Review articleReading skills in children with Down syndrome: A meta-analytic review
Highlights
► A meta-analysis of reading skills in children with Down syndrome is presented. ► We examine the reading profile of children with Down syndrome. ► A control group of typically developing children matched for level of word recognition is included. ► The groups had similar level of nonword reading skills. ► Vocabulary, but not phonological awareness is reliably predictors of reading skills.
Section snippets
Reading skills in children with Down syndrome: A meta-analytic review
Learning to read is critical for educational success and effective independent living. There are limited data on reading abilities among children with Down syndrome, and the present study is the first meta-analytic review to investigate reading skills in children with this diagnosis. The aim of the review is to examine the profile of reading skills in children with Down syndrome by looking at strengths and weaknesses compared with those of typically developing children matched on word
Inclusion criteria
We used the following criteria to select studies for inclusion in the meta-analysis:
- 1.
We only included studies that compare children and adolescents with Down syndrome to typically developing children matched on level of word recognition. Thus, we excluded studies using a reading comprehension measure or a mix of nonword decoding and word recognition as the initial matching variable.
- 2.
Children and adolescents with Down syndrome had to be monolingual and had no additional specified diagnosis.
Results
The searches yielded a total of 781 publications, and the final set of unique studies after excluding duplicates was 434. All abstracts were reviewed according to the inclusion criteria and, finally, after coding all the data and removing duplicates, a total of eight papers met the criteria for inclusion. Characteristics of the included studies are presented in Table A1 in the Appendix.
The main reason for excluding an empirical study was that the study did not include a comparison group of
Discussion
The purpose of this meta-analytic review was to examine the profile of reading skills in children with Down syndrome by comparing nonword decoding skills in this group with those seen in typically developing children with the same level of word recognition ability. A secondary aim was to examine the role of vocabulary and phonological awareness as predictors of variance in learning to read. There were no significant differences in nonword decoding skills between the two groups (g = −0.63).
Summary and conclusions
The results of the present meta-analysis are generally in line with earlier research suggesting that decoding skills are a relative strength in children with Down syndrome, and adding that the limited number of studies in this area means that more research is needed. The role of vocabulary knowledge in learning to decode words has also been highlighted. Children with Down syndrome perform in line with typically developing children at the same word recognition level on measures of nonword
References1 (45)
Discussion: Learning to read in absence of phonological awareness? A comment on Cossu, Rossini and Marshall (1993)
Cognition
(1993)- et al.
When reading is acquired but phonemic awareness is not: A study of literacy in Down's syndrome
Cognition
(1993) - et al.
Phonological awareness of children with Down syndrome: Its role in learning to read and the effectiveness of related interventions
Research in Developmental Disabilities
(2010) - et al.
What lesson for dyslexia from Down's syndrome? Comments on Cossu, Rossini and Marshall (1993)
Cognition
(1993) - et al.
The early reading skills in preschoolers with Down syndrome and their typically developing peers. Findings from recent research
Down Syndrome News and Update
(2002) - et al.
Threat-related attentional bias in anxious and nonanxious individuals: A meta-analytic study
Psychological Bulletin
(2007) Reading skills in Down syndrome
(2005)Vocabulary development and instruction: A prerequisite for school learning
- et al.
A study of functional literacy skills in young adults with Down syndrome
International Journal of Disability, Development and Education
(2001) - et al.
Comprehensive meta-analysis version 2 (software)
(2005)
Introduction to meta-analysis
Literacy skills in children and adolescents with Down syndrome
Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal
Reading, language, and memory skills: A comparative longitudinal study of children with Down syndrome and their mainstream peers
British Journal of Educational Psychology
Can individuals with Down syndrome acquire alphabetic literacy skills in the absence of phoneme awareness?
Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal
Is sensitivity to rhyme a developmental precursor to sensitivity to phoneme? Evidence from individuals with Down syndrome
Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal
Component reading skills in children with Down syndrome
Reading and Writing
Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences
Early reading acquisition and its relation to reading experience and ability ten years later
Developmental Psychology
Phonological awareness and oral reading skill in children with Down syndrome
Journal of Speech Language and Hearing Research
Trim and fill: A simple funnel plot based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis
Biometrics
The impact of vocabulary instruction on passage-level comprehension of school-age children: A meta-analysis
Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness
Cited by (50)
Reading for comprehension: the contribution of decoding, linguistic and cognitive skills
2019, International Review of Research in Developmental DisabilitiesCitation Excerpt :Furthermore, group comparisons revealed that individuals with Down's syndrome differed from typically developing children having the same level of reading comprehension because they were more advanced in word reading and less advanced in listening comprehension. A striking result is that the less advanced ability, namely listening comprehension, is more strongly related to reading comprehension, rather than the more advanced ability, namely word recognition (Gombert, 2002; Groen, Laws, Nation, & Bishop, 2006; Naess, Melby-Lervag, Hulme and Halaas Lyster, 2011; Verucci, Menghini, & Vicari, 2006). A substantial influence of poor listening on reading comprehension could, at least in part, explain why reading comprehension lags behind word recognition.
Speech disfluencies in children with Down Syndrome
2018, Journal of Communication DisordersCitation Excerpt :This instrument consists of 3 components, i.e. frequency, duration, and physical concomitants. For all of the participants, the nonreaders version was used to measure the stuttering frequency because of the delay in reading skills in children with DS (Næss, Melby-Lervåg, Hulme, & Halaas Lyster, 2012). Physical concomitants, such as distracting sounds and facial grimaces, were rated on a 6-point scale, ranging from 0 (none) to 5 (severe and painful looking).
Modeling individual variation in early literacy skills in kindergarten children with intellectual disabilities
2018, Research in Developmental DisabilitiesSpoken fictional narrative and literacy skills of children with Down syndrome
2019, Journal of Communication DisordersHome literacy environment and literacy outcomes in individuals with Williams syndrome and Down syndrome
2024, Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability
- 1
References marked with an asterisk indicate studies included in the meta-analysis.