Abstract
Patient noncompliance is a substantial obstacle to the achievement of therapeutic goals. This paper reviews a number of practical interventions with demonstrated efficacy in enhancing patient adherence, including (1) improving patients' levels of information concerning the specifics of their regimens, reinforcing essential points with review, discussion, and written instruction, and emphasizing the importance of the therapeutic plan, (2) taking clinically appropriate steps to reduce the cost, complexity, duration, and amount of behavioral change required by the regimen and increasing the regimen's convenience through “tailoring” and other approaches, (3) obtaining a compliance-oriented history of the patient's prior experiences and present health beliefs and, where necessary, employing strategies to modify those perceptions likely to inhibit compliance, (4) improving levels of patient satisfaction, particularly with the provider-patient relationship, (5) arranging for the continued monitoring of the patient's subsequent compliance to treatment, (6) increasing staff awareness of the magnitude and determinants of the noncompliance phenomenon and attempting to develop an “active influence orientation” in each member of the health care team, (7) using such techniques as patient-provider contracts to involve the patient in therapeutic decisions and in the setting of treatment objectives and creating incentives (through rewards and reinforcements) for achieving these objectives, (8) arranging for as much continuity of provider (and other staff) as possible, (9) establishing methods of supervising the patient, including involvement of the patient's social support network, and (10) involving fully the assistance of all available health care providers, assigning specific roles and responsibilities for activities directed at improving adherence to treatment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Dunbar JM, Stunkard AJ: Adherence to diet and drug regimen. In R. Levy, et al (eds.):Nutrition, Lipids and Coronary Heart Disease. New York, Raven Press, 1979. Pp 391–423.
Bergman AB, Werner RJ: Failure of children to receive penicillin by mouth.N Engl J Med 268 1334–1338, 1963.
Fox W: Self-administration of medications: A review of published work and study of problems.Bull Int Union Tuberc 32 307–331, 1962.
Marston M: Compliance with medical regimens: A review of the literature.Nurs Res 19 312–323, 1970.
Mitchell JH: Compliance with medical regimens: An annotated bibliography.Health Educ Mongr 2 75–87, 1974.
Prather EC: A time to act (editorial)Am J Public Health 64 937, 1974.
Sackett DL: The magnitude of compliance and noncompliance. In DL Sackett, RB Haynes (eds):Compliance with Therapeutic Regimens. Baltimore, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976. Pp 9–25.
Haynes RB A Critical review of the “determinants” of patient compliance with therapeutic regimens. In DL Sackett, RB Haynes (eds):Compliance with Therapeutic Regimens. Baltimore, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976. Pp 26–39.
Korsch BM, Gozzi EK, Francis V: Gaps in doctor-patient communication: I. Doctor-patient interaction and patient satisfaction.Pediatrics 42 855–871, 1968.
Korsch BM, Negrete VF: Doctor-patient communication.Sci Am 227 66–74, 1972.
Wilson JT: Compliance with instructions in the evaluation of therapeutic efficacy: A common but frequently unrecognized major variable.Clin Pediatr 12 333–340, 1973.
Svarstad B.The Doctor-Patient Encounter: An Observational Study of Communication and Outcome. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin, 1974.
Podell RN:Physician's Guide to Compliance in Hypertension. West Point, Pennsylvania, Merck and Co, 1975.
Sackett DL, et al:Patient Counseling and Health Educ 1 18–21, 1978.
Tagliacozzo DM, Ima K: Knowledge of illness as a predictor of patient behavior.J Chronic Dis 22 765–775, 1970.
McKenney JM, et al: The effect of clinical pharmacy services on patients with essential hypertension.Circulation 48 1104–1111, 1973.
Ley P, et al: A method for increasing patients' recall of information presented by doctors.Psychol Med 3 217–220, 1973.
Ley P: Primacy, rated importance, and the recall of medical statements.J Health Soc Behav 13 311–317, 1972.
