Understanding depressive rumination from a cognitive science perspective: The impaired disengagement hypothesis
Research highlights
►Rumination is a crucial cognitive risk factor for depression. ►Information-processing biases and impairments underlie ruminative tendencies. ►An impaired disengagement framework is proposed to understand the relation between information-processing, rumination, and depression.
Introduction
Persistent negative cognition is a hallmark of depression and anxiety that is assumed to play an important role in the etiology and maintenance of affective disorders (Clark et al., 1999, Watkins, 2008). Although engaging in prolonged and repetitive thinking about one's self in relation to the social environment, which could increase upon the encounter of stressful events or emotional states, is in essence a constructive and normative process, this process can become exaggerated and associated with detrimental effects in several forms of psychopathology (Watkins, 2008). In this article we focus on an important form of depressive cognition, rumination, and we propose a new theory based on information-processing and affective neuroscience research to account for heightened levels of rumination observed in depression. This new theory holds important implications with regard to strategies that can directly target the mechanisms underlying rumination.
It is important to mention that, at the outset, we clearly distinguish between cognitive processes and products, as proposed by Ingram, Miranda, and Segal (1998). Attentional control, as measured by experimental tasks, is considered a process influencing rumination as measured by questionnaires. Although definitions of rumination (as will be discussed in the later part) sometimes refer to rumination as “a process” of thinking, we regard rumination as a certain style of self-referential thinking. The negative cognitions associated with a ruminative thinking style are seen as cognitive products.
Cognitive theories have emphasized the role of negative cognitions in the etiology and maintenance of depression. According to Beck's influential cognitive theory (Beck, Rush, Shaw, & Emery, 1979), depression is characterized by presence of negative schemas, defined as mental representations of past experiences, containing dysfunctional attitudes about the self (Beck, 1967, Beck, 1995). These underlying schemas have an important influence on the way information is processed, guiding one's interpretation, attention and memory for personally relevant negative experiences (Clark et al., 1999). Activation of the schemas in confrontation with stressful life events and negative mood states leads to specific negative automatic thoughts including negative cognitions about the self, the world and the future (the so called negative cognitive triad, Beck, 1995). Negative cognitions, in turn, further maintain and exacerbate negative affect, leading to a vicious cognitive–affective circle with enhanced depressive symptoms (Teasdale, 1988, Watkins, 2008).
Although the negative content of depressive cognition is proposed to play an important role in the vulnerability for depression (Alloy et al., 2000, Clark et al., 1999), recent theoretical models highlight the importance of underlying cognitive processes that might be responsible for elevated and persistent negative cognition and affect (Joormann, Yoon, & Zetsche, 2007). Research has demonstrated that activation of negative cognitions or representations in working memory may not necessarily result in increased and prolonged negative affect. Instead, it is the ability to regulate negative affect that plays an instrumental role in determining which individuals are at risk to experience prolonged negative affect upon encounter of stress (Joormann et al., 2007). Regulation of negative mood however seems to be dependent upon the efficient exercise of working memory functions involved in the regulation of negative information. In a related manner, individual differences in the cognitive control functions are proposed to be related to a ruminative thinking style (Davis & Nolen-Hoeksema, 2000).
In recent years, rumination has been defined as “behaviors and thoughts that focus one's attention on one's depressive symptoms and on the implications of those symptoms” (Nolen-Hoeksema, 1991, p. 569). The response style theory of depression (Nolen-Hoeksema, 1991) proposes that individuals differ in their reaction to negative mood states and that rumination is a trait-like response style to distress. Individuals are engaged in depressive rumination because they believe that ruminating about their mood and symptoms will help to understand themselves better. However, rather than leading to increased self-understanding, depressive rumination augments sad mood and negative thinking by focusing attention on current mood (Lyubomirsky & Nolen-Hoeksema, 1995). Later, it was proposed that the harmful effects of rumination stem not from attention to distress per se, but from self-focused attention that is negative, evaluative and judgmental (Rude, Maestas, & Neff, 2007).
