Skip to main content
Erschienen in: Neurocritical Care 2/2018

15.08.2018 | Current Opinion/Arguments

Truly Reconciling the Case of Jahi McMath

verfasst von: D. Alan Shewmon

Erschienen in: Neurocritical Care | Ausgabe 2/2018

Einloggen, um Zugang zu erhalten

Abstract

This article clarifies some issues raised by Dr. Ariane Lewis in her recent “Current Opinion/Arguments” article on the case of Jahi McMath. Review of case materials. Jahi’s case most likely represents an instance of global ischemic penumbra (GIP) mimicking brain death (BD), with intracranial blood flow too low to support neuronal function or to be detected by radionuclide scan but sufficient to prevent widespread necrosis. Her MRI scan 9 months after the ischemic insult showed gross preservation of cortical and internal structures, incompatible with there ever having been a period of completely absent blood flow. Regarding Jahi’s alleged intermittent responsiveness, the set of videos, unsystematic as they are, constitutes convincing evidence that her movements in seeming response to command are not of spinal cord origin and are indeed voluntary responses, placing her in the category of minimally conscious state (MCS). In the absence of serial examinations by experts in MCS, the benefit of the doubt should be given. Unfortunately, her death on June 22, 2018, 4½ years after the diagnosis of BD, precludes such examinations. During those 4½ years, Jahi underwent menarche, with three documented menstrual periods, and ongoing pubertal development. Her case is an important example of false-positive diagnosis of BD, demonstrating the inability of current diagnostic standards to distinguish true BD from potentially reversible brain nonfunction due to GIP. The incidence of such mimicry is impossible to determine, because in most cases a BD diagnosis becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Literatur
2.
Zurück zum Zitat Shewmon DA. False-positive diagnosis of brain death following the Pediatric Guidelines: case report and discussion. J Child Neurol. 2017;32:1104–17.CrossRefPubMed Shewmon DA. False-positive diagnosis of brain death following the Pediatric Guidelines: case report and discussion. J Child Neurol. 2017;32:1104–17.CrossRefPubMed
4.
Zurück zum Zitat Wijdicks EFM, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM. Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 2010;74:1911–8.CrossRefPubMed Wijdicks EFM, Varelas PN, Gronseth GS, Greer DM. Evidence-based guideline update: determining brain death in adults: report of the Quality Standards Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. Neurology. 2010;74:1911–8.CrossRefPubMed
5.
Zurück zum Zitat Nakagawa TA, Ashwal S, Mathur M, Mysore M, Committee for Determination of Brain Death in Infants and Children. Guidelines for the determination of brain death in infants and children: an update of the 1987 Task Force recommendations—executive summary. Ann Neurol. 1987;2012(71):573–85. Nakagawa TA, Ashwal S, Mathur M, Mysore M, Committee for Determination of Brain Death in Infants and Children. Guidelines for the determination of brain death in infants and children: an update of the 1987 Task Force recommendations—executive summary. Ann Neurol. 1987;2012(71):573–85.
6.
Zurück zum Zitat President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Defining death: medical, legal, and ethical issues in the determination of death. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office; 1981. President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. Defining death: medical, legal, and ethical issues in the determination of death. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office; 1981.
7.
Zurück zum Zitat Coimbra CG. Implications of ischemic penumbra for the diagnosis of brain death. Braz J Med Biol Res. 1999;32:1479–87.CrossRefPubMed Coimbra CG. Implications of ischemic penumbra for the diagnosis of brain death. Braz J Med Biol Res. 1999;32:1479–87.CrossRefPubMed
8.
Zurück zum Zitat Walker AE, Diamond EL, Moseley J. The neuropathological findings in irreversible coma: a critique of the “respirator brain”. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 1975;34:295–323.CrossRefPubMed Walker AE, Diamond EL, Moseley J. The neuropathological findings in irreversible coma: a critique of the “respirator brain”. J Neuropathol Exp Neurol. 1975;34:295–323.CrossRefPubMed
9.
10.
Zurück zum Zitat Wijdicks EF, Pfeifer EA. Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology. 2008;70:1234–7.CrossRefPubMed Wijdicks EF, Pfeifer EA. Neuropathology of brain death in the modern transplant era. Neurology. 2008;70:1234–7.CrossRefPubMed
11.
Zurück zum Zitat Nguyen D. The new definitions of death for organ donation. Bern: Peter Lang; 2018.CrossRef Nguyen D. The new definitions of death for organ donation. Bern: Peter Lang; 2018.CrossRef
12.
Zurück zum Zitat Suzuki Y, Mogami Y, Toribe Y, et al. Prolonged elevation of serum neuron-specific enolase in children after clinical diagnosis of brain death. J Child Neurol. 2012;27:7–10.CrossRefPubMed Suzuki Y, Mogami Y, Toribe Y, et al. Prolonged elevation of serum neuron-specific enolase in children after clinical diagnosis of brain death. J Child Neurol. 2012;27:7–10.CrossRefPubMed
13.
14.
