Hostname: page-component-848d4c4894-75dct Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-05-24T05:14:34.329Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Volatile Sovereignty: Governing Crime through the Community in Khayelitsha

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2024

Gail Super
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper asks what crime prevention looks like for residents in informal settlements in Khayelitsha, a black township on the outskirts of Cape Town. It engages with the idea of vigilantism and hybrid policing formations, analyzing the overlaps and intersections between legal community-based crime prevention initiatives, and local ‘punitive practices’. The focus is not on the intensely violent spectacle of ‘mob justice’, where suspects are killed, but on the more ubiquitous, hybrid formations that also fall on the vigilantism continuum. These include coercive practices such as banishment, corporal punishment, retrieval of stolen goods by local policing formations and, trials conducted by street committees. The core argument I make is that, at times, particularly in poor areas where the state is absent and encourages citizens to take responsibility for their own crime prevention, the boundary between legality and coercive illegality collapses in on itself. Thus, the notion of voluntarism, that is so important to official discourse on crime, is particularly problematic when applied in poor communities with high rates of unemployment and high crime rates. As such, the state's encouraging of citizens to take responsibility for their own safety, alongside a punitive state discourse on crime and criminality, creates the space for illegal vigilante style actions to emerge in the shadow of legal crime prevention initiatives.

Type
Articles
Information
Law & Society Review , Volume 50 , Issue 2 , June 2016 , pp. 450 - 483
Copyright
© 2016 Law and Society Association.

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

This work is based on research that was partly supported by the South African National Research Foundation and the Safety and Violence Initiative, University of Cape Town. The author would like to thank the anonymous reviewers and Dr. SJ Cooper-Knock for their insightful comments.

References

Aas, K. (2014) “Bordered Penality: Precarious Membership and Abnormal Justice,” 16(5) Punishment & Society, 520–41.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abrahams, R. (1998) Vigilant Citizens, Vigilantism and the State. Cambridge, Malden: Polity Press.Google Scholar
Abrahams, R. (2008) “Some Thoughts on Vigilantism,” in Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Adler, G. & Steinberg, J. (2000) “Introduction,” in Adler, G., & Steinberg, J., eds., From Comrades to Citizens, The South African Civics Movement and the Transition to Democracy. New York: Macmillan Press: Houndsmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, London, St Martins Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Affordable Land and Housing Data Centre (undated) Suburb Profiles. Available at: http://www.alhdc.org.za/static_content/?p=91 (accessed 30 June 2015).Google Scholar
Allison, J. (1990) “In Search of Revolutionary Justice in South Africa,” 18 International J. of the Sociology of Law 409–28.Google Scholar
Amin, A. (2005) “Local Community on Trial,” 34 Economy and Society, 612–33.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Anderson, E. (1999) Code of the Street, Decency, Violence and the Mora Life of the Inner City. New York/London: WW Norton and Company.Google Scholar
Beckett, K. and Evans, H. (2015) “Crimmigration at the Local Level: criminal case processing in the shadow of deportation,” 49 L. and Society Rev. 241–277.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brewer, J. (1994) Black and Blue, Policing in South Africa. Oxford: Clarendon.Google Scholar
Browning, C., Feinberg, S., & Dietz, R. (2004) “The Paradox of Social Organization: Networks, Collective Efficacy, and Violent Crime in Urban Neighborhoods,” 83(2) Social Forces 503–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bruce, D. (2010) “An Acceptable Price to Pay? The Use of Lethal Force by the Police,” Criminal Justice Initiative, Occasional Paper Series 8, Open Society Foundation, Available at: http://osf.org.za/wp/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/CJI_Occasional_Paper_81.pdf (accessed 5 January 2014).Google Scholar
