Background
Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are one of the most commonly acquired bacterial infections. Over 50% of women will have a UTI during their lifetimes, and approximately 25% of women will have at least one recurrence [
1‐
3]. Recurrent UTIs (RUTI), defined as at least three episodes of UTI in the last 12 months or two episodes in the last six months, can occur in susceptible women and are a significant source of patient morbidity and health care costs [
4].
The treatment of RUTIs can vary depending upon the physician and patient. The Infectious Disease Society of America 2010 recommends a five-day course of nitrofurantoin as a first line treatment of acute, uncomplicated cystitis; however, patients may be prescribed other antibiotics as well [
5]. Antibiotic prophylaxis can also be initiated in patients with recurrent UTIs. One study showed that 6 to 12 months of antimicrobial prophylaxis was more effective than placebo in reducing the risk of RUTIs in pre- and postmenopausal women [
4]. In some cases, patients may self-treat with post-coital antibiotics if RUTIs are related to intercourse [
6]. Unfortunately, continuous and sporadic antibiotic use has the potential to select for highly adaptive, multi-drug resistant organisms and can reduce the numbers of beneficial, commensal bacteria in the intestinal flora. Also, long-term use of nitrofurantoin, a common prophylactic antibiotic, has been associated with health risks including pulmonary toxicity, acute and chronic hepatic disease, neuropathy, and anemia [
7]. Further, there is no evidence-based recommendation of ideal prophylactic antibiotic, dosage, or duration of treatment for RUTI [
8]. Therefore, it is reasonable to consider alternative, readily-available nutritional supplements as prophylactic agents for RUTIs in susceptible women.
Cranberry products have been studied for UTI prevention and treatment. The most common products tested include juices and pills or capsules containing cranberry extracts or powdered fruit, both of which have demonstrated conflicting evidence for prevention of RUTIs [
9‐
11]. One proposed mechanism of action is that one of the primary compounds in cranberries, proanthocyanidins (PACs), inhibit P-fimbriated
E. coli from adhering to uroepithelial cells [
12]. P-fimbriae mediate adherence to uroepithelial cells via the P adhesin gene (
papG), which contains three unique allelic variants, with the allele III variant being highly associated with acute cystitis [
13].
While previous studies have evaluated cranberry juice and other cranberry products for UTI prophylaxis, none have investigated whether consumption of dried cranberries have the potential to decrease the incidence of RUTIs in susceptible women. Dried cranberries contain high concentrations of polyphenols that may be active in interfering with
E. coli biologic or metabolic processes in the intestine or inhibiting bacterial adherence to vaginal or bladder epithelial cells. In addition, because
E. coli is the predominant uropathogen isolated from acute and RUTIs in women and it is believed that the infecting bacteria originate from the intestinal flora, the intestinal tract may be an alternate site in which components of the dried cranberries can interact with
E. coli to reduce infectivity [
14,
15].
The clinical study presented here investigated the efficacy of consuming sweetened, dried cranberries (SDC) to reduce UTI incidence in women with RUTIs. We observed a reduction in the number of UTIs in the six months following consumption of SDC daily for two weeks. There were no significant changes in the virulence profiles of intestinal E. coli during the study period.
Materials and methods
Twenty women with a history of recurrent UTI, defined as at least three UTIs in the past year (subjects with two UTI’s in the past six months but not three in the past year were also enrolled) provided informed consent at the outpatient clinic of the University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics, and were enrolled in the trial approved by the University of Wisconsin Health Sciences Institutional Review Board. The number of subjects was based on achieving a statistical power of at least 80% for each of two parameters, infection-free status at the end of the study, and changes in the
E. coli strain diversity measure. A six-month infection-free incidence of 60% in 20 UTI-susceptible women consuming SDC compared to a 20% incidence in untreated women would provide 80% power with p = 0.05 using a two-tailed
t-test. Similarly, analysis of the diversity of
E. coli strains isolated from 20 subjects pre- and post-consumption would have at least 80% power to detect a 0.66 standard deviation shift in the Kullback Liebler (KL) diversity measure [
16] using a two-tailed
t-test conducted at a significance level of 0.05. The mean age of participants was 37, with a range of 18 to 64, and the mean number of UTIs in the past six months was 2.4 with a range of two to five. Exclusion criteria included immune-compromising diseases, co-morbidities, chronic inflammatory bowel disease, diabetes, or cranberry allergy. Although target enrollment for the study was 20 subjects, data from 3 subjects were removed from the analysis due to one patient with exclusionary criteria realized after enrollment, one patient with sample contamination, and one patient with UTI contracted within one week of study enrollment.
