Theory as mediating variables: Why aren't community interventions working as desired?

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1047-2797(97)80011-7Get rights and content

Purpose: This paper discusses the role of theory in explaining why recent community intervention trials for chronic disease prevention are not achieving the level of desired behavioral effects and related outcomes.

Method: Literature review and analysis are used to derive an explanation.

Results: All interventions (e.g., school nutrition education) effect change in behavioral outcomes (e.g., dietary behaviors) through mediating variables. Selected from the social and behavioral theories, these mediating variables can be environmental (e.g., increased availability of the targeted food) or intrapersonal (e.g., increased self-efficacy for eating the targeted foods). The percentage of variance of the outcome variables accounted for by the mediating variables has been modest to low. This places one limit on how much change interventions can achieve in outcomes. Another limit is imposed by the ability of the interventions to produce change in the mediating variables, which also has been weak.

Conclusions: More basic research should examine: (i) the relationships between mediating variables and behavior; and (ii) how interventions effect change in mediating variables. One possible six phase process for developing such research is described.

References (49)

  • HA Lando et al.

    Changes in adult cigarette smoking in the Minnesota Heart Health Program

    Am J Public Health

    (1995)
  • RV Luepker et al.

    Community education for cardiovascular disease prevention: Risk factor changes in the Minnesota Heart Health Program

    Am J Public Health

    (1994)
  • Community interventional trial for smoking cessation (COMMIT). 1. Cohort results from a four year community intervention

    Am J Public Health

    (1995)
  • Community interventional trial for smoking cessation (COMMIT). II. Changes in adult cigarette smoking prevalence

    Am J Public Health

    (1995)
  • RV Luepker et al.

    Outcomes of a field trial to improve children's dietary patterns and physical activity. The Child and Adolescent Trial for Cardiovascular Health (CATCH)

    JAMA

    (1996)
  • MA Winkleby et al.

    Joint analysis of three U.S. Community intervention trials for reduction of cardiovascular disease risk

    Am J Public Health

    (1997)
  • EBJ Fisher

    The results of the COMMIT Trial

    Am J Public Health

    (1995)
  • MA Winkleby

    The future of community-based cardiovascular disease intervention studies

    Am J Public Health

    (1994)
  • M Fishbein

    Great expectations, or do we ask too much from community level interventions

    Am J Public Health

    (1996)
  • Deleted in...
  • R Winett

    A framework for health promotion and disease prevention programs

    Am Psychol

    (1995)
  • WE Hansen et al.

    The law of maximum expected potential effect: constraints placed on program effectiveness by mediator relationships

    Health Education Research, Theory and Practice

    (1996)
  • DP MacKinnon et al.

    Estimating mediated effects in prevention studies

    Evaluation Review

    (1993)
  • RM Baron et al.

    The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations

    J Pers Soc Psychol

    (1986)
  • Cited by (251)

    • Identifying Behaviour Change Techniques and Motivational Interviewing Techniques in Small Steps for Big Changes: A Community-Based Program for Adults at Risk for Type 2 Diabetes

      2020, Canadian Journal of Diabetes
      Citation Excerpt :

      Our findings suggest that SSBC includes the delivery 43 BCTs and 20 MI techniques designed to promote long-term adherence to diet and exercise changes. Specifically, “Goals and Planning” (1), “Feedback and Monitoring” (2) and “Repetition and Substitution” (8) were the most frequently used BCT categories, whereas “Engaging” and “Evoking” were the most frequently used MI processes. This is unsurprising, as techniques within these categories are associated with increased effectiveness within physical activity and dietary interventions (26).

    • Change in behavioral exercise program-associated self-regulation enhances self-regulation-induced eating improvements across levels of obesity severity

      2019, Evaluation and Program Planning
      Citation Excerpt :

      Therefore, the persistent but spurious belief that educating individuals in those areas is the key to their success might be a major reason for the minimal progress in the area of sustained weight loss over many decades (MacLean et al., 2015). Even when theory-driven cognitive-behavioral programs were incorporated, researchers rarely decomposed their findings to determine what psychosocial correlates were associated with changes in exercise and eating behaviors, although that has been strongly recommended (Baranowski, Lin, Wetter, Resnicow, & Hearn, 1997; MacKinnon & Luecken, 2008). Only recently have sporadic research efforts begun to discern the “active ingredients” of positive change, and their interrelationships, in order to advance the architectures of programs (Teixeira et al., 2015).

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    1

    From the Department of Behavioral Science, Division of Cancer Prevention, University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas

    2

    From the Department of Biostatistics, Rollins School of Public Health of Emory University, Atlanta, GA

    3

    From the Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Georgia State University, Atlanta, GA.

    View full text