Skip to main content
Log in

Analysis of local recurrence rates after surgery alone for rectal cancer

  • Original Articles
  • Published:
International Journal of Colorectal Disease Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Local recurrence (LR) continues to be a major problem following surgical treatment for rectal cancer, and proposed ways of reducing this remain controversial. The aim of this study was to review results from published surgical series in which adjuvant therapies were not used. A Medline search identified series published between January 1982 and December 1992 with follow-up on at least 50 patients with rectal cancer treated surgically for cure, without adjuvant therapy. Fifty one papers reported follow-up on 10,465 patients with a median LR rate of 18.5%. LR was 8.5%, 16.3% and 28.6% in Dukes' A, B and C patients respectively, 16.2% following anterior resection and 19.3% following abdominoperineal resection. Nine papers (1,176 patients) reported LR rates of 10% or less. LR was 7.1% in 1,033 patients having total mesorectal excision and 12.4% in 476 patients having extended pelvic lymphadenectomy. Routine cytocidal stump washout in 1,364 patients was associated with 12.2% LR, however a higher proportion (41%) also underwent total mesorectal excision. In 52% of cases, LR was reported to have occurred with no evidence of disseminated disease. Surgical technique is an important determinant of LR risk. LR rates of 10% or less can be achieved with surgery alone in expert hands.

Résumé

Les récidives locales (LR) représentent toujours un problème majeur après traitement chirurgical des cancers du rectum et les moyens de réduire cette incidence sont toujours sujets à controverse. Le but de cette étude est de faire une revue des résultats des séries publiées de traitement chirurgical sans traitement adjuvant. A l'aide de Medline les séries publiées entre janvier 1982 et décembre 1992 avec un follow-up portant sur au minimum 50 patients traités par une chirurgie curatrice sans traitement adjuvant ont été identifiés. Cinquante-et-un articles portant sur 10465 patients avec un taux de récidive locate moyen de 18.5% ont été publiés. Les récidives locales sont respectivement de 8,5% en case de Dukes A, 16,3% en cas de Dukes B, 28,6% en cas de Dukes C, 16,2% après résection antérieure basse et 19,3% après amputation abdomino-périnéale. Neuf articles (1176 patients) publient des récidives locales de moins de 10%. Le taux de récidive locale est de 7,1% chez 1033 patients ayant subi une excision totale du méso-rectum et de 12,4% chez 476 patients ayant subi une lymphadénectomie pelvienne étendue. Le lavage de routine du moignon rectal avec un cytostatique a été réalisé chez 1'364 patients avec un taux de récidive locale de 12,2% bien qu'une proportion élevée (41%) avait subi également une excision du méso-rectum. Dans 52% des cas, la récidive locale est observée alors même qu'il n'y a pas d'évidence d'une dissémination de la maladie. La technique chirurgicale est un facteur déterminant important dans la survenue d'une récidive locale. Des taux de récidive de 10% ou moins peuvent être obtenus avec la chirurgie seule réalisée par des mains expertes.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  1. Goligher JC (1979) Recent trends in the practice of sphincter saving excision for rectal cancer. Ann R Coll Surg Eng 61:169–173

    Google Scholar 

  2. Pollett WG, Nicholls RJ (1983) The relationship between the extent of distal clearance and survival and local recurrence rates after curative anterior resection for carcinoma of the rectum. Ann Surg 198:159–163

    Google Scholar 

  3. Kirwan WO, O'Riordan MG, Waldron R (1989) Declining indications for abdominoperineal resection. Br J Surg 76: 1061–1063

    Google Scholar 

  4. Williams NS (1986) Changing patterns in the treatment of rectal cancer. Br J Surg 76:5–6

    Google Scholar 

  5. Malcolm AW, Perencevich NP, Olson RN, et al. (1981) Analysis of recurrence patterns following curative resection for carcinoma of the colon and rectum. Surg Gynecol Obstet 152:131–136

    Google Scholar 

  6. Galandiuk S, Wieand HS, Moertel CG, et al. (1992) Patterns of recurrence after curative resection of carcinoma of the colon and rectum. Surg Gynecol Obstet 174:27–32

