How to Manage a Failed Cartilage Repair: A Systematic Literature Review

 

 Permissions and Reprints

Abstract

Purpose The aims of this paper are to report the rate and risk factors for the failure of the most common cartilage repair technique, and analyze the most important factors that could influence the choice of a specific surgical treatment to revise a failed cartilage repair.

Methods A review of the literature was performed focusing on failed cartilage repair and related treatments. Two of the authors independently screened articles. Conflicts about the inclusion of a paper was resolved by further evaluation by the senior author. Review articles, articles written in languages different from/other than English, case reports, and papers that did not evaluate the outcomes of interest were excluded. Full-text version of each included paper was obtained and relevant data were extracted and collected in a database.

Results At the end of the screening process, 31 articles were included. Microfractures and mosaicplasty showed a nonnegligible failure rate at short- and midterm. Better results, especially in terms of time to failure or revision, were reported with the use of autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) and osteochondral allograft (OCA) transplantation. Regarding the treatment of failed cartilage repair, the use of OCA transplantation in patients with previous failed cartilage repair may be a safe option. The revision of failed OCA transplantation with further OCA seems to have a greater failure rate. Patients with previous failed ACI or matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation (MACI) who underwent further MACI or ACI reported acceptable results. Otherwise, ACI in patients with history of previous subchondral marrow stimulation (SMS) demonstrated a greater failure rate.

Conclusion From the analysis of the literature, OCA transplantation seems to be the most reliable treatment of a failed SMS. ACI or MACI showed acceptable results in patients with previously failed MACI or ACI.

Level of Evidence Level IV, systematic review of level I-IV studies.