To assess individual differences in the tendency to ruminate, Nolen-Hoeksema and Morrow (1991) developed the Ruminative Response Scale (RRS). This scale has high internal consistency and acceptable convergent validity (Butler & Nolen-Hoeksema, 1994, Nolen-Hoeksema & Morrow, 1991). Various versions of this 22-item scale have been used in numerous studies over the years. Factor analyses of the RRS have identified two distinct subtypes of rumination (Treynor, Gonzalez, & Nolen-Hoeksema, 2003). The first, reflective pondering, is a more adaptive form of rumination and reflects the degree to which individuals engage in cognitive problem solving to improve their mood. The second, depressive brooding, is a more maladaptive form of rumination and reflects the degree to which individuals passively focus on symptoms of distress and the meaning of those symptoms. Both rumination scales involve focusing on distress, but the brooding scale contains more self-critical, evaluative, and judgmental statements (Rude et al., 2007). Depression is specifically characterized by high levels of brooding (Burwell & Shirk, 2007, Joormann et al., 2006, Treynor et al., 2003).
Rumination in response to negative mood increases vulnerability to depression. Experimental studies testing the effects of rumination have generally used the rumination induction procedure developed by Nolen-Hoeksema and Morrow (1993). This procedure increases ruminative thinking and has been shown to heighten and prolong negative mood and cognition in dysphorics (Morrow & Nolen-Hoeksema, 1990, Nolen-Hoeksema & Morrow, 1993) and in clinically depressed participants (Donaldson & Lam, 2004, Lavender & Watkins, 2004, Watkins & Moulds, 2005, Watkins & Teasdale, 2001). Induction of rumination also hampers problem solving and task performance (Watkins & Brown, 2002). In addition, numerous studies have demonstrated that rumination is associated concurrently with depressive symptoms (Treynor et al., 2003) and prospectively with the onset (Nolen-Hoeksema, 2000), severity (Just & Alloy, 1997, Nolen-Hoeksema & Morrow, 1991) and duration (Nolen-Hoeksema, 2000, Nolen-Hoeksema et al., 1993) of depression, and recovery from depression (Kuehner & Weber, 1999, Schmaling et al., 2002).
Section snippets
The impaired disengagement hypothesis
Despite marked progression in the understanding of the affective consequences of rumination, there is less clarity on the underlying mechanisms of rumination. We argue that information-processing factors play a crucial role in rumination. We will first outline a basic model of information-processing in rumination and will subsequently discuss the empirical evidence for each of its specific components.
Rumination and attentional control: clues from affective neuroscience
Depression is associated with hypoactivation in cortical structures involved in attentional control which can be related to impaired emotion regulation. There is a wealth of research showing an enhanced amygdala activity upon the encounter of stress in depression, with the amygdala being primarily implicated in processing of negative emotions. In a study by Siegle, Steinhauer, Thase, Stenger and Carter (2002) depressed individuals showed sustained amygdala responses to negative words that
Clinical implications
Conceptualizing rumination as being mainly driven by information-processing deficiencies has specific implications for clinical treatment of rumination. With regard to psychological treatments, traditional cognitive therapy for depression which is considered one of the most efficacious treatments for depression (Hollon & Dimidjian, 2009) would use verbal interventions that target negative thinking through challenging some of the core beliefs that are reported by the depressed individual. Other
Future challenges
The impaired disengagement hypothesis provides a useful framework for understanding the persistence of rumination in depression. At a broader level there is emerging cognitive as well as biological research pointing to the relevance of attentional factors in depression (De Raedt & Koster, 2010). Despite wealth of correlational data indicating the link between attentional control and rumination, an important area of investigation will be to test the directional hypothesis that attentional
Acknowledgements
Preparation of this paper was supported by Grant BOF10/GOA/014 for a Concerted Research Action of Ghent University (awarded to Rudi De Raedt and Ernst Koster) and a Royal Society Joint International Grant (awarded to Nazanin Derakhshan and Ernst Koster). Evi De Lissnyder, is funded as a Research Assistant of the Fund for Scientific Research-Flanders (FWO), Belgium. We are grateful to Tine Vervoort for her careful proofreading of the manuscript.
References (93)
- et al.
A controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in medication-resistant major depression
Biological Psychiatry
(2006) - et al.
Attentional bias training in depression: Therapeutic effects depend on depression severity
Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry
(2010) - et al.
