Regular ArticleBones and Groundwater: Towards the Modelling of Diagenetic Processes
Abstract
This paper develops a theory for describing those diagenetic changes in bone which involve its interaction with groundwater. Three main processes are considered, as examples of such changes; namely the uptake of uranium, the dissolution of bone, and the increase of crystallinity of the bone mineral (carbonate hydroxyapatite or dahllite). Here simple models of the chemistry involved are postulated (although how bone interacts with water on amolecularscale is not clearly known) in order to demonstrate the theory with explicit mechanisms and values. Greater emphasis is given to uranium uptake, since the model used is comparatively detailed, being based on the authors' previous work.
The basic assumption is that the rate-limiting process in diagenetic change is the movement of solutes to, from, or within the bone. Therefore the main thrust of the paper is to show how the physical structure of the bone itself, together with the hydrology of the burial site, interact to determine how water and its solutes move into, within and from a bone during burial. This interaction can be of three kinds, defined by the site hydrology. These are termed here, diffusion, hydraulic flow and recharge. All three types may operate together, and their relative importance depends on the extent to which the pore structure of a bone has been altered by diagenesis, as well as the type of chemical change taking place. It is shown that diffusion is usually the most common and important process, but that it is possible to predict the hydrological regimes in which other mechanisms dominate. It is shown how knowledge of site hydrology (mainly the specification of soil structure and moisture variation), the physical state of the bone, and the chemistry of the diagenetic process can provide estimates for the rate and manner of the particular diagenetic process. Such estimates agree with observation, suggesting this approach to be on the right lines. Qualitative predictions also result from the theory. The main value of this approach is to identify those situations where particular diagenetic changes are simplest (e.g. sites where the hydrology gives rise to a single and quantifiable hydraulic process) so that they may be decisively tested against the quantitative predictions of the theory.
References (0)
Cited by (242)
Employing biomolecular analyses and radiocarbon AMS chronologies to disentangle complex mortuary assemblages: Reinterpreting the Kane mortuary complex enigma in greater Cahokia
2024, Journal of Archaeological Science: ReportsThe acknowledged importance of documenting legacy assemblages led to efforts in the mid-1990s to re-examine such collections from Illinois. In some cases this involved applying traditional methods and emerging techniques to address complex questions of context, chronology, and aspects of identity for American Indian ancestral sites and individuals. These efforts included the Kane Mounds mortuary complex salvaged in the early 1960s and long interpreted as a late Mississippian mortuary area related to Cahokia. Drawing on available data from original field and analysis records, past biomolecular analysis, and combined with an evolving understanding of the people and culture history of the American Bottom, we use results from isotopic analyses and radiocarbon AMS chronologies obtained prior to 2018 to disentangle complex multicomponent mortuary settings. These studies revealed the mortuary importance of Kane spanned 1500 years, from as early as 500 BCE into the 14th century CE, a period that saw a major shift in diet with the increased consumption of maize and a population comprised of individuals local to the American Bottom and as well as immigrants. Available biomolecular information and radiocarbon AMS chronologies demonstrate both temporal and geographic diversity within the Kane mortuary complex, as well as continuity in the importance of this mortuary location.
Preservation of bone organic fraction is not predictive of the preservation of bone inorganic fraction when assessing stable isotope analysis sample quality control measures
2024, Journal of Archaeological ScienceStable isotope analysis of carbon (C), nitrogen (N), hydrogen (H), and oxygen (O) of archaeological bone has become an increasingly common research method for interpreting human behavior in the past. However, diagenesis of skeletal material can invalidate stable isotope ratios, thereby compromising interpretations. We examine patterns of bone diagenesis using infrared spectroscopy of bone bioapatite samples in relation to indicators of organic preservation quality indicators. We assess crystallinity, an indicator of bioapatite preservation, using the infrared splitting factor (IR-SF) and carbonate content (carbonate to phosphate ratio, C/P) calculated from infrared spectra. We then test the assumption that if the organic fraction of bone is preserved, the mineral fraction will also be unaffected by postmortem chemical alteration. We analyzed 454 bone bioapatite and extracted bone organic sample pairs from modern, historic, and prehistoric humans. Consistent with previous studies, we observed a strong, statistically significant negative linear relationship between IR-SF and C/P (r = −0.855, p < 0.001). Modern bone bioapatite samples unaltered by diagenesis have low IR-SF and high C/P values. There was no significant association between the collagen yield or atomic C:N ratio and IR-SF or C/P values. The range of variation in IR-SF and C/P values for samples with organic yields between 0 and >20 percent spanned the range of modern bone bioapatite unaltered by diagenesis as well as bone bioapatite significantly affected by diagenesis. The lack of predictive patterning between bone inorganic and organic diagenesis suggests that the depositional context and site formation history play critical and independent roles in the organic and mineral fraction of bone. Thus, the preservation of the organic fraction of bone is not predictive of the preservation of the inorganic fraction (e.g., bioapatite).