Ley P, Spelman MS:Communicating with the Patient. St. Louis, W.H. Green, Inc, 1967.
Likewich JA, Catalano RB, Hack HL: The effect of packaging and instruction on outpatient compliance with medication regimens.Drug Intelligence and Clinical Pharmacy 8 10–15, 1974.
Dickey FF, Mattar RM, Chudzek GM: Pharmacist counseling increases drug regimen compliance.Hospitals 49 85–88, 1975.
Hulka BS, Cassel JC, Kupper LL, et al. Communication, compliance, and concordance between physicians and patients with prescribed medications.Am J Public Health 66 847–853, 1976.
Lasagna L: The patient package insert. In L Lasagna (ed):Patient Compliance. Mount Kisco, New York, Futura Publishing Co, 1976. Pp 77–82.
Joyce CRB, Caple G, Mason M, et al. Quantitative study of doctor-patient communication.Quart J Med 38 183–194, 1969.
Pratt L. Seligmann A, Reader G: Physicians' views on the level of medical information among patients.Am J Public Health 47 1277–1283, 1957.
Ley P: Towards better doctor-patient communications. In AE Bennett (ed):Communications Between Doctors and Patients. London, Oxford University Press, 1976. Pp 75–98.
Samora J, Saunders L, Larson R: Medical vocabulary knowledge among hospital patients.J Health Hum Behav 2 83–92, 1961.
Mazullo J, Lasagna L, Grinar P: Variations in interpretation of prescription instructions.JAMA 227 929–931, 1974.
Collen MB: The educational adjunct to multiphasic health testing.Prev Med 2 247–260, 1973.
Atwater JB: Adapting the venereal disease clinic to today's problem.Am J Public Health 64 433–437, 1974.
Egbert LD, Battit GE, Welch CE, et al. Reduction of postoperative pain by encouragement and instruction of patients.N Engl J Med 270 825–827, 1964.
Levine P, Britten AF: Supervised patient management of hemophilia.Ann Intern Med 78 195–201, 1973.
Miller L. Goldstein J: More efficient care of diabetic patients in a county hospital setting.N Engl J Med 286 1388–1391, 1972.
Rosenberg SG: Patient education leads to better care for heart patients.HSMHA Health Rep 86 793–802, 1971.
Ross HS, Collen, FB, Soghikian K: Pilot study of discussion groups for “Worried Well” patients in an ambulatory care setting.Health Educ Monogr 5 51–61, 1977.
Avery CH, Green LW, Kreider S: Reducing emergency visits of asthmatics: An experiment in health education. Testimony, President's Commission on Health Education. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Jan. 11, 1972.
Maiman LA, Green LW, Gibson G, et al. Education for self-treatment by adult asthmatics.JAMA 241 1919–1922, 1979.
Green LW, Werlin SH, Schauffer HH, et al. Research and demonstration issues in self-care.Health Educ Monogr 5 161–189, 1977.
Zapka J, Averill BW: Self-care for colds: A cost-effective alternative to upper respiratory infection management.Am J Public Health 69 814–816, 1979.
Roccella EJ: Potential for reducing health care costs by public and patient education: Summary of selected studies.Public Health Rep 91 223–225, 1976.
Bowen RG, Rich R. Schlatfeldt RM: Effects of organized instruction for patients with the diagnosis of diabetes mellitus.Nurs Res 10 151–159, 1961.
McAlister AL, Farquhar JW, Thorensen CE, et al. Behavioral science applied to cardiovascular health: Progress and research needs in the modification of risk-taking habits in adult populations.Health Educ Monogr 4 45–74, 1976.
Shepard DS, Moseley TA: Mailed versus telephoned appointment reminders to reduce broken appointments in a hospital outpatient department.Med Care 14 268–273, 1976.
Schroeder SA: Lowering broken appointment rates at a medical clinic.Med Care 11 75–78, 1973.
