Fruit-Derived Polyphenol Supplementation for Athlete Recovery and Performance

Polyphenols possess radical scavenging properties related to their chemical structure. Phenolic hydroxyl groups can donate an electron to radicals and the polyphenol aromatic ring can then stabilise the resulting aroxyl radicals [17]. Polyphenols are also metal chelators and hence can reduce metal-catalysed free radical formation [18]. However, maximum plasma concentrations of conjugated and unconjugated polyphenols have been estimated to range from 0.1 to 22 µmol L⁻¹ [19, 20]. When compared to the concentration of plasma urate (150–450 µmol L⁻¹), which is also an important plasma compartment antioxidant, it seems unlikely that plasma phenolics are effective direct antioxidants in vivo. Many of the studies reviewed in this article have quantified changes in the debunked [21] plasma total antioxidant capacity (TAC) after polyphenol supplementation. However, TAC only quantifies the cumulative action of small molecule antioxidants present in plasma, and ignores the important contribution of intracellular enzymes such as superoxide dismutase, catalase and peroxiredoxin. This cannot therefore be regarded as a true measure of in vivo antioxidant capacity. The increases in TAC observed after polyphenol supplementation are likely to be almost entirely dependent upon changes in plasma urate related to fructose metabolism, and independent of changes in plasma phenolics [22]. There is now growing evidence that phenolics are able to upregulate endogenous antioxidant capacity via the Nrf2/antioxidant response element (ARE) pathway. Nrf2 is a master regulator of the antioxidant response through the regulation of a wide range of antioxidant and phase II detoxification genes [23], and protects cells from stressors including reactive oxygen species (ROS), and dietary xenobiotics such as polyphenols [24]. Keap1 is a cysteine-rich protein that represses Nrf2 signalling by serving as a bridge between Nrf2 and ubiquitination ligase cullin-3, which is required for the ubiquitination of the protein and subsequent proteasomal degradation [25, 26]. Oxidative stressors or electrophiles induce covalent modification of Keap1 cysteine residues and therefore inhibit ubiquitination-dependent degradation and increase nuclear accumulation of Nrf2, resulting in increased synthesis of downstream endogenous antioxidants such as superoxide dismutase, catalase and peroxiredoxin [27]. Although dietary polyphenols are not present in sufficient quantity in vivo to contribute directly to antioxidant function as radical scavengers, phenolics will be converted to electrophilic quinones and hydroquinones upon exposure to ROS, which are then able to interact with Keap 1 and activate Nrf2 (for a review, see Huang et al. [24]). Paradoxically it seems that antioxidant effects of polyphenols arise from their pro-oxidant action after in vivo exposure to ROS, although much of the evidence for this is currently from in vitro work, and there is a need for human in vivo studies to verify this hypothesis. Polyphenols also seem to possess anti-inflammatory properties and have been shown in vitro to inhibit cyclo-oxygenase enzymes, COX1 and COX2 [28], to reduce NF-ƘB expression signalling [29] and to inhibit nuclear translocation of NF-ƘB [30].

In resting human studies, changes in plasma biomarkers of oxidative damage and inflammation support the antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects of fruit-derived polyphenols including cherries [31], blueberries [32, 33], blackcurrant [34], pomegranate [35] and cocoa [36]. There is also consistent evidence that both acute and chronic supplementation with polyphenols improves vascular function, specifically endothelium-dependent vasodilation, which is nitric oxide (NO) dependent and measured in vivo as flow-mediated dilatation (FMD). A meta-analysis of 42 cocoa studies found significant increases in FMD following acute (3.2%) and chronic (1.3%) supplementation, respectively [37]. A smaller number of studies have been performed to assess the acute or chronic effects of fruit polyphenols on FMD, and these have mostly utilised grape-derived polyphenols as well as pomegranate, chokeberry or blueberry. Rodriguez-Mateos et al. [14] showed that a range of blueberry polyphenol doses (0.3–1.88 g polyphenols) increased FMD in healthy men peaking at 1 h and this paralleled reduction in neutrophil nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate (NADPH) oxidase activity. This suggests that reduced superoxide production and hence decreased conversion of NO to peroxynitrite likely contributes to the increased vasodilation response by improving NO bioavailability.

