Intra-abdominal Pressures during Voluntary and Reflex Cough

Neurophysiological protection of the upper airway is a critical function of the laryngeal cough reflex (LCR). Coughing involves coordinated contractions of the thoracic, abdominal and pelvic muscles. On videofluoroscopy, reflex cough (RC) caused increased upward displacement of the diaphragm as compared with voluntary cough (VC) [1]. This diaphragmatic displacement is a result of the contraction of the external abdominal obliques, intercostals and associated expiratory muscles. The force of these contractions compresses the abdominal viscera and proportionately displaces the diaphragm superiorly, almost to mid-sternal levels in reflex cough, but not for VC. These contractions cause an increase in intra-abdominal pressure (IAP), which is synchronized with urethral and rectal closure to prevent incontinence.

Although different patterns of "cough" have been described; the "classical" definition of cough starts with an inspiration, which is followed by compressive and expulsive phases; and is either a brainstem reflex or a cortically mediated response characteristic of VC. VC appears to play a role in clearing the vocal cords during speech [2]. However, the expiration reflex is a brainstem mediated reflex that initiates an immediate series of expiratory efforts without an inspiratory phase precedes the noxious stimulus. This type of cough is characterized by a synchronous series of expiratory reflex coughs with a short latency [3‐5], and has a role in clearing the upper airway of potential aspirants during inhalation and swallowing [6]. Increased IAP provides the expiratory force for the protective airway clearing function of the LCR and producing a VC). This distinction is physiologically important because the two types of reflex differ in neurophysiological and pharmacological mechanisms [6‐8].

Previously, it has not been possible to reliably analyze the quantitative changes in the IAP associated with VC and the LCR. The changes in IAP during cough may be measured using pressure catheters in the bladder and/or rectum. Since quantitative measurement of changes in IAP during VC and reflex cough may be useful in the clinical setting, this investigation was designed to assess VC and LCR IAPs using intravesicular pressure catheters and urodynamic analysis of pressure changes.

This study evaluated changes in the IAP during VC and the LCR as indicated by the measurements of the mean and peak IAPs, and mathematical calculations of the area under the curve (AUC, pressure·time) values during VC and LCR cough epochs.

Following informed consent, eleven female subjects between the ages of 18 and 75 were enrolled. Nine subjects had complaints of mild stress urinary incontinence without any neurological history. One subject (subject 10) had multiple sclerosis (MS) and was non-ambulatory with internuclear ophthalmoplegia and neurological deficits associated with cranial nerves II, III, IV and VI, but no history of pneumonia. A further subject (subject 11) was tested 8 weeks after sustaining a T₄ complete spinal cord injury (SCI) and therefore had serious loss of control of her expiratory muscles; her results are mentioned briefly but are not included in the statistical analyses.

Evaluations were performed with a multi-channel urodynamic (UD) system that used a fiber-optic, disposable strain gauge pressure transurethral bladder catheter and a rectal catheter. With sterile technique, the calibrated bladder catheter was placed and secured to the subject's thigh. With continuous dual-channel recording, the subject's bladder was filled slowly with sterile water until 200 ml had been introduced.

Subjects were asked to deeply inhale and perform strong voluntary coughs, which were recorded on the UD system. Tartaric acid-induced reflex cough test (RCT) was used to elicit a LCR in all subjects [2, 5, 9‐18]. The RCT used a jet nebulized concentration of 20% L-(+)-tartaric acid dissolved in 0.15 mM sterile NaCl solution (Nephron Pharmaceuticals, Orlando, FL). The jet nebulizer was activated with 50 psi from a tank that produced an average droplet diameter of 1–2 microns or less. During the RCT, the subject was asked to exhale completely, the nostrils were pinched closed, the nebulizer mouthpiece was placed in the mouth and subjects sealed the mouthpiece with their lips during the brisk inhalation. The RCT normally causes an immediate episode of several coughs. During VC and LCR, the intravesicular (bladder) pressure, rectal pressure and urethral EMG were also recorded for all subjects. (Fig. 1A) [19].

