Background
During the past 20 years, many strains of
Plasmodium falciparum have become resistant to chloroquine and other anti-malarial drugs [
1]. The emergence and spread of drug-resistant parasites has generated an urgent need for the development of novel anti-malarial drugs. One strategy for reducing malaria prevalence is the use of drugs in combination. Drug combinations protect each component drug from the development of resistance and reduce the overall transmission of malaria [
2]. Since 2001, more than 60 countries have officially adopted artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) for the treatment of falciparum malaria; moreover, ACT is now the official first-line treatment against malaria in Africa [
3]. In ACT, the artemisinin derivative causes rapid and effective reduction of parasite biomass and gametocyte carriage, while the partner drug, which has an extended duration of activity, achieves effective clinical and parasitological cure. However, the clinical failures, or at least the extended parasite clearance times associated with ACT have been described in Cambodia [
4‐
7]. In addition, prior therapy with ACT containing amodiaquine has selected for
P. falciparum isolates with reduced response to monodesethylamodiaquine, thereby suggesting that amodiaquine-containing regimens may have rapidly reduced efficacy in Africa [
8].
Dakar, the capital city of Senegal, has an urban population of approximately 1.1 million and a suburban population of 2.3 million; the city covers the majority of the Cap-Vert Peninsular. Malaria is transmitted in Dakar and its surrounding suburbs, with a human biting rate ranging from 0.1 to 43.7 bites per person per night, according to different districts and entomological inoculation rates (EIR) ranging from 0 to 16.8 infected bites per person per year [
9,
10]. Malaria transmission rates are associated with environmental factors, such as vegetation and built-up area [
11]. Malaria accounted for 25.9% of the total cases observed in the Infectious Disease Clinic in Dakar between 2001 and 2003. Of those cases, 65.6% presented as severe forms [
12]. In 2004, malaria attacks accounted for 13.7% (2977 cases) of all consultations at the Dispensaire St Martin in Dakar, which increased from October to December [
13].
Since 2002, ACT has been routinely and widely used in Senegal for managing uncomplicated malaria. ACT is delivered free-of-charge in health centres. Together, artemether-lumefantrine and artesunate-amodiaquine were the ACT recommended as the first-line anti-malarial regimen since it became available in the public system in 2006. Since then, more than 1.5 million treatments have been administered [
14]. In 2002-2003, an open randomized study with the drug Artequin
® (artesunate-mefloquine) showed an excellent clinical and parasitological response rate of 100% on day 28 [
15]. In 2008, in Kaolack (200 km south-east of Dakar), a study showed that Artequin was efficacious in paediatric patients with a cure rate of 96.2% in intention-to-treat analysis and was as well tolerated as artemether-lumefantrine [
16]. Artesunate-amodiaquine associated cure rates were > 99.3% in Mlomp and Keur-Socé when administered either as a single daily intake or two daily intakes [
17]. The fixed-dose combination of artesunate-amodiaquine (ASAQ) shows a cure rate > 98.5% [
18]. The cure rates were 100% in both populations experiencing a second and third episode of uncomplicated malaria following treatment with ASAQ [
14].
Since the introduction of ACT in Senegal, there have been very few reports on the ex vivo susceptibility of P. falciparum to anti-malarial drugs. To examine whether parasite susceptibility has been affected by the widespread use of ACT, an ex vivo susceptibility study was conducted with local isolates obtained at the military hospital of Dakar. The new term 'ex vivo susceptibility' is used to describe studies on fresh isolates, while the term 'in vitro susceptibility' should now refer to studies on strains of the parasite, which have been either kept in culture for at least two to three generations or which have been cryo-preserved. The malaria isolates obtained from patients at the Hôpital Principal de Dakar were assessed for susceptibility to chloroquine (CQ), quinine (QN), monodesethylamodiaquine (MDAQ), the active metabolite of amodiaquine, mefloquine (MQ), lumefantrine (LMF), dihydroartemisinin (DHA), the active metabolite of artemisinin derivatives and doxycycline (DOX).
Conclusions
This report describes the evaluation of the
ex vivo susceptibility of
P. falciparum isolates taken from patients in Dakar to seven standard anti-malarial drugs. Analysis of the
in vitro susceptibility of
P. falciparum isolates has three important attributes [
27]. First, this approach allows one to assay the response of clinical isolates to individual drugs that remain intact and unmodified by important host factors that influence drug efficacy
in vivo. Second, the progressive decline in drug susceptibility of isolates from the same site may identify incipient resistance in the parasite population. Finally, strains with reduced susceptibilities to anti-malarial drugs can be established in continuous culture, thus providing the material needed to investigate novel molecular mechanisms of resistance. These cultures can also provide material for tests of susceptibility to other anti-malarial agents.
