Abstract
Objectives: To determine the most appropriate outlier trimming method when the main source of information for case mix classification is length of stay (LOS) because cost information is unavailable. Methods: Discharges (35,262) from two public hospitals were analysed. LOS and cost outliers were calculated using different trimming methods. The agreement between cost and LOS trimming was analysed. Results: The trimming method using the geometric mean with two standard deviations (GM2) showed the highest level of agreement between cost and LOS and revealed the greatest proportion of extreme costs. Nearly 5% of cases were outliers, containing 16% of total LOS. This was the best approximation to 18% of extreme cost because when GM2 was applied to LOS, 88% of outlier cost was revealed. Conclusions: The methods were analysed because they are the most frequently used but the same methodology could be employed to compare other outlier determination methods. Outliers should be calculated because they ought to be valued differently from inlier cases.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
P. Armitage and G. Berry, Statistical Methods in Medical Research (Blackwell Science Ltd., 1994).
C. Beaver, Y. Zhao, S. McDermid and D. Hindle, Casemix-based funding of northern territory public hospitals: Adjusting for severity and socio-economic variations, Health Economics 7 (1998) 53–61.
A. Briggs and A. Gray, The distribution of health care costs and their statistical analysis for economic evaluation, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 3 (1998) 233–245.
J.R.G. Butler, Hospital Cost Analysis (Kluwer Academic Publishers, The Netherlands, 1995).
J.R.G. Butler, C.M. Furnival and R.F.G. Hart, Estimating treatment cost functions for progressive disease: A multiproduct approach with an application to breast cancer, Journal of Health Economics 14 (1995) 361–385.
K.A. Calore and L. Iezzoni, Disease staging and PMCs. Can they improve DRGs? Medical Care 25 (1987) 724–737.
G.M. Carter, P.D. Jacobson, G.F. Kominski and M.J. Perry, Use of diagnosis-related groups by non-Medicare payers, Health Care Financing Review 16 (1994) 127–158.
G.M. Carter and J.D. Rumpel, Payment Rates for Unusual Medicare Hospital Cases (RAND, Santa Mónica, 1992).
M. Casas, Sistemes d'informació hospitalària basats en la casuística: Grups relacionats amb el diagnòstic, Impacte en la gestió hospitalària, Thesis/Dissertation (Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, 1990).
M. Casas and R. Tomas, Producing DRG statistics at the European level: Lessons from the EURODRG Project, in: Diagnosis Related Groups in Europe. Uses and Perspectives, eds. M. Casas and M. Wiley (Springer, Berlin, 1993).
I.R. Chandler, R.B. Fetter and R.C. Newbold, Cost accounting and budgeting, in: DRGs. Their Design and Development, eds. R.B. Fetter, D.A. Brand and D. Gamache (Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1991).
F. Cots and X. Castells, Cómo pagamos a nuestros hospitales. La referencia de Cataluña y el contrapunto desde Andalucía, Gaceta Sanitaria 15 (2001) 172–181.
F. Cots, X. Castells, A. Garcia and M. Saez, Relación de los costes directos de hospitalización con la duración de la estancia, Gaceta Sanitaria 11 (1997) 287–295.
F. Cots, D. Elvira, X. Castells and E. Dalmau, Medicare's DRGWeights in a European environment: The Spanish experience, Health Policy 51 (2000) 31–47.
F. Cots, L. Mercadé and X. Castells, El outlier es un problema estadístico, clínico o asistencial? Red pÚblica de hospitales de Catalunya 1996, Gaceta Sanitaria 14(suplemento 1) (2000) 12.
A. Elixhauser, C. Steiner, R. Harris and R.M. Coffey, Comorbidity measures for use with administrative data, Medical Care 36 (1998) 8– 27.
A.R. Feinstein, Clinical epidemiology, The Architecture of Clinical Research (Sounders Company, 1985).
R.B. Fetter and J.L. Freeman, Grupos relacionados con el diagnóstico: Gestión por líneas de productos en los hospitales, in: Los Grupos Relacionados por el Diagnóstico: Experiencia y Perspectivas de Utilización, ed. M. Casas (Masson/ S.G. Editores, Barcelona, 1991).