Table 1 gives pressure values for each of the ten subjects analyzed, and summary statistics are given in Table 2. VC and LCR mean IAP values were 45.6 ± 4.65 and 44.5 ± 9.31 cm H₂O, respectively (p = 0.05). Although the peak (maximum) IAP values for the LCR (164.9 ± 15.8) appeared greater than the VC peak IAP (139.5 ± 14.2 cm H₂O), the difference was not significant (p = 0.07) (Table 2).

The number of peak pressures, duration of cough events, and AUC values were all significantly greater with the RCT relative to voluntary cough (Fig. 2 and Fig. 3; Table 2). The number of peak IAPs was greater for the LCR than for VC (6.00 ± 0.94 vs. 1.78 ± 0.28, p < 0.01), as was the episode duration (27.0 ± 0.74 s vs. 10.2 ± 1.36 s, p < 0.01). The mean (± SEM) AUC values for VC and the RCT were 349.6 ± 55.2 cm H₂O·s and 986.6 ± 116.8 cm H₂O·s (p < 0.01; Table 2), respectively.

In the subjects with neurological impairment (Fig. 4), subject 10 had VC and RCT AUC values of 201 and 964 cm H₂O·s, respectively (Table 1), and these normal values are included within the statistical analysis of Table 2. Subject 11, who had a T₄ complete SCI, had VC and RCT AUC values of 22 and 111 cm H₂O·s, respectively. When compared with responses in subjects without any history of neurological impairment, all of these parameters were decreased in the SCI subject (Fig. 4), but were similar to normal values in the non-ambulatory MS subject (subject 10).

The data from the SCI subject was not included in the statistical analysis due to their low magnitude. There were no adverse events experienced by the 11 subjects in this study.

The greater AUC value with the RCT, which triggers the laryngeal cough reflex [5, 21], could be due to the continual and simultaneous activation of cough-associated expiratory muscles with rapid and repeated glottal closure, compared with VC with its brief and often single event of brief glottal closure (Addington et al. cited in [22]) [1, 3]. The differences in the AUC between the two types of cough provide a new perspective to study the neurophysiological differences between these two events. Voluntary cough appears useful in clearing the vocal cords for speech and clearing the airways once material is present in the tracheobronchial tree; it seems similar to reflex cough from the tracheobronchial tree, which starts with an inspiration to increase lung volume. The LCR does not have an initial inspiration and is essentially a series of 'expiration reflexes' with intervening inspirations; it is for involuntary airway protection in response to a threatening stimulus [2]. The term "cough reflex" is often used generically to include both types of "cough" and also cough bouts or epochs.

The UD tracings indicated that the IAP appeared to be greater when there was no expiratory flow and the glottis was adducted. During VC and RCT cough, the IAP appeared to decrease when the glottis was abducted. However, during the coughing associated with the RCT episodes, the tracings showed a continuous increase in IAP above the initial baseline in all subjects, regardless of the duration of the cough episode and despite the subject having fully exhaled before initiating the LCR, which prevented any subsequent effective deep inhalation to assist the coughs. Although the LCR episodes may have had some brief inspiratory activity late in the epoch, the IAP remained elevated above the initial baseline throughout the entire event – this was a consistent finding irrespective of the number of expiratory efforts or the duration of the cough episode. Regarding neurological airway protection, we suggest that the main components of the LCR are primarily a continuous series of expiratory cough reflexes [6‐8] with the possibility of some inspiratory efforts later in the epoch – what may resemble the initial stages of "true" cough. Thus, the continuously increased IAP during the duration of the LCR provides the sustained expiratory force for the protective airway function of the LCR. The neurophysiological status of airway protection appears to be appropriately assessed by the ability to measure the elevated intra-abdominal pressures over time.