Burman, S., & Schärf, W. (1990) “Creating People's Justice: Street Committees and People's Courts in a South African City,” 24(3) Law and Society Rev. 693–744.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buur, L. (2003) “Crime and Punishment on the Margins of the Postapartheid State,” 28(1) Anthropology and Humanism 23–42.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buur, L., & Jensen, S. (2004) “Introduction: Vigilantism and the Policing of Everyday Life in South Africa,” 63(2) African Studies 139–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Buur, L., & Jensen, S. (2007) “The South Africanisation of post-apartheid South Africa: nation-state building and consequences for mobile livelihoods,” in Buur, L., Jensen, S. & Stepputat, F., eds., The Security-Development Nexus: Expressions of Sovereignty and Securitization in Southern Africa, Pretoria: HSRC Press.Google Scholar
Census (2011) Statistical Release (Revised). Available at: http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P03014/P030142011.pdf (accessed 29 June 2015).Google Scholar
Cherry, J. (2000) “Hegemony, Democracy and Civil Society: Political particpation in KwaZakkele township. 1980-1993,” in Adler, G. & J. Steinberg, eds., From Comrades to Citizens, The South African Citizens Movement and the Transition to Democracy. New York: Macmillan Press. 86–113CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Citizen Surveys and Centre for Justice and Crime Prevention (2011) “Community Safety Barometer,” Cape Town: Department of Community Safety, April.Google Scholar
Comaroff, J., & Comaroff, J. (2004) “Criminal Obsessions, after Foucault: Postcoloniality, Policing, and the Metaphysics of Disorder,” 30(4) Critical Inquiry 800–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cooper-Knock, S. (2014) “Policing in Intimate Crowds: Moving Beyond ‘The Mob’ in South Africa,” 113 African Affairs 563–82.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Darracq, V. (2008) “The African National Congress (ANC) Organization at the Grassroots,” 107(429) African Affairs 589–609.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
De Klerk, J. (1999) “Community Policing Forums’ – Inducing Vigilantism, 92 Servamus 48–52.Google Scholar
De Kock, C. (2012) “Serious Crime in Khayelitsha and surrounding areas, Crime Research, Crime Intelligence,” Affidavit of Major-General De Kock (AL30), 3 August 2012, Available at: http:///www.khayelitshacommission.org.za/images/highcourtpapers/282 (accessed 15 April 2014).Google Scholar
Delgado, R. (2008) “Law Enforcement in Subordinated Communities: Innovation and Response,” 106 Michigan Law Rev. 1193.Google Scholar
Department of Community Safety (2009) “10 Safety Audits. Final Report on Khayelitsha Police Station,” Cape Town, 30 March. KPMG Services.Google Scholar
Department of Community Safety (2013) “Community Safety Neighbourhood Watch Training Learner Guide,” Cape Town.Google Scholar
Department of Community Safety (2010) “Uniform Constitution for Community Police Forums and Boards in the Western Cape.”Google Scholar
Department of Safety and Security (1998) “White Paper on Safety and Security. In the Service of Safety, 1998-2003,” September.Google Scholar
Department of Safety and Security (1999) “Policing Priorities and Objectives for 1999/2000.”Google Scholar
de Sousa Santos, B. (1987) “Law: A Map of Misreading. Toward a Postmodern Conception of Law,” 14(3) J. of Law and Society 279–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Dixon, B. & Johns, L., (2001) “Gangs, Pagad and the State: Vigilantism and Revenge Violence in the Western Cape,” Johannesburg: Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation.Google Scholar
Evans, and Wicks, (2015) Available at: http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Viral-video-shows-vigilantism-not-xenophobia-police-20150411 (accessed 11 April 2015).Google Scholar
Ewick, P., & Silbey, S. (1992) “Conformity, Contestation, and Resistance: An Account of Legal Consciousness,” 26 New England Law Rev. 731–49.Google Scholar
Fourchard, L. (2011) “The Politics of Mobilization for Security in South African Townships,” 110/441 African Affairs 607–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fourchard, L. (2012) “Security and Party Politics in Cape Town,” 43 Geoforum 199–206.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frith, A. (2013) Dot-Maps of Racial Distribution in South African Cities. Available at: http://blog.adrianfrith.com/dot-maps/(accessed 19 August 15).Google Scholar
