Shaping End-of-Life Care: Behavioral Economics and Advance Directives

 

 Buy Article Permissions and Reprints

Abstract

A central but unmet challenge in health care delivery is to increase the probability that the care patients receive near the end of their life is consistent with their goals, values, and preferences. Providing patient-centered care at the end of life is challenging. In their final days, nearly a third of older Americans need critical decisions made regarding the use or nonuse of life-sustaining interventions, but the patients themselves cannot participate in those decisions. Although this observation highlights the promise of advance directives (ADs), to date ADs have not delivered on this promise. This article provides a new framework, based in behavioral economic theory, that may explain the current failures of ADs and point to potential solutions. Specifically, it discusses how five well-described cognitive biases that pervade human decision making (affective forecasting errors, optimism bias, present-biased preferences, focusing effects, and default options) may account for deficiencies in the uptake, efficacy, and patient-centeredness of ADs. The text suggests potential solutions in need of evaluation, discusses metrics for assessing these interventions' benefits, and considers alternatives to the approaches advocated.

• References

• 1 Fields MJ, Cassel CK. Approaching Death, Improving Care at the End of Life. Washington, DC: National Academy Press; 1997
  Google Scholar
• 2 Time Magazine/SRBI. March 22–24, 2005. Survey. http://www.srbi.com/TimePoll-Final_Report-2005-03-25.pdf . Accessed August 2, 2011
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 3 Angus DC, Barnato AE, Linde-Zwirble WT , et al; Robert Wood Johnson Foundation ICU End-Of-Life Peer Group. Use of intensive care at the end of life in the United States: an epidemiologic study. Crit Care Med 2004; 32 (3) 638-643
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 4 Facts on dying. 2001. http://www.chcr.brown.edu/dying/2001DATA.HTM . Accessed July 9, 2012
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 5 National Mortality Followback Survey. 1998. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/98facts/93nmfs.htm . Accessed July 9, 2012
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 6 Hogan C, Lunney J, Gabel J, Lynn J. Medicare beneficiaries' costs of care in the last year of life. Health Aff (Millwood) 2001; 20 (4) 188-195
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 7 Hoover DR, Crystal S, Kumar R, Sambamoorthi U, Cantor JC. Medical expenditures during the last year of life: findings from the 1992-1996 Medicare current beneficiary survey. Health Serv Res 2002; 37 (6) 1625-1642
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 8 Wright AA, Keating NL, Balboni TA, Matulonis UA, Block SD, Prigerson HG. Place of death: correlations with quality of life of patients with cancer and predictors of bereaved caregivers' mental health. J Clin Oncol 2010; 28 (29) 4457-4464
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 9 Wright AA, Zhang BH, Ray A , et al. Associations between end-of-life discussions, patient mental health, medical care near death, and caregiver bereavement adjustment. JAMA 2008; 300 (14) 1665-1673
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 10 Temel JS, Greer JA, Muzikansky A , et al. Early palliative care for patients with metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer. N Engl J Med 2010; 363 (8) 733-742
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 11 Bakitas M, Lyons KD, Hegel MT , et al. Effects of a palliative care intervention on clinical outcomes in patients with advanced cancer: the Project ENABLE II randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2009; 302 (7) 741-749
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 12 Connor SR, Pyenson B, Fitch K, Spence C, Iwasaki K. Comparing hospice and nonhospice patient survival among patients who die within a three-year window. J Pain Symptom Manage 2007; 33 (3) 238-246
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 13 Azoulay E, Pochard F, Kentish-Barnes N , et al; FAMIREA Study Group. Risk of post-traumatic stress symptoms in family members of intensive care unit patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2005; 171 (9) 987-994
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 14 Detering KM, Hancock AD, Reade MC, Silvester W. The impact of advance care planning on end of life care in elderly patients: randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2010; 340: c1345
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 15 Wendler D, Rid A. Systematic review: the effect on surrogates of making treatment decisions for others. Ann Intern Med 2011; 154 (5) 336-346
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 16 Silveira MJ, Kim SYH, Langa KM. Advance directives and outcomes of surrogate decision making before death. N Engl J Med 2010; 362 (13) 1211-1218
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 17 Knaus WA, Connors AF, Dawson NV , et al; The SUPPORT Principal Investigators. A controlled trial to improve care for seriously ill hospitalized patients. The study to understand prognoses and preferences for outcomes and risks of treatments (SUPPORT). JAMA 1995; 274 (20) 1591-1598