A two-week antibiotic washout period of non-prophylactic antibiotics (i.e. full treatment course for acute UTI) was required before beginning the study. Women who were taking daily prophylactic antibiotics, however, were allowed to participate in the study, provided they met the inclusion criteria. A total of three women who were taking prophylactic antibiotics were enrolled in this study. The women in the study consumed one serving (42 g) of SDC, provided by Ocean Spray Cranberries Inc., each day for two weeks. Rectal swabs were collected at the time of study entry to sample intestinal bacterial flora, and SDC consumption began the following day. Rectal swabs were again collected after two weeks of SDC consumption, and within one day of final SDC consumption.
Clinical efficacy was determined by 1.) Comparison of six-month UTI rates pre- and post-consumption, and 2.) Kaplan-Meier analysis of the time until a patient’s first UTI since beginning the study compared to a previous control group with similar inclusion/exclusion criteria. The six-month UTI rate was based on patient self-reports and documentation of the total number of UTIs in the year prior to the study and six-months since beginning the study. Patients also reported the date of their first UTI since the start of the study.
The presence of
E. coli,
Enterococcus sp.,
Klebsiella sp.,
S. Saprophyticus,
S. aureus, and
Proteus sp. were quantified as colony forming units (CFU) per ml from rectal swab eluates on BBL™ CHROMagar Orientation media (24hr growth at 37°C).
Lactobacillus was quantified as CFU/ml on deMan Rogosa Sharpe (MRS)
Lactobacillus agar and grown anaerobically for 72hr at 37°C. In addition, rectal swab eluates were streaked separately onto eosin methylene blue agar to isolate
E. coli, and the last five colonies at the end of the streak area, including any other morphologically distinct colonies, were stored for further analysis. This method provides ≥97% probability of capturing the predominant strain in the sample [
17].
E. coli strain heterogeneity was determined by Diversilab™ DNA fingerprinting based on ERIC repetitive PCR [
18]. Five
E. coli strains were isolated from rectal swabs pre- and post-consumption, and the number of unique fingerprints was determined. The KL diversity measure was used to determine changes in intestinal
E. coli heterogeneity pre- and post- SDC consumption [
16].
All isolates were confirmed as
E. coli by amplification of the glutamate decarboxylase (
gad) gene in addition to the colorimetric reaction on BBL™ CHROMagar Orientation media [
19]. Mulitplex PCR was used to determine phylotype (A, B1, B2, or D) and the presence of six pathogenicity islands (PAIs) and 15 VFs related to iron-uptake, adhesion and toxicity [
20‐
22]. The PAIs tested were from
E. coli J96 (II
J96),
E. coli CFT073 (I
CFT, and II
CFT) and
E. coli 536 (I
536, II
536, and IV
536) [
23]. The individual siderophore genes tested included
fyuA,
iroN
E.coli
, and
iutA . The adhesion genes tested were
sfa,
papG allele II/III,
sfaS, and
iha. The toxins included
hlyA,
cnf1,
pic,
tsh,
sat, and
tosA, and other genes tested were
K1 and iss.
Two separate statistical analyses were used to evaluate clinical efficacy. A two-tailed paired t-test and mean differences with standard errors (SE) was used to determine significant differences in the six-month UTI rates pre- and post-consumption. A log-rank test was used to compare the time until first UTI between the current study group and two placebo groups from previous clinical trials. The two placebo groups from the previous trials were pooled (p = 0.83).
Significant differences in the numbers (CFU/ml) of bacteria present pre- and post-consumption were determined using the Wilcoxon matched pairs signed rank test using log-transformed values to calculate geometric means with 95% confidence intervals (CI), and the presence of VFs was expressed as percentages.
Discussion
Here we report the results of a modified observational clinical trial of two-week SDC consumption for the prevention of UTIs in susceptible women. Using two different methods to determine efficacy, consumption of SDC was shown to be beneficial in reducing the occurrence of UTIs in susceptible women. The significant decrease in six-month UTI rates per individual patient and the comparison of UTI recurrences to a previous control group of women with equivalent UTI histories provide evidence of the potential prophylactic effect of SDC.