Finnerty FA, Mattie EC, Finnerty FA: Hypertension in the inner city. I. Analysis of clinic dropouts.Circulation 47 73–75, 1973.
Gates SJ, Colborn DK: Lowering appointment failures in a neighborhood health center.Med Care 14 263–267, 1976.
Fletcher SW, Appel FA, Bourgois M: Improving emergency-room patient follow-up in a metropolitan teaching hospital.N Engl J Med 291 385–388, 1974.
Alpert JJ: Broken appointments.Pediatrics 34 127–132, 1964.
Nazarian LF, et al: Effect of a mailed appointment reminder on appointment keeping.Pediatrics 53 349–352, 1974.
Shmarak KL: Reduce your broken appointment rate: How one children and youth project reducedits broken appointment rate.Am J Public Health 61 2400–2404, 1971.
Young SA, Halpin TJ, Johnson DA, et al. Effectiveness of a mailed reminder on the immunization levels of infants at high risk of failure to complete immunizations.Am J Public Health 70 422–424, 1980.
Foote A, Erfurt JC: Controlling hypertension: A cost-effective model.Prev Med 6 319–343, 1977.
Johannsen W, Hellmuth G. Sorauf T: On accepting medical recommendations.Arch Environ Health 12 63–69, 1966.
Haynes RB: Strategies for improving compliance: A methodologic analysis and review. In DL Sackett, RB Haynes (eds):Compliance with Therapeutic Regimens. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976. Pp. 69–82.
Weintraub M: Intelligent noncompliance and capricious compliance. In L Lasagna (ed):Patient Compliance. Mount Kisco, New York, Futura Publishing Co, 1976. Pp 39–47.
Matthews D, Hingson R: Improving patient compliance: A guide for physicians.Med Clin North Am 61 879–889, 1977.
Fink DL: Tailoring the consensual regimen. In DL Sackett, RB Haynes (eds):Compliance with Therapeutic Regimens. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976. Pp 110–118.
Best JA: Tailoring smoking withdrawal procedures to personality and motivational differences.J Consult Clin Psychol 43 1–8, 1975.
Hallburg JC: Teaching patients self-care.Nurs Clin North Am 5 223–231, 1970.
Haynes RB, Sackett DL, Gibson ES, et al. Improvement of medication compliance in uncontrolled hypertension.Lancet 1 1265–1268, 1976.
Dunbar JMAdherence to Medication Regimen: An Intervention Study with Poor Adherers. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Stanford University, 1977.
Becker MH (ed):The Health Belief Model and Personal Health Behavior. Thorofare, New Jersey, Charles B. Slack, Inc, 1974.
Becker MH, Kaback MM, Rosenstock IM, et al. Some influences on public participation in a genetic screening program.J Community Health 1 3–14, 1975.
Rosenstock IM: Patients' compliance with health regimens.JAMA 234 402–403, 1975.
Becker MH: The Health Belief Model and sick role behavior.Health Educ Monogr 2 409–419, 1974.
Becker MH, Drachman RH, Kirscht JP: A new approach to explaining sick-role behavior in lowincome populations.Am J Public Health 64 205–216, 1974.
Becker MH, Maiman LA, Kirscht JP, et al. The Health Belief Model and prediction of dietary compliance: A field experiment.J Health Soc Behav 18 348–366, 1977.
Becker MH, Radius SM, Rosenstock IM, et al. Compliance with a medical regimen for asthma: A test of the Health Belief Model.Public Health Rep 93 268–277, 1978.
Hartman PE, Becker MH: Noncompliance with prescribed regimen among chronic hemodialysis patients: A method of prediction and educational diagnosis,Dialysis and Transplantation 7 978–989, 1978.
Kasl SV, Cobb S: Health behavior, illness behavior, and sick role behavior. I. Health and illness behavior.Arch Environ Health 12 246–266, 1966.
Kirscht JP, Rosenstock IM: Patient adherence to antihypertensive medical regimens.J Community Health 3 115–124, 1977.
