Trends in Ecology & Evolution
ReviewMeta-analysis: synthesizing research findings in ecology and evolution
Abstract
The growing number of empirical studies performed in ecology and evolution creates a need for quantitative summaries of research domains to generate higher-order conclusions about general trends and patterns. Recent developments In meta-analysis (the area of statistics that is designed for summarizing and analyzing multiple independent studies) have opened up new and exciting possibilities. Unlike more traditional qualitative and narrative reviews, meta-analysis allows powerful quantitative analyses of the magnitude of effects and has a high degree of objectivity because it is based on a standardized set of statistical procedures. The first pioneering applications in ecology and evolution demonstrate that meta-analysis is both tractable and powerful.
References (37)
- G. Cowlishaw et al.
Anim. Behav.
(1991) - F. Breden et al.
Trends Ecol. Evol.
(1994) - K.S. Shrader-Frechette et al.
Trends Ecol. Evol.
(1992) - R. Poulin
Anim. Behav.
(1994) - J. Gurevitch et al.
- J.E. Hunter et al.
Methods of Meta-Analysis
(1990) - L.V. Hedges et al.
Statistical Methods for Meta Analysis
(1985) - R. Rosenthal
Meta-Analytic Procedures for Social Research
(1991) - B. Mullen
Advanced BASIC Meta-Analysis
(1989)
Meta-Analysis in Social Research
BASIC Meta-Analysis: Procedures and Programs
Essentials of Behavioural Research: Methods and Data Analysis
Curr Bibliogr Med.
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
Science
Science
Cited by (444)
Factors influencing cadmium accumulation in plants after inoculation with rhizobacteria: A meta-analysis
2024, Science of the Total EnvironmentRhizobacteria have the potential to enhance phytoremediation by generating substances that stimulate plant development and influence the effectiveness of cadmium (Cd) remediation by adjusting Cd availability via metal solubilization. Furthermore, rhizobacterial inoculation affects plants' metal tolerance and uptake by controlling the expression of several metal transporters, channels, and metal chelator genes. A meta-analysis was conducted to quantitatively assess the effects of rhizobacteria on Cd accumulation in plants using 207 individual observations from 47 articles. This meta-analysis showed an average Cd concentration increase of 8.09 % in plant cells under rhizobacteria treatment. The effects of different plant-microbial interactions on the bioaccumulation of Cd in plants varied. Selecting the proper rhizobacteria-plant association is essential to affect Cd buildup in plant roots and shoots. A more extended planting period (>30 days) and a suitable soil pH (<6, 7–8) would aid in the phytoextraction of Cd from the soil. This study comprehensively and quantitatively investigated the effects of plants, rhizobacteria, soil pH, planting period, experimental sites, and plant organs on plant Cd accumulation. According to the analysis of explanatory factors, plant species, planting period, soil pH, and rhizobacteria species have a more decisive influence on Cd accumulation than other factors. The results provide information for future research on the successful remediation of soils contaminated with Cd. More investigations are required to elucidate the intricate interactions between plant roots and microorganisms.
A global assessment of the long-term effects of biochar application on crop yield
2024, Current Research in Environmental SustainabilityThe impact of biochar application on crop yield has always been a topic of concern. However, most current research focuses on the short-term effects of biochar on crop growth. Investigating the long-term effects of biochar in increasing crop yields is crucial for food security and sustainable agricultural development. To address this issue, this study performed a coupling of meta-analysis and structural equation model (SEM) based on the establishment of a dataset containing 981 sets of observations. The results demonstrated that biochar significantly and durably boosted crop yield, and biochar also has shown an average increase of 36.2% in SOC over a monitoring period exceeding 2 years. Crop yields increased by an average of 16% after biochar application for the long-term scale, although the increase varied across crop types, and biochar application performed better on corn and wheat than paddy rice production. It is noteworthy that the yield still increased by 15% on average after 6 years of biochar application. According to SEM, the yield increase was positively correlated with the application amount of biochar, and the yield increase was higher under low nitrogen (N) input than under high N input. The long-term yield-increasing effect of biochar was more attributable to its enhancement of SOC rather than its effects on soil bulk density and pH.
Climate Change: A bibliometric study of the Great Lakes Basin
2024, Journal of Great Lakes ResearchThe Great Lakes region of North America is experiencing climate-driven disturbances that threaten the safety and livelihoods of coastal communities and people. Limitations to the spatial and temporal coverage of research have the potential to hamper the ability to predict site-specific conditions and responses to climatic events. In this paper, we contextualize these spatial and temporal limitations of climate change research. Our summary reveals an uneven spatial distribution of research across the basin and publication outlets, with research focused on Lakes Superior, Michigan, and Huron, and the increasing availability of biological and ecological data to forecast future conditions. The spatial and temporal limitations related to historical data, region-wide monitoring efforts, research during the winter season, and the technological and methodological developments in natural resource management that can overcome these limitations are explored. Future research and emerging data needs are discussed, including the need for increased inclusion of the social sciences and improving relationships with Indigenous and First Nation communities in terms of research, data sharing, and governance.
