Background
Methods
Description of studies
Study site, year Reference | Study Population | Antimalarial treatment | Primary Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
Randomized trials*
| |||
Nigeria, 1994–1997 [14] | Pregnant women infected with P. falciparum malaria after treatment failure§ | 1) Artemether IM + mefloquine n = 22 2) Artemether IM n = 23
Artemether overall dosage: 3.2–9.6 mg/kg
| Parasitaemia at day 28; AEs Foetal outcomes; infant neurodevelopment |
Thailand, 1995–1998 [10] | Pregnant women infected with P. falciparum malaria§ | 1)Quinine n = 29 2)Artesunate+ mefloquine n = 28
Artesunate overall dose: 12 mg/kg
| Time to parasite & fever clearance; anaemia; AEs; neurological examination Perinatal assessment; birth outcomes; infant physical and neurological assessment |
TBB, 1995–1997 [12] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria | 1)Quinine n = 42 2)Artesunate+mefloquine n = 66
Artesunate overall dose: 12 mg/kg
| Parasite clearance; anaemia; AEs; neurological deficit Birth outcomes; infant developmental milestones |
TBB, 1997–2000 [13] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria | 1)Quinine+clindamycin n = 65 2) Artesunate n = 64
Artesunate overall dose: 12 mg/kg
| Treatment failure at day 42 or before delivery; anaemia; AEs Birth outcomes; infant developmental milestones |
TBB, 2001–2003 [11] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated P. falciparum or mixed malaria | 1)Quinine n = 42 2) Artesunate atovaquone-proguanil n = 39
Artesunate overall dose: 12 mg/kg
| Fever, parasite clearance; treatment failure at day 63; anaemia; AEs Birth outcomes; infant developmental milestones |
Case series
| |||
China, 1976–1980 [15] | Pregnant women infected with P. falciparum or P vivax malaria§ Trimesters (n): 3rd (1), 2nd (5) | Artemisinin IM or Artemether
Overall artemisinins dose: 500–900 mg
| Therapeutic effects and adverse reactions for mother and child |
TBB, 1992–1996 [17] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated multi-drug resistant P. falciparum or mixed malarial infection Trimesters (n): 3rd & 2nd (74), 1st (16) | Artesunate alone or with mefloquine; or Artemether+mefloquine
Overall artemisinins dose: 12–16 mg/kg
| Treatment failure at day 42; anaemia; ADR; neurological deficit Birth outcome; infant neurological development |
TBB, 1991–1996 [18] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated multi-drug resistant P. falciparum malarial infection after treatment failure Trimesters (n): 3rd & 2nd (74), 1st (16) | Artesunate alone or with mefloquine; or Artemether+mefloquine
Overall artemisinins dose: 12–16 mg/kg
| Treatment failure at day 42; anaemia; ADR; neurological deficit Birth outcome; infant neurological development |
TBB, 1992–2000 [16] | Pregnant women with uncomplicated multi-drug resistant P. falciparum or mixed malarial infection Trimesters (n): 3rd (211), 2nd (201), 1st (42) | Artesunate alone or with mefloquine; clindamycin atovaquone-proguanil;or coartemether, artemether IM
Overall artemisinins dose: 12–16 mg/kg
| Treatment failure at day 42; anaemia; ADR; neurological deficit Birth outcome; infant developmental milestones |
TBB 1999–2001 [19] | Pregnant women with multi-drug resistant P. falciparum or mixed malarial infection Trimesters (n): 3rd & 2nd (24), 1st (3) | Artesunate+atovaquone-proguanil
Artesunate overall dose: 12–14 mg/kg
| Treatment failure at day 42; parasite clearance; AEs Birth outcomes |
TBB 2000–2001 [20] | Pharmacokinetic study: pregnant women with multi-drug resistant P. falciparum or mixed malarial infection Trimesters (n): 3rd (13) & 2nd (11) | Artesunate+atovaquone-proguanil
Artesunate overall dose: 12 mg/kg
| Pharmacokinetic parameters; AEs (including ECG); parasite clearance Birth outcomes |
Gambia, 1999 [41] | Pregnant women participating in mass prevention campaign Trimesters (n): 1st (77) | Artesunate + SP
Artesunate overall dose: 200 mg
| MDA 1° aim: malaria transmission Pregnancy outcomes |
Sudan, 1997–2001 [22] | Pregnant women infected with P. falciparum malaria after treatment failure§ Trimesters (n): 3rd (15), 2nd (12), 1st (1) | Artemether IM