Based on the significant decrease in UTI incidence, potential mechanisms of SDC action were investigated. We examined whether the reduction in UTIs could be accounted for by significant changes in the numbers or prevalence of intestinal E. coli or other bacterial species following SDC. E. coli was the only bacteria that showed a significant decrease in overall numbers over the course of the study. It is possible that polyphenols from SDC blocked adherence of E. coli to the intestinal surface and thus decreased their overall numbers, rather than exerting a bactericidal effect. The lack of SDC toxicity is also supported by the observation of no significant changes in the numbers of the other intestinal bacteria surveyed. It is thus likely that SDC are not affecting the growth of commensal bacteria, which is contrary to what would occur if patients were taking prophylactic antibiotics. The lower numbers of intestinal E. coli, combined with the lack of interference with other types of bacteria, may provide a potential benefit since it produces no adverse effects and results in decreased likelihood of UTI.
Although there were no changes in the heterogeneity of intestinal E. coli strains after SDC consumption, we questioned whether there were differences in the intestinal E. coli phylotypes or virulence gene profiles after SDC consumption. The proportion of E. coli with A and D phylotypes was higher after SDC consumption than E. coli with B1 and B2 phylotypes. Phylotypes A and B1 are considered to be less uropathogenic than D and B2. Thus, the increased presence of the A phylotype and decreased presence of the B2 phylotype could be beneficial; however, this does not explain the increased and decreased presence of E. coli with D and B1 phylotypes, respectively. Although there were changes in the phylotypes of E. coli pre- and post-consumption, there was little change in the proportions of strains carrying VF genes associated with UTI. The prevalence of only the iutA and PAI ICFT VF genes in strains differed by more than ten percent after SDC consumption. Overall, the heterogeneity of E. coli and the presence of VFs did not change as a result of SDC consumption, which suggests that SDC do not directly influence the underlying make-up of E. coli in the intestinal flora.
Because the significant reduction in the number of UTIs following SDC consumption is most likely not related to reducing the prevalence or heterogeneity of intestinal uropathogenic
E. coli or other potential uropathogens, alternative mechanisms whereby cranberry phytochemicals could directly influence bacterial phenotypes should be considered. One intriguing possibility is that some components of cranberries may be able to modulate expression of
E. coli VF genes and reduce infectivity and pathogenicity. Support for this concept comes from several studies. Trans-cinnamaldehyde was shown to decrease
E. coli attachment to uroepithelial cells and to reduce cellular invasion in vitro by downregulating expression of the
fimH gene coding for the adhesin of type 1 pili [
25]. Cinnamaldehyde and some of its derivatives were also shown to reduce the virulence of
Vibrio species by decreasing the quorum sensing response [
26]. It has also been reported that compounds in crushed cranberries or cranberry proanthocyanidins inhibited expression of the
fliC flagella structural gene in the CFT073 UPEC strain, with subsequent loss of motility [
27]. Resveratrol, which is present in cranberries, decreased the pathogenicity of
Proteus mirabilis by inhibiting swarming as well as reduced hemolysin production and urothelial cell invasion [
28]. It is possible that these, or other compounds found in cranberries could similarly decrease the virulence of intestinal
E. coli by gene modulation that reduces motility as well as uroepithelial cell adherence and invasion, thereby reducing uropathogenic
E. coli persistence and infectivity in the vagina and bladder.
Another potential mechanism to consider for the observed clinical benefits of SDC consumption is that cranberry phytochemicals may boost mucosal immunity to uropathogens in the gastrointestinal tract. A recent study has shown that cranberry proanthocyanidins can be used as an adjunct to increase intestinal
sIgA levels in mice receiving enteral nutrition [
29]. A clinical investigation found that consuming a cranberry beverage for ten weeks resulted in a five-fold increase in proliferation of T cells ex vivo, a 30% increase in NK cell proliferation, and a 20% reduction in IL-17 secretion, as well as a significant reduction in cold and flu symptoms compared to placebo [
30]. Further studies on the immune enhancing effects of SDC in vivo could define which components of the intestinal immune system are targeted by cranberry phytochemicals.
Although SDC consumption did not prevent UTIs in every patient, none of the patients reported any adverse effects. Therefore, it may be suggested that SDC be used as a prophylactic supplement for patients with recurrent UTIs, since the potential benefits greatly outweigh the risks. A larger, randomized, placebo-controlled study is needed to confirm that daily consumption of SDC is beneficial in the reduction of recurrent UTIs.
One of the limitations of the efficacy assessment is the comparison of patients consuming SDC in this study to a control group from a previous study. We are confident, however, that this comparison between groups is applicable and informative even though it is not the most appropriate comparison for rigorous statistical analysis. Because the women in the current trial and the previous placebo-controlled study had equivalent UTI histories and similar demographics, we would expect women in both groups to acquire UTIs at the same rate over a six-month period without treatment interventions. Randomized, placebo-controlled studies are necessary to further determine the efficacy of SDC consumption.
Competing interests
The authors declare they have no competing interests.