New horizons for comparative studies and meta-analyses
2024, Trends in Ecology and EvolutionComparative analyses and meta-analyses are key tools to elucidate broad biological principles, yet the two approaches often appear different in purpose. We propose an integrated approach that can generate deeper insights into ecoevolutionary processes. Marrying comparative and meta-analytic approaches will allow for (i) a more accurate investigation of drivers of biological variation, (ii) a greater ability to account for sources of non-independence in experimental data, (iii) more effective control of publication bias, and (iv) improved transparency and reproducibility. Stronger integration of meta-analytic and comparative studies can also broaden the scope from species-centric investigations to community-level responses and function-valued traits (e.g., reaction norms). We illuminate commonalities, differences, and the transformative potential of combining these methodologies for advancing ecology and evolutionary biology.
The use of hairy vetch (Vicia villosa Roth.) as cover crop is increasing worldwide. Hairy vetch can contribute as a nitrogen (N) source with potential to impact subsequent high N demanding cereals such as maize (Zea mays L.). Contrasting literature results emphasize the need for a global synthesis analysis to quantify changes in maize yield after hairy vetch.
A meta-analysis was conducted to i) quantify maize yield response to hairy vetch as previous crop, ii) explore hairy vetch influence on fertilized and non-N fertilized maize yields, and iii) assess the tillage and environment factors on maize yield response to hairy vetch.
The global systematic search yielded 23 publications selected by the following criteria, i) hairy vetch dry matter at the end of the season, ii) maize grain yield, and iii) experimental design with (Mzhv) and without (Mzcontrol) hairy vetch treatments. Information such as N fertilization for maize, N accumulation in hairy vetch, organic matter, and tillage before maize sowing were recorded. Hairy vetch effects (effect size) were expressed as a ratio (percentage of grain yield variation in Mzhv/Mzcontrol).
Under non-N fertilization (n = 9), results revealed hairy vetch had mostly a positive effect, ranging from 13 to 45% (n = 6). In contrast, N-fertilized maize (n = 20) showed a high chance of neutral effects (n = 12), moderate probability of positive yield impact (7 to 38%, n = 6), and a low likelihood of negative effects (−32 and −17%, n = 2). Notably, maize yields improved by 21–25% when the N accumulation in hairy vetch ranged from 95 to 150 kg ha−1 and N rate from 0 to 120 kg ha−1. Non-N-fertilized maize exhibited a 14% increase in response in no-till systems and a 31% increase with conventional tillage.
This study summarizes potential benefits of hairy vetch preceding maize. Yet, the heterogeneous outcomes deserve further exploration in terms of environment and management factors.
Grazing management impacts on ecosystem services under contrasting climatic conditions in Texas and North Dakota
2023, Journal of Environmental ManagementGrazing management is an important factor affecting the delivery of ecosystem services at the watershed scale. Moreover, characterizing the impacts of climate variation on water resources is essential in managing rangelands. In this study, the effects of alternative grazing management scenarios on provisioning, regulating, and supporting services were assessed in two watersheds with contrasting climates; the Lower Prairie Dog Town Fork Red River (LPDTFR) Watershed in North Texas and the Apple Watershed in South Dakota. The impacts of heavy stocking continuous grazing, light stocking continuous grazing, Adaptive Multi-Paddock (AMP) grazing, and an ungrazed exclosure were compared using the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model. Our results indicate that the quantity of snow and timing of snow melt substantially influenced grazing management effects on ecosystem services in the Apple Watershed. In contrast, precipitation was the main factor influencing these effects in the LPDTFR Watershed because it highly affected the variation in water cycling, streamflow, sediment, and nutrient controls. Simulated results indicated that AMP grazing was the optimal grazing management approach for enhancing water conservation and ecosystem services in both watersheds regardless of climatic conditions. The Apple Watershed, which is a snow-dominated watershed, exhibited greater ecosystem service improvements under AMP grazing (50.6%, 58.7%, 74.4%, 61.5% and 72.6% reduction in surface runoff, streamflow, and sediment, total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) losses, respectively as compared to HC grazing) than the LPDTFR Watershed (46.0%, 22.8%, 34.1%, 18.9% and 38.4% reduction in surface runoff, streamflow, and sediment, TN and TP losses, respectively). Our results suggest that improved grazing management practices enhance ecosystem services and water catchment functions in rangeland-dominated areas, especially in colder climates.