Artemether overall dose: 480 mg
| Treatment failure at day 28; anaemia; neurological deficit Birth outcomes |
Sudan, 2004–2005 [23] | Pregnant women infected with uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria§ Trimesters (n): 3rd (22), 2nd (10) | Artesunate + SP
Artesunate overall dose: 200 mg
| Treatment failure at day 28; anaemia Birth outcomes |
Randomized controlled trials
Descriptive studies
Results
Study site, year Ref | Antimalarial treatment | N (% follow up) | Outcomes of interests | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Maternal Safety
¥
|
Pregnancy outcomes
| |||
Nigeria, 1994–1997 [14] | 1) Artemether IM + mefloquine n = 22 2) Artemether IM n = 23 | 45 (100%) | Minimal, only A+M: abdominal discomfort (9%) and dizziness (9%) | Neonatal jaundice (n = 2 A & n = 1 A+M) 6 (13%) followed up to 1 year |
Thailand, 1995–1998 [10] | 1) Quinine n = 29 2) Artesunate+ mefloquine n = 28 | 60 (95%) | Neurological exam: all normal. Nausea (16%), vomiting (12%), vertigo (12%), tinnitus (18%), and hypoglycaemia (3%) more frequent in Q (p < 0.05). Other no difference: Palpitation (6%), blurring vision (11%). | Neonatal jaundice (n = 5 Q & n = 1 A+M) 46 (81%) followed up to 1 year |
TBB, 1995–1997 [12] | 1) Quinine n = 42 2) Artesunate+ mefloquine n = 66 | 108 (85%) | Neurological exam 1 maternal death* Tinnitus (15%) and dizziness (42%) more frequent in Q (p < 0.05). Headache (21%), nausea (45%), abdominal pain (28%), vertigo (12%), muscle/joint pain (32%), and anorexia (35%) no difference with Q (p > 0.05). | Abortions (n = 2 A+M) 46 (49%) followed up to 1 year Neonatal deaths (n = 2 A+M & n = 1 Q) |
TBB, 1997–2000 [13] | 1) Quinine)+ clindamycin n = 65 2) Artesunate n = 64 | 129 (91%) | Tinnitus (9%) more frequent in Q+C (p < 0.05). Headache (30%), dizziness (41%) nausea (25%), vomiting (8%), abdominal pain (18%), rash (9%), contractions (35%), muscle/joint pain (12%), and anorexia (42%) no difference with Q+C (p > 0.05). | Stillbirths (n = 1 A & n = 1 Q+C) Congenital abnormality: midline epidermoid cyst (n = 1 Q+C) Neonatal deaths (n = 1 A & n = 2 Q+C) 72 (62%) followed up to 1 year |
TBB, 2001–2003 [11] | 1)Quinine n = 42 2) Artesunate atovaquone-proguanil (AAP) n = 39 | 81 (91%) | 1 maternal death** Tinnitus (24%) more frequent in Q (p < 0.05). | Stillbirth (n = 1 not specified maternal death) Congenital abnormalities: polythelia (n = 1 AAP); cleft lip & palate (n = 1 AAP); aural atresia (n = 1 Q) Neonatal deaths (n = 1 A & n = 2 Q+C) 59 (78%) followed up to 1 year Developmentally delayed (n = 1 AAP) |
TOTAL
|
No 1
st
trimester,
P. falciparum
or mixed malaria 17% to 100% symptomatic 242 artemisinins exposures
|
423 (94%)
|
2 maternal deaths
Neurological exam in 2 studies
|
Stillbirths (n = 1 A; n = 1 Q+C & n = 1 unknown)
Congenital abnormality: (n = 2 A & n = 2 Q)
Neonatal deaths (n = 4 A+M & n = 5 Q)
229 (59%) infant followed up to 1 year
|
Study site, year Ref | Antimalarial treatment | N (% Follow-up) | Outcomes of interests | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maternal Safety
|
Pregnancy outcomes
| ||||
Overall
|
1
st
trimester exposures
| ||||
China, 1976–1980 [15] | Artemisinin IM or Artemether | 6 (100%) | No adverse effect | 6 (100%) followed up at 5–9 year | None |
TBB, 1992–2000 [16] | Artesunate alone or with mefloquine; clindamycin atovaquone-proguanil; coartemether, artemether IM | 461 (89%) | No ADRs (pruritus) Maternal deaths (n = 2)* | Abortions 4.8% (n = 20) Stillbirth 1.8% (n = 7) Congenital abnormalities 0.8%: anencephaly (n = 1); midline epidermoid cyst (n = 1) | Abortions 23% (n = 10) |
TBB 1999–2001 [19] | Artesunate+atovaquone-proguanil | 27 (100%) | Symptoms possible ADRs: Headache (42%); muscle/joint pain (30%); abdominal pain (42%); anorexia (40%); nausea (25%); vomiting (10%); rash (15%); dizziness (70%), tinnitus (24%); contraction (15%) and sleep disturbance (8%) | Neonatal deaths (n = 1) | Normal deliveries and healthy newborns |