A number of studies have also found improvements in endothelial-dependent vasodilatation after chronic supplementation with fruit polyphenols especially amongst study populations with impaired cardiovascular function (grape juice [38, 39], red grapes [40], grape polyphenols [41], grape seed [42], chokeberry juice [43]) or with low habitual fruit and vegetable intake (blackcurrant [44]). A meta-analysis revealed that after supplementation with a mix of flavonoids, the absolute mean difference in % dilatation was ∆ 2.33% (based on 18 acute supplementation studies) and ∆ 0.73% with chronic supplementation (based on 14 studies) [45]. The optimal dose identified was 500 mg per day total flavonoids or 300 mg per day of procyanidins.

The improvement in FMD in response to acute and chronic polyphenol supplementation is by definition a result of increased NO bioavailability, since FMD is NO dependent. These effects are likely achieved through a variety of synergistic mechanisms. There is evidence from in vitro studies that polyphenols induce endothelial nitric oxide synthase 3 (eNOS) activation via signalling through oestrogen receptor-α via G protein, extracellular-signal-regulated kinase (ERK) and phosphatidylinositide 3-kinase (PI3 K) pathways [46]. In addition, polyphenols have been shown to inhibit NADPH oxidase, one of the key sources of superoxide production [47], and to induce signalling through Nrf2, thus increasing endogenous antioxidant capacity [48], both of which will preserve NO bioavailability by reduced formation of peroxynitrite. In addition to the health benefits associated with these antioxidant, anti-inflammatory and vasoactive properties of polyphenols, they are also of relevance for exercise performance and recovery from intensive exercise.

Exercise-induced fatigue has been extensively investigated, but the mechanisms remain controversial due its complex multifactorial nature and specificity to exercise mode, intensity and duration. Fatigue may relate to: (i) depletion of muscle fuel substrates such as phosphocreatine (PCr) or glycogen, (ii) accumulation of metabolic by-products such as ammonia and hydrogen ions, (iii) perturbation of ionic gradients between intra- and extracellular compartments thus interfering with action potential transmission, (iv) impaired excitation contraction coupling via altered calcium sensitivity and sequestration to the sarcoplasmic reticulum, (v) altered central drive due to afferent feedback from the exercising muscle conveying changes in the metabolic milieu (for a review, see Allen et al. [49]). The ability to regulate and co-ordinate the function of cardiovascular, respiratory, metabolic and neuromuscular systems is pivotal to ensure that the kinetics of substrate supply and waste product removal match the requirements of the specific exercise bout and thus performance is preserved.

Skeletal muscle is a net producer of reactive oxygen species from a variety of sources including the mitochondrial respiratory chain and enzymatic sources such as NADPH oxidase and xanthine oxidase [50]. Paramagnetic electron spin resonance experiments demonstrate that ROS generation increases with exercise intensity [51, 52]. ROS are important signalling molecules and have been implicated in contraction-mediated increases in muscle glucose uptake [53] and control of skeletal muscle blood flow [54]. For instance, Durand et al. [55] found that hydrogen peroxide caused vasodilation in exercising muscle. It appears that under conditions of low oxidative stress and redox balance, ROS promote optimal vasodilation and hyperaemia in exercising muscle. However, under conditions of oxidative stress or already disturbed redox balance, ROS generation during exercise impairs blood flow and vasodilatory capacity [56]. Ryanodine receptors are the major calcium release channel in the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR), and due to the high number of cysteine residues in this protein, it is redox sensitive [57], as is SR Ca2 + ATPase activity. Excess ROS generation has been shown to impair calcium handling and sensitivity resulting in reduced contractile force development, thus impairing exercise performance [50, 58]. Additionally, group III and IV afferents are sensitive to ROS, so ROS production within exercising muscle will be sensed by the somatosensory cortex, which may result in altered efferent activity and central drive to the muscle, contributing to the development of central fatigue [59]. Therefore, during high intensity or prolonged exercise where ROS generation exceeds the antioxidant capacity and results in disturbed redox balance, it is plausible that antioxidant supplementation may counteract fatigue and enhance performance via enhanced perfusion of the exercising muscle, better maintained excitation–contraction coupling and central drive. There is some empirical evidence to support this view, since supplementation with antioxidants such as N-acetyl cysteine [60‐62] has been shown to improve exercise performance. There is also evidence that acute (Table 2) or chronic (Table 3) supplementation with fruit-derived polyphenols is ergogenic for performance.