Garland, D. (1996) “The Limits of the Sovereign State: Strategies of Crime Control in Contemporary Society,” 36(4) British J. of Criminology 445–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gastrow, V., & Amit, R. (2012) “Elusive Justice, Somali Traders Access to Formal and Informal Justice Mechanisms in the Western Cape,” ACMS Research Report, Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand.Google Scholar
Geach (2014) Available at: http://www.iol.co.za/news/crime-courts/search-for-man-who-whipped-gardener-1.1778304#.Vdwr0-lEew4 (accessed 11 November 2014).Google Scholar
Goldstein, D. (2008) “Flexible Justice: Neoliberal Violence and Self-Help,” in Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Gottschalk, M. (2013) “The Carceral State and the Politics of Punishment,” in Simon, J., & Sparks, R., eds., The Sage Handbook of Punishment and Society. Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, Singapore, Washington, DC: Sage.Google Scholar
Gray, P. (2013) “Assemblages of Penal Governance, Social Justice and Youth Justice Partnerships,” 17 Theoretical Criminology 517–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hansard, Appropriation Bill, Debate on Vote 6, Justice, Vol. 1 (1994), cols. 1–2304.Google Scholar
Hansard, Appropriation Bill, Debate on Vote 20 (1999), Justice, cols. 1747–3494, 10 March to 25 March.Google Scholar
Hansard, “Interpellations, Questions and Replies,” 2 February – 14 April, Vol. 36A (2000), cols. 1–1284.Google Scholar
Hansard, “Interpellations, Questions and Replies,” Vol. 42 (2001), 15 February-28 June, cols. 1–2960.Google Scholar
Häefele, B. (2006) “Vigilantism in the Western Cape,” Department of Community Safety, Provincial Government Western Cape. Available at: https://www.westerncape.gov.za/text/2006/4/vigilantism_in_the_western_cape (accessed 4 December 2012).Google Scholar
Haysom, N. (1989) “Vigilantes: A Contemporary Form of Repression.” Johannesburg: Seminar paper presented at the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation, Seminar No. 4, 25 May.Google Scholar
Hornberger, J. (2013) “From General to Commissioner to General—On the Popular State of Policing in South Africa,” 38 Law & Social Inquiry 598–614.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horwitz, D. (1992) “Images of People's Justice in a Changing South Africa,” Unpublished MA Thesis in School of Criminology at Simon Fraser University.Google Scholar
Huggins, M. (1991) “Introduction: Vigilantism and the State – A Look South and North,” in Huggins, M. ed., Vigilantism and the State in Modern Latin America, Essays on Extralegal Violence. New York, Westport, Connecticut, London: Praeger.Google Scholar
Irvine, H., & Gaffkin, M. (2006) “Getting In, Getting On and Getting Out: Reflections on a Qualitative Research Project,” 19(1) Accounting, Auditing & Accountability J. 115–45.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jarman, N. (2008) “Vigilantism, Transition and Legitimacy: Informal Policing in Northern Ireland,” in Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Jensen, S. (2008) “Policing Nkomazi: Crime, Masculinity and Generational Conflicts,” Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Johnson, L. (1996) “What is Vigilantism?,” 36(2) British J. of Criminology 220–36.Google Scholar
Johnson, D., Maguire, E., & Kuhns, J. (2014) “Public Perceptions of the Legitimacy of the Law and Legal Authorities: Evidence from the Caribbean,” 48(4) Law and Society Rev. 947–78.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jordaan, N. (2015) “Operation Fiela 'demoralises and dehumanises' migrants,” Available at: http://www.timeslive.co.za/local/2015/07/22/Operation-Fiela-demoralises-and-dehumanises-migrants) (accessed 22 July 2015).Google Scholar
Kynoch, G. (2005) “Crime, Conflict and Politics in Transition-Era South Africa,” 104(416) African Affairs 493–514.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kynoch, G. (2011) “Of Compounds and Cell Blocks: The Foundations of Violence in Johannesburg, 1890s – 1950s,” 37(3) J. of Southern African Studies 463–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lamoer, A (2014) “Western Cape Annual Performance Plan 2012/2013,” Annexure PC1, Affidavit of Provincial Commissioner Western Cape, Arno Heinrich Lamoer, Available at: http://www.khayelitshacommission.org.za/images/witnesses/83._Lieutenant_General_Arno_Lamoer.pdf (accessed 15 April 2014).Google Scholar