• References

• 1 Curl WW, Krome J, Gordon ES, Rushing J, Smith BP, Poehling GG. Cartilage injuries: a review of 31,516 knee arthroscopies. Arthroscopy 1997; 13 (04) 456-460
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 2 Biant LC, McNicholas MJ, Sprowson AP, Spalding T. The surgical management of symptomatic articular cartilage defects of the knee: consensus statements from United Kingdom knee surgeons. Knee 2015; 22 (05) 446-449
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 3 Bedi A, Feeley BT, Williams III RJ. Management of articular cartilage defects of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2010; 92 (04) 994-1009
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 4 Salzmann GM, Sah B, Südkamp NP, Niemeyer P. Reoperative characteristics after microfracture of knee cartilage lesions in 454 patients. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2013; 21 (02) 365-371
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 5 Solheim E, Øyen J, Hegna J, Austgulen OK, Harlem T, Strand T. Microfracture treatment of single or multiple articular cartilage defects of the knee: a 5-year median follow-up of 110 patients. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 2010; 18 (04) 504-508
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 6 Steadman JR, Briggs KK, Matheny LM, Guillet A, Hanson CM, Willimon SC. Outcomes following microfracture of full-thickness articular cartilage lesions of the knee in adolescent patients. J Knee Surg 2015; 28 (02) 145-150
  Article in Thieme ConnectPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 7 Bentley G, Biant LC, Vijayan S, Macmull S, Skinner JA, Carrington RW. Minimum ten-year results of a prospective randomised study of autologous chondrocyte implantation versus mosaicplasty for symptomatic articular cartilage lesions of the knee. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2012; 94 (04) 504-509
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 8 Robb CA, El-Sayed C, Matharu GS, Baloch K, Pynsent P. Survival of autologous osteochondral grafts in the knee and factors influencing outcome. Acta Orthop Belg 2012; 78 (05) 643-651
  PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 9 Degen RM, Coleman NW, Chang B, Tetreault D, Mahony GT, Williams RJ. Outcomes following structural grafting of distal femoral osteochondral injuries in patients aged 40 years and older. J Knee Surg 2017; 30 (03) 244-251
  Article in Thieme ConnectPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 10 Minas T, Von Keudell A, Bryant T, Gomoll AH. The John Insall Award: a minimum 10-year outcome study of autologous chondrocyte implantation. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2014; 472 (01) 41-51
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 11 Beris AE, Lykissas MG, Kostas-Agnantis I, Manoudis GN. Treatment of full-thickness chondral defects of the knee with autologous chondrocyte implantation: a functional evaluation with long-term follow-up. Am J Sports Med 2012; 40 (03) 562-567
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 12 Gomoll AH, Gillogly SD, Cole BJ. , et al. Autologous chondrocyte implantation in the patella: a multicenter experience. Am J Sports Med 2014; 42 (05) 1074-1081
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 13 Farr J. Autologous chondrocyte implantation improves patellofemoral cartilage treatment outcomes. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2007; 463: 187-194
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 14 Minas T, Gomoll AH, Solhpour S, Rosenberger R, Probst C, Bryant T. Autologous chondrocyte implantation for joint preservation in patients with early osteoarthritis. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2010; 468 (01) 147-157
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 15 Jungmann PM, Salzmann GM, Schmal H, Pestka JM, Südkamp NP, Niemeyer P. Autologous chondrocyte implantation for treatment of cartilage defects of the knee: what predicts the need for reintervention?. Am J Sports Med 2012; 40 (01) 58-67
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 16 Erggelet C, Kreuz PC, Mrosek EH. , et al. Autologous chondrocyte implantation versus ACI using 3D-bioresorbable graft for the treatment of large full-thickness cartilage lesions of the knee. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2010; 130 (08) 957-964
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 17 Niemeyer P, Pestka JM, Kreuz PC. , et al. Characteristic complications after autologous chondrocyte implantation for cartilage defects of the knee joint. Am J Sports Med 2008; 36 (11) 2091-2099
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 18 Niethammer TR, Valentin S, Ficklscherer A, Gülecyüz MF, Pietschmann MF, Müller PE. Revision surgery after third generation autologous chondrocyte implantation in the knee. Int Orthop 2015; 39 (08) 1615-1622
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 19 Briggs DT, Sadr KN, Pulido PA, Bugbee WD. The use of osteochondral allograft transplantation for primary treatment of cartilage lesions in the knee. Cartilage 2015; 6 (04) 203-207
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 20 Frank RM, Lee S, Levy D. , et al. Osteochondral allograft transplantation of the knee: analysis of failures at 5 years. Am J Sports Med 2017; 45 (04) 864-874
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 21 Levy YD, Görtz S, Pulido PA, McCauley JC, Bugbee WD. Do fresh osteochondral allografts successfully treat femoral condyle lesions?. Clin Orthop Relat Res 2013; 471 (01) 231-237
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 22 Sadr KN, Pulido PA, McCauley JC, Bugbee WD. Osteochondral allograft transplantation in patients with osteochondritis dissecans of the knee. Am J Sports Med 2016; 44 (11) 2870-2875
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 23 Gracitelli GC, Meric G, Pulido PA, Görtz S, De Young AJ, Bugbee WD. Fresh osteochondral allograft transplantation for isolated patellar cartilage injury. Am J Sports Med 2015; 43 (04) 879-884
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 24 Meric G, Gracitelli GC, Görtz S, De Young AJ, Bugbee WD. Fresh osteochondral allograft transplantation for bipolar reciprocal osteochondral lesions of the knee. Am J Sports Med 2015; 43 (03) 709-714
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 25 Murphy RT, Pennock AT, Bugbee WD. Osteochondral allograft transplantation of the knee in the pediatric and adolescent population. Am J Sports Med 2014; 42 (03) 635-640
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 26 Farr J, Gracitelli GC, Shah N, Chang EY, Gomoll AH. High failure rate of a decellularized osteochondral allograft for the treatment of cartilage lesions. Am J Sports Med 2016; 44 (08) 2015-2022
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 27 Dhollander AA, Liekens K, Almqvist KF. , et al. A pilot study of the use of an osteochondral scaffold plug for cartilage repair in the knee and how to deal with early clinical failures. Arthroscopy 2012; 28 (02) 225-233
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 28 Joshi N, Reverte-Vinaixa M, Díaz-Ferreiro EW, Domínguez-Oronoz R. Synthetic resorbable scaffolds for the treatment of isolated patellofemoral cartilage defects in young patients: magnetic resonance imaging and clinical evaluation. Am J Sports Med 2012; 40 (06) 1289-1295
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 29 Berruto M, Delcogliano M, de Caro F. , et al. Treatment of large knee osteochondral lesions with a biomimetic scaffold: results of a multicenter study of 49 patients at 2-year follow-up. Am J Sports Med 2014; 42 (07) 1607-1617
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 30 Gracitelli GC, Meric G, Pulido PA, McCauley JC, Bugbee WD. Osteochondral allograft transplantation for knee lesions after failure of cartilage repair surgery. Cartilage 2015; 6 (02) 98-105
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 31 Gracitelli GC, Meric G, Briggs DT. , et al. Fresh osteochondral allografts in the knee: comparison of primary transplantation versus transplantation after failure of previous subchondral marrow stimulation. Am J Sports Med 2015; 43 (04) 885-891
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 32 Horton MT, Pulido PA, McCauley JC, Bugbee WD. Revision osteochondral allograft transplantations: do they work?. Am J Sports Med 2013; 41 (11) 2507-2511
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 33 Stone KR, Pelsis JR, Crues III JV, Walgenbach AW, Turek TJ. Osteochondral grafting for failed knee osteochondritis dissecans repairs. Knee 2014; 21 (06) 1145-1150
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 34 Vijayan S, Bentley G, Rahman J, Briggs TW, Skinner JA, Carrington RW. Revision cartilage cell transplantation for failed autologous chondrocyte transplantation in chronic osteochondral defects of the knee. Bone Joint J 2014; 96-B (01) 54-58
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 35 Rosa D, Balato G, Ciaramella G, Soscia E, Improta G, Triassi M. Long-term clinical results and MRI changes after autologous chondrocyte implantation in the knee of young and active middle aged patients. J Orthop Traumatol 2016; 17 (01) 55-62
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 36 Bert JM. Abandoning microfracture of the knee: has the time come?. Arthroscopy 2015; 31 (03) 501-505
  CrossrefPubMedGoogle Scholar
• 37 Zedde P, Cudoni S, Giachetti G. , et al. Subchondral bone remodeling: comparing nanofracture with microfracture. an ovine in vivo study. Joints 2016; 4 (02) 87-93
  Article in Thieme ConnectPubMedGoogle Scholar