Gender differences in sore throat and hoarseness following endotracheal tube or laryngeal mask airway: a prospective study

Postoperative sore throat (POST) and hoarseness (PH) after general anaesthesia are common but minor adverse events after endotracheal intubation (ETT) and laryngeal mask airway (LMA). A systematic review found a lower incidence of airway morbidity following the use of an LMA compared to an ETT [1].

Previous studies have shown that women are at a greater risk for POST compared to men after an ETT [2‐4]. There is no consensus in the literature today as to what constitutes POST, and how or when it should be measured [2, 5‐7]. Therefore, the results between studies may not be comparable [8]. Another contributing factor towards the variation in results could be that different ETT sizes have been used in women: size number 6.5 [4], number 7.0 [9] or 7.5 [2] while some authors do not state what ETT size was used [3]. Since patient satisfaction with anaesthesia may be further improved by reducing the risk of POST and PH [10, 11] the symptoms needs to be continuously re-evaluated in different settings. The appropriate ETT size in women and men is still unclear and debated in the anesthesia community [12]. However, there seems to be some evidence that women benefit from a smaller size ETT [13]. The etiology of POST is also not clearly understood, but it appears to be an inflammatory process since the tracheal mucosa has been found to release inflammatory mediators after intubation [14]. However, the exact anatomical location of sore throat still remains uncertain in patients [8]. Although the evidence points towards female gender as a risk factor for POST, there have been few studies evaluating the difference between genders in recent years [15].Therefore we sought to determine if there are any gender differences in relation to the incidence of sore throat and hoarseness following endotracheal intubation and laryngeal mask airway.

This study was done with the primary aim to determine if there is a gender difference in the incidence and location of postoperative sore throat, and for the incidence of hoarseness after a laryngeal mask airway and endotracheal tube. We also determined the duration or persistence of these symptoms.

This investigation was a non-randomized, prospective and longitudinal study performed at the Örebro University Hospital, Sweden. After approval from Regional Ethics committee in Uppsala, Sweden (nr. 2012/392), informed written and verbal consent were obtained from all patients. The patients were either inpatients or ambulatory patients.

The inclusion criteria were: age >18 years, elective surgery with either a laryngeal mask airway or endotracheal tube. The exclusion criteria were: surgery in the mouth or throat area, nasal intubation, the use of oesophageal probe, ongoing upper airway infection and expected duration of surgery >240 minutes.

During the period January to April 2013 a total of 301 patients, (men n = 115 and women n = 186) from five different surgical departments (Urology, General-, Orthopedic-, Gynecological- and Hand- surgery) were consecutively screened and enrolled in the study. Four patients were subsequently excluded from the analysis since they had both an LMA and an ETT during anaesthesia. In one man, several unsuccessful attempts were made to insert a Proseal LMA and he was subsequently intubated. Two men and one woman had to be intubated during surgery because of in adequate ventilation when using an LMA. Therefore, a total of 297 patients were included in the final analysis (Figure 2). Men weighed more (p < 0.001) and were taller (p < 0.001) and required more intraoperative fentanyl (p = 0.008). There were no gender differences in morphine and ketobemidone consumption at the PACU (Table 1).

The number of attempts needed to intubate men and women respectively were as follows: one attempt in 32(29%) and 72 (39%), two attempts in 21 (19%) and 15(8%) and three or more attempts in 6 (6%) and 0 (p = 0.002). A stylet was used to aid insertion in more men compared to women 12 vs. 7 (63% vs. 32%; p = 0.017) .

The LMA was used in 134 (91%) and Pro Seal in 13 (9%) of patients. The registered nurse anaesthetist or anaesthesiologist chose the size of LMA from personal experience and using the guidelines recommended by the manufacturers. There were no gender differences in how the LMA was inserted i.e. with the cuff partially inflated or deflated cuff (p = 0.3). Rotation of the LMA during insertion was more common in men (p = 0.001). The LMA insertion was graded in women as follows; easy 82% (n = 77), some difficulty 15% (n = 14) and difficult 3% (n = 3). Corresponding values for men were, easy 80% (n = 41), some difficulty 12% (n = 6) and difficult 8% (n = 4). Even though insertion was considered easy, more women had POST compared to men (p = 0.07). Irrespective of airway device (ETT or LMA) used there were no significant gender difference in POST or PH at the PACU. When stratified for different surgical departments, irrespective of airway device, there were more women who had POST after hand-, orthopedic-, gynecology and general surgery. However, more men had POST after urology surgery. There were no significant differences between women and men after an ETT (27% vs. 38%, p = 0.2 ). However, there were more women than men who had POST after an LMA (26% vs. 6%, p = 0.004). If the Proseal LMA was removed from the analysis there were more women than men who had POST (24% vs. 5%, p = 0.004) and there were no significant difference in PH between genders. More women (n = 11) than men (n = 1) said that POST was present during swallowing after an LMA (Table 2). There were no significant differences in PH after either an ETT or an LMA between men and women. There was a higher incidence of POST in the ETT group compared to the LMA group (32% vs. 19%, p = 0.012) as well as a higher incidence of PH in the ETT group compared to the LMA group (57% vs. 33%, p < 0.001) in the PACU.

Our main findings were that no statistically significant differences in POST and PH were found, irrespective of gender (male or female) or type of airway used (LMA or ETT). This shows that postoperative sore throat and hoarseness are a concern for the patient regardless of whether an ETT or an LMA was used. Also, there were no significant gender differences in POST after an ETT. However, more women had POST after an LMA than men. Finally, no statistically significant differences in PH were found between genders or the type of airway used.