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 18 Lynn J, Teno JM, Phillips RS , et al; SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments. Perceptions by family members of the dying experience of older and seriously ill patients. Ann Intern Med 1997; 126 (2) 97-106
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 19 Curtis JR, Nielsen EL, Treece PD , et al. Effect of a quality-improvement intervention on end-of-life care in the intensive care unit: a randomized trial. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2011; 183 (3) 348-355
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 20 Perkins HS. Controlling death: the false promise of advance directives. Ann Intern Med 2007; 147 (1) 51-57
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 21 Fagerlin A, Schneider CE. Enough. The failure of the living will. Hastings Cent Rep 2004; 34 (2) 30-42
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 22 Molloy DW, Guyatt GH, Russo R , et al. Systematic implementation of an advance directive program in nursing homes: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2000; 283 (11) 1437-1444
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 23 Degenholtz HB, Rhee Y, Arnold RM. Brief communication: the relationship between having a living will and dying in place. Ann Intern Med 2004; 141 (2) 113-117
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 24 Lo B, Steinbrook R. Resuscitating advance directives. Arch Intern Med 2004; 164 (14) 1501-1506
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 25 Allais M. Le comportement de l'homme rationnel devant le risque: critique des postulats et axiomes de l'école Américaine. Econometrica 1953; 21: 503-546
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 26 Tversky A, Kahneman D. Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. Science 1974; 185 (4157) 1124-1131
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 27 Tversky A, Kahneman D. The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice. Science 1981; 211 (4481) 453-458
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 28 Kahneman D, Knetsch JL, Thaler RH. Anomalies: the endowment effect, loss aversion, and status-quo bias. J Econ Perspect 1991; 5: 193-206
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 29 Loewenstein G, Prelec D. Anomalies in Intertemporal Choice - Evidence and an Interpretation. Q J Econ 1992; 107: 573-597
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 30 Camerer C, Issacharoff S, Loewenstein G, O'Donoghue T, Rabin M. Regulation for conservatives: Behavioral economics and the case for asymmetric paternalism. Univ PA Law Rev 2003; 151: 1211-1254
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 31 Swindell JS, McGuire AL, Halpern SD. Shaping patients' decisions. Chest 2011; 139 (2) 424-429
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 32 Slovic P. The construction of preference. Am Psychol 1995; 50: 364-371
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 33 Swindell JS, McGuire AL, Halpern SD. Beneficent persuasion: techniques and ethical guidelines to improve patients' decisions. Ann Fam Med 2010; 8 (3) 260-264
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 34 Sudore RL, Fried TR. Redefining the “planning” in advance care planning: preparing for end-of-life decision making. Ann Intern Med 2010; 153 (4) 256-261
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 35 Tulsky JA. Beyond advance directives: importance of communication skills at the end of life. JAMA 2005; 294 (3) 359-365
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 36 Fried TR, Bullock K, Iannone L, O'Leary JR. Understanding advance care planning as a process of health behavior change. J Am Geriatr Soc 2009; 57 (9) 1547-1555
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 37 Back AL, Arnold RM, Baile WF , et al. Efficacy of communication skills training for giving bad news and discussing transitions to palliative care. Arch Intern Med 2007; 167 (5) 453-460
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 38 Back AL, Arnold RM, Tulsky JA, Baile WF, Fryer-Edwards KA. Teaching communication skills to medical oncology fellows. J Clin Oncol 2003; 21 (12) 2433-2436
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 39 Lo B, Ruston D, Kates LW , et al; Working Group on Religious and Spiritual Issues at the End of Life. Discussing religious and spiritual issues at the end of life: a practical guide for physicians. JAMA 2002; 287 (6) 749-754
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 40 Lee Char SJ, Evans LR, Malvar GL, White DB. A randomized trial of two methods to disclose prognosis to surrogate decision makers in intensive care units. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2010; 182 (7) 905-909
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 41 Curtis JR, White DB. Practical guidance for evidence-based ICU family conferences. Chest 2008; 134 (4) 835-843
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 42 Evans LR, Boyd EA, Malvar G , et al. Surrogate decision-makers' perspectives on discussing prognosis in the face of uncertainty. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009; 179 (1) 48-53