Long-lasting effects of high frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in major depressed patients
Psychiatry Research
(2007) - et al.
Default-mode brain dysfunction in mental disorders: A systematic review
Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews
(2009) - et al.
Self-projection and the brain
Trends in Cognitive Science
(2007) - et al.
Cognitive and emotional influences in anterior cingulate cortex
Trends in Cognitive Sciences
(2000) - et al.
Attention and rumination in major depression
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(2007) - et al.
Deficient inhibition of emotional information in depression
Journal of Affective Disorders
(2006) - et al.
Resting-state functional connectivity in major depression: Abnormally increased contributions from subgenual cingulate cortex and thalamus
Biological Psychiatry
(2007) - et al.
Working memory, comprehension, and aging: A review and a new view
Adaptive and maladaptive components of rumination? Diagnostic specificity and relation to depressive biases
Behavior Therapy
Cognitive inhibition in depression
Applied and Preventive Psychology
The unity and diversity of executive functions and their contributions to complex “frontal lobe” tasks: A latent variable analysis
Cognitive Psychology
The neurobiology of emotion perception, I: towards an understanding of the neural basis of normal emotion perception
Biological Psychiatry
Can't shake that feeling: Assessment of sustained event-related fMRI amygdala activity in response to emotional information in depressed individuals
Biological Psychiatry
The interaction of attention and emotion
Neural Networks
Impairments in cognitive control persist during remission from depression and are related to the number of past episodes: An event related potentials study
Biological Psychology
Prefrontal-subcortical pathways mediating successful emotion regulation
Neuron
Positive beliefs about rumination in depression—A replication and extension
Personality and Individual Differences
The human amygdala and the emotional evaluation of sensory stimuli
Brain Research Reviews
The Temple-Wisconsin cognitive vulnerability to depression project: Lifetime history of axis I psychopathology in individuals at high and low cognitive risk for depression
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
The units of thought
Hippocampus
Depression: Causes and treatment
Cognitive therapy: Basics and beyond
Cognitive therapy for depression
The modification of attentional bias to emotional information: A review of the techniques, mechanisms, and relevance to emotional disorders
Cognitive Affective and Behavioral Neuroscience
Subtypes of rumination in adolescence: Associations between brooding, reflection, depressive symptoms, and coping
Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology
Gender differences in responses to depressed mood in a college sample
Sex Roles
On the self-regulation of behavior
Scientific foundations of cognitive theory and therapy for depression
Feeling is believing: Some affective influences on belief
Depression: Perspectives from affective neuroscience
Annual Review of Psychology
Cognitive inflexibility among ruminators and nonruminators
Cognitive Therapy and Research
The assocation between depressive symptoms and executive control impairments in response to emotional and non-emotional information
Cognition & Emotion
Understanding vulnerability for depression from a cognitive neuroscience perspective: a reappraisal of attentional factors and a new conceptual model
Cognitive Affective and Behavioral Neuroscience
Rumination, mood and social problem-solving in major depression
Psychological Medicine
Subthreshold depression in adolescence and mental health outcomes in adulthood
Archives of General Psychiatry
From childhood to adult age: 18-year longitudinal results and prediction of the course of mental disorders in the community
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
State sadness reduces neural sensitivity to nonrewards versus rewards
Neuroreport
Resting-state functional connectivity effects structural connectivity in the default mode network
Cerebral Cortex
Medial prefrontal cortex and selfreferential mental activity: Relation to a default mode of brain function
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Spatio-temporal dynamics of error processing dysfunctions in Major Depressive Disorder
Archives of General Psychiatry
Cognitive and behavioral treatment of depression
The neural mechanisms of topdown attentional control
Nature Neuroscience
Cited by (596)
Relationship between ruminative style and adolescent depression
2024, Asian Journal of PsychiatryImagine before you leap: Episodic future thinking combined with transcranial direct current stimulation training for impulsive choice in repetitive negative thinking
2024, International Journal of Clinical and Health PsychologyFrom tripping and falling to ruminating and worrying: a meta-control account of repetitive negative thinking
2024, Current Opinion in Behavioral SciencesA cognitive model of depression and political attitudes
2024, Electoral Studies