This study is one of few studies that did not find any gender differences in POST after an ETT [15, 26]. One reason for this finding could be that there is some evidence in the literature that a smaller sized ETT in women decreases POST [12, 27, 28]. In our present study, most women had a small ETT, which may consequently have reduced the incidence of POST in women. However, we did find that women have more POST after an LMA than men, which confirms the findings of Nott et al.[25], but not Grady et al.[24] who found that men and women had a similar incidence of POST (20%). The low incidence of POST in men in our study compared to the other studies raises questions as to why men and women respond differently to a standard LMA. Despite the manufacturers recommendation many anaesthetists inserted the LMA with a partially inflated cuff. Having said this, earlier studies have not confirmed that the insertion technique is associated with POST [29, 30]. The anatomy of the pharynx differs between the sexes [31] and it is possible that currently used LMAs are devised to better suit the anatomical features of the male pharynx rather than the female and therefore the lower incidence of POST in men. Another possible confounder in this study could be the wide range of cuff pressure in the LMAs. The reason for following the manufactures guidelines were because of the lack of consensus amongst researchers in an association between cuff pressure and POST. In the study by Burgard et al.[32], the cuff pressure in the control group was not adjusted during surgery and it became as high as 200 cm H₂O while the cuff pressure was held below 60 cm H₂O intra-operatively in the intervention group. However, in the study by Rieger et al.[33], there were no significant differences between intervention and the control group when the cuff pressure was at 30 mmHg (41 cm H₂O) and 180 mmHg (244 cm H₂O) respectively. A recently published study showed that a cuff pressure at 60 cm H₂O compared to 25 cm H₂O in LMA Supreme can increase pharyngolaryngeal adverse events. However, this study made no comparison between genders [34]. Although we used a smaller LMA in women than men, the anatomical formation of the LMA rather than its size may play an important role in the development of POST. We also found a higher incidence of PH in our patients after an LMA compared to the study by Yu et al.[1]. In one previous study, the authors suggest that a larger LMA (size 5) may contribute to an increase in the frequency of PH in men. However, the LMA size (3 or 4) was not associated with a higher incidence of PH in women [24]. Whatever the reason, patients are less likely to be satisfied with anaesthesia if they have PH [10, 23]. The etiology of PH may differ between airway devices, e.g. after an ETT it may result from direct trauma to the vocal cords causing edema [35], while the cuff in the LMA may cause compression of the laryngeal nerve [36]. It is, however, important to point out that all patients in our department receive oxygen via nasal prongs in the PACU, which may also have contributed to the symptoms of both PH and POST because of the high flow of dry oxygen.

Persistent symptoms can be a constraint for patients, and one cause of patient dissatisfaction. In our previous study, 10% of the patients had persistent symptoms of POST and/or PH 96 h after an ETT [28], which contrasts with only 3% of the women who had either POST/PH after 96 hours in the present study. Thus, persistent symptoms of POST/PH after 96 hours, seem to occur in only a small number of patients and all patients were symptom-free approximately two weeks after the anaesthetic in this study.

Research investigating gender difference in anaesthesia revealed that women have a different recovery profile than men [37]. Despite the fact that women emerged faster from general anesthesia [37, 38], their Quality of Recovery was poorer than that of men. In this study, however, there seem to be no significant differences between men and women in the recovery from POST and PH after LMA or ETT. However, there were significant differences between the sexes in pain medication peroperatively. Men received higher dosage of opioids than women which could be due to the calculation of doses in μg/kg. Cortisone intravenously is known to decrease POST in the postoperative period [39, 40]. In this study, betamethasone was used for decreasing postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV). Bethamethasone are commonly used in women who are prone to suffer from PONV [41]. The use of betamethasone for preventing postoperative nausea may influence the development of POST.

To the best of our knowledge only Joorgensen et al.[42] have studied the location of POST as assed by the patient. One reason for not asking about the precise location of POST may be that it is difficult to explain correctly. Despite the complexity of pain localization, we did find that our patients seem to be able to localize pain in the throat. We found that more patients located the pain below the larynx after an ETT compared to an LMA, probably due to the design and shape of the cuff in the ETT [43]. Pain above the larynx, was more common after an LMA than an ETT (52% vs. 37%), which is likely because the LMA cuff exerts pressure on the mucosa above the larynx [18]. However, pain above the larynx after an ETT could also be caused by laryngoscopy [15].

Pain in the throat was more common when using an LMA than an ETT in women during swallowing. As far as we know, no difference between the sexes has been reported before even though the findings by Rieger et al. confirmed that pain during swallowing was more common after an LMA than an ETT [23]. There are also many patients who experienced pain in the throat in the PACU at all time, namely, during rest, swallowing and talking in this study.

The follow-up questions were asked in a non-leading but direct manor by trained personnel. Direct questioning is known to increase the number of events reported by patients, which may explain the high incidence of PH in our study [44]. According to Myles et al. there may be a gender difference in the ability to report postoperative symptoms, and that women may find it easier to report symptoms to a nurse than do men [45]. If this indeed was the case in the present study remains unclear.

Our study contradicts previous studies regarding the gender difference of POST and PH following general anaesthesia. In a clinical setting where women are intubated with a smaller size ETT there were no significant difference in POST or PH between genders. Additionally, more women than men have POST when an LMA is used. This is important to know so that one can take appropriate steps to prevent the development of sore throat or hoarseness in men and women.