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 43 Johnson SK, Bautista CA, Hong SY, Weissfeld L, White DB. An empirical study of surrogates' preferred level of control over value-laden life support decisions in intensive care units. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2011; 183 (7) 915-921
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 44 Lautrette A, Darmon M, Megarbane B , et al. A communication strategy and brochure for relatives of patients dying in the ICU. N Engl J Med 2007; 356 (5) 469-478
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 45 White DB, Evans LR, Bautista CA, Luce JM, Lo B. Are physicians' recommendations to limit life support beneficial or burdensome? Bringing empirical data to the debate. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009; 180 (4) 320-325
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 46 Ubel PA, Loewenstein G, Schwarz N, Smith D. Misimagining the unimaginable: the disability paradox and health care decision making. Health Psychol 2005; 24 (4, Suppl) S57-S62
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 47 Halpern J, Arnold RM. Affective forecasting: an unrecognized challenge in making serious health decisions. J Gen Intern Med 2008; 23 (10) 1708-1712
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 48 Weinstein ND. Unrealistic optimism about future life events. J Pers Soc Psychol 1980; 39: 806-820
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 49 Moorman SM, Carr D. Spouses' effectiveness as end-of-life health care surrogates: accuracy, uncertainty, and errors of overtreatment or undertreatment. Gerontologist 2008; 48 (6) 811-819
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 50 Seckler AB, Meier DE, Mulvihill M, Paris BEC. Substituted judgment: how accurate are proxy predictions?. Ann Intern Med 1991; 115 (2) 92-98
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 51 Shalowitz DI, Garrett-Mayer E, Wendler D. The accuracy of surrogate decision makers: a systematic review. Arch Intern Med 2006; 166 (5) 493-497
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 52 Laibson D. Golden eggs and hyperbolic discounting. Q J Econ 1997; 112: 443-477
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 53 Burt RA. Death Is That Man Taking Names. Berkeley: University of California Press; 2004
  Google Scholar
• 54 Quill TE. Perspectives on care at the close of life. Initiating end-of-life discussions with seriously ill patients: addressing the “elephant in the room”. JAMA 2000; 284 (19) 2502-2507
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 55 Kahneman D, Krueger AB, Schkade D, Schwarz N, Stone AA. Would you be happier if you were richer? A focusing illusion. Science 2006; 312 (5782) 1908-1910
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 56 Schkade DA, Kahneman D. Does living in California make people happy? A focusing illusion in judgments of life satisfaction. Psychol Sci 1998; 9: 340-346
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 57 Terry PB, Vettese M, Song J , et al. End-of-life decision making: when patients and surrogates disagree. J Clin Ethics 1999; 10 (4) 286-293
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 58 Singer PA, Martin DK, Lavery JV, Thiel EC, Kelner M, Mendelssohn DC. Reconceptualizing advance care planning from the patient's perspective. Arch Intern Med 1998; 158 (8) 879-884
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 59 Mead GE, O'Keeffe ST, Jack CIA, Maèstri-Banks AM, Playfer JR, Lye M. What factors influence patient preferences regarding cardiopulmonary resuscitation?. J R Coll Physicians Lond 1995; 29 (4) 295-298
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 60 Steinhauser KE, Christakis NA, Clipp EC, McNeilly M, McIntyre L, Tulsky JA. Factors considered important at the end of life by patients, family, physicians, and other care providers. JAMA 2000; 284 (19) 2476-2482
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 61 Halpern SD, Ubel PA, Asch DA. Harnessing the power of default options to improve health care. N Engl J Med 2007; 357 (13) 1340-1344
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 62 Loewenstein G, Brennan T, Volpp KG. Asymmetric paternalism to improve health behaviors. JAMA 2007; 298 (20) 2415-2417
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 63 Emanuel LL, Barry MJ, Stoeckle JD, Ettelson LM, Emanuel EJ. Advance directives for medical care—a case for greater use. N Engl J Med 1991; 324 (13) 889-895
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 64 Loewenstein G. Projection bias in medical decision making. Med Decis Making 2005; 25 (1) 96-105
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 65 Teno JM, Gruneir A, Schwartz Z, Nanda A, Wetle T. Association between advance directives and quality of end-of-life care: a national study. J Am Geriatr Soc 2007; 55 (2) 189-194
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 66 Degner LF, Sloan JA. Decision making during serious illness: what role do patients really want to play?. J Clin Epidemiol 1992; 45 (9) 941-950
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 67 Ende J, Kazis L, Ash A, Moskowitz MA. Measuring patients' desire for autonomy: decision making and information-seeking preferences among medical patients. J Gen Intern Med 1989; 4 (1) 23-30