    Google Scholar 

  7. Karanjia ND, Schache DJ, North WRS, Heald RJ (1990) ‘Close shave’ in anterior resection. Br J Surg 77:501–512

    Google Scholar 

  8. Nilsson E, Gregersen N-P, Hartvig B, Sjodahl L (1984) Carcinoma of the colon and rectum. Acta Chir Scand 150:177–182

    Google Scholar 

  9. Balslev IB, Pedersen M, Teglbjaerg PS, et al. (1986) Postoperative radiotherapy in Dukes' B and C carcinoma of the rectum and rectosigmoid. A randomized multicentre study. Cancer 58:22–28

    Google Scholar 

  10. Gunderson LL, Sosin H (1974) Areas of failure at reoperation (second or symptomatic look) following “curative surgery” for adenocarcinoma of the rectum. Cancer 34:1278–1292

    Google Scholar 

  11. Pilipshen SJ, Heilweil M, Quan HQ, Sternberg SS, Enker WE (1984) Patterns of pelvic recurrence following definitive resections of rectal cancer. Cancer 53:1354–1362

    Google Scholar 

  12. Cohen AM, Minsky BD (1990) Aggressive surgical management of locally advanced primary and recurrent rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 33:432–438

    Google Scholar 

  13. Gilbert JM, Jeffrey I, Evans M, Kark AE (1984) Sites of recurrent tumour after ‘curative’ colorectal surgery: implications for adjuvant therapy. Br J Surg 71:203–205

    Google Scholar 

  14. Heald RJ, Ryall RDH (1982) The mesorectum in rectal cancer surgery — the clue to pelvic recurrence? Br J Surg 69:613–616

    Google Scholar 

  15. Hojo K, Sawada T, Moriya Y (1989) An analysis of survival and voiding, sexual function after wide iliopelvic lymphadenectomy in patients with carcinoma of the rectum, compared with conventional lymphadenectomy. Dis Colon Rectum 32:128–133

    Google Scholar 

  16. Enker WE, Pilipshen SJ, Heilweil ML, et al. (1986) En bloc pelvic lymphadenectomy and sphincter preservation in the surgical management of rectal cancer. Ann Surg 203:426–433

    Google Scholar 

  17. Yasutomi M, Shindo K, Mori N, Matsuda T (1991) [Does the pelvic nodes dissection for the rectal cancer patients make any contribution to the end-results of surgery?] Gan To Kagaku Ryoho 18:541–546

    Google Scholar 

  18. Glass RE, Ritchie JK, Thompson HR, Mann CV (1985) The results of surgical treatment of cancer of the rectum by radical resection and extended abdomino-ilaic lymphadenectomy. Br J Surg 72:599–601

    Google Scholar 

  19. Michelassi F, Block GE, Vannucei L, Montag A, Chappell R (1988) A 5- to 21-year follow-up and analysis of 250 patients with rectal adenocarcinoma. Ann Surg 208:379–389

    Google Scholar 

  20. Umpleby HC, Williamson RCN (1987) Anastomotic recurrence in large bowel cancer. Br J Surg 74:873–878

    Google Scholar 

  21. Dahl O, Horn A, Morild I, et al. (1990) Low-dose preoperative radiation postpones recurrences in operable rectal cancer. Cancer 66:2286–2294

    Google Scholar 

  22. Frykholm GJ, Glimelius B, Påhlaman L (1993) Preoperative or postoperative irradiation in adenocarcinoma of the rectum: final treatment results of a randomized trial and an evaluation of late secondary effects. Dis Colon Rectum 36:564–572

    Google Scholar 

  23. Gerard A, Buyse M, Nordlinger B, et al. (1988) Preoperative radiotherapy as adjuvant treatment in rectal cancer. Ann Surg 208:606–614

    Google Scholar 

  24. Niebel W, Schulz U, Ried M, et al. (1988) Five-year results of a prospective and randomised study: Experience with combined radiotherapy and surgery of primary rectal carcinoma. Recent Results Cancer Res 110:111–113

    Google Scholar 

  25. Stockholm Rectal Cancer Study Group (1987) Short-term preoperative radiotherapy for adennocarcinoma of the rectum. Am J Clin Oncol 10:369–375