Zurück zum Zitat Machado C, DeFina PA, Estévez M, et al. A reason for care in the clinical evaluation of function on the spectrum of consciousness. Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon. 2018;7:43–53. Machado C, DeFina PA, Estévez M, et al. A reason for care in the clinical evaluation of function on the spectrum of consciousness. Funct Neurol Rehabil Ergon. 2018;7:43–53.
15.
Zurück zum Zitat Giacino JT, Ashwal S, Childs N, et al. The minimally conscious state. Definition and diagnostic criteria. Neurology. 2002;58:349–53.CrossRefPubMed Giacino JT, Ashwal S, Childs N, et al. The minimally conscious state. Definition and diagnostic criteria. Neurology. 2002;58:349–53.CrossRefPubMed
16.
Zurück zum Zitat Giacino JT. The vegetative and minimally conscious states: consensus-based criteria for establishing diagnosis and prognosis. NeuroRehabilitation. 2004;19:293–8.PubMed Giacino JT. The vegetative and minimally conscious states: consensus-based criteria for establishing diagnosis and prognosis. NeuroRehabilitation. 2004;19:293–8.PubMed
17.
Zurück zum Zitat Shewmon DA. The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating “brain death” with death. J Med Philos. 2001;26:457–78.CrossRefPubMed Shewmon DA. The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating “brain death” with death. J Med Philos. 2001;26:457–78.CrossRefPubMed
18.
Zurück zum Zitat Shewmon DA. Chronic “brain death”: meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology. 1998;51:1538–45.CrossRefPubMed Shewmon DA. Chronic “brain death”: meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology. 1998;51:1538–45.CrossRefPubMed
19.
Zurück zum Zitat Nakagawa TA. Declaration of Thomas A. Nakagawa, M.D., FAAP, FCCM in support of defendants’ motion for summary adjudication of plaintiff Jahi McMath’s first cause of action for personal injuries. Superior Court of California, Alameda County, R-1838158; 2017. Nakagawa TA. Declaration of Thomas A. Nakagawa, M.D., FAAP, FCCM in support of defendants’ motion for summary adjudication of plaintiff Jahi McMath’s first cause of action for personal injuries. Superior Court of California, Alameda County, R-1838158; 2017.
20.
Zurück zum Zitat Bernat JL. Refinements in the definition and criterion of death. In: Youngner SJ, Arnold RM, Schapiro R, editors. The definition of death: contemporary controversies. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1999. p. 83–92. Bernat JL. Refinements in the definition and criterion of death. In: Youngner SJ, Arnold RM, Schapiro R, editors. The definition of death: contemporary controversies. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1999. p. 83–92.
21.
Zurück zum Zitat Wijdicks EF. The case against confirmatory tests for determining brain death in adults. Neurology. 2010;75:77–83.CrossRefPubMed Wijdicks EF. The case against confirmatory tests for determining brain death in adults. Neurology. 2010;75:77–83.CrossRefPubMed
22.
Zurück zum Zitat Nair-Collins M, Northrup J, Olcese J. Hypothalamic-pituitary function in brain death: a review. J Intensive Care Med. 2016;31:41–50.CrossRefPubMed Nair-Collins M, Northrup J, Olcese J. Hypothalamic-pituitary function in brain death: a review. J Intensive Care Med. 2016;31:41–50.CrossRefPubMed
23.
Zurück zum Zitat Miller FG, Truog RD. Death, dying, and organ transplantation. Reconstructing medical ethics at the end of life. New York: Oxford University Press; 2012. Miller FG, Truog RD. Death, dying, and organ transplantation. Reconstructing medical ethics at the end of life. New York: Oxford University Press; 2012.
24.
Zurück zum Zitat Pope TM. Brain death forsaken: growing conflict and new legal challenges. J Leg Med. 2017;37:265–324.CrossRefPubMed Pope TM. Brain death forsaken: growing conflict and new legal challenges. J Leg Med. 2017;37:265–324.CrossRefPubMed
25.
Zurück zum Zitat Yanke G, Rady MY, Verheijde JL. Ethical and legal concerns with Nevada’s brain death amendments. J Bioeth Inq. 2018;15:193–198.CrossRef Yanke G, Rady MY, Verheijde JL. Ethical and legal concerns with Nevada’s brain death amendments. J Bioeth Inq. 2018;15:193–198.CrossRef
26.
Zurück zum Zitat Lewis A, Bernat JL, Blosser S, et al. An interdisciplinary response to contemporary concerns about brain death determination. Neurology. 2018;90:423–6.CrossRefPubMed Lewis A, Bernat JL, Blosser S, et al. An interdisciplinary response to contemporary concerns about brain death determination. Neurology. 2018;90:423–6.CrossRefPubMed
27.
Zurück zum Zitat Tchekmedyian A. ‘A girl with a brain injury.’ Jahi McMath, whose 2013 declaration of brain death sparked a legal fight to keep her on life support, dies. Los Angeles Times, 2018; B1–B2. Tchekmedyian A. ‘A girl with a brain injury.’ Jahi McMath, whose 2013 declaration of brain death sparked a legal fight to keep her on life support, dies. Los Angeles Times, 2018; B1–B2.
Metadaten
Titel
Truly Reconciling the Case of Jahi McMath
verfasst von
D. Alan Shewmon
Publikationsdatum
15.08.2018
Verlag
Springer US
Erschienen in
Neurocritical Care / Ausgabe 2/2018
Print ISSN: 1541-6933
Elektronische ISSN: 1556-0961
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12028-018-0593-x

Weitere Artikel der Ausgabe 2/2018

Neurocritical Care 2/2018 Zur Ausgabe

Neurocritical care through history

On Aneurysmal Rupture and Rerupture

Leitlinien kompakt für die Neurologie

Mit medbee Pocketcards sicher entscheiden.

Seit 2022 gehört die medbee GmbH zum Springer Medizin Verlag

Neu im Fachgebiet Neurologie

Update Neurologie

Bestellen Sie unseren Fach-Newsletter und bleiben Sie gut informiert.