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 68 Sutherland HJ, Llewellyn-Thomas HA, Lockwood GA, Tritchler DL, Till JE. Cancer patients: their desire for information and participation in treatment decisions. J R Soc Med 1989; 82 (5) 260-263
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 69 Strack F, Martin LL, Schwarz N. Priming and Communication - Social Determinants of Information Use in Judgments of Life Satisfaction. Eur J Soc Psychol 1988; 18: 429-442
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 70 Schwarz N, Strack F, Mai HP. Assimilation and Contrast Effects in Part-Whole Question Sequences - a Conversational Logic Analysis. Public Opin Q 1991; 55: 3-23
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 71 Smith DM, Schwarz N, Roberts TR, Ubel PA. Why are you calling me? How study introductions change response patterns. Qual Life Res 2006; 15 (4) 621-630
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 72 Roter DL, Larson S, Fischer GS, Arnold RM, Tulsky JA. Experts practice what they preach: A descriptive study of best and normative practices in end-of-life discussions. Arch Intern Med 2000; 160 (22) 3477-3485
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 73 Tulsky JA, Fischer GS, Rose MR, Arnold RM. Opening the black box: how do physicians communicate about advance directives?. Ann Intern Med 1998; 129 (6) 441-449
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 74 Sharot T, Riccardi AM, Raio CM, Phelps EA. Neural mechanisms mediating optimism bias. Nature 2007; 450 (7166) 102-105
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 75 Armor DA, Taylor SE. When Predictions Fail: The Dilemma of Unrealistic Optimism. In: Gilovich T, Griffin D, Kahneman D, eds. Heuristics and biases: The psychology of intuitive judgment. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2002
  CrossrefGoogle Scholar
• 76 Ritov I, Baron J. Status quo and omission biases. J Risk Uncertain 1992; 5: 49
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 77 Samuelson W, Zeckhauser R. Status quo bias in decision making. J Risk Uncertain 1988; 1: 7-59
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 78 Choi JJ, Laibson D, Madrian BC, Metrick A. Defined contribution pensions: plan rules, participant decisions, and the path of least resistance. In: Poterba JM, ed. Tax Policy and the Economy. Vol 16. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2002: 67-113
  Google Scholar
• 79 Madrian BC, Shea DF. The power of suggestion: Inertia in 401(k) participation and savings behavior. Q J Econ 2001; 116: 1149-1187
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 80 Johnson EJ, Hershey JC, Meszaros J, Kunreuther H. Framing, probability distortions, and insurance decisions. J Risk Uncertain 1993; 7: 35-51
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 81 Johnson EJ, Goldstein D. Medicine. Do defaults save lives?. Science 2003; 302 (5649) 1338-1339
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 82 Horvat LD, Cuerden MS, Kim SJ, Koval JJ, Young A, Garg AX. Informing the debate: rates of kidney transplantation in nations with presumed consent. Ann Intern Med 2010; 153 (10) 641-649
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 83 Kressel LM, Chapman GB, Leventhal E. The influence of default options on the expression of end-of-life treatment preferences in advance directives. J Gen Intern Med 2007; 22 (7) 1007-1010
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 84 Kressel LM, Chapman GB. The default effect in end-of-life medical treatment preferences. Med Decis Making 2007; 27 (3) 299-310
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 85 Torke AM, Sachs GA, Helft PR , et al. Timing of do-not-resuscitate orders for hospitalized older adults who require a surrogate decision-maker. J Am Geriatr Soc 2011; 59 (7) 1326-1331
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 86 Five Wishes. Accessed July 26, 2011, at http://www.agingwithdignity.org/five-wishes.php .
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 87 Powe NA, Bateman IJ. Ordering effects in nested ‘top-down’ and ‘bottom-up’ contingent valuation designs. Ecol Econ 2003; 45: 255-270
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 88 Kahneman D, Knetsch JL. Valuing public goods: the purchase of moral satisfaction. J Environ Econ Manage 1992; 22: 55-70
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 89 Carmon Z, Wertenbroch K, Zeelenberg M. Option attachment: When deliberating makes choosing feel like losing. J Consum Res 2003; 30: 15-29
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 90 Carroll GD, Choi JJ, Laibson D, Madrian BC, Metrick A. Optimal Defaults and Active Decisions. Q J Econ 2009; 124 (4) 1639-1674
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 91 Knottnerus JA, Bouter LM. The ethics of sample size: two-sided testing and one-sided thinking. J Clin Epidemiol 2001; 54 (2) 109-110
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 92 Garland A, Connors AF. Physicians' influence over decisions to forego life support. J Palliat Med 2007; 10 (6) 1298-1305
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 93 Malloy TR, Wigton RS, Meeske J, Tape TG. The influence of treatment descriptions on advance medical directive decisions. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992; 40 (12) 1255-1260
  PubMedGoogle Scholar