The conflicting findings across studies with regard to the effects of polyphenol supplementation are most likely due to the differences in research design including: the supplement composition, timing and dose of supplementation variation in the studied population, and performance tasks employed and therefore differences in the predominant processes contributing to fatigue development. The ergogenic effects of polyphenols seem to involve altered vascular function with augmentation of the measured increases in brachial artery diameter and blood flow after a 1 min occlusion, induced by pomegranate supplementation, which paralleled the ergogenic effects for performance [63, 65]. Similarly, Richards et al. [83] found that \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) was enhanced by supplementation with green tea-derived epigallocatechin (EGCG) supplementation for 2 days (135 mg three times per day) and a last dose 2 h pre-exercise. However, maximum cardiac output was not affected by EGCG, which therefore implies that the performance-enhancing effects were achieved via increased arterio-venous oxygen difference, i.e. improved oxygen extraction in the exercising muscle presumably coupled with better spatial distribution of muscle perfusion. Goncalves et al. [84] used nail-fold videocapillaroscopy of the fourth finger of the left hand in a temperature-controlled environment to assess microvascular function in triathletes in response to consuming 300 ml·day⁻¹ of organic grape juice (~ 1600 mg polyphenols) for 20 days. Functional capillary density (capillaries with red cell flux), red blood cell velocity and time to peak velocity after 1 min arterial occlusion were all improved after grape juice supplementation, supporting the likelihood of better tissue perfusion after polyphenol supplementation, although this clearly needs to be directly tested in muscle. The ergogenic effects of blackcurrant supplementation are also proposed to be dependent on vascular mechanisms, but until recently there has been limited empirical data to support this assertion. Cook et al. [85] found that 7 days of supplementation with 600 mg of blackcurrant powder (twice the daily dose provided in the exercise performance studies [75‐77, 79]) resulted in increased femoral artery diameter during a sustained submaximal maximum voluntary contraction (MVC) of the knee extensors (30% MVC for 120 s). These effects were accompanied by lower systolic and diastolic blood pressure and lower total peripheral resistance estimated via beat–beat finger blood pressure analysis.

The most plausible mechanisms for these apparent vascular effects are either reduced generation of ROS or improved capacity to detoxify ROS via antioxidant systems. Such reduced exposure to ROS will improve bioavailability of the potent vasodilator NO, due to reduced production of peroxynitrite via the reaction of superoxide and NO. In vivo and in vitro evidence demonstrate that phenolic metabolites reduce NADPH oxidase activity, one of the key sources of superoxide production during exercise [47]. This is corroborated by the evidence that acute polyphenol supplementation protects against endurance exercise-induced oxidative damage. Consumption of a black grape, raspberry and redcurrant polyphenol blend (2000 mg polyphenols, including 1212 mg anthocyanins) during 90 min of cycling at 70% \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) attenuated the exercise-induced elevation in plasma thiobarbituric acid-reacting substances (TBARS) and protein carbonyls in trained male cyclists [86]. Recreationally active participants experienced a reduced F2-isoprostane response to 2.5 h cycling at 60% \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) when completed 2 h after consuming 100 g of dark chocolate (~ 250 mg polyphenols [12]). Lyall et al. [87] found that the increase in plasma protein carbonyls after 30 min rowing at 80% \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) was attenuated when blackcurrant powder (120 mg anthocyanins) was consumed immediately prior to exercise by recreationally active participants. However, none of these studies included an assessment of exercise performance.

