The effect of Helicopter Emergency Medical Services on trauma patient mortality in the Netherlands
Introduction
In the Netherlands, all emergency medical services (EMS) are staffed by paramedics who have years of clinical experience and education (e.g., in intensive care or emergency medicine), supplemented with three additional years of specific ambulance training. All paramedics are Pre-Hospital Trauma Life Support (PHTLS) certified. Since 1997, in addition to the EMS, Helicopter Emergency Medical Services (HEMS) have been available to provide on-scene assistance to trauma patients. The aim of the HEMS is to provide an on-demand upgrade to standard care at the scene to improve the outcome of severely injured patients. The HEMS is always staffed by a specially trained anaesthesiologist or trauma surgeon and nurse. HEMS is called in by the same EMS dispatcher who dispatched the EMS to the scene, based on criteria like suspicion of high energetic trauma, entrapment and drowning or secondary criteria based EMS on-scene observations of patient conditions.1 The dispatch of the HEMS is not related to distance because of the relatively short distances to hospitals in the Netherlands.2 The specific dispatch criteria approved by the Ministry of Health are shown in Table 1.1 Patients are transported to a hospital predominantly by ambulance. Currently, there are four HEMS (in Groningen, Amsterdam, Rotterdam, Nijmegen) that can reach about 75% of the Dutch population within 13 min of dispatch.1, 3
The St. Elisabeth Hospital in Tilburg is a level I trauma centre in the middle of Noord-Brabant county. The hospital serves an area of 5082 km2 and 2.4 million inhabitants.4 The hospital does not have its own HEMS. The hospital is served by the HEMS of Nijmegen and Rotterdam, which are just outside the county borders. In Noord-Brabant, five teaching and seven non-teaching hospitals are capable of resolving acute problems concerning airway, breathing and life-threatening haemorrhaging. All of these hospitals can be reached within 15 min by ambulance from anywhere in the county. The St. Elisabeth Hospital has a large neurosurgical unit. Patients with severe head injury are either taken directly from the scene to the unit or are secondarily transferred from a primary hospital after stabilisation. Because of the flat Dutch topography, short distances and a high hospital density, the EMS dispatcher does not have much difficultly in sending EMS for “scoop and run” of patients without dispatch of the HEMS.
The main goal of the introduction of the HEMS in 1997 was to improve the survival chances of severely injured patients. However, the value of the HEMS is still a subject of discussion, and scientific evidence to support the benefits of the HEMS in the Netherlands is still scarce. In addition, the role of time from trauma until definitive diagnosis and medical treatment in the survival of severely injured patients remains unclear in prehospital care.2, 5, 6, 7 In the present study, the assumption that treatment by the on-scene HEMS decreases the mortality of trauma patients was investigated. Also, the effect of time between trauma and hospital treatment on the association between treatment by HEMS and mortality was studied.
Section snippets
Trauma registry and study population
In the Netherlands, both immediately admitted trauma patients and secondary referrals are registered in a prospective, comprehensive nationwide registry. Trauma victims who are dead on arrival or who die in the emergency department of a hospital are also included. The validated Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS-90, update 98)8, 9 is used to define the severity of separate injuries and forms the basis of the ISS that assesses overall trauma severity. To compute the ISS, each of six anatomical
Results
The mean age of the study population (n = 372) was 37.8 with a standard deviation (SD) of 20.3 years, and 25% (n = 93) were female. The mean ISS was 22.7 (SD 14.2), and 43% of patients (n = 158) suffered TBI.
Table 2 shows the differences between patients treated by EMS only and patients treated by EMS and HEMS categorised by whether or not the patient suffered TBI. The ISS of the patients with TBI and treated by EMS only was not significantly lower (30.8, SD 11.6) than the ISS of the patients treated
Discussion
In the present study, the value of a HEMS, staffed by a trained and experienced anaesthesiologist or surgeon, added to the regular EMS by ambulance, staffed by highly trained and experienced paramedics, in improving mortality outcomes for trauma victims in the Netherlands was investigated. A group of patients treated by the EMS with the assistance of the HEMS was compared to a matched group of patients treated by the EMS only. The patients were matched by ISS, age, gender, mechanism of trauma
Conclusions
Our results cannot prove the benefit of the HEMS in the Netherlands and suggest in particular for TBI patients that prehospital times should be shortened to decrease in-hospital mortality.
