Elsevier

Health Policy

Volume 123, Issue 2, February 2019, Pages 140-151
Health Policy

HTA programme response to the challenges of dealing with orphan medicinal products: Process evaluation in selected European countries

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.healthpol.2017.03.009Get rights and content
Under a Creative Commons license
open access

Highlights

  • OMPs are often cost-ineffective and their value is characterised by greater uncertainty.

  • New EU/national HTA programmes for (ultra-)OMPs aim to overcome these challenges.

  • These programmes are stand-alone or supplementary to standard HTA/payer processes.

  • Wider considerations from patients and clinicians contribute to understanding value of OMPs.

  • Cross-border collaboration is essential to deliver OMPs that demonstrate value for money.

Abstract

Background

Challenges commonly encountered in HTA of orphan medicinal products (OMPs) were identified in Advance-HTA. Since then, new initiatives have been developed to specifically address issues related to HTA of OMPs.

Objective and methods

This study aimed to understand why these new HTA initiatives in England, Scotland and at European-level were established and whether they resolve the challenges of OMPs. The work of Advance-HTA was updated with a literature review and a conceptual framework of clinical, regulatory and economic challenges for OMPs was developed. The new HTA programmes were critiqued against the conceptual framework and outstanding challenges identified.

Results

The new programmes in England and Scotland recognise the challenges identified in demonstrating the value of ultra-OMPs (and OMPs) and that they require a different process to standard HTA approaches. Wider considerations of disease and treatment experiences from a multi-stakeholder standpoint are needed, combined with other measures to deal with uncertainty (e.g. managed entry agreements). While approaches to assessing this new view of value of OMPs, extending beyond cost/QALY frameworks, differ, their criteria are similar. These are complemented by a European initiative that fosters multi-stakeholder dialogue and consensus about value determinants throughout the life-cycle of an OMP.

Conclusion

New HTA programmes specific to OMPs have been developed but questions remain about whether they sufficiently capture value and manage uncertainty in clinical practice.

Keywords

Rare diseases
Technology assessment
Value of life
England
Scotland
Europe
Uncertainty

Cited by (0)