In addition, there is evidence that chronic polyphenol consumption increases endogenous antioxidant system capacity via signalling through Nrf2 and antioxidant response element pathways (see Sect. 2) in a similar fashion to exercise adaptation [88]. Chronic polyphenol supplementation lowers exercise-induced oxidative stress, for instance 250 g blueberries consumed every day for 6 weeks with 375 g consumed 2 h prior to a 2.5 h run at 72% \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) attenuated the exercise-induced increase in plasma F2-isoprostanes and urinary oxidation products of RNA [89]. Young men consuming a diet supplemented with anthocyanin-rich purple sweet potato leaves versus a low polyphenol diet for 7 days experienced reduced plasma protein carbonyls and TBARS at rest and after 1 h exercise at 70% \({\dot{\text V}}{\text O}_{2}\max\) [90]. Fuster-Munoz et al. [91] found that plasma malondialdehyde (MDA) and PC were reduced in endurance athletes undergoing normal training when consuming 200 ml·day⁻¹ of pomegranate juice for 21 days. The ergogenic effects of polyphenols therefore seem to be underpinned by vascular and antioxidant mechanisms. However, there is clearly a need for well-designed studies that measure exercise performance alongside robust measures of oxidative damage, antioxidant enzyme content and activity, inflammatory processes, macro- and micro-vascular function, and plasma phenolics to confirm these ergogenic effects and the mediators of these effects.

Exercise-induced muscle damage involves both mechanical and biochemical processes. Muscle fibres are exposed to high mechanical forces especially during explosive and/or eccentric contractions, which can result in disruption to the extracellular matrix, contractile proteins, sarcoplasmic reticulum, t-tubules and sarcolemma. There is subsequent disruption of calcium homeostasis with elevated resting calcium concentration [92], which may then contribute to further damage through activation of calcium sensitive proteases such as calpain resulting in increased proteolysis of susceptible proteins such as desmin and actin, thus worsening the ultrastructural damage [92]. In addition, there is increased generation of reactive oxygen species in an exercise intensity- and mode-dependent fashion [51, 93], which will cause oxidative modification of proteins and other molecules resulting in altered function and damage. Such processes will be particularly important contributing factors to the initial damage induced by high-intensity prolonged activities that do not involve eccentric muscle actions.

This initial damage, whether mechanical or biochemical, triggers a potent inflammatory response with damaged fibres releasing pro-inflammatory cytokines, which serve as chemo-attractants for neutrophils and macrophages and activate ROS generating enzymes within the muscle [94]. Neutrophil infiltration and activation occurs within 2 h of damage, generally peaking within 6–24 h and then rapidly decreasing [95]. Neutrophils are rich in enzymes such as NADPH oxidase, and release ROS and proteolytic enzymes that may exacerbate the initial muscle damage [96], but also facilitate regeneration by removal of debris and activation of satellite cells [97]. Shortly after neutrophil infiltration, macrophages derived from blood monocytes accumulate within the damaged tissue. Their role is to scavenge debris and apoptotic cells and in addition release a range of growth factors and other substances that trigger remodelling of extracellular matrix, contractile and vascular elements. Two macrophage populations have been identified: M1 and M2. M1 macrophages are pro-inflammatory and infiltrate muscle in the early stages of damage, and have been linked to proliferation of satellite cells [98]. It has been suggested that phagocytosis of damaged myogenic cells by M1 macrophages triggers their conversion to M2 macrophages [99]. These M2 macrophages release anti-inflammatory cytokines (transforming growth factor-β and interleukin 10) and release growth factors such as insulin-like growth factor 1 to support regeneration of the damaged tissue [100].

The central involvement of ROS generation and inflammation within the muscle damage and healing process suggests that polyphenol supplementation will influence these processes and therefore the rate of recovery. Polyphenols have been shown to inhibit activity of key ROS-generating enzymes such as NADPH oxidase, serve as radical scavengers, and with chronic supplementation also enhance endogenous antioxidant capacity. In addition, polyphenols have been shown to inhibit cyclo-oxygenase activity and suppress inflammation [101‐103].

