Review articleGlucose sensors: toward closed loop insulin delivery☆
Section snippets
Uses of continuous glucose monitoring
Continuous glucose monitoring could help avoid severe highs and lows (the alarm function), identify patterns in diabetic control, and, ultimately, control an insulin delivery system. The requirements for each role differ in detail, although in the end an accurate, precise, and robust sensor is the ideal.
Any sensor that can signal when blood glucose is too low or too high serves an obvious purpose. The set point to trigger high or low alarms could be programmed individually, and could include
Assessment of glucose sensors
Glucose sensors can be assessed quantitatively in terms of precision, accuracy, sensitivity, and stability. Among the important performance characteristics are calibration requirements, availability of results, longevity, and robustness. In vivo use is to be distinguished from in vitro, or factory operation. Accuracy assesses how close sensor results are to some “gold standard,” and can be expressed as mean error (eg, mg/dL) or relative error (% error). Precision is a different measure,
General approaches to continuous glucose monitoring
The general approaches to glucose-sensing technology are summarized in Table 1. Over 100 universities and companies are working on the subject to develop these technologies [24], none of which is yet either ready to drive an artificial pancreas or ideally suited to routine clinical use.
Sensors based on the enzyme glucose oxidase are the most reliable compared, for example, to spectroscopic or viscosity-based sensors, because glucose oxidase is specific for glucose. Most of the sensors under
Source of analyte measured
Although many fluid sources can be imagined (eg, tears, saliva, urine, cerebrospinal fluid), two locations are used commonly for measuring glucose: interstitial and intravascular. For continuous monitoring, the interstitial approach is the most popular because it is less invasive and less prone to triggering a clotting reaction. There are several ways to measure interstitial glucose: (1) inserting the glucose sensor into the subcutaneous tissues, either short- or long-term; (2) microdialysis
Clinically available subcutaneous glucose sensors
Regulatory approval and market availability of medical devices changes from month to month, but it is useful to consider which continuous glucose monitors are available, which may become available soon, and which are less certain or unlikely to be available for some years. There are three currently available glucose sensors.
Systems approaching clinical availability
The exact status of clinical availability changes from month to month. The authors describe the clinical availability of the systems as of this writing, but specific devices may move in (and out) of clinical availability quickly.
GluOnline
The GluOnline system is being developed by Disetronic Medical Systems (Burgdorf, Switzerland). It uses microdialysis to obtain interstitial fluid, but the analysis is coupled to a unique nonenzymatic glucose sensor referred to as the viscometric-affinity sensor. The working principle is that the viscosity of a liquid containing dextran and concanavalin A (ConA) is highly glucose-dependent [72]. Free glucose modulates the viscosity of this fluid by competing with dextran to bind at the
Implanted glucose sensors
Implanted glucose sensors would have the obvious advantage of requiring no transdermal fluid collection, and no risk for infection or irritation once the device is implanted. Because they involve an initial surgical procedure, they must function for much longer periods than is the case if they can be changed every few days, and because they cannot be removed as easily in the event of failure, they must be more robust.
Closing the loop: the artificial endocrine pancreas
Since insulin pump and sensor work began, the notion of a fully automated artificial pancreas has been the final goal. The basic elements of the closed loop artificial pancreas are not hard to imagine: a sensor, a delivery system, and programming to link the two. The delivery systems, external and implanted, have developed far more successfully over the past decades, but sensor technology is now moving forward quickly.
As with most advances in medicine, the closed-loop insulin delivery based on
Summary
Sensor-driven, closed-loop insulin delivery has been a long-term goal of many researchers. Delivery systems (insulin pumps), both external and implanted, are used widely and successfully, but the sensor component has been more difficult to bring to practical reality. Over the past few years, however, rapid progress has been made in glucose sensing. CGMS was the first continuous glucose monitor to be approved for use by the US Food and Drug Administration, and the GlucoWatch was the second. Each
References (102)
- et al.
A method for the estimation of sugar in small quantities of blood
J Biol Chem
(1915) - et al.
Home monitoring of blood-glucose. Method for improving diabetic control
Lancet
(1978) - et al.
Analytical performance of glucometers used for routine glucose self-monitoring of diabetic patients
Clin Chim Acta
(2003) - et al.
Wearable artificial endocrine pancrease with needle-type glucose sensor
Lancet
(1982) - et al.
In vivo evaluation of an electroenzymatic glucose sensor implanted in subcutaneous tissue
Biosens Bioelectron
(1992) - et al.
Clinical evaluation of the GlucoWatch biographer: a continual, non-invasive glucose monitor for patients with diabetes
Biosens Bioelectron
(2001) - et al.
Development of a potentially wearable glucose sensor for patients with diabetes mellitus: design and in-vitro evaluation
Biosens Bioelectron
(1990) - et al.
French multicentre experience of implantable insulin pumps. The EVADIAC Study Group. Evaluation of active implants in diabetes society
Lancet
(1994) The discovery of insulin
(1982)- et al.