Maiman LA, Becker MH, Kirscht JP, et al. Scales for measuring Health Belief Model dimensions: A test of predictive value, internal consistency, and relationships among beliefs.Health Educ Monogr 5 215–230, 1977.
Becker MH, Nathanson CA, Drachman RH, et al. Mothers' health beliefs and children's clinic visits: A prospective study.J Community Health 3 125–135, 1977.
National Analysts, Inc:A Study of Health Practices and Opinions. Public Health Service Publication PB-210978. Washington, DC, Government Printing Office, 1972.
Barofsky I: Sociological and psychological aspects of medication compliance. In I Barofsky (ed):Medication Compliance: A Behavioral Management Approach. Thorofare, New Jersey, Charles B. Slack, Inc, 1977. Pp 29–44.
Green LW, Roberts BJ: The research literature on why women delay in seeking medical care for breast symptoms.Health Educ Monogr 2 129–177, 1974.
Kirscht JP, et al: A national study of health beliefs.J Health Hum Behav 7 248–254, 1966.
Jenkins CD: An approach to the diagnosis and treatment of problems of health related behavior.Int J Health Educ 22 [Suppl]: 3–24, 1979.
Inui TS, Yourtee EL, Williamson JW: Improved outcomes in hypertension after physician tutorials: A controlled trial.Ann Intern Med 84 646–651, 1976.
Kirscht JP, Becker MH, Haefner DP, et al. Effects of threatening communications and mothers' health beliefs on weight change in obese children.J Behav Med 1 147–157, 1978.
Kirscht JP, Haefner DP: Effects of repeated threatening health communications.Int J Health Educ 16 3–12, 1973.
Leventhal H: Fear appeals and persuasion: The differentiation of a motivational construct.Am J Public Health 61 1208–1224, 1971.
Leventhal H: Changing attitudes and habits to reduce risk factors in chronic disease.Am J Cardiol 31 571–579, 1973.
Henderson JB, Berkanovic E, Enelow AJ: Applying behavioral science to cardiovascular risk: Summary of the conference. In AJ Enelow, JB Henderson (eds):Applying Behavioral Science to Cardiovascular Risk. Dallas, American Heart Association, 1975.
Canfield RE: The physician as a teacher of patients.J Med Educ 48 79–87, 1973.
Levine DM, Bonito AJ: Impact of clinical training on attitudes of medical students: Self-perpetuating barrier to change in the system?Br J Med Educ 8 13–16, 1974.
Wolle JM: Multidisciplinary teams develop programming for patient education.Health Serv Rep 89 8–12, 1974.
Coe RM, Wessen A: Social-psychological factors influencing the use of community health resources.Am J Public Health 55 1024–1031, 1965.
Becker MH, Maiman LA: Sociobehavioral determinants of compliance with health and medical care recommendations.Med Care 13 10–24, 1975.
Davis MS: Variations in patients' compliance with doctors' advice: An empirical analysis of patterns of communication.Am J Public Health 58 274–288, 1968.
Francis V, Korsch BM, Morris MJ: Gaps in doctor-patient communication: Patients' response to medical advice.N Engl J Med 280 535–540, 1969.
Hulka B, Kupper L, Cassel J, et al. Doctor-patient communication and outcomes among diabetic patients.J Community Health 1 15–27, 1975.
Rokart JF, Hofmann PB: Physician and patient behavior under different scheduling systems in a hospital outpatient department.Med Care 7 463–470, 1969.
Schulman BA: Active patient orientation and outcomes in hypertensive treatment: Application of a socio-organizational perspective.Med Care 17 267–280, 1979.
Glanz K: Dietitians' effectiveness and patient compliance with dietary regimens.J. Am Diet Asoc 75 631–636, 1979.
Shangold MM: The health care of physicians: “Do as I say and not as I do.”J Med Educ 54 668, 1979.