There is now a growing body of evidence that suggests that fruit-derived polyphenol supplementation enhances restoration of muscle function and reduces soreness after intensive exercise (Table 4). The effects of Montmorency cherry supplementation on recovery of muscle function or exercise performance after intensive exercise have been investigated in nine published studies thus far, of which five studies found favourable effects [104‐108]. These studies involved recreationally active men [104], recreational runners [105] or trained athletes [106‐108], so unlike the acute performance effects of polyphenol supplementation, it seems that beneficial effects on recovery are accessible to both trained and less well-trained individuals. Nor does the efficacy of the supplement seem to be influenced by the mode of exercise used to induce muscle damage, since different approaches or muscle groups were damaged in each of these studies (intensive knee extensor resistance exercise [106]; eccentric elbow flexor exercise [104]; marathon running [105]; high-intensity stochastic cycling [108] or 90 min repeated high-intensity shuttle running [107]). In these studies, Montmorency cherry was provided in the form of a juice drink, which was consumed morning and evening for at least 3 days prior to exercise, and provided at least 1200 mg polyphenols per day. Conversely, in studies where recovery of muscle function or exercise performance was not enhanced [109‐111, 120], either a lower (and presumably insufficient) dose of Montmorency cherry was provided in powder form (480 mg Montmorency cherry powder in a single dose [109]; 733 mg polyphenols split into two doses [110]) or the intensive exercise task did not induce a measurable decline in muscle strength [110] or exercise performance [111], thus by definition making it impossible to improve recovery. As well as differences in dose and frequency of supplementation, it is possible that differences in post-harvest processing of cherries between juice and powder production may induce variation in the polyphenol blend, and thus contribute to the discrepancy in findings across studies utilising Montmorency cherry powder [109, 110] versus juice [104‐108, 111, 112]. In summary, consumption of Montmorency cherry juice or concentrate providing 600 mg polyphenols morning and evening for at least 3 days prior to exercise and during recovery has consistently been shown to improve recovery of muscle function. Further studies are required to identify the optimal dose, frequency and duration of consumption.

The effect of Montmorency cherry supplementation on muscle soreness after intensive exercise has been assessed in eight studies, and soreness measured using a visual analogue pain scale [104, 107, 112] or pressure pain tolerance [109] was reduced in half of these studies. There is no clear pattern to explain this variation across studies: in two studies favourable effects on both recovery of muscle strength and soreness were evident [104, 107]; in others favourable effects on muscle function but not soreness were observed [105, 106]; and Beals et al. [110] and McCormick et al. [111] found no effects on either soreness or muscle function, but the exercise protocol did not induce loss of muscle strength or soreness. Lastly, Kuehl et al. [112] found significant reductions in muscle soreness in runners who consumed Montmorency cherry juice (1200 mg polyphenols) for 7 days prior to and on the day of the Hood to Coast relay race, but changes in muscle function were not assessed. Suppression of inflammation induced by muscle damage is the proposed mechanism by which polyphenol supplementation may attenuate muscle soreness [113]. At present measures of serum markers of inflammation are available for some but not all studies, and there seems to be no relationship between reduced soreness after Montmorency cherry supplementation and serum markers of inflammation. Levers et al. [109] found reduced soreness but no effect on serum TNFα, IL1β, IL6 or IL8; Kuehl et al. [112] and Connolly et al. [104] found reductions in soreness but no serum inflammatory marker data are available. Howatson et al. [105] found reduced serum IL6 and C-reactive protein (CRP) after cherry supplementation but no significant effect on soreness; only Bell et al. [107] found reductions in both soreness and serum IL6 response, but serum TNFα, IL1β, IL8 and CRP were not affected by Montmorency cherry supplementation. Several studies found no effects of Montmorency cherry supplementation on serum markers of inflammation [106, 110, 111], but these involved unilateral and/or relatively small muscle group exercise, which did not result in elevations in systemic markers of inflammation. Therefore, the absence of polyphenol effects in these studies is unsurprising. By definition, soreness is a highly subjective measure even when pressure pain tolerance is measured using an algometer, hence although important for athlete performance it is difficult to reliably and objectively quantify. The quantification of inflammation within the damaged muscle itself, alongside measures of muscle soreness, could be an important step forward in understanding the effects of polyphenols.