This study represents the first use of the 3D7 ratio to address the requirement of the in vitro module of WWARN. The use of this 3D7 ratio could allow for the minimization of bias induced by IC50 variations, which can be caused by plate batches, atmospheric conditions and varying methodologies in general. The 3D7 ratio could allow researchers to compare data and monitor the spatial and temporal evolution of resistance to anti-malarial drugs. However, the estimation of the 3D7 ratio cut-off for in vitro resistance or reduced susceptibility must be refined by using a large series of 3D7 IC50. Nevertheless, the results in terms of prevalence of resistance are relatively similar between the two estimations.
Previous
ex vivo studies in Dakar and in the Fatick region (Dielmo and Ndiop, 280 km south-east of Dakar) were conducted using the same methodology (42-h
3H-hypoxanthine uptake inhibition method in controlled atmospheric conditions 5% CO
2 and 10% O
2) [
24,
28‐
35], while certain conditions varied from that in the present study (atmospheric generators for capnophilic bacteria Genbag CO2
® at 5% CO
2 and 15% O
2 and pLDH ELISA). However, the re-evaluation of the cut-off values for
in vitro resistance or reduced susceptibility in these new experimental conditions induced by the use of the atmospheric generators for capnophilic bacteria Genbag CO2
® allows for the comparison of these data with previous data assessed by the standard 42-h
3H-hypoxanthine uptake inhibition method in controlled incubator conditions (5% CO
2 and 10% O
2) [
25].
Surprisingly, the prevalence of isolates with reduced susceptibility to MQ reached 50%. This level has increased since previous studies conducted in Senegal. In Dielmo and Ndiop, the percent of isolates with decreased susceptibility was 22% in 1995 [
28] and 15% in 1999 [
33,
35]. In Dakar, it was 17% in 2001 [
36] and 13% in 2002 [
24]. Prophylaxis failure with MQ has been previously described in Senegal [
37]. MQ is one of the three anti-malarial drugs recommended for travellers as an anti-malarial prophylaxis in Senegal. Clinical trials are in progress to evaluate the efficacy of MQ for intermittent preventive treatment for infants and during pregnancy, while MQ is still used for the treatment of uncomplicated malaria in infants in Dakar. Nevertheless, MQ has been employed relatively infrequently in Africa as compared to Asia. The combination artesunate-mefloquine, which is administered to patients in Asia, is not yet used in Senegal. However, scientific data are not available for MQ monotherapy. A positive correlation was shown between MQ and QN (
r = 0.421;
r
2
= 0.178) and between the responses to the components of the ACT used in Dakar, LMF (
r = 0.413;
r
2
= 0.171), MDAQ (
r = 0.412;
r
2
= 0.170) and DHA (
r = 0.402;
r
2
= 0.161). However, to suggest common mechanisms of action or resistance for two compounds that could induce cross-resistance, the coefficient of determination must be high. A coefficient of determination of 0.161, 0.170, 0.171 and 0.178 means that only 16.1%, 17.0%, 17.1% and 17.8% of the variation in the response to MQ is explained by the variation in the response to DHA, MDAQ, LMF and QN, respectively. The IC
50 value of the isolate with the highest DHA IC
50 (9.37 nM) was 3.22 nM for MQ. Meanwhile, the IC
50 value of the isolate with the highest MQ IC
50 (170 nM) was 1.63 nM for DHA. Very few data are available on the
in vitro decreased susceptibility to MQ and its clinical implications in Africa. It is important to monitor the evolution of
P. falciparum susceptibility to MQ, to archive suspicious isolates and to correlate clinical outcomes with pharmacokinetic and phenotypic responses and with molecular markers.