Landau, L. (2005) “Transplants and transients: nativism, nationalism and migration in inner-city Johannesburg,” Johannesburg: Forced Migration Studies Programme, Working Paper #19.Google Scholar
Larcom, S. (2015) “Internalizing Legal Norms: An Investigation into the Legitimacy of Payback Killings in the New Guinea Islands,” 49(1) Law & Society Rev 178–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, R., & Seekings, J. (2002) “Vigilantism and Popular Justice After Apartheid,” in Feenen, D. ed., Informal Criminal Justice. Farnham, Burlington: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Lenz, T. (1988) “Republican Virtue and the American Vigilante,” 12 Legal Studies 117.Google Scholar
Little, C., & Sheffield, C. (1983) “Frontiers and Criminal Justice: English Private Prosecution Societies and American Vigilantism in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries,” 48(6) American Sociological Review 796.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lund, C. (2006) “Twilight Institutions: Public Authority and Local Politics in Africa” 37 Development and Change 685–705.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Marks, M., & McKenzie, P. (2001) “Alternative Policing Structures? A Look at Youth Defence Structures in Gauteng,” in Schärf, W., & Nina, D., eds., The Other Law, Non-State Ordering in South Africa. Lansdowne: Juta.Google Scholar
Martin, J. (2010) “Vigilantism and Informal Social Control in South Africa,” 23(3) Acta Criminologica 53–70.Google Scholar
Massoud, M. (2015) “Work Rules: How International NGOs Build Law in War-Torn Societies,” 49(2) Law and Society Rev. 333–64.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maxfield, M., & Babbie, E. (2010) Research Methods for Criminal Justice and Criminology, Stamford: Cengage Learning.Google Scholar
Merry, S. (1988) “Legal Pluralism,” 22 Law and Society Rev. 869–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Merry, S. (1993) “Sorting out Popular Justice,” in Merry, S., & Milner, N., eds., The Possibility of Popular Justice: A Case Study of Community Mediation in the United States, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Minnaar, A. (2001) “The New Vigilantism in Post-April 1994 South Africa: Crime Prevention or an Expression of lawlessness.” Pretoria: Institute for Human Rights and Criminal Justice Studies Technikon RSA.Google Scholar
Newburn, T. (2007) Criminology. Portland, London: Willan.Google Scholar
Nina, D. (2001) “Popular Justice and the ‘Appropriation’ of the State Monopoly on the Definition of Justice and Order: The Case of Anti-Crime Committees in Port Elizabeth,” in Schärf, W., & Nina, D., eds., The Other Law, Non-State Ordering in South Africa. Lansdowne: Juta.Google Scholar
Nombembe, P. (2014) Cries Got Baby Back to Mom. Available at: http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2015/01/06/cries-got-baby-back-to-mom (accessed 6 January 2015).Google Scholar
O'Regan, K., & Pikoli, V. (2014) “Towards a Safer Khayelitsha, Report of the Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of Police Inefficiency and a Breakdown in Relations Between SAPS and the Community of Khayelitsha” August, Available at: http://www.khayelitshacommission.org.za/images/towards_khaye_docs/Khayelitsha_Commission_Report_WEB_FULL_TEXT_C.pdf (accessed 15 September 2014).Google Scholar
Owen, O., & Cooper-Knock, S. (2015) “Between Vigilantism and Bureaucracy: Improving our Understanding of Police Work in Nigeria and South Africa,” 19 Theoretical Criminology 355–75.Google Scholar
Palmer, A. (1998) “Colonial and Modern Genocide: Explanations and Categories,” 21(1) Ethnic and Racial Studies 89–115.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pillay, S. (2008) “Crime, Community and the Governance of Violence in Post-Apartheid South Africa,” 35 Politikon: South African J. of Political Studies 141–158.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pratten, D., & Sen, A. (2008) “Global Vigilantes: Perspectives of Justice and Violence,” in Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Rodgers, D. (2008) “When Vigilantes Turn Bad,” in Pratten, D., & Sen, A., eds., Global Vigilantes. New York: Columbia University Press.Google Scholar
Rush, N. (2015) “Rejecting Rights: Vigilantism and Violence in Post-Apartheid South Africa,” 114/456 African Affairs 341–60.Google Scholar