    Google Scholar 

  26. Treurniet-Donker AD, van Putten WLJ, Wereldsma JCJ et al. (1991) Postoperative radiation therapy for rectal cancer. Cancer 67:2042–2048

    Google Scholar 

  27. MRC Working Party (1984) The evaluation of low dose preoperative X-ray therapy in the management of operable rectal cancer, results of a randomly controlled trial. Br J Surg 71:21–25

    Google Scholar 

  28. Fisher B, Wolkman N, Rockette H et al (1988) Postoperative adjuvant chemotherapy or radiation therapy for rectal cancer: results form NSABP protocol R-01. J Natl Cancer Inst 80:21–29

    Google Scholar 

  29. Gastrointestinal Tumor Study Group (1985) Prolongation of the disease-free interval in surgically treated rectal carcinoma. N Eng J Med 312:1465–1472

    Google Scholar 

  30. Krook JE, Moertel CG, Gunderson LL et al. (1991) Effective surgical adjuvant therapy for high-risk rectal carcinoma. N Engl J Med 324:709–715

    Google Scholar 

  31. Quirke P, Dixon MF, Durdey P, Williams NS (1986) Local recurrence of rectal adenocarcinoma due to inadequate surgical resection. Lancet 2:996–999

    Google Scholar 

  32. MacFarlane JK, Ryall RDH, Heald RJ (1993) Mesorectal excision for rectal cancer. Lancet 341:457–460

    Google Scholar 

  33. Twomey P, Burchell M, Strawn D, Guernsey J (1989) Local control in rectal cancer. A clinical review and meta-analysis. Arch Surg 124:1174–1179

    Google Scholar 

  34. Påhlman L, Glimelius B (1992) Pre-operative and post-operative radiotherapy and rectal cancer. World J Surg 16:858–865

    Google Scholar 

  35. Abulafi AM, Williams NS (1994) Local recurrence of colorectal cancer: the problem, mechanisms management and adjuvant therapy. Br J Surg 81:7–19

    Google Scholar 

  36. Dukes C (1932) The classification of cancer of the rectum. J Pathol 35:323–332

    Google Scholar 

  37. Fielding LP, Arsenault PA, Chapuis PH et al. (1991) Working Party. Report to the World Congress of Gastroenterology, Sydney, 1990. Clinicopathological staging for colorectal cancer: an International Documentation System (IDC) and an International Comprehensive Anatomical Terminology (ICAT). J Gastroenterol Hepatol 6:325–344

    Google Scholar 

  38. Schofield PF, Walsh S, Tweedle DEF (1986) Survival after treatment of carcinoma of the rectum. Br Med J 293:496–497

    Google Scholar 

  39. Halvorsen KT (1986) Combining results from independent investigations. Meta-analysis in medical research. In: Medical uses of statistics. Bailar JC, Mosteller F (eds) Waltham: NEJM Books, 392–416

    Google Scholar 

  40. Fielding LP, Stewart-Brown S, Dudley HAF (1987) Surgeonrelated variables and the clinical trial. Lancet 2:778–779

    Google Scholar 

  41. McArdle CS, Hole D (1991) Impact of variability among surgeons on postoperative morbidity and mortality and ultimate survival. BMJ 302:1501–1505

    Google Scholar 

  42. Phillips RKS, Hittinger R, Blesovsky L, Fry JS, Fielding LP (1984) Local recurrence following ‘curative’ surgery for large bowel cancer: I. The overall picture. Br J Surg 71:12–16

    Google Scholar 

  43. Hermanek PJ, Wiebelt H, Riedl S, Staimmer D, Hermanek P (1994) Long-term results of surgical therapy for colon cancer. Results of the German Study Group for Colorectal Cancer (SGCRC). Chirurg 65:287–297

    Google Scholar 

  44. Wiggers T, Jeekel J, Arendst JW, et al. (1988) No-touch isolation technique on colon cancer: a controlled prospective trial. Br J Surg 75:409–415

    Google Scholar 

  45. Stocker M, Coates A (1993) What have we learned from meta-analysis? Med J Aust 159:291–293

    Google Scholar 

  46. Elwood MJ (1992) Combining results from several studies: overviews. In Causal relations in medicine. A practical system for critical appraisal. Oxford Medical Publications Oxford, pp 160–162

    Google Scholar 

  47. Watcher KW (1988) Disturbed by meta-analysis? Science 241:1407–1408

    Google Scholar 

  48. Isbister WH (1990) Basingstoke revisited. Aust NZ J Surg 60:243–246

    Google Scholar 

  49. Abcarian H (1992) Operative treatment of colorectal cancer. Cancer 70:1350–1354

    Google Scholar 

  50. Hohenberger P, Liewald F, Schlag P, Herfarth C (1990) Lectins and immunohistochemistry of colorectal cancer, its recurrences and metastases. Eur J Surg Oncol 16:289–297

    Google Scholar 

  51. Belli L, Beati CA, Frangi M, Aseni P, Rondinara GF (1988) Outcome of patients with rectal cancer treated by stapled anterior resection. Br J Surg 75:422–424

    Google Scholar 

  52. Cawthorn SJ, Paruns DV, Gibbs NM, et al. (1990) Extent of mesorectal spread and involvement of lateral resection margin as prognostic factors after surgery for rectal cancer. Lancet 335:1055

    Google Scholar 

  53. Colombo PL, Foglieni CLS, Morone C (1987) Analysis of recurrence following curative low anterior resection and stapled anastomoses for carcinoma of the middle third and lower rectum. Dis Colon Rectum 30:457–464

    Google Scholar 

  54. Dixon AR, Maxwell WA, Thornton Holmes J (1991) Carcinoma of the rectum: a 10-year experience. Br J Surg 78:308–311

    Google Scholar 

  55. Jatzko G, Lisborg P, Wette V (1992) Improving survival rates for patients with colorectal cancer. Br J Surg 79:588–591

    Google Scholar 

  56. Moran BJ, Blenkinsop J, Finnis D (1992) Local recurrence after anterior resection for rectal cancer using a double stapling technique. Br J Surg 79:836–838

    Google Scholar 

  57. Hyland J, Joyce W, Dolan J (1993) The mesorectum: re-appraisal of its morphology and its unique importance in rectal cancer. Tripartitie Colorectal Meeting, Sydney (Abstract)

  58. Anderberg B, Enblad P, Sjodahl R, Wetterforts J (1983) Recurrent rectal carcinoma after anterior resection and rectal stapling. Br J Surg 70:1–4

    Google Scholar 

  59. Parrott NR, Lennard TW, Taylor RM, et al. (1986) Effect of perioperative blood transfusion on recurrence of colorectal cancer. Br J Surg 73:970–973

    Google Scholar 

  60. Busch ORC, Hop WCJ, Hoynck van Papendrecht MAW, Marquet RL, Jeekel J (1993) Blood transfusion and prognosis in colorectal cancer. N Engl J Surg 328:1372–1376

    Google Scholar 

  61. Walsh PC, Schlegel PN (1988) Radical pelvic surgery with preservation of sexual function. Ann Surg 208:391–400

    Google Scholar 

  62. Slanetz CA (1984) The effect of inadvertent intraoperative perforation on survival and recurrence in colorectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 27:792–797

    Google Scholar 

  63. Ranbarger KR, Johnson WD, Chang JC (1982) Prognostic significance of surgical perforation of the rectum during abdominoperineal resection for rectal carcinoma. Am J Surg 143:186–188

    Google Scholar 

  64. Zirngibl H, Husemann B, Hermanek P (1990) Intraoperative spillage of tumor cells in surgery for rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 33:610–614

    Google Scholar 

  65. Amato A, Pescatori M, Butti A (1991) Local recurrence following excision and anterior resection for rectal carcinoma. Dis Colon Rectum 34:317–322

    Google Scholar 

  66. Harnsberger JR, Vernava AM, Longo WE (1994) Radical abdominopelvic lymphadenectomy: historical perspective and current role in the surgical management of rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 37:73–87

    Google Scholar 

  67. Long RT, Edwards RH (1989) Implantation metastasis as a cause of local recurrence of colorectal cancer. Am J Surg 157:194–201

