibited TGF-β1-induced fibrotic changes in an in vitro model for postoperative subconjunctival scarring using HconF cells [
59]. They also reported that topical administration of an mTOR inhibitor in a rabbit model of trabeculectomy effectively suppressed deposition of COLs in rabbit eyes after trabeculectomy. Based on these findings, they suggested that the use of mTOR inhibitors may be a novel treatment strategy to reduce the fibrotic response in HconF resulting in improvement of bleb survival (rates) after filtration surgery [
59]. In our recent study, we compared the effects of three major TGF-b isoforms, TGF-β1, TGF-β2 and TGF-β3, on conjunctival fibrogenesis using our established in vitro 2D and 3D culture models [
73]. Our results showed that all three isoforms induced fibrogenetic effects but that the efficacies of the isoforms were quite different. That is, the effects of TGF-β1 and TGF-β3 on 2D HconF planar cell proliferation assessed by TEER and cellular metabolic functions assessed by a Seahorse bioanalyzer and on physical properties of 3D HconF cells were significantly different and the effects of TGF-β2 were the average effects of both isoforms, suggesting the rationale to use TGF-β2 as a representative TGF-β isoform in the current study. Our present study to examine the effects of mTOR inhibitors demonstrated that Rapa and Torin1 on TGF-β2 induced conjunctival fibrogenesis by using recently established in vitro models using 2D and 3D cultures of HconF cells in the presence of TGF-β2 replicating planar and subepithelial fibrogenesis, respectively. The results indicated that (1) Rapa or Torin1 significantly increased planar proliferation of TGF-β2-untreated 2D HconF cells, but this was inhibited or enhanced, respectively, in TGF-β2-treated cells, (2) mono-treatment of Rapa or Torin1 did not affect cellular metabolism, but both drugs induced a significant energy shift from oxidative phosphorylation to glycolysis in TGF-β2-treated HconF cells, (3) subepithelial proliferation, as evidenced by the 3D spheroid’s stiffness, was markedly decreased by both Rapa and Torin1 independent of TGF-β2 and (4) the gene expression of ECM metabolism-related molecules fluctuated among the conditions for both the 2D and 3D TGF-β2-untreated or TGF-β2-treated cultures. Differences between gene expression profiles of ECM proteins and their modulators in 2D and 3D cell cultures have been observed in other cells including human orbital fibroblasts [
54], human trabecular meshwork cells [
74] and others due to the differences of cell-to-cell interactions, 2D; side by side, vs 3D; cell can interact on everywhere around another cell, as suggested by previous study [
75].
The mechanism by which mTOR inhibition can suppress mitochondrial function and enhance glycolytic capacity only under the condition of TGF-β2-induced fibrogenesis in HconF cells is still speculative. However, given that mTORC1 has been reported to be involved in mitochondrial biosynthesis in several types of cells [
76,
77], the explanation that mTOR inhibition induced a compensatory shift in cellular metabolism to glycolysis from oxidative phosphorylation in response to metabolic demand by TGF-β2 is reasonable. Therefore, investigating whether these metabolic responses are also observed in other cells and the effects of mTOR inhibition on different time courses of fibrogenesis are our next research projects.
Taken together, we conclude that these mTOR inhibitors may increase and reduce planar proliferation and subepithelial proliferation of HconF cells, respectively. However, as study limitations in the current investigation, the following issues should be taken into consideration. Firstly, as revealed by Seahorse metabolic measurements, Rapa and Torin1 significantly modulated both mitochondrial and glycolytic functions, especially in the presence of TGF-β2, although the underlying molecular mechanisms have not yet been elucidated. Secondly, we simply used 2D planar cultures and 3D spheroid cultures as models of conjunctival superficial and subconjunctival scarring. However, previous studies demonstrated that culture conditions could significantly influence the cell phenotype and the maintenance of specific cell populations [
78], and, in fact, gene expression levels were reported to be altered in conjunctiva among ex vivo, primary conjunctiva and cultured conjunctival cell lines (Tong et al. 2009) [
79]. In addition, our currently used method for evaluating the barrier functions of 2D cultured HconF cells involves estimating conjunctival superficial re-epithelialization and wound contraction. However, several previous studies have suggested that commercially available HconF cells may have characteristics that are different from those of primary cultured human conjunctival cells or cell lines derived from them. For example, benzalkonium chloride (BAC) was reported to cause shrinkage and plate detachment in primary cultured human conjunctival fibroblasts [
80] and a low dose of BAC (10
−4%) was reported to cause cell lysis in a human conjunctival cell line [
81], whereas in our recent study, no morphological changes or changes in TEER were detected in HconF 2D-cultured cells that were exposed to BAC [
61]. In fact, KRT24 is expressed in the human conjunctiva [
82,
83] but not in HconF cells [
84]. Therefore, investigation of additional types of conjunctival cells will be required to confirm that our current results could be clinically relevant. Thirdly, it is well known that TGF-β induces conjunctival fibrogenesis [
85,
86], and we therefore used a representative TGF-β isoform, TGF-2, among various factors. However, in several previous studies, other TGF-β isoforms, TGF-β1 and TGF-β3 [
42,
43,
46,
87‐
90], and nerve growth factor (NGF) [
91‐
93] were also identified as possible pivotal fibrogenetic inducing factors in the conjunctiva. Fourthly, it has been shown that various types of crosslinking can occur between PI3K/Akt, the Smad, and the non-Smad MAPK and RhoA/Rho-kinase signaling pathways in ocular fibrotic disorders [
94]. Therefore, for a better understanding new results related to the effects of mTOR inhibitors on fibrogenetic changes of 2D and 3D cultures of HconF cells, additional investigations will be required to elucidate the currently unidentified issues related to our current observations among several complex signaling networks of mTOR, other TGF-β isoforms such as TGF-β1, TGF-β3 and others, and NGF as well as the use of additional animal models with conjunctival fibrosis.
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.