Pomegranate juice consumption has also been shown to enhance recovery of elbow flexor [114‐116], and knee extensor [116] muscle function after intensive exercise in recreationally active men. However, Trombold et al. [115] found that in resistance-trained men, pomegranate juice (250 ml providing ~ 620 mg polyphenols) consumption twice per day for 7 days prior to and after exercise resulted in faster recovery of elbow flexor but not knee extensor isometric strength compared to placebo, after muscle damage was induced by eccentric elbow flexor and knee extensor exercise. The knee extensors were relatively refractory to muscle damage (15–20% reduction in isometric strength vs. 25–35% loss of elbow flexor isometric strength) in this population, which may contribute to the lack of polyphenol effects in knee extensors in this population. In contrast, Machin et al. [116] found that recovery of both elbow flexor and knee extensor strength in recreationally active men was enhanced by consumption of pomegranate concentrate providing 650 mg polyphenols either once or twice per day for 3 days prior to exercise, suggesting that the lower polyphenol dose was equally effective.

Only Trombold et al. [115] found that pomegranate supplementation reduced muscle soreness, specifically after eccentric elbow flexor exercise in resistance-trained men, but no serum markers of inflammation were measured in this study. Trombold et al. [114] and Machin et al. [116] measured muscle damage markers myoglobin (Mb) and/or creatine kinase (CK) and found that the exercise-induced increases were not affected by pomegranate supplementation. Serum markers of inflammation were measured in only one study [114], and there were no effects of pomegranate supplementation. However, as observed for Montmorency cherry supplementation studies, damage to a relatively small muscle group (elbow flexors) was not sufficient to induce any change in serum IL6 or CRP, hence it is unsurprising that polyphenol effects were not detectable.

Blueberry supplementation consumed in the form of a smoothie on the day of exercise (1360 mg polyphenols) and during 2 days of recovery (420 mg polyphenols per day) enhanced recovery of knee extensor strength after unilateral eccentric exercise in recreationally active women, but did not reduce muscle soreness or serum IL6 although there was a strong tendency for reduced oxidative modification of serum proteins (protein carbonyls) [117]. Conversely, Peschek et al. [118] found no effect of the addition of cocoa flavanols to chocolate milk in the recovery of muscle strength or 5-km time trial performance or muscle soreness in eight endurance-trained males, when consumed 1 and 2 h after downhill running. However, this finding in this randomised crossover trial is confounded by the use of downhill running to induce muscle damage, with all second trials likely to be affected by repeated bout effect, irrespective of treatment [119]. With the exception of McCormick et al. [111], all other studies reported here either adopted unilateral exercise for crossover trials to minimise repeated bout effects or utilised parallel group design to avoid repeated bout effects, although such studies are susceptible to the high degree of inter-individual variation evident in muscle damage and soreness responses.

Serum markers of oxidative damage (TBARS, MDA, lipid hydroperoxides, F2-isoprostanes, protein carbonyls, nitrotyrosine) were measured in five of the nine studies that found favourable effects of polyphenol supplementation on recovery of muscle function. Oxidative damage was suppressed either significantly (TBARS [105]; protein carbonyls [106]) or there was a strong non-statistically significant trend (lipid hydroperoxides [107]; protein carbonyls [117]) or in only one study there was no effect (lipid hydroperoxides [108]). A number of other studies have found reductions in oxidative damage markers after intensive exercise with prior polyphenol supplementation, although changes in muscle function were not measured (Montmorency cherry, 1300 mg·day⁻¹ polyphenols [120]; blackcurrant, 240 mg anthocyanin [87]; pomegranate juice, 2560 mg·day⁻¹ polyphenols [121]). As described earlier (Sect. 2.1), it seems unlikely that polyphenols serve as direct antioxidants due to their relatively low concentration relative to endogenous antioxidants in serum and tissue. It is more likely that chronic supplementation (> 3 days) reduces serum markers of oxidative damage via upregulation of endogenous antioxidants through Nrf2 and antioxidant response element pathway signalling [24, 122]. Tart cherry juice consumption has been shown to increase hepatic superoxide dismutase and glutathione peroxidase activity in mice [123]. Supplementation with anthocyanins isolated from purple sweet potato increased Nrf2 gene expression and Nrf2 nuclear translocation in rat liver [124]. Charles et al. [125] recently demonstrated that the age-related increases in oxidative stress and declines in mitochondrial function in mice were prevented by supplementation with an anthocyanin-rich extract derived from red grapes. This was achieved both via reduced reactive oxygen species generation as well as increased endogenous antioxidant enzyme gene expression. Dark chocolate supplementation for 3 months has also been shown to enhance superoxide dismutase and catalase expression in muscle of patients with heart failure and type 2 diabetes [48], and more recently has been shown to reduce carbonylation of proteins within skeletal muscle of healthy adults [126]. In contrast, McLeay et al. [117] only commenced blueberry supplementation 10 h prior to intensive exercise and hence increased endogenous antioxidant capacity is an unlikely explanation of the enhanced restoration of muscle function and a strong trend for lower serum protein carbonylation. Blueberry supplementation has been shown to suppress neutrophil NADPH oxidase activity [14], one of the key sources of superoxide production, which may contribute to the observed effects. A range of polyphenols have been shown to inhibit superoxide producing enzymes, such as NADPH oxidase and xanthine oxidase (for review, see Maraldi [47]).