Home blood glucose monitoring as an aid in diabetes management
Diabetes Care
(1978)
Self-monitoring of blood glucose
Diabetes Care
The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the development and progression of long-term complications in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus
N Engl J Med
Preventive-care practices among persons with diabetes—United States, 1995 and 2001
MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep
Electrode systems for continuous monitoring in cardiovascular surgery
Ann N Y Acad Sci
The enzyme electrode
Nature
Automation control of blood glucose: a servo mechanism for glucose monitoring and control
Am J Med Electron
An artificial endocrine pancreas
Diabetes
Clinical control of diabetes by the artificial pancreas
Diabetes
The artificial beta cell—a continuous control of blood sugar by external regulation of insulin infusion (glucose controlled insulin infusion system)
Horm Metab Res
The development of Biostator, a glucose controlled insulin infusion system (GCIIS)
Horm Metab Res
Teledyne Sleep Sentry: evaluation in pediatric patients for detection of nocturnal hypoglycemia
Diabetes Care
Metabolic and cutaneous events associated with hypoglycemia detected by sleep sentry
Diabetes Care
Guide for Measures of Precision and Accuracy
Anal Chem
Accuracy of perceiving blood glucose in IDDM
Diabetes Care
Evaluating clinical accuracy of systems for self-monitoring of blood glucose
Diabetes Care
Reservations on the use of error grid analysis for the validation of blood glucose assays
Diabetes Care
Understanding error grid analysis
Diabetes Care
Validation of home blood glucose meters with respect to clinical and analytical approaches
Diabetes Care
Optical glucose sensing in biological fluids: an overview
J Biomed Opt
Progress toward a potentially implantable, enzyme-based glucose sensor
Diabetes Care
Evaluation of a subcutaneous glucose sensor out to 3 months in a dog model
Diabetes Care
Development of the implantable glucose sensor. What are the prospects and why is it taking so long?
Diabetes
A subcutaneous glucose sensor with improved longevity, dynamic range, and stability of calibration
Diabetes Care
Advances and prospects in glucose assay technology
Diabetologia
Implanted electrochemical glucose sensors for the management of diabetes
Annu Rev Biomed Eng
Whole body glucose metabolism
Am J Physiol
Subcutaneous glucose predicts plasma glucose independent of insulin: implications for continuous monitoring
Am J Physiol
The MiniMed Continuous Glucose Monitoring System (CGMS)
J Pediatr Endocrinol Metab
Efficacy and reliability of the continuous glucose monitoring system
Diabetes Technol Ther
Continuous glucose monitoring in previously unstudied population subgroups
Diabetes Technol Ther
Continuous subcutaneous glucose monitoring improved metabolic control in pediatric patients with type 1 diabetes: a controlled crossover study
Pediatrics
Continuous subcutaneous glucose monitoring in children with type 1 diabetes
Pediatrics
The continuous glucose monitoring system is useful for detecting unrecognized hypoglycemias in patients with type 1 and type 2 diabetes but is not better than frequent capillary glucose measurements for improving metabolic control
Diabetes Care
Therapy adjustments based on CGMS data lower HbA1c with less hypoglycemia than blood glucose meter data alone
Diabetes
Reproducibility of glucose measurements using the glucose sensor
Diabetes Care
Spurious reporting of nocturnal hypoglycemia by CGMS in patients with tightly controlled type 1 diabetes
Diabetes Care
Improved performance of the Metronic MiniMed CGMS using redesigned glucose sensors and updated calibration software
Diabetes
Reproducibility of the continuous glucose monitoring system matches previous reports and the intended use of the product
Diabetes Care
Clinical performance of CGMS in type 1 diabetic patients treated by continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion using insulin analogs
Diabetes Care
A pilot study of the continuous glucose monitoring system: clinical decisions and glycemic control after its use in pediatric type 1 diabetic subjects
Diabetes Care
Cited by (34)
Optimization of insulin pump therapy based on high order run-to-run control scheme
2015, Computer Methods and Programs in BiomedicineCitation Excerpt :On the other hand, finger stick is widely used in previous years and it can only provide sparse glucose measurements for therapy optimization. While over the recent years, there are significant improvements on the continuous glucose monitoring system (CGMS), which has successfully been applied in clinical practice [24–27]. Correspondingly, blood glucose prediction is a hot topic in the related field [28,29].
A near infrared holographic glucose sensor
2015, Biosensors and BioelectronicsCitation Excerpt :Theoretical models for continuous glucose monitoring predict a 5-year increase in a patient's lifespan, 8 more years of sight and 6 years free from kidney disease and amputations, with a decrease in excess mortality for diabetic patients (Brimelow, 2013; Vaddiraju et al., 2010). A real-time glucose sensor will offer a more descriptive and accurate map of metabolic changes that will assist the clinician in prescribing a more reliable and precise insulin administration regime, a schematic proposal of patient's lifestyle and choices for maintaining their blood glucose concentration (Chia and Saudek, 2004; Michael and Boyne et al., 2003). In addition, implementing access to healthcare information via remote mobile devices (smart phones) allows a discrete, confidential and immediate communication between the patient and the clinician irrespective of location (Dimitrov, 2013).
DeSyRe: On-demand system reliability
2013, Microprocessors and MicrosystemsCitation Excerpt :As shown in Fig. 23(a), the current system contains a module for processing sensory data and calculating the insulin dose, and a module for data logging that includes compression, encryption and checksuming. In developing this application, we adopt the latest achievements in artificial-pancreas research [21,12,13], while improving on the state of the art by providing highly defect-tolerant devices, suitable for chronic implantation. The encrypted data logging feature is a further innovation in our system.
Roadmap to the artificial pancreas
2006, Diabetes Research and Clinical PracticeTowards an artificial pancreas: Software architectural model and implementation for personalized insulin administration
2019, Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System SciencesA review on B-type natriuretic peptide monitoring: assays and biosensors
2016, Heart Failure Reviews
- ☆
This work was supported by National Institute of Health grant R01 DK55132 and General Clinical Research Center grant RR00051.
Dr. Saudek is on the Medical Advisory Board for DexCom, Inc., the advisory panel for Cygnus, Inc., and has received research support from Medtronic MiniMed, Inc.