Gambia, 1999 [41] | Artesunate + SP | 325 (88%) | Maternal deaths (n = 1)** | Stillbirth (n = 11) Congenital abnormalities: umbilical hernia (n = 1); undescended testis; (n = 1) Neonatal deaths (n = 8) | Not reported |
Sudan, 1997–2001 [22] | Artemether IM | 28 (100%) | NR | Neonatal deaths (n = 1) | Normal delivery and healthy newborn |
Sudan, 2004–2005 [23] | Artesunate + SP | 32 (100%) | Giddiness and nausea (13%) Neurological exam. | Neonatal deaths (n = 1) | None |
TOTAL
|
123 1
st
trimester,
P. falciparum
or mixed malaria 7% to 100% symptomatic 945 artemisinin exposures
|
879 (90%)
|
3 maternal deaths
Neurological exam in 2 studies
|
Abortions n = 20
Stillbirths (n = 18)
Congenital abnormality: (n = 4) Neonatal deaths (n = 11)
65 (15%) infant followed up to 1 year
|
Abortions n = 10
|
Maternal adverse events
Pregnancy outcomes
Discussion
Study Setting | Design & Drug Regimen | Outcome | Status (start date-completion date) |
---|---|---|---|
Safety/Efficacy prevention trial in pregnancy | |||
Ifakara, Tanzania CDC/IHRDC-IMPACT | Randomised open label, n = 1200 (400 per arm) IPT p Control: SP 2 doses Intervention: 1. SP monthly 2. SP+artesunate monthly | 1°: Placental parasitaemia and AEs 2°: Maternal illness and parasitaemia at delivery, birth outcome (BW, Gestational age, foetal and infant health), childhood developmental milestones | Recruitment concluded; ongoing follow up (01/03-ongoing) |
Safety/Efficacy Treatment trial in Pregnancy | |||
ANC at Muheza Hospital, Tanzania GMP | Randomised open label, target (Phase III) n = 350 2nd or 3rd trimesters Control: SP Intervention: SP+amodiaquine, Amodiaquine+artesunate, Chloroporguanil-dapsone | 1°: Treatment failure at day 28; Treatment outcome (parasite/fever clearance, parasite recrudescence) 2°: Foetal viability and birth outcomes (preterm delivery, foetal death, perinatal/neonatal mortality, neonatal abnormality); maternal AE (hypoglycaemia) | Recruitment completed (01/04–07/06) |
Shoklo Malaria Research Unit (SMRU) ANC, Thailand UNICEF-UNDP-World Bank-WHO-TDR | Randomized intervention trial n = 250 2nd or 3rd trimesters Group 1: Artesunate Group 2: Co-artemether (artemether/lumefantrine) | 1°: Treatment outcome at day 42 or at delivery (parasite/fever clearance, parasite recrudescence) 2°:Gametocyte carriage; pharmacokinetic parameters; histo-pathology examination of the placenta | Currently recruiting (06/02/2004–31/12/2008) |
Bangladesh WHO | Randomised controlled trial n = 684 Control: placebo rectal capsule Intervention: Artesunate rectal capsule | Pregnancy outcomes | Currently recruiting (10/11/2003-ongoing) |
Malawi; Prof Meshnick, UNC | Randomised open label, n = 141 2nd or 3rd trimesters Control: SP Intervention: SP+artesunate or SP+azithromycin | 1°: Parasitological failure rates; parasite clearance time; fever clearance times and incidence rate of adverse events 2°: Prevalence rate of abortions; still births; peripheral parasitaemia at delivery; placental malaria and of maternal anaemia | Recruitment completed (09/2003–10/2005) |
Efficacy/Pharmacokinetic trial in Pregnancy | |||
Mozambique UCT, South Africa | Non-Randomized openLabel, target n = 30 2nd or 3rd trimester pregnant HistoricalControl Intervention: SP+artesunate | 1°: Pharmacokinetic parameters 2°: gametocyte carriage, maternal AE & birth outcomes | Currently recruiting (03/2006–09/2008) |
Kinshasa, DRC, NIH-NICHD | Dose-equivalence trial: part of investigational new drug application n = 60 2nd or 3rd trimester Control: SP Intervention: Artesunate-mefloquine combinations | Pharmacokinetic parameters | Recruitment completed (07/2005–12/2005) |
Pharmacovigilance: Post-marketing surveillance | |||
Tanzania, CDC | Pharmacovigilance surveillance system: part of a large ongoing study to look at district wide use of ACTs 1st trimester Control: SP Intervention: SP+Artesunate | Pregnancy outcome and status of child | Ongoing (2005–2007) |
A partnership between Novartis WHO-TDR and the Government of Zambia. [43] | Pregnancy Registry Prospective active surveillance cohort. Expected n = 1600 Control: SP Intervention: artemether-lumefantrine | Maternal and neonatal outcomes examined | Ongoing (2005) |