The fact that peak IAP was usually greater for the LCR than for VC was surprising. The LCR was preceded by a forced exhalation before the RCT, and the VC was preceded by a forced deep inhalation before producing the VC. Videofluoroscopy clearly demonstrated the changes in the size of the thoracic cavity by the upward displacement of the diaphragm during VC and RCT (LCR) [1]. It is well established that the expiratory strength of cough is considerably greater when starting from a large lung volume compared with a small one [23, 24]. The extent to whether this difference is due to the mechanical effect of stretched expiratory muscles, or to a lung reflex activated by lung inflation and enhancing the expiratory effort is debatable, although probably both mechanisms apply [1, 22, 25]. We did not measure lung volumes. The fact that the expected greater expiratory strength of the VC compared with the LCR was absent, even reversed, emphasizes a significant functional difference between the LCR and voluntary cough in this investigation. The AUCs were also much greater for LCR than for VC. Although this might be due to greater AUCs for individual expiratory efforts, this seems unlikely and the difference probably reflects the greater number and frequency of expiratory efforts for the LCR compared with the VC, with overlapping positive pressure curves. We cannot say if these differences also apply to cough from the lower airways.

Lasserson et al. demonstrated differences in muscle activation between voluntary and reflex cough [4]. Reflex cough from irritant chemical stimulation, assessed by surface electromyography (EMG), revealed simultaneous activation of all the expiratory muscles involved in cough, both primary and accessory. However, voluntary cough activated primary expiratory muscles first and then the contraction of accessory muscles occurred especially with a stronger voluntary cough effort. Their results for peak cough flow rates revealed that voluntary cough flow rate and the maximal cough flow rate achieved in any one effort was significantly higher for voluntary cough than for reflex cough. The involuntary cough results suggest that the glottis remains closed except for brief bursts of expulsive efforts. This would help to maintain the increased level of IAP found in our results and necessary for the next expiratory cough as well as to conserve lung volume until the threat to the airway has been resolved. The mean EMG duration of the voluntary cough effort was significantly longer than for reflex cough [4], but they did not consider the total expiratory electromyographic activity that occurs throughout the epoch of the LCR.

Lasserson's findings are important regarding the motor sequencing activation in voluntary compared with reflex cough [4]. Our experiments differ from theirs in that we may have used a stronger reflex cough stimulus, and more targeted to the larynx, with the aim of producing strong expiratory efforts. But it is clear from our findings that reflex cough can be assessed from one result of the stimulus, specifically an elevated mean intra-abdominal pressure over time. This pressure is sustained probably because the glottis is closed except for very brief episodes of abduction associated with the expiratory airflow. These series of expiratory coughs are essential for clearing the airway of a threatening supraglottic stimulus. The maintained closed glottis with the LCR explains our finding of elevated AUC values, and Lasserson's decreased peak expiratory flows with reflex compared with voluntary cough. The shorter EMG burst duration with reflex cough is modulated to maintain the elevated pressure without using too much pressure or losing the vital air needed to clear the airway over time. Since a forceful inspiration during airway clearing may result in aspiration of material into the lungs, if inspiration does occur during an episode of involuntary coughing, it is brief and appears weak. Voluntary cough peak airflows and EMG assessments are unreliable determinants of airway protection since their role is to clear rather than to protect the airways, and because the patient's participation can vary greatly. These considerations may have limited application to the usual cough from the lower airways, where large expiratory airflows may be necessary to remove material from the lungs.

We believe that you cannot determine involuntary neurological airway protection status from the assessment of voluntary cough. Involuntary cough function has multiple complex synchronous neurophysiological determinants that cannot be obtained from the assessment of voluntary cough. Voluntary cough is defined by deep inhalation followed by expiratory flows and expiratory pressures. Our data demonstrated that this is significantly different than expiratory (protective) cough reflex physiology.

Our definition of the LCR as it relates to neurophysiological airway protection in humans is the involuntary rapid synchronous expiratory muscle activation that causes and sustains an elevated intra-abdominal pressure event over time, sufficient for airway protection following a threatening supraglottic laryngeal stimulus [1‐3, 5, 12, 21]. The AUC values indicate that VC and the LCR are significantly different neurophysiological events. Quantification of the LCR using mean or peak IAP or AUC values may be useful as a clinical tool for determining the neurophysiological status of airway protection for an individual (Addington et al. cited in [22]).