Conflict of interest statement
There are no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgment
We thank the regional EMS services for providing access to their registration systems.
References (29)
- et al.
Physician-staffed HEMS dispatch in the Netherlands: adequate deployment or minimal utilization?
Air Med J
(2005) - et al.
AIS 2005 a contemporary injury scale
Injury
(2006) - et al.
Level of prehospital care and risk of mortality in patients with and without severe blunt head injury
Injury
(2003) - et al.
Out-of-hospital endotracheal intubation in traumatic brain injury: outcomes research provides us with an unexpected outcome
Ann Emerg Med
(2004) - et al.
Out-of-hospital rapid sequence intubation: are we helping or hurting our patients?
Ann Emerg Med
(2003) - et al.
Lives saved by helicopter emergency medical services: an overview of literature
Air Med J
(2009) - et al.
Evaluation of trauma care by comparing mortality risks and admission policy in a Dutch trauma region
Injury
(2008) - et al.
Prehospital interventions: time wasted or time saved? An observational cohort study of management in initial trauma care
Emerg Med J
(2008) - et al.
Helicopter-Mobile Medical Teams in The Netherlands: significant differences in deployment frequencies between different emergency room regions
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd
(2008) - Kerncijfers Provinciemonitor 2010. Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek; 2011. Available from:...
Emergency medical services intervals and survival in trauma: assessment of the “golden hour” in a North American prospective cohort
Ann Emerg Med
The golden hour: scientific fact or medical “urban legend”?
Acad Emerg Med
Helicopter emergency medical services (HEMS): impact on on-scene times
J Trauma
Committee on injury scaling: the abbreviated injury scale 1990 revision, update 1998
Cited by (43)
Characteristics of fatal penetrating injury; data from a retrospective cohort study in three urban regions in the Netherlands
2023, InjuryCitation Excerpt :HEMS are available in the Netherlands since the late 1990′s to provide high level of care at the scene, performing surgical procedures such as thoracocentesis and resuscitative thoracotomy to improve outcome and reduce mortality of the severely injured patient [17]. Survival benefits have been reported in several Dutch studies [17–19]. MOI was divided into stab- and gunshot injuries.
The Impact of Prehospital Transport Mode on Mortality of Penetrating Trauma Patients
2020, Air Medical JournalCitation Excerpt :However, most studies were limited by residual confounders, were not performed at a national level, did not compare more than 2 modes of transport, had a mixture of penetrating and blunt trauma, or had a limited number of subjects. A number of studies performed either at a single center with a lower total number of patients or accounting for a limited number of covariates, concluded that there was no significant difference in mortality between the various modes of transport.9-15 On the other hand, several studies proved that HEMS was associated with a survival benefit compared with other ground ambulances.16-20
Hospital Mortality Based on the Mode of Emergency Medical Services Transportation
2017, Air Medical JournalPrehospital Glasgow Coma Score Predicts Emergent Intervention following Helicopter Transfer for Spontaneous Subarachnoid Hemorrhage
2016, World NeurosurgeryCitation Excerpt :Of the nonrandomized studies that have been done, most have focused on traumatic injury and direct scene calls, in particular. Although some studies have demonstrated that helicopter transport is associated with improved outcomes,3-6 others have concluded that there is not a significant clinical benefit and that this resource is substantially overused.7-11 A Cochrane review stated that the benefit of HEMS could not be determined for adults with major trauma.12
Risk factors and mortality associated with undertriage after major trauma in a physician-led prehospital system: a retrospective multicentre cohort study
2023, European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery