Original CommunicationNo cash no whiplash?: Influence of the legal system on the incidence of whiplash injury☆
Section snippets
1. Introduction
In countries of Roman or French influence the assessment of bodily damage in civil law and the juridical implications form one of the main working areas of the forensic medicine specialist.1 Whiplash injuries, where the diagnosis is largely subjective and the ideal treatment controversial, have provided a continuous source of controversy due to their association with compensatory litigation claims secondary to motor vehicle accidents.2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 We have studied the incidence of whiplash
2. Material and methods
Over a three-year period from 2000 to 2002 inclusive, we studied 10,608 patients injured in traffic accidents in the areas within the mandates of the Institute of Legal Medicine of the University of Santiago de Compostela, (G-Spain) and the National Institute of Legal Medicine, Coimbra and Porto delegations, (NC-Portugal).
This enabled us to take into account those accidents in which the judicial and compensatory processes had concluded. Only patients with an initial diagnosis of whiplash injury
3. Results
We studied 8796 patients from NC-Portugal and 1812 from G-Spain. Of these, 162 in G-Spain were patients initially diagnosed with WAD as the sole pathology, whereas in NC-Portugal the corresponding number was only 35. We found a statistically significant difference between Spain and Portugal in the incidence of WAD, which was much greater in Spain (odds ratio: 24.57). Although the mean age differs between the groups (32.17 in G-Spain and 42.6 for NC-Portugal) no significant relationship between
4. Discussion
A significant difference in the recovery time between sexes was noted in both groups and is similar to that reported by Pearce 8 and Evans.9
Despite the socio-economic and road traffic similarities, there is a much greater incidence of WAD in Galicia than in North-Central Portugal. The odds ratio we found is impressive (24.57), and is particularly noticeable in the much longer period of recovery time taken in Spain. In addition, for group G-Spain, in cases with an identical initial diagnosis of
References (11)
Some observations on whiplash injuries
Neuro Clin
(1992)Assessment of bodily damage in civil law: harmonisation of an expert protocol
Rev Port Dano Corp
(2003)- et al.
Whiplash: fact or fiction?
Am J Orthop
(2005) - et al.
Scientific monograph of the Quebec task force on whiplash-associated disorders: redefining “whiplash” and its management
Spine
(1995) - et al.
Biomechanic analysis in whiplash injuries
Forensic Sci Int
(2003)
Cited by (18)
Temporomandibular joint trauma and disability assessment - A longitudinal exploratory study
2021, Journal of Forensic and Legal MedicineCitation Excerpt :This mechanism, responsible for the transmission of energy to the neck, can damage hard and soft tissues which can give rise to a variety of clinical manifestations such as pain and dysfunction.38,42–44 Nonetheless, some authors emphasize that a non-liability for the road accident, consequence of a judicial-decision, can be responsible for TMJ injury.45 Regarding professional status and age range analysis, despite the fact that there is no statistically association between TMJ injury or TMJ sequela and professional status (p = 0.748 and p = 0.236, respectively), the majority of the individuals had no active profession at the time of the event (Grade = 0), which can be related to social and economic position in society.
Video-nystagmographic evidence in more than 700 consecutive cases of road traffic whiplash injury
2021, American Journal of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Medicine and SurgeryCitation Excerpt :The whiplash syndrome is a well-known disorder that is easily prone to pretense, since the damage assessment and quantification could be mainly led by the subjective symptoms complained of by the person concerned, which are difficult to objectify, especially in the absence of a neuro-otological expert and appropriate instrumental investigations [11]. As a consequence of this evaluative attitude devoid of instrumental evidence, the very nosographic existence of whiplash disorder is questioned and sometimes referred to as an evanescent medical-legal illusion [12–14]. The Quebec Task Force [6] defined late whiplash syndrome as the presence of pain, restriction of motion or other symptoms six months or more after a whiplash injury, sufficient to hinder a return to normal activities such as driving, leisure pursuits and usual occupation.
Chronic neck pain patients with traumatic or non-traumatic onset: Differences in characteristics. A cross-sectional study
2017, Scandinavian Journal of PainCitation Excerpt :Some former studies have shown that the presentation of several symptoms may be dependent upon the onset being traumatic or non-traumatic: sensory alterations [15,20], sensorimotor function [21], morphological changes [22], and specific psychological factors [23–25]; other studies have not found such group differences [26–28]. Furthermore, whiplash is a controversial diagnosis [29–32]. As a consequence, in a recent report from Canada, the term ‘Whiplash’ in Whiplash Associated Disorders (WAD) was replaced with ‘Neck’ (Neck and Associated Disorders-NAD) [33].
The importance of the impact biomechanics on the assessment of whiplash injury
2016, Revista Espanola de Medicina LegalFunctional capacity evaluation: Does it change the determination of the degree of work disability?
2015, Disability and Health JournalDelayed recovery in patients with whiplash-associated disorders
2012, InjuryCitation Excerpt :Accumulating evidence suggests that WADs are not only a medical issue but also a condition that is influenced by external non-injury related factors. Numerous factors have been investigated for their influence on prognosis, including physical and psychosocial,3,4 system of compensation/litigation,1,5–8 and social/demographic factors.9 This increasingly substantial body of research has created considerable controversy, with few healthcare issues receiving more emotionally laden attention.
- ☆
Partially supported by Grant 2006/CI194 from the University of Santiago de Compostela (USC).