    Google Scholar 

  68. McDermott FT, Hughes ESR, Pihl E, Johnson WR, Price AB (1985) Local recurrence after potentially curative resection for rectal cancer in a series of 1008 patients. Br J Surg 72:34–37

    Google Scholar 

  69. Adloff M, Arnaud JP, Schloegel M, Thibaud D (1985) Factors influencing local recurrence after abdominoperineal resection for cancer of the rectum. Dis colon Rectum 28:413–415

    Google Scholar 

  70. Athlin L, Bengtsson NO, Stenling R (1988) Local recurrence and survival after radical resection of rectal carcinoma. Acta Chir Scand 154:225–229

    Google Scholar 

  71. Secco GB, Fardelli R, Campora E, Rovida S, Bertoglio S (1989) Factors influencing local recurrence after curative surgery for rectal cancer. Oncology 46:10–13

    Google Scholar 

  72. Theile DE, Cohen JR, Evans EB, Quinn RL, Davis NC (1982) Pelvic recurrence after curative resection for carcinoma of the rectum. Aust NZ J Surg 52:391–394

    Google Scholar 

  73. Wolmark N, Gordon PH, Fisher B, et al. (1986) A comparison of stapled and handsewn anastomoses in patients undergoing resection for Duke's B and C colorectal cancer. An analysis of disease-free survival and survival from the NSABP prospective clinical trials. Dis Colon Rectum 29:344–350

    Google Scholar 

  74. West of Scotland and Highland Anastomosis Study Group (1991) Suturing or stapling in gastrointestinal surgery: a prospective randomised study. Br J Surg 78:337–341

    Google Scholar 

  75. Lasson ALL, Eklund GR, Lindstrom CG (1984) Recurrence risk after stapled anastomosis for rectal carcinoma. Acta Chir Scand 150:85–89

    Google Scholar 

  76. Rosen CB, Beart RWJ, Ilstrup DM (1985) Local recurrence of rectal carcinoma after hand-sewn and stapled anastomosis. Dis Colon Rectum 28:305–309

    Google Scholar 

  77. Luukkonen P, Jarvinen H (1993) Stapled vs hand-sutured lieoanal anastomosis in restorative proctocolectomy. A prospective, randomized study. Arch Surg 128:437–440

    Google Scholar 

  78. Leff El, Shaver JO, Hoexter B, et al. (1985) Anastomotic recurrences after low anterior resection. Stapled vs hand-sewn. Dis Colon Rectum 28:164–167

    Google Scholar 

  79. Phillips RKS (1992) Adequate distal margin of resection for adenocarcinoma of the rectum. World J Surg 16:463–466

    Google Scholar 

  80. Feil W, Wunderlich M, Kovats E, et al. (1988) Rectal cancer: factors influencing the development of local recurrence after radical anterior resection. Int J Colorect Dis 3:195–200

    Google Scholar 

  81. Cawthorn SJ, Gibbs NM, Marks CG (1986) Clearance technique for the detection of lymph nodes in colorectal cancer. Br J Surg 73:58–60

    Google Scholar 

  82. Editorial (1990) Breaching the mesorectum. Lancet 335:1067–1068

    Google Scholar 

  83. Chan KW, Boey J, Wong SKC (1985) A method of reporting radial invasion and surgical clearance of rectal cancer. Histopathology 9:1319–1327

    Google Scholar 

  84. Sheffield JP, Talbot IC (1992) Gross examination of the large intestine. J Clin Pathol 45:751–755

    Google Scholar 

  85. Meager AP, Kollmorgen CF, Wolff BG, et al. (1994) The long term effect of postoperative chemoradiotherapy for rectal carcinoma on bowel function. Proc. Royal Australasian College of Surgeons ASC Hobart, May 125

  86. Braun J, Pfingsten F, Schippers E, Schumpelick V (1992) Rectal cancer. Results of continence-preserving resections. Leber Magen Darm 22:59–66

    Google Scholar 

  87. Carlsson U, Lasson A, Ekelund G (1987) Recurrence rates after curative surgery for rectal carcinoma, with special reference to their accuracy. Dis Colon Rectum 30:431–434