Polyphenols have been shown to inhibit cyclo-oxygenase activity (COX1 and COX2) in similar fashion to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and there is extensive in vitro and in vivo evidence of anti-inflammatory effects of polyphenols (for review see Peluso et al. [127]). The important and complex contribution of inflammatory pathways to the healing and remodelling process suggests the anti-inflammatory effects of polyphenols may be a key component of the mechanisms of action. Ten of the reviewed studies included serum markers of inflammation, with polyphenol-induced reductions in serum IL6 response to intensive exercise in five studies [34, 105, 107, 108, 120]). However, muscle soreness was attenuated in only one of these studies [107], whilst recovery of muscle function was enhanced in both studies where isometric force and inflammatory marker data were available [105, 107]. In four studies [106, 110, 111, 114], there was no effect of polyphenol supplementation on serum markers of inflammation; however, the exercise protocol employed did not induce elevation in any serum markers in these studies. In the remaining studies, polyphenol supplementation did not affect serum markers of inflammation despite enhanced recovery of muscle function [117] and reduced soreness [109]. The reliance on proxy serum markers of inflammation does not provide sufficient sensitivity to understand processes taking place within the damaged muscle itself. This point was clearly confirmed by Jajtner [128], since supplementation with a proprietary blend of green and black tea polyphenols suppressed IL8 protein expression in human skeletal muscle after intensive exercise, but there was no effect on circulating IL8 concentration. Myburgh et al. [129] investigated the effect of grape seed-derived proanthocyanidolic oligomer (PCO) supplementation on the healing process after hindlimb contusion injury in male Wistar rats. PCO treated rats exhibited reduced neutrophil activation on day 1, normal magnitude but earlier macrophage response and earlier satellite cell activation. However, equivalent data from studies with human participants are not yet available.

Sleep is an important component of an athlete’s programme to ensure optimal recovery. However, use of stimulant supplements, evening training sessions and matches, travel and other aspects of an athlete’s busy life can compromise both sleep quantity and quality. There is some evidence to suggest that Montmorency cherry [130, 131] and Jerte valley [132, 133] cherry supplementation improves sleep quality (assessed via accelerometry and sleep questionnaire), which may also contribute to the observed benefits for recovery. Modulation of the pro-inflammatory cytokine response to exercise has been suggested as one possible mechanism by which sleep quality may be improved, as well as the melatonin content of cherries. Elevation of urinary melatonin metabolites after 7 days’ cherry supplementation in parallel with enhanced sleep quality supports this assertion. However, in these studies supplements were consumed in the morning and evening whereas melatonin supplements are normally prescribed to be consumed prior to sleep, and in addition the dose provided by cherries is relatively low (85 µg vs. 2–3 mg clinical dose) and there is some scepticism surrounding this proposition [134]. Nevertheless, recent data from in vivo rat studies suggest that co-ingestion of melatonin with caffeic acid and/or quercetin enhances melatonin pharmacokinetics [135]. More human in vivo studies are needed to verify the somniferous effects of Montmorency cherry and other polyphenols and improve understanding of the mechanism.