Cell density dependent plating efficiency affects outcome and interpretation of colony forming assays

doi:10.1016/0167-8140(96)01767-7

Radiotherapy and Oncology

Volume 40, Issue 2, August 1996, Pages 121-125

https://doi.org/10.1016/0167-8140(96)01767-7 Get rights and content

Abstract

Background and purpose. The usefulness of colony forming assays (CFA) has been established for almost 40 years (Puck and Marcus, J. Exp. Med. 103: 653–666,1956). Although time-consuming and not successful for all cell lines, it is generally considered to be the gold standard of assays for testing the sensitivity of cell lines to ionizing radiation or other cytotoxic agents in vitro. We recently found for several cell lines that the plating efficiencies of both control and irradiated cells is dependent upon the density of cells seeded for colony formation; that is, increasing cell inoculum levels resulted in a non-linear relationship with colony formation, even at relatively low colony numbers. Material and methods. All data from a human melanoma cell line, transfected with c-myc or N-ras, as well as from normal human diploid fibroblasts, were taken to see how this phenomenon influenced outcome and interpretation of clonogenic assays. Survival was recalculated using all data, or only data with a linear relationship between inoculum level and colony formation. Results. It is found that when data with a non-linear relationship between inoculum level and colony formation are included, survival can be underestimated due to inhibition of colony formation in treated cultures. Conclusion. For validity, colony forming assays must be standardized to assure a constant relationship between the cell density and colony forming efficiency. This usually requires a much lower density of colonies than has been typically published for many cell survival studies.

References (9)

F.B. Geara et al.
Radiosensitivity measurement of keratinocytes and fibro-blasts from radiotherapy patients
Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys.
(1992)
C. Aubert et al.
Tumorigenicity of human malignant melanocytes in nude mice in relation to their differentiation in vitro
J. Natl. Cancer Inst.
(1980)
J.F. Eliason et al.
Non-linearity of colony formation by human tumour cells from biopsy samples
Br. J. Cancer
(1985)
F.B. Geara et al.
Intrinsic radiosensitivity of normal human fibroblasts and lymphocytesafter high- and low-dose-rate irradiation
Cancer Res.
(1992)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (36)

Integrated High-Throughput Screening and Large-Scale Isobolographic Analysis to Accelerate the Discovery of Radiosensitizers With Greater Selectivity for Cancer Cells
2024, International Journal of Radiation Oncology Biology Physics
High-throughput screening (HTS) platforms have been widely used to identify candidate anticancer drugs and drug-drug combinations; however, HTS-based identification of new drug-ionizing radiation (IR) combinations has rarely been reported. Herein, we developed an integrated approach including cell-based HTS and computational large-scale isobolographic analysis to accelerate the identification of radiosensitizing compounds acting strongly and more specifically on cancer cells.
In a 384-well plate format, 160 compounds likely to interfere with the cell response to radiation were screened on human glioblastoma (U251-MG) and cervix carcinoma (ME-180) cell lines, as well as on normal fibroblasts (CCD-19Lu). After drug exposure, cells were irradiated or not and short-term cell survival was assessed by high-throughput cell microscopy. Computational large-scale dose-response and isobolographic approach were used to identify promising synergistic drugs radiosensitizing cancer cells rather than normal cells. Synergy of a promising compound was confirmed on ME-180 cells by an independent 96-well assay protocol, and finally, by the gold-standard colony forming assay.
We retained 4 compounds synergistic at 2 isoeffects in U251-MG and ME-180 cell lines and 11 compounds synergistically effective in only one cancer cell line. Among these 15 promising radiosensitizers, 5 compounds showed limited toxicity combined or not with IR on normal fibroblasts.
Overall, this study demonstrated that HTS chemoradiation screening together with large-scale computational analysis is an efficient tool to identify synergistic drug-IR combinations, with concomitant assessment of unwanted toxicity on normal fibroblasts. It sparks expectations to accelerate the discovery of highly desired agents improving the therapeutic index of radiation therapy.
Hydroxyethyl disulfide as an efficient metabolic assay for cell viability in vitro
2012, Toxicology in Vitro
Citation Excerpt :
Although one or many of these approaches have been used for more than three decades in biomedical sciences, each one of them has disadvantages ranging from non-linearity to high background and complicated cumbersome and time consuming protocols. Clonogenic assay is a measure of colony (50 cells/colony) forming ability of a single cell, which quantifies the cytotoxic effects of drugs or radiation (Franken et al., 2006; Kuwahara et al., 2010; Pomp et al., 1996; Wouters et al., 2010). Most studies for high throughput screening (HTS) of cancer drugs avoid using this assay because of the difficulties in terms of time consuming and complicated protocols combined with low plating efficiency (PE) of the cells at low density (Pomp et al., 1996).
Cell viability assays have a variety of well known practical and technical limitations. All the available approaches have disadvantages, such as non-linearity, high background and cumbersome protocols. Several commonly used tetrazolium chemicals rely upon generation of a colored formazan product formed by mitochondrial reduction of these compounds via phenazine methosulfate (PMS). However, sensitivity is inherently limited because their reduction relies on mitochondrial bioreduction and cellular transport of PMS, as well as accessibility to tetrazolium chemicals. In this study, we identify hydroxethyldisulfide (HEDS) as an inexpensive probe that can measure cellular metabolic activity without the need of PMS. In tissue culture medium, HEDS accurately quantitated metabolically active live cells in a linear manner superior to tetrazolium based and other assays. Cell toxicity produced by chemotherapeutics (cisplatin, etoposide), oxidants (hydrogen peroxide, acetaminophen), toxins (phenyl arsine oxide, arsenite) or ionizing radiation was rapidly determined by the HEDS assay. We found that HEDS was superior to other commonly used assays for cell viability determinations in its solubility, membrane permeability, and intracellular conversion to a metabolic reporter that is readily transported into the extracellular medium. Our findings establish the use of HEDS in a simple, rapid and low cost assay to accurately quantify viable cells.
MmuPV1 E6 induces cell proliferation and other hallmarks of cancer
2023, mBio
A genome-wide CRISPR/Cas9 screen identifies DNA-PK as a sensitiser to <sup>177</sup>Lutetium-DOTA-octreotate radionuclide therapy
2023, Theranostics
Establishment and characterization of a new fibroblast-like cell line from the skin of a vertebrate model, zebrafish (Danio rerio)
2023, Molecular Biology Reports
Establishment and characterization of a new fibroblast-like cell line from the skin of a vertebrate model, zebrafish (Danio rerio)
2022, Research Square

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Original paperCell density dependent plating efficiency affects outcome and interpretation of colony forming assays

Abstract

Int. J. Radiat. Oncol. Biol. Phys.

Tumorigenicity of human malignant melanocytes in nude mice in relation to their differentiation in vitro

J. Natl. Cancer Inst.

Non-linearity of colony formation by human tumour cells from biopsy samples

Br. J. Cancer

Intrinsic radiosensitivity of normal human fibroblasts and lymphocytesafter high- and low-dose-rate irradiation

Cancer Res.

Original paper
Cell density dependent plating efficiency affects outcome and interpretation of colony forming assays