L.I. Iezzoni, A.S. Ash, M. Shwartz, J. Daley, J.S. Hugues and Y.D. Mackiernan, Judging hospitals by severity-adjusted mortality rates: The influence of the severity-adjustment method, American Journal of Public Health 86 (1996) 1379–1387.
L.I. Iezzoni, A.S. Ash, M. Shwartz, B.E. Landon and Y.D. Mackiernan, Predicting in-hospital deaths from coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Do different severity measures give different predictions? Medical Care 36 (1998) 28–39.
E.B. Keeler, G.M. Carter and S. Trude, Insurance aspects of DRG outlier payments, Journal of Health Economics 7 (1988) 193–214.
D.A. Kenny, Statistics for the Social and Behavioral Sciences (Little, Brown and Company, Boston, 1987).
H. Lee, Outliers in business surveys, in: Business Survey Methods, eds. B.G. Cox, D.A. Binder, B.N. Chinnappa, A. Christianson, M.J. Colledge and P.S. Kott (Wiley, New York, 1995).
L.K. Lichtig, Hospital Information Systems for Casemix Management (Wiley, New York, 1986).
G. López Casasnovas and A. Wagstaff, La financiación hospitalaria basada en la actividad en sistemas sanitarios pÚblicos, regulación de tarifas y eficiencia: El caso de la concentración hospitalaria en Cataluña, in: La Regulación de los Servicios Sanitarios en España, eds. G. López Casasnovas and D. Rodríguez (Editorial Civitas, Madrid, 1997).
J.P. Newhouse, Reimbursing health plans and health providers: Effi-ciency in production versus selection, Journal of Economic Literature 34 (1996) 1236–1263.
S. Peiró, Limitaciones en la medición de los resultados de la atención hospitalaria: Implicaciones para la gestión, in: Instrumentos Para la Gestión en Sanidad, ed. AES (SG-Editores S.A., Barcelona, 1995).
G. Rhodes, M. Wiley, R. Tomas, M. Casas and R. Leidl, Comparing EU hospital efficiency using diagnosis-related groups, European Journal of Public Health 7 (1997) 42–50.
D.L. Sackett, R.B. Haynes, G.H. Guyatt and P. Tugwell, Epidemiología clínica, in: Ciencia Básica para la Medicina Clínica (Panamericana, Buenos Aires, 1994).
H.F. Sanderson, P. Anthony and L.M. Mountney, Healthcare resource groups. Version 2, Journal of Public Health Medicine 17 (1995) 349– 354.
T. Smith, D. Archer and F. Butler, Healthcare resources groups and general practitioner purchasing, in: Casemix for All, eds. H. Sanderson, P. Anthony and L. Mountney (Radcliffe Medical Press, Oxon, 1998).
N. Söderlund, Product definition for healthcare contracting: An overview of approaches to measuring hospital output with reference to the UK internal market, Journal of Epidemiology Community Health 48 (1994) 224–231.
N. Söderlund, A. Gray, R. Milne and J. Raftery, The construction of resource-weights for healthcare resource groups: A comparison of alternative data sources and methodological approaches (National Casemix Office, London, 1996).
N. Söderlund, A. Gray, R. Milne and J. Raftery, Case mix measurement in english hospitals: An evaluation of five methods for predicting resource use, Journal of Health Services Research and Policy 1 (1996) 10–19.
J.L. Temes, J.L. Díaz and B. Parra, El Coste por Proceso Hospitalario (Editorial Interamericana McGraw-Hill, Madrid, 1994).
J.W. Thomas and M.L.F. Ashcraft, Measuring severity of illness: Six severity systems and their ability to explain cost variations, Inquiry 28 (1991) 39–55.
S. Udpa, Activity-based costing for hospitals, Health Care Management Review 21 (1996) 83–96.
D.W. Young and L.K. Pearlman, Managing the stages of hospital cost accounting, Healthcare Financial Management 47 (1993) 58–80.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cots, F., Elvira, D., Castells, X. et al. Relevance of Outlier Cases in Case Mix Systems and Evaluation of Trimming Methods. Health Care Management Science 6, 27–35 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021908220013
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1021908220013