    Google Scholar 

  88. Danzi M, Ferulano GP, Abate S, Dilillo S, Califano G (1986) Survival and locations of recurrence following abdomino-perineal resection for rectal cancer. J Surg Oncol 31:235–239

    Google Scholar 

  89. Domergue J, Rouanet P, Daures JP, et al. (1989) Multivariate analysis of prognostic factors for curative resectable recta cancer. Eur J Surg Oncol 15:93–98

    Google Scholar 

  90. Fick TE, Baeten CGMI, von Meyenfeldt MF, Obertop H (1990) Recurrence and survival after abdominoperineal and low anterior resection for rectal cancer, without adjuvant therapy. Eur J Surg Oncol 16:105–108

    Google Scholar 

  91. Gillen P, Peel AL (1986) Comparison fo the mortality and incidence of local recurrence in patients with rectal cancer treated by either stapled anterior resection or abdominoperineal resection. Br J Surg 73:339–341

    Google Scholar 

  92. Heimann TM, Szporn A, Bolnick K, Aufses AH (1986) Local recurrence following surgical treatment fo rectal cancer. Comparison of anterior and abdominoperineal resection. Dis Colon Rectum 29:862–864

    Google Scholar 

  93. Kennedy HL, Langevin JM, Goldberg SM, et al. (1985) Recurrence following stapled coloproctostomy for carcinomas of the mid portion of the rectum. Surg Gynecol Obstet 160:513–516

    Google Scholar 

  94. Localio SA, Eng K, Coppa GF (1983) Abdominosacral resection for midrectal cancer. Ann Surg 198:320–324

    Google Scholar 

  95. Malmberg M, Graffner H, Ling L, Olsson SA (1986) Recurrence and survival after anterior resection of the rectum using the end to end anastomotic stapler. Surg Gynecol Obstet 163:231–234

    Google Scholar 

  96. Neville R, Fielding LP, Amendola C (1987) Local tumor recurrence after curative resection for rectal cancer. A ten-hospital review. Dis Colon Rectum 30:12–17

    Google Scholar 

  97. Påhlman L, Glimelius B (1984) Local recurrences after surgical treatment for rectal carcinoma. Acta Chir Scand 150:513–516

    Google Scholar 

  98. Pheils MT, Chapuis PH, Newland RC, Colquhoun K (1983) Local recurrence following curative resection for carcinoma of the rectum. Dis Colon Rectum 26:98–102

    Google Scholar 

  99. Phillips RKS, Hittinger R, Blesovsky L, Fry JS, Fielding LP (1984) Local recurrence following ‘curative’ surgery for large bowel cancer: II. The rectum and rectosigmoid. Br J Surg 71:17–20

    Google Scholar 

  100. Reed WJ, Garb JL, Park WC, et al. (1988) Long-term results and complications of pre-operative radiation in the treatment of rectal cancer. Surgery 103:161–167

    Google Scholar 

  101. Rich T, Gunderson LL, Lew R, et al. (1983) Patterns of recurrences of rectal cancer after potentially curative surgery. Cancer 52:1317–1329

    Google Scholar 

  102. Rubbini M, Vellorello GF, Guerrera C, et al. (1990) A prospective study of local recurrence after resection and low stapled anastomosis in 183 patients with rectal cancer. Dis Colon Rectum 33:117–121

    Google Scholar 

  103. Sweeney JL, Ritchie JK, Hawley PR (1989) Resection and sutured peranal anastomosis for carcinoma of the rectum. Dis Colon Rectum 32:103–106

    Google Scholar 

  104. Tonak J, Gall FP, Hermanek P, Hager TH (1982) Incidence of local recurrence after curative operations for cancer of the rectum. Aust NZ J Surg 52:23–27

    Google Scholar 

  105. Williams NS, Durdey P, Johnston D (1985) The outcome following sphincter-saving resection and abdomino-perineal resection for low rectal cancer. Br J Surg 72:595–598

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

McCall, J.L., Cox, M.R. & Wattchow, D.A. Analysis of local recurrence rates after surgery alone for rectal cancer. Int J Colorect Dis 10, 126–132 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00298532

Download citation

  • Accepted:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00298532

Keywords

Navigation