An FTIR-based model for the diagenetic alteration of archaeological bones
2024, Journal of Archaeological ScienceBones and teeth from archaeological records are direct evidence of past individuals and they represent valuable archives for palaeo-anthropological and palaeoenvironmental studies. However, pristine information may be obliterated by the diagenetic alteration of bone specimens. Thus, defining in detail their preservation state is fundamental to assess the potential of extracting information about the past life of the individual, as well as to investigate the palaeo-environment at the burial site. For this reason, we have selected a set of archaeological samples (petrous bones and tooth roots) of different origin and chronology that have experienced diverse environmental and burial conditions, from arid and semi-arid to temperate regions in a time span from prehistoric to fresh bones. Thus, the selected samples underwent a variety of diagenetic processes, resulting in different types and extent of alteration patterns. Here we have applied a minimally-invasive sampling strategy and an analytical protocol based on Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) in order to ensure the investigation of a statistically significant set of samples. We provide a method to describe and quantify the changes in the physico-chemical properties of both the organic and inorganic constituents of bones, by establishing a set of parameters calculated from the FTIR spectra and evaluating their sensitivity in describing the alteration types and extent in bone specimens. Through FTIR spectral analysis, we have defined the most suitable parameters to effectively describe the alteration degree of bone specimens. Notably, the results have shown that, despite the complexity of multifactorial diagenetic processes, their measurable effects on differently altered bones can be described by a common mechanism. This indicates a progressive loss of collagen which is paralleled to the recrystallization of bioapatite and the loss of structural carbonate, regardless of the origin and chronology of the specimens. Thus, here we propose an FTIR-based model for bone diagenesis of general validity, highlighting that distinct diagenetic processes affecting the archaeological bones have acted according to common alteration mechanisms.
The bottom line: Exploring analytical methods for assessing bioapatite preservation in archaeological bone using FTIR-ATR
2023, Journal of Archaeological Science: ReportsWe conducted a meta-content analysis of FTIR (Fourier Transform Infra-red) spectroscopy methods and application throughout five journals, and evaluated variation present in FTIR-ATR spectra across original data sets from bone samples from distinct archaeological contexts. The meta-analysis revealed a lack of standardization and consistency in methodology and reporting for FTIR practices. Results suggest wavenumbers used for calculating IRSF and C/P in addition to baseline correction impact interpretations of bioapatite preservation. We recommend that FTIR spectra should always be baseline corrected and analyzed in absorbance (A). We also recommend consistent reporting of methods to demonstrate data fidelity prior to interpretation.
Multifactorial approach to describe early diagenesis of bones: The case study of the Merovingian cemetery of Saint-Linaire (France)
2023, Quaternary InternationalThe excavation of the Merovingian cemetery of Saint-Linaire (France) was an opportunity to describe the completeness of the tombs preserved from soil erosion. An anthropobiological study was carried out on the osteological material and the different categories of graves. On the basis of a complete archaeo-anthropological corpus we have undertaken an analysis of the differential preservation of the bones according to the different archaeobiological parameters such as the type of bone, the individual age but also the type of grave such as earthen graves, coffin, or sarcophagus.
In order to establish whether and how funerary practices had impacted the early diagenesis of the bones, FTIR was used to investigate the carbonate and fluoride content of the bones, and the infra-red splitting factor (SF), while XRD analysis was performed to estimate the crystallinity index (CI). In addition, the micro, macro and total porosity of the bones were measured by water adsorption, and bone carbon and nitrogen amounts were obtained by EA-IRMS. These diagenetic variables were analysed with regards to environmental (grave filling: humus, calcareous, clay), cultural (type of grave) and biological (mature versus immature individuals) factors. While there is a tendency of a better preservation of the skeletons in humus, and of juvenile bones to show less post-mortem alteration than the adult skeletons, the most important factor which determines the fate of the skeleton is the type of bone, with a preferential preservation of the ribs at Saint-Linaire.
Marine sponge bioerosion in the forensic taphonomy of terrestrial bone
2023, Quaternary InternationalBone and teeth, specialised bio-mineralized connective tissues, are left after the typical decomposition process of any vertebrate organism. Their analysis can reveal insights into an organism's life and retrace the history of the remains after death (also known as taphonomy), which ultimately evolves to destruction or fossilization. Studies on the taphonomy of terrestrial mammalian bio-mineralized tissues have mostly focussed on terrestrial depositional environments. Here, samples submerged in the marine environment are investigated.
Five archaeological bones of terrestrial mammalian species (pig and oxen) with historically known post-mortem submersion interval (PMSI) (69–316 years) and recovery sites, were analysed macroscopically, microscopically and by microCT. The aim was to characterize for the first time the alterations produced by marine bioeroding sponges, and to discuss their potential interdisciplinary application, with special focus on forensic investigations.
The pig samples showed microanatomical preservation (Oxford Histological Index = 3–5), increased total porosity, the presence of old tissue flakes with sponge spicules and traces of bioerosion, such as papillary holes, canals and chambers with microsculptured walls. The presence of such tissue flakes suggested that, at the time of recovery, they may have been free of sediment and inhabited by live sponges. The shape of one internal chamber was identified as the ichnospecies Entobia convoluta as typically produced by shallow, warm-water Cliothosa spp. Surface analyses for further biological evidence remained inconclusive.
The taphonomy of skeletal remains has always been relevant in anthropological, natural and forensic studies. In forensics, the role of taphonomy is to contribute to personal identification, cause of death and post-mortem interval (PMI). This study detected the past colonization of terrestrial mammalian bone by marine bioeroding sponges, and aimed to link the taphonomic findings to natural processes and environments. Bioeroding sponges are for the first time confirmed to colonize terrestrial mammalian bone submerged in marine environments, and to promote diagenesis through bioerosion.