Schärf, W. (2001) “Policy Options on Community Justice,” in Schärf, W., & Nina, D., eds., The Other Law, Non-State Ordering in South Africa. Lansdowne: Juta.Google Scholar
Schärf, W. and Nina, D. (2001) “Introduction: The Other Law,” The Other Law, Non-State Ordering in South Africa. Lansdowne: Juta.Google Scholar
Shaw, M. (2002) Crime and Policing in Post-Apartheid South Africa Transforming Under Fire. London: Hurst and Company.Google Scholar
Seekings, J. (1992) “The Revival of “People's Courts” : Informal Justice in Transitional South Africa,” in Moss, G., & Obery, I., eds., South African Review, Vol. 6. Johannesburg: Ravan. 186–200.Google Scholar
Seekings, J. (2001) “Social Ordering and Control in the African Townships of South Africa: An Historical Overview of Extra-State Initiatives from the 1940s to the 1990s,” in Schärf, W., & Nina, D., eds., The Other Law, Non-State Ordering in South Africa. Lansdowne: Juta.Google Scholar
Seekings, J. (2013) “Economy, Society and Municipal Services in Khayelitsha, Report for the Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of Police Inefficiency in Khayelitsha and a Breakdown in Relations between the Community and the Police in Khayelitsha.” Cape Town: Centre for Social Science Research, University of Cape Town.Google Scholar
Sekhonyane, M. & Louw, A. (2002) “Monograph 72: Violent Justice, Vigilantism and the State's Response,” Available at: http://www.issafrica.org (accessed 1 April 2014).Google Scholar
Serban, M. (2014) “The Loss of Property Rights and the Construction of Legal Consciousness in Early Socialist Romania (1950–1965).” 8 Law and Society Rev. 773–805.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Social Justice Coalition: Community Testimony for ‘Safe and Clean Toilets Campaign’ (unpublished).Google Scholar
Sisulu, Z. (1986) “Keynote address at the NECC (National Education Crisis Committee) Conference, Durban, 27-28 March 1986 (AK 2915 CALS A1.3), South African History Archives, University of the Witwatersrand.Google Scholar
Sosibo, K., de Wet, P., & Zwane, T. (2014) “Township Politics Fuels the Attacks,” Mail and Guardian, January 30-February 5.Google Scholar
Super, G. (2013) Governing through Crime in South Africa, The Politics of Race and Class in Neoliberalizing Regimes. Farnham, Burlington: Ashgate.Google Scholar
Super, G. (2014) “20 Years of Punishment (and Democracy) in South Africa, the Pitfalls of Governing Crime through the Community,” 48 South African Crime Q 7–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Swanepoel, M., Duvenhage, A., & Coetzee, T. (2011) “Vigilantism: A Theoretical Perspective as Applied to People's Courts in Post-1994 South Africa,” June. North West University, Available at: http://www/dspace.nwu.za (accessed 12 January 2013).Google Scholar
Tabane, R. (2013) “Brutality prevails when hope is lost,” Mail & Guardian, November 8–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tankebe, J. (2009) “Self-Help, Policing, and Procedural Justice: Ghanaian Vigilantism and the Rule of Law,” 43(2) Law and Society Rev. 247–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
The Citizen (2008) “SAPS Must Fight Fire With Fire,” 12 November.Google Scholar
The Star (2008) “‘Kill the bastards’ – Minister's Astonishing Order to Police,” 10 April.Google Scholar
The State v. Mziwabantu Mncwengi, Mzimasi Mncwengi, Buyelwa Mncwengi, Lumnko Babalaza, Xolani Makapela, Mawende Siboma, Case Number SS03/2013, Western Cape High Court, South Africa, part-heard.Google Scholar
Tshehla, B. (2002) “Non-state justice in the post-apartheid South Africa - a scan of Khayelitsha,” 6 African Sociological Rev. 47–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valverde, M. (2008) “Analyzing the Governance of Security: Jurisdiction and Scale,” 1 Behemoth: A J. on Civilisation 3–15.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Violence Prevention through Urban Upgrading, Volunteer data, December 2012, unpublished mimeo.Google Scholar
Wilson, R. (2002) The Politics of Truth and Reconciliation in South Africa, Legitimizing the Post-Apartheid State. Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Zille, H. (2012) “O'Regan and Pikoli to Head Khayelitsha Policing Inquiry. Politicsweb,” Available at: http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71654?oid=321110&sn=Detail&pid=71654 (accessed 22 August 2012).Google Scholar