Death is defined in the Quran with a single criterion of irreversible separation of the ruh (soul) from the body. The Quran is a revelation from God to man, and the primary source of Islamic knowledge. The secular concept of death by neurological criteria, or brain death, is at odds with the Quranic definition of death. The validity of this secular concept has been contested scientifically and philosophically. To legitimize brain death for the purpose of organ donation and transplantation in Muslim communities, Chamsi-Pasha and Albar (concurring with the US President’s Council on Bioethics) have argued that irreversible loss of capacity for consciousness and breathing (apneic coma) in brain death defines true death in accordance with Islamic sources. They have postulated that the absence of nafs (personhood) and nafas (breath) in apneic coma constitutes true death because of departure of the soul (ruh) from the body. They have also asserted that general anesthesia is routine in brain death before surgical procurement. Their argument is open to criticism because: (1) the ruh is described as the essence of life, whereas the nafs and nafas are merely human attributes; (2) unlike true death, the ruh is still present even with absent nafs and nafas in apneic coma; and (3) the routine use of general anesthesia indicates the potential harm to brain-dead donors from surgical procurement. Postmortem general anesthesia is not required for autopsy. Therefore, the conclusion must be that legislative enforcement of nonconsensual determination of neurological (brain) death and termination of life-support and medical treatment violates the religious rights of observant Muslims.
Choong, K. A., & Rady, M. Y. (2016). Re A (A Child) and the United Kingdom Code of practice for the diagnosis and confirmation of death: Should a secular construct of death override religious values in a pluralistic society? HEC Forum. doi: 10.1007/s10730-016-9307-y.
Hanson, S. G., & Bentley, T. S. (2014). Milliman Research Report of 2014 U.S. organ and tissue transplant cost estimates and discussion. http://www.milliman.com/insight/research/health/2014-U_S_-organ-and-tissue-transplant-cost-estimates-and-discussion/. Accessed August 20, 2017.
Joffe, A. R. (2009). Brain death is not death: A critique of the concept, criterion, and tests of brain death. Reviews in the Neurosciences, 20(3–4), 187–198. PubMed
Khandelwal, N., Benkeser, D., Coe, N. B., Engelberg, R. A., Teno, J. M., & Curtis, J. R. (2016). Patterns of cost for patients dying in the intensive care unit and implications for cost savings of palliative care interventions. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 19(11), 1171–1178. CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMed
Kotloff, R. M., Blosser, S., Fulda, G. J., Malinoski, D., Ahya, V. N., Angel, L., et al. (2015). Management of the potential organ donor in the ICU: Society of Critical Care Medicine/American College of Chest Physicians/Association of Organ Procurement Organizations Consensus Statement. Critical Care Medicine, 43(6), 1291–1325. CrossRefPubMed
Mollaret, P., & Goulon, M. (1959). The depassed coma (preliminary memoir). Revue Neurologique, 101, 3–15. PubMed
Nahle, N. (2009). A thermodynamic description of life and death in biosystems. Journal of Human Thermodynamics, 5, 7–14.
Nature. (2009). Delimiting death. Nature, 461(7264), 570. CrossRef
Peterson, A., Cruse, D., Naci, L., Weijer, C., & Owen, A. M. (2015). Risk, diagnostic error, and the clinical science of consciousness. NeuroImage: Clinical, 7, 588–597. CrossRef
Rady, M. Y., & Verheijde, J. L. (2013). Brain-dead patients are not cadavers: The need to revise the definition of death in Muslim communities. HEC Fourm: HealthCare Ethics Committee Forum, 25(1), 25–45. CrossRef
Rady, M. Y., Verheijde, J. L., & Yanke, G. (2017). Nonconsensual determination of neurologic (brain) death: Is it a violation of constitutional rights? Chest, 152(4), 909–910. CrossRef
Rouleau, N., Murugan, N. J., Tessaro, L. W. E., Costa, J. N., & Persinger, M. A. (2016). When is the brain dead? Living-Like electrophysiological responses and photon emissions from applications of neurotransmitters in fixed post-mortem human brains. PLoS ONE, 11(12), e0167231. CrossRefPubMedCentralPubMed
Saari, R. J., & Cooper, D. K. C. (2017). Financial aspects of organ procurement from deceased donors in the USA—Relevance to xenotransplantation. Xenotransplantation, 24(4), e12322. CrossRef
Shewmon, D. A. (2009). Brain death: Can it be resuscitated? Issues in Law and Medicine, 25(1), 3–14. PubMed
The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. (2008). A code of practice for the diagnosis and confirmation of death. A report of the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. Updated online August 10, 2010. http://www.aomrc.org.uk/publications/reports-guidance/ukdec-reports-and-guidance/code-practice-diagnosis-confirmation-death/. Accessed August 20, 2017.
The Lancet. (2011). Religion, organ transplantation, and the definition of death. The Lancet, 377(9762), 271. CrossRef
The President’s Council on Bioethics. (2008). Controversies in the determination of death: A White Paper by the President’s Council on Bioethics. https://bioethicsarchive.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/. Accessed August 20, 2017.
The Quran. (n.d.). The Mohsin Khan English Translation. (The Translation of the Meanings of the Quran by Muhammad Taqi-ud-Din Al-Hilali & Muhammad Mohsin Khan). http://www.searchtruth.com. Accessed August 20, 2017.
Verheijde, J. L., Rady, M. Y., & McGregor, J. L. (2009). Brain death, states of impaired consciousness, and physician-assisted death for end-of-life organ donation and transplantation. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 12(4), 409–421. CrossRef
- Legislative Enforcement of Nonconsensual Determination of Neurological (Brain) Death in Muslim Patients: A Violation of Religious Rights
Mohamed Y. Rady
Joseph L. Verheijde
- Springer US