Cockerham WC, Creditor MC, Creditor UK, et al. Minor ailments and illness behavior among physicians.Med Care 18 164–173, 1980.
Lewis CE, Michnich M: Contracts as a means of improving patient compliance, In I Barofsky (ed):Medication Compliance: A Behavioral Management Approach. Thorofare, New Jersey, Charles B. Slack, Inc, 1977. Pp 69–75.
Etzwiler DD: The contract for health care.JAMA 224 1034, 1973.
Dapcich-Miura E, Hovell MF: Contingency management of adherence to a complex medical regimen in an elderly heart patient.Behav Ther 10 193–201, 1979.
Boudin HM: Contingency contracting as a therapeutic tool in the deceleration of amphetamine use.Behav Ther 3 604–608, 1972.
Lowe K, Lutzker JR: Increasing compliance to a medical regimen with a juvenile diabetic.Behav Ther 10 57–64, 1979.
Magrab PR, Papadopoulou H: The effect of a token economy on dietary compliance for children on hemodialysis.J Appl Behav Anal 10 573–78, 1977.
Mann RA: The behavior-therapeutic use of contingency contracting to control an adult behavior problem: Weight control.J Appl Behav Anal 5 99–109, 1972.
Aragona J, Cassady J, Drabman RS: Treating overweight children through parental training and contingency contracting.J Appl Behav Anal 8 269–278, 1975.
Harris MB, Bruner CG: A comparison of a self-control and a contract procedure for weight control.Behav Res and Ther 9 347–354, 1971.
Jeffrey RW, Thompson PD, Wing RR: Effects on weight reduction of strong monetary contracts for calorie restriction or weight loss.Behav Res Ther (in press).
Elliott R, Tighe TJ: Breaking the cigarette habit: Effects of a technique involving threatened loss of money.Psychol Rec 18 503–513, 1968.
Winnett RA:Parameters of Deposit Contracts in the Modification of Smoking. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, State University of New York, Stony Brook, 1971.
Levy RL, Yamashita D, Pow G: The relationship of an overt commitment to the frequency and speed of compliance with symptom reporting.Med Care 17 281–284, 1979.
Steckel SB, Swain MA: Contracting with patients to improve compliance.J Am Hosp Assn 51 81–84, 1977.
Brownell KD, Heckerman CL, Westlake RJ, et al. The effect of couples training and partner cooperativeness in the behavioral treatment of obesity.Behav Res Ther 16 323–333, 1978.
Saccone AJ, Israel AC: Effects of experimenter versus significant other controlled reinforcement and choice of target behavior on weight loss.Behav Ther 9 271–278, 1978.
Israel AC, Saccone AJ: Follow-up of effects of choice of mediator and target of reinforcement on weight loss.Behav Ther (in press).
Zitter RE, Fremouw WJ: Individual versus partner consequation for weight loss.Behav Ther 9 808–813, 1978.
Stuart RB, Davis B.Slim Chance in a Fat World. Chicago, Research Press, 1972.
Mahoney MJ, Mahoney K: Treatment of obesity: A clinical exploration. In BJ Williams, S Martin, JP Foreyt (eds):Obesity: Behavioral Approaches to Dietary Management. New York, Bunner/Mazel, 1976.
O'Leary KD, Wilson GT:Behavior Therapy: Application and Outcome. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall, 1975.
Green LW, Levine DM, Deeds SG: Clinical traits of health education for hypertensive outpatients: Design and baseline date.Prev Med 4 417–425, 1975.
Green LW, Levine DM, Wolle J, et al. Development of randomized patient education experiments with urban poor hypertensives.Patient Counselling and Health Educ 1 106–111, 1979.
Levine DM, Green LW, Chwalow AJ, et al. Health education for hypertensive patients.JAMA 241 1700–1703, 1979.
Oakes TW, Ward JR, Gray R, et al. Family expectations and arthritis patient compliance to a hand resting splint regimen.J Chronic Dis 22 757–764, 1970.