As far back as 1988,
in vitro P. falciparum resistance to CQ was reported in Dakar, and reports of resistance in other regions of the country followed shortly [
38]. From 1991 to 1995, parasitological failures were observed in 21% of patients in Pikine and in 23% of patients in another region of Senegal [
39]. The
in vitro resistance to CQ increased from 1995 to 1999 in Dielmo with 32% resistance in 1995 [
29] as compared to 49% resistance in 1996 [
30], 44% resistance in 1997 [
34] and 55% resistance in 1999 [
33]. Certain single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), such as the
P. falciparum chloroquine resistance transporter gene (
pfcrt) polymorphism K76T, are associated with decreased susceptibility to CQ. Furthermore, this decreased susceptibility to CQ in Dielmo was confirmed by evaluation of the K76T mutation [
40]. In Dielmo, the incidence of clinical malaria for patients within seven days of CQ treatment increased from 2.6% in 1995 to 13% in 1999, despite strictly controlled anti-malarial use [
40]. A similar increase in
in vitro resistance was seen in Dakar and the suburb of Pikine with a prevalence of 30% to 31% of strains being resistant to CQ in 2000 [
41,
42] increasing to 52% after 2002 [
24,
43]. The prevalence of the K76T mutation, which is associated with CQ resistance, was greater than 50% in both 2001 [
41,
43] and 2002 [
24]. In 2009, in Dakar, only 22% of isolates were found to be resistant
ex vivo to CQ. These data are consistent with the work of Ndiaye
et al., who showed that 23% of parasites were resistant to CQ in 2007 in Thies (75 km south-east of Dakar) [
44]. This decrease in CQ resistance parallels the withdrawal of CQ drug treatment and the introduction of ACT in 2002 in Senegal. However, in 2003, CQ was still being administered to patients. CQ was found in the urine samples of two nine-year-old children, with a prevalence ranging from 14.5% to 47.5% in children from north Senegal and from 9.0% to 21.4% in children from south Senegal [
45]. In 2006, Senegal reported 10.6% CQ use and 9.7% ACT use [
46]. Since 2006, more than 1.5 million ACT treatments have been administered in Senegal [
14]. A similar reduction in CQ resistance was reported in Malawi after withdrawal of CQ treatment [
47]. This observation prompted a CQ
in vivo study in Malawi five years later, in which CQ was found to be 99% effective [
48]. The rapid dissemination of CQ resistance in Dielmo, despite strictly controlled anti-malarial drug use, argues against the re-introduction of CQ in places where the resistant allele has dropped to very low levels following discontinuation of CQ treatment [
40].
Encouragingly, only 6% of isolates show
in vitro reduced susceptibility to MDAQ. This rate is stable with 0% resistance in 1996 and 1999 in Dielmo [
29,
35] and 5% in Mlomp (Casamance, south-western Senegal) in 2004 [
49]. The rates remained low even after the introduction of artesunate-amodiaquine in 2002 in Senegal. A positive correlation was shown between MDAQ and CQ responses (
r = 0.569;
r
2
= 0.324), which means that 32.4% of the variation in the response to MDAQ is explained by variation in the response to CQ. A study in Dakar and Mlomp from 1996 to 1998 showed that monotherapy with amodiaquine remained effective for treating uncomplicated malaria in areas where CQ resistance was prevalent [
50].
Only one isolate exhibited reduced susceptibility to DHA. This result is consistent with previous studies that did not show any parasites resistant to artesunate [
24,
33,
35]. However, Agnamey
et al. reported that 3% - 23% of isolates had IC
50 values greater than 15 nM in Mlomp between 2000 and 2004 [
50]. High IC
50 values can also be found for artemisinin with IC
50 > 30 nM in Dakar [
44] and artesunate with IC
50 > 45 nM [
38].
The other ACT first-line treatment for uncomplicated
P.
falciparum malaria in Senegal is the combination of artemether-lumefantrine. Only 1% of the isolates presented reduced susceptibility to LMF. This prevalence did not rise in Senegal after the introduction of ACT. In 1996, 6% of isolates from Dielmo were resistant
in vitro to LMF [
31].
Six percent of isolates showed reduced susceptibility to QN, which is in accordance with previous studies in Dakar [
24,
36] and Dielmo [
28,
33,
35]. Isolates with high IC
50 to QN were already identified in 1984 [
51]. However, a QN clinical failure was reported in a patient who spent two months in Dielmo in 2007 [
52]. QN is often associated with DOX in the treatment of severe malaria in Dakar.
A prevalence of 12% of isolates with
in vitro reduced susceptibility to DOX was observed in Dakar in 2009. The mean IC
50 was similar to those estimated in Dielmo in 1998 [
32,
53]. Parasite populations in Senegal were distributed among three groups with low (4.9 μM), medium (7.7 μM) and high (17.7 μM) IC
50 to DOX [
53]. The slow activity of DOX
in vitro has a delayed effect upon growth and requires prolonged incubation of parasites [
32,
54]. However, the standard 42-h test is still used to monitor DOX
in vitro susceptibility.
The introduction of ACT in 2002 in Senegal did not induce a decrease in P. falciparum susceptibility to individual drug components, such as DHA, MDAQ and LMF. However, prevalence of P. falciparum isolates with reduced drug susceptibility increased for both MQ and DOX. Clinical failures with QN have been reported in Senegal. Additionally, isolates with high IC50 values for artemisinin derivatives have been described for Senegal and for clinical failures, or at least delayed parasite clearance times, have been described in Cambodia. For all of these reasons, an intensive surveillance of the in vitro P. falciparum susceptibility to anti-malarial drugs must be conducted in Senegal.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' contributions
BF, SD, KS, EB, YD, RB and BP carried out in vitro testing of drug susceptibility and drafted the manuscript. BD, KBF, PSM, FF and BW carried out diagnostic tests, monitored the patients, collected clinical and epidemiological data and drafted the manuscript. BF, CR, RB and BP analysed the data. All authors conceived and designed the study and read and approved the final manuscript.