Elsevier

Journal of Voice

Volume 31, Issue 1, January 2017, Pages 120.e9-120.e13
Journal of Voice

Treatment Efficacy of Voice Therapy for Vocal Fold Polyps and Factors Predictive of Its Efficacy

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvoice.2016.02.014Get rights and content

Summary

Objectives

Vocal fold polyps can be treated with either surgical resection or conservative therapy based on voice therapy. This study was designed to analyze the success rate of voice therapy and identify factors that are predictive of the response to this treatment for vocal fold polyps.

Methods

This was a retrospective cohort study of 92 consecutive patients who were diagnosed with vocal fold polyp(s) and received voice therapy. We divided the patients into responding and non-responding groups. We analyzed clinical and voice parameters related to the voice results.

Results

After voice therapy, 40 patients showed improved findings and did not undergo surgical treatment. By univariate analysis, female patients (54.9%) and small polyps (56.1%) showed a good response to voice therapy. In multivariate analysis, female sex (odds ratio [OR] = 0.34; confidence interval [CI]: 0.14–0.81, P = 0.01) and small size (OR = 0.15; CI: 0.05–0.47, P <0.01) were significantly related to a successful voice response. In small polyps, the sessile type of polyp was found to be related to a good response rate (OR = 0.24; CI: 0.11–0.95, P = 0.04).

Conclusions

Voice therapy is more effective for small vocal polyps, particularly the sessile type, in female patients.

Introduction

A vocal fold polyp is usually a unilateral lesion occurring on the vocal folds and is a common benign laryngeal lesion. Phonotrauma disrupts the microstructure in the superficial layer of the lamina propria (Reinke's space). This trauma induces local edema, which contributes to subsequent formation of hyalinized stroma, vocal fold polyps, or nodules.1 Repeated injuries to the true vocal fold induce permanent changes and disturbances in the mucosal vibration, and closure of the vocal fold induces voice changes, hoarseness, and increased vocal effort.2 Vocal fold polyps can be observed in various forms, such as sessile versus pedunculated types, and hemorrhagic versus non-hemorrhagic types.3 These distinct features are likely to attribute to different stages or etiologies of polyp formation.

Whereas the preferred treatment for vocal fold nodules involves a conservative management approach, vocal fold polyps are treated with either surgical or non-surgical therapies.4, 5 Traditionally, surgical therapy, such as resection under the guidance of a laryngomicroscope with mucosa preservation, has been preferred with expected spontaneous healing.5, 6 Voice therapy or vocal hygiene education plays an adjunctive role after surgery. Surgery as a treatment modality has the associated risks of general anesthesia and voice aggravation induced by scar formation following surgery. However, current studies have proposed conservative treatments, including voice therapy and vocal hygiene, as acceptable alternative definite therapies to improve voice outcome.7 Although conservative management has a longer duration than surgical treatment and may require guidance from a speech language pathologist, the avoidance of invasive surgical treatment may override those limitations.

Definitive treatment guidelines for choosing surgery or conservative management for the treatment of vocal fold polyps have not yet been established. Vocal polyps of a small size, with hemorrhagic features, and occurring in females show a better response to voice therapy or vocal hygiene education.4, 8, 9 It is necessary to find predicting factors related to effective response to voice therapy when deciding treatment modality for vocal fold polyps. Here, this study was designed to analyze the success rate of voice therapy and determining factors for response to voice therapy for vocal fold polyps.

Section snippets

Participants

We performed a retrospective cohort study of consecutive patients who underwent voice therapy from January 2012 to December 2013 at Asan Medical Center, Seoul, Korea. This study was approved by our Institutional Review Board. Ninety-two patients over 18 years old and diagnosed with vocal fold polyp(s) upon videostroboscopy were enrolled for voice therapy. Patients with history of previous treatment (either surgical or non-surgical therapy), other types of accompanying organic lesions, missing

Results

The age range of the subjects (41 males and 51 females) was 22–72 years, with an average age of 51. After voice therapy, 40 patients showed polyp shrinkage more than 50% and did not undergo surgical treatment, whereas 52 patients showed no significant change and 41 patients of them (78.8%) underwent laryngomicroscopic surgery. By univariate analysis, female patients (n = 28, 54.9%) presented a good response to voice therapy compared with male patients (n = 12, 29.3%, P = 0.01; Table 1). Age and

Discussion

This study evaluated the efficacy of voice therapy for vocal fold polyp. Our protocol for vocal fold polyp prefers voice therapy for vocal fold polyp as an initial approach to avoid unnecessary surgical resection.11 In our present study, 40 of the enrolled patients (43.8 %) improved after they received voice therapy. Patients with small polyps and female patients showed the most effective response to voice therapy. Among our cases of small polyps, the sessile type rather than the pedunculated

Conclusions

Voice therapy is a feasible treatment approach for a vocal fold polyp. Female patients and small vocal fold polyps are positive indicators for voice therapy. In small-sized polyps, in particular, the sessile type responds to voice therapy more frequently compared with the pedunculated type. These factors should be considered when choosing a treatment modality for a vocal fold polyp, and the findings of our current study may help such patients to avoid unnecessary surgical resection and instead

Acknowledgment

This study was supported by a grant (2014-620) from the Asan Institute for Life Sciences, Asan Medical Center, Seoul, Korea.

References (20)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (40)

  • Effectiveness and Feasibility of Telepractice on Voice Therapy for Female Teachers in Elementary Schools with Self-Reported Voice Disorders

    2024, Journal of Voice
    Citation Excerpt :

    The survey conducted by Fu et al. (2016) on 47,796 kindergarten, elementary and middle school teachers in Tianjin found that the overall prevalence of throat disease and voice disorders among teachers in Tianjin was 33.81%.13 Although traditional face-to-face voice therapy has been proven to be an effective treatment method for voice disorders,4,5,14-21 reduced compliance has been a major challenge due to the travel distance and scheduling difficulties.22,23 In addition, the COVID-19 pandemic requires social distancing between people, and face masks also make the face-to-face treatment difficult to implement.

  • Spontaneous Vocal Fold Polyps Remission after Lockdown for Covid-19 Pandemic: Does Vocal Load Matter?

    2023, Journal of Voice
    Citation Excerpt :

    The patients with nearly complete remission were the ones with the most severe lesions: the haemorrhagic sessile polyp was associated with a recent subepithelial diffuse right vocal fold haemorrhage, while the pedunculated gelatinous polyp was associated with an haemorrhagic contralateral lesion (Figure 1). The results of the present case series confirm the findings of Nakawa,14 Jeong19 and Lee,28 as all the patients involved in the study were females, with small sized VFPs and a short duration of symptoms. These aspects should be taken into account in clinical practice, in order to consider conservative approaches for VFPs that are more likely to regress spontaneously or with conservative approaches.

View all citing articles on Scopus

Conflict of interest: The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

1

These authors contributed to this article equally.

View full text