Ferguson K, Bole GG: Family support, health beliefs, and therapeutic compliance in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.Patient Counselling and Health Educ 1 101–105, 1979.
Heinzelmann F, Bagley RW: Response to physical activity programs and their effects on health behavior.Public Health Rep 85 905–911, 1970.
Green LW:Status Identity and Preventive Health Behavior. Pacific Health Education Reports No 1. Berkeley, University of California, 1970.
Parks CM, Brown GW, Monck EM: The general practitioner and the schizophrenic patient.Br Med J 1 972–976, 1962.
Willcox DRC, Gillan R, Hare EH: Do psychiatric outpatients take their drugs?Br Med J 2 790–792, 1965.
Baric L: Conjugal roles as indicators of family influence on health-directed action.Int J Health Educ 13 58–65, 1970.
Hunt GM, Azrin NH: A community-reinforcement approach to alcoholism.Behav Res Ther 11 91–104, 1973.
Mechanic D: Illness and social disability: Some problems in analysis.Pacific Soc Rev 2 39–49, 1959.
Parsons T, Fox R: Illness, therapy and the modern urban American family.J Soc Issues 8 2–3, 31–44, 1952.
Petroni FA: Significant others and illness behavior: A much neglected role contingency.Social Quart 10 32–41, 1969.
Picken B, Ireland G: Family patterns of medical care utilization: Possible influences of family size, role and social class on illness behavior.J Chronic Dis 22 181–191, 1969.
Stokes CS, Dudley CJ: Family planning and conjugal roles: Some further evidence.Soc Sci Med 6 157–161, 1972.
Vincent CE: The family in health and illness: Some neglected areas.Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci 346 109–116, 1963.
Becker MH, Green LW: A family approach to compliance with medical treatment: A selective review of the literature.Int J Health Educ 18 173–182, 1975.
Marston M-'V: Nursing management of compliance with medical regiments. In I Barofsky (ed):Medication Compliance: A Behavioral Management Approach. Thorofare, New Jersey, Charles B. Slack, Inc, 1977. Pp 139–164.
Canada AT: The pharmacist and drug compliance. In DL Sackett, RB Haynes (eds):Compliance with Therapeutic Regimens. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1976. Pp 129–134.
Schwartz MA: The role of the pharmacist in the patient-health team relationship. In L Lasagna (ed):Patient Compliance. Mount Kisco, New York, Futura Publishing Company, 1976. Pp 83–95.
Sharpe TR: The pharmacist's potential role as a factor in increasing compliance. In I Barofsky (ed):Medication Compliance: A Behavioral Management Approach. Thorofare, New Jersey, Charles B. Slack, Inc, 1977. Pp. 133–138.
Mattar ME, Markello J, Yaffe SJ: Pharmaceutic factors affecting pediatric compliance.Pediatrics 55 101–108, 1975.
Cushing H:The Life of Sir William Osler. New York, Oxford University Press, 1925. Vol I, Chap 14.
Green LW: Toward cost-benefit evaluations of health education: Some concepts, methods and examples.Health Educ Monogr 2 [Suppl]: 34–64, 1974.
Green LW: Educational strategies to improve compliance with therapeutic and preventive regimens: The recent evidence. In RB Haynes, DW Taylor, DL Sackett (eds):Compliance in Health Care. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1979. Pp 157–173.
Additional information
Dr. Becker is Professor, Department of Health Behavior and Health. Education, University of Michigan, School of Public Health, 1420 Washington Heights, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109. Dr. Maiman is Assistant Professor, Department of Pediatrics, University of Rochester, School of Medicine, 601 Elmwood Avenue, Rochester, New York 14642. Work for this review was supported in part by Grant No. 5K04-HD00237 from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Becker, M.H., Maiman, L.A. Strategies for enhancing patient compliance. J Community Health 6, 113–135 (1980). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01318980
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01318980