Brief clinical and laboratory observation

Immunoglobulin G deposits in the choroid plexus of a child with systemic lupus erythematosus

The pathogenesis of neuropsychiatric lupus (NPSLE) is believed to include the entry of circulating neuropathic antibodies to the brain via a pathologically permeable blood-brain barrier (BBB). Nevertheless, direct evidence of BBB pathology or mechanisms underlying BBB dysfunction is missing. Here, we examined BBB integrity in an established NPSLE mouse model (MRL/fas^lpr/lpr). Surprisingly, challenging the barrier with various exogenous tracers demonstrated insignificant changes in BBB permeability. Furthermore, electron microscopy showed no ultrastructure changes supporting hyper-permeability. However, we found that abnormal function of the blood-cerebrospinal fluid barrier (BCSFB) in the choroid plexus underlies brain exposure to neuropathic antibodies. Considerable intrathecal lymphocyte infiltration likely occurs through the BCSFB, accompanied by epithelial hyper-permeability to antibodies. Our results challenge the commonly held view of BBB disruption in NPSLE, supporting a shift in focus to BCSFB dysfunction as a causative factor in the disease.

Many avenues of research have been pursued in an effort to clarify the pathogenic mechanisms underlying the development of diffuse neuropsychiatric systematic lupus erythematosus (NPSLE). Given their overall importance in the development of SLE, the identification of specific autoreactive antibodies with neural antigenic determinants has been aggressively sought. The leading candidate autoantibodies appear to be anti-NMDAR and anti-P antibodies, which have repeatedly (albeit somewhat inconsistently) been associated with various presentations of NPSLE both in human patients and mouse models. However, this inconsistency may represent an underappreciated facet of NPSLE pathogenesis, namely that the source of immune penetrance into the central nervous system (CNS) is unclear. Furthermore, the potential for a CNS-derived aberrant immunity (i.e., local production of neurotoxic antibodies and other pathogenic mediators) tends to be discounted. When factoring in cytokine and chemokine contributors to its overall pathogenesis, it is clear that NPSLE is a particularly complex manifestation of SLE. It is more than likely that several contributors may operate convergently in the development of NPSLE, the various combinations of which potentially contribute to the diverse presentations found in lupus patients.

Experts have previously postulated a linkage between lupus associated vascular pathology and abnormal brain barriers in the immunopathogenesis of neuropsychiatric lupus. Nevertheless, there are some discrepancies between the experimental evidence, or its interpretation, and the working hypotheses prevalent in this field; specifically, that a primary contributor to neuropsychiatric disease in lupus is permeabilization of the blood brain barrier. In this commonly held view, any contribution of the other known brain barriers, including the blood-cerebrospinal fluid and meningeal barriers, is mostly excluded from the discussion. In this review we will shed light on some of the blood brain barrier hypotheses and try to trace their roots. In addition, we will suggest new research directions to allow for confirmation of alternative interpretations of the experimental evidence linking the pathology of intra-cerebral vasculature to the pathogenesis of neuropsychiatric lupus.

Changes in brain water and cerebral volume can lead to brain edema that may be one of the underlying causes of death in many neurological diseases. Cerebral water content is regulated by aquaporin 4 (AQ4) present in astrocytic end feet and around blood vessels. In systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) studies of the brain have demonstrated lesions with the prominent appearance of edema. Activation of complement may play a significant role in the pathogenesis of lupus cerebritis by causing inflammation that can lead to edema. In this study, the well-established MRL/lpr lupus mouse model was used to evaluate the role of complement in lupus cerebritis. IgG and C1q colocalized in perivascular deposits indicating that the blood–brain barrier was compromised. Both RNA and protein expressions of AQ4 were significantly increased in brains of MRL/lpr mice. Chronic administration of the soluble complement inhibitor, Crry-Ig, reduced inflammation as measured by decreased accumulation of IgG. In contrast to control MRL/lpr mice, AQ4 expression in complement inhibited MRL/lpr mice was not changed relative to untreated congenic controls. These results illustrate that complement activation in brains of lupus mice leads to enhanced AQ4 expression and inflammation. It is conceivable that increased AQ4 expression results in cerebral edema and hence complement inhibition may provide a new therapeutic option in inflammatory cerebral disorders such as lupus cerebritis.

Evidence is presented that the immune system can affect central nervous system functioning, leading to changes in learning. Immune complex disease is induced in rats and their behavior tested using a Lashley maze. Significant differences in behavior were found between the animals with high disease activity and those with low disease activity and the non-disease controls. These changes were not due to uremia and are most likely due to the immune response. There is some evidence immune complex deposits in the choroid plexus may play some role, but not the sole or major role in the behavioral changes. This provides a model by which immunologic processes can cause neuropsychiatric manifestations in autoimmune diseases like lupus, as well as